The Compleat McAndrews 


THE BRAIN OF AN EINSTEIN -THE 
MIND OF AN ENGINEER 

Presenting the space adventures of Arthur Morton McAndrew, space-time expert and 
scientist extraordinaire, and his long-suffering companion, spaceship skipper Jeanie 
Roker. Jeanie first met McAndrew on a routine run to Titan and quickly learned he was a 
genius of the caliber of Newton or Einstein. When McAndrew invented a space drive that let 
frail humans survive hundreds of gravities of acceleration, he disappeared while testing it, 
and Jeanie had to find him, using a trail of cryptic messages he had left behind. 

That was the beginning of a beautiful friendship, in spite of the gray hairs that Jeanie 
began accumulating as a result of McAndrew's impractical nature and his talent for getting 
himself into trouble with much more practical villains, such as ... 

A mass-murderer of several million people 

A highly-placed government official whose life McAndrew saved, 
but in an embarrassing way, and who consequently wants to kill 
both him and Jeanie 

The ruler of a slower-than-light spaceship that left Earth a long time ago, giving it time to 
develop some very strange customs by the time McAndrew and Jeanie visited it. And there 
are still more adventures of this spacegoing odd couple in The Compleat McAndrew. 


Publisher's Note: Part of this book was previously 
published as One Man's Universe. 
"Like Arthur C. Clarke and Greg Bear . . . brilliantly balanced seesaw between enormous 
concept and lifesize characterisation." --The London Times 

Cover art by Dru Blair 

Paperback 

This is a work of fiction. All the characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, 
and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. 

First printing, April 2000 

Distributed by Simon & Schuster 
1230 Avenue of the Americas 
New York, NY 10020 

Printed in the United States of America 

ISBN: 0-671-57857-X 

Copyright © 2000 by Charles Sheffield 

All rights reserved, including the right to reproduce this book or portions thereof in any 
form. 

A Baen Books Original 
Baen Publishing Enterprises 

P.O. Box 1403 
Riverdale, NY 10471 
http://www.baen.com 

Typeset by Windhaven Press 
Auburn, NH 

Electronic version by WebWrights 
http://www.webwrights.com 


Acknowledgements 

Portions of this work have appeared previously in revised form, as follows: 
"Killing Vector," (c) UPD Publications, 1978 

"Moment of Inertia," (c) Davis Publications, 1980 

"All the Colors of the Vacuum," (c) Davis 

Publications, 1981 

"The Manna Hunt," (c) Davis Publications, 1982 

"Rogue World," (c) Mercury Press, 1983 

"Shadow World (The Hidden Matter of 

McAndrew)," (c) Davis Publications, 1992 

"The Invariants of Nature," (c) Bantam 

Doubleday Dell, 1993 

"Out of Focus," (c) Charles Sheffield, 1999 (first appeared in SF Age) 

"The Fifth Commandment," (c) Charles Sheffield, 1999 (first appeared in Analog) 


UNSUITABLE ENVIRONMENT 

"McAndrew and Roker." Kleeman's voice came from the speakers, calm and superior. "There will 
be punishment unless you return at once." 

I was at last at the airlock. McAndrew and Wicklund were there. Without speaking, McAndrew 
turned and pointed towards the wall of the lock. I looked, and felt a sudden sickness. The wall where 
the line of spacesuits should be hanging was empty. 

"No suits?" I said stupidly. 

He nodded. "Kleeman has been thinking a move ahead of you." There was a long and terrible pause. 
"I looked out," he said at last. "Through the viewport there. The ship's capsule is still where we left it." 

"You're willing to chance it?" I looked at Wicklund, who stood there not following our conversation 
at all. 

Mac nodded. "I am. But what about him?" 

I walked forward and stood in front of Wicklund. "Do you still want to go with us? Leave the Ark 
forever?" 

Wicklund licked his lips, then nodded. 

"Into the lock." We moved forward together and I closed the inner door. 

"Do not be foolish." It was Kleeman's voice, with a new expression of alarm. "There is nothing to be 
served by sacrificing yourselves to space. McAndrew, you are a rational man. Come back and we will 
discuss this together." 

Mac swung open the outer airlock door. The air was gone in a puff of ice vapor. I saw the capsule at 
the top of the landing tower. To reach it we had to traverse sixth meters of the interstellar vacuum. 


BAEN BOOKS by Charles Sheffield 

The Compleat McAndrew 

Convergent Series 
Transvergence 
The Mind Pool 
Proteus in the Underworld 
Borderlands of Science 
My Brother's Keeper (forthcoming) 



The Compleat McAndrew 


Table of Contents 

Acknowledgements 

UNSUITABLE ENVIRONMENT 
Introduction 
FIRST CHRONICLE: Killing Vector 
SECOND CHRONICLE: Moment of Inertia 
THIRD CHRONICLE: All the Colors of the Vacuum 
FOURTH CHRONICLE: The Manna Hunt 
FIFTH CHRONICLE: The Hidden Matter of McAndrew 
SIXTH CHRONICLE: The Invariants of Nature 
SEVENTH CHRONICLE: Rogueworld 
EIGHTH CHRONICLE: With McAndrew, Out of Focus 
NINTH CHRONICLE: McAndrew and the Fifth Commandment 
APPENDIX: Science & Science Fiction 

Kernels, black holes, and singularities. 
The McAndrew balanced drive. 
Life in space and the Oort cloud. 
Missing matter and the beginning of the Universe. 
Invariance and science. 
Rogue planets. 
The solar focus. 
Compressed matter. 



Introduction 


A glance at the copyright dates on the stories in this book shows that McAndrew has been with me 
for almost as long as I have been writing fiction. My own manuscript notes make that point even more 
clearly: the first piece of fiction that I ever published appeared in the April, 1977 issue of Galaxy 
magazine. The handwritten date on the first page of the manuscript of "Killing Vector," my first 
McAndrew story, is just two months later: June 15, 1977. Since then, at apparently random intervals 
ranging from a few weeks to a few years, I have produced another tale of Arthur Morton McAndrew 
and his long-time and long-suffering companion, Jeanie Roker. 

What's the fascination of these characters for me, and why do I return to them again and again? As a 
related question, is there any pattern to the stories? 

First, let me point out that the order in which they appear in this volume is not the order in which the 
stories were written. Chronologically, the order would be "Killing Vector," "Moment of Inertia," "All the 
Colors of the Vacuum," "The Manna Hunt," "Rogueworld," "Shadow World," "The Invariants of 
Nature," "Out of Focus," and "The Fifth Commandment." 

The most obvious point about these stories is that each revolves around some central issue of 
science. I go into that subject in detail in the Appendix at the end of the book. Whenever I become 
interested in something, especially when that something involves physics and astronomy, a McAndrew 
story is likely to emerge from my hindbrain. 

That explains the chosen themes, but not McAndrew himself. I might suggest that he is some form of 
alter ego, the me that I wish I were, except that others have already assigned that role to Behrooz Wolf 
(of Sight of Proteus, Proteus Unbound, and Proteus in the Underworld). 

Of course, I may have an alter ego suffering from multiple personality disorder. However, my better 
guess is that McAndrew is an excuse. I derive great pleasure from sitting around, reading and calculating 
on matters of no earthly value and importance. I do this happily for hours and days, limited only by the 
arguments of conscience that I ought to be doing something useful and productive. To give one example, 
I have for the past five years tried, sporadically and unsuccessfully, to analyze a particular mathematical 
game. I can state the game simply, and to avoid (or possibly create) reader frustration I may as well do 
so. Two players, A and B, take turns throwing a die. There is a probability p that the die will show a 
score of 2, and a probability of (1 - p) that the die will show a score of 1. Given a whole number N, 
what is the probability that player A will be the first to reach a score of at least N? 

I cannot justify wasting so much time on such a trivial game, except to use the all-work-and-no-play 
defense. However, if an area of apparently useless interest can one day become the basis for a 
McAndrew story, I have a rationale for my actions. Surely, if I write and publish a story, no one can say 
that all my preliminary reading and calculating was pointless. 

As for an overall pattern to the stories, I do see a general trend. However, I suspect that the trend 
mirrors changes not in science but in me. If I had to categorize myself at the time I wrote "Killing 
Vector," it would be as a practicing scientist whose knowledge of science fiction was mainly as a reader, 
a person who despite some first-hand experience of America and Americans was basically English, with 
an English wife and children. Today, twenty-one years and four or five million published words on, I 
would describe myself as a writer with a strong amateur interest in science; a person mostly American, 
with an American wife and children, albeit also a person with strong social and family ties to England and 
the English. And, a fact not to be dismissed, I am twenty-one years older. I am rather less interested in 
science, and more interested in people. 

These changes affect the stories. When first we meet him, McAndrew the scientist is all there, but I 
don't think I could in the early tales ever have given him a child (as in "Rogueworld"), and still less a 
mother (as in "The Fifth Commandment"). That last story also points out an implicit element in most of 
the earlier stories: the relationship between Jeanie Roker and McAndrew is in some ways that of 
parent-child. He is the small boy whose rash actions lead him into trouble, she is the responsible and 


experienced adult who gets him out. I think that's who I would really like to be, the curious child who is 
not quite responsible for his own actions. That is the reason why I continue to write about Arthur 
Morton McAndrew. 

Two other brief answers to questions: Will I ever write a McAndrew novel? An e-mail 
correspondent pointed out that although there are references to McAndrew in others of my novels, he 
has never had one of his own. My answer is, McAndrew will get a novel when I run across a neat 
scientific idea so large and complex that I can't get a handle on it in a story of ten to twenty thousand 
words. 

And finally, is this really the Complete McAndrew, as the title suggests? 

To this, I can only offer the Clintonian reply: it all depends on how you define the word, is. Certainly, 
at this time there exist no other McAndrew stories, so what you have is the complete McAndrew. 
Equally certainly, there will in the future be fascinating scientific ideas that just jump up and down, crying 
out, "Me, me, write about me." 

I'm not sure I will be able to resist their pleas. But "The Incomplete McAndrew" makes a poor book 
title. 


FIRST CHRONICLE: Killing Vector 


Everyone on the Control Stage found a reason to be working aft when Yifter came on board. There 
was maximum security, of course, so no one could get really close without a good reason. Even so, we 
all took the best look that we could manage-you don't often have a chance to see a man who has killed 
a billion people. 

Bryson from the Planetary Coordinators' Office was at Yifter's elbow. The two men weren't shackled 
or anything melodramatic like that. Past a certain level of notoriety, criminals are treated with some 
deference and even respect. Bryson and Yifter were talking together in a friendly way, although they 
were in the middle of a group of top-rank security men, all heavily armed and watchful. 

They were taking safety to extremes. When I stepped forward to greet Bryson and his prisoner, two 
guards carefully frisked me before I could get within hand-kill range, and they stood close beside me 
when the introductions were made. I haven't lived on Earth for a long time, and they must have known 
that I have no close relatives there; but they were taking no chances. Yifter was a prime target for 
personal revenge. A billion people leave a lot of friends and relatives. 

From a distance of one meter, Yifter's appearance did not match his reputation. He was of medium 
height, slightly built, with bushy, prematurely white hair and mild, sad eyes. He smiled at me in a tired, 
tolerant way as Bryson introduced us. 

"I am sorry, Jeanie Roker," he said. "Your ship will be filled with strangers on this trip. I'll do my best 
to keep out of your way and let you do your job." 

I hoped he could live up to his words. Since I took over the runs to Titan, I've carried most things in 
the connected set of cargo spheres that make up the Assembly. Apart from the kernels, and we carry a 
few of those on the outbound leg of every trip, we've had livestock, mega-crystals, the gravity simulator, 
and the circus. That's right, the circus. They must have had a terrible agent, that's all I can say. I took 
them both ways, to Titan and back to L-5. Even with all that, Yifter was still a novelty item. After he had 
been caught and the rest of the Lucies had gone underground, nobody had known quite what to do with 
him. He was Earth's hottest property, the natural target for a billion guns and knives. Until they decided 
how and when he would come to trial, they wanted him a long way from Earth. It was my job to deliver 
him to the Titan penal colony, and return him when they got themselves sorted out on Earth. 

"I'll arrange for you and your guards to travel in a separate part of the Assembly," I said. "I assume 
that you will prefer privacy." 

Yifter nodded agreeably, but Bryson wasn't having any. 

"Captain Roker," he said. "Let me remind you that Mr. Yifter has not been found guilty on any 
charge. On this journey, and until his trial, he will be treated with proper courtesy. I expect you to house 
both of us here in the Control Stage, and I expect that you will invite us to take our meals here with you." 

In principle, I could have told him to go and take a walk outside. As captain, I said who would travel 
in the Control Stage, and who would eat with me-and innocent people were not usually sent to the Titan 
penal colony, even before their trial. On the other hand, Bryson was from the Planetary Coordinators' 
office, and even off-Earth that carried weight. I suppressed my first reaction and said quietly, "What 
about the guards?" 

"They can travel in the Second Section, right behind the Control Stage," replied Bryson. 

I shrugged. If he wanted to make nonsense of Earth's security efforts, that was his choice. Nothing 
had ever happened on any of my two-month runs from Earth to Titan, and Bryson was probably quite 
right; nothing would happen this time. On the other hand, it seemed like a damned silly charade, to ship 
twenty-five guards to keep an eye on Yifter, then house them in a separate part of the Assembly. 

Yifter, with an uncanny empathy, had read through my shrug. "Don't worry about security, Jeanie 
Roker," he said. He smiled again, that tired, soothing smile that began deep in his sad, brown eyes. "You 
have my assurance, I will be a model prisoner." 

He and Bryson walked on past me, into the main quarters. Was that really Yifter, the bogey-man, the 


notorious head of the Hallucinogenic Freedom League? It seemed hard to believe. Three months earlier, 
the Lucies-under Yifter's messianic direction-had planted hallucinogenic drugs in the water supply lines 
of most of Earth's major cities. An eighth of the world had died in the resulting chaos. Starvation, 
epidemic, exposure, and mindless combat had revisited the Earth and exacted their age-old tribute. The 
monster who had conceived, planned, and directed that horror was difficult to match with Yifter, the 
seemingly mild and placid man. 

My thoughts were quickly diverted to more immediate practical matters. We had the final masses of 
all the cargo, and it was time for the final balancing of the whole Assembly. One might assume that just 
means balancing the kernels correctly, since they out-mass everything else by a factor of a million. But 
each Section containing a kernel has an independent drive unit, powered by the kernel itself. We leave 
those on Titan, and travel back light, but on the trip out the dynamic balancing is quite tricky. 

I reviewed the final configuration, then looked around for McAndrew. I wanted him to review the 
balance calculations. It's my responsibility, but he was the kernel expert. I realized that he hadn't been 
present when Yifter came aboard. Presumably he was over on one of the other Sections, crooning over 
his beloved power sources. 

I found him in Section Seven. The Assembly is made up of a variable number of Sections, and there 
would be twelve on this trip, plus the Control Stage. Until we accelerate away from the Libration Colony 
station, all the Sections are physically connected-with actual cables-to each other and to the Control 
Stage. In flight, the coupling is done electromagnetically, and the drives for the powered Sections are all 
controlled by a computer on the Control Stage. The Assembly looks like a small bunch of grapes, but 
the stalks are nonfunctional-there are no cables in the System that could take the strains, even at lowest 
acceleration. Moving among the spherical Sections when we're in flight isn't easy. It means we have to 
cut the drives, and turn off the coupling between the Sections. That's why I thought the idea of having 
Yifter's guards in a different Section was so dumb-from there, they couldn't even reach the Control 
Stage when the drives were on. 

I wanted McAndrew to check the configuration that we would hold in flight, to see if he agreed that 
the stresses were decently balanced among the different Sections. We never run near the limit on any of 
them, but there's a certain pride of workmanship in getting them all approximately equal, and the stresses 
as low as possible. 

He was standing on the ten-meter shield that surrounded the Section Seven kernel, peering through a 
long boresight pointed in towards the center. He was aware of my presence but did not move or speak 
until the observation was complete. Finally he nodded in satisfaction, closed the boresight cap, and 
turned to me. 

"Just checking the optical scalars," he said. "Spun up nicely, this one. So, what can I do for you, 
Jeanie?" 

I led him outside the second shield before I handed him the trim calculations. I know a kernel shield 
has never failed, but I'm still not comfortable when I get too close to one. I once asked McAndrew how 
he felt about working within ten meters of Hell, where you could actually feel the gravity gradient and the 
inertial dragging. He looked at me with his little, introspective smile, and made a sort of throat-clearing 
noise-the only trace of his ancestry that I could ever find in him. 

"Och," he said. "The shields are triply protected. They won't fail." 

That would have reassured me, but then he had rubbed his high, balding forehead and added, "And if 
they do, it won't make any difference if you are ten meters away, or five hundred. That kernel would 
radiate at about two gigawatts, most of it high-energy gammas." 

The trouble was, he always had the facts right. When I first met McAndrew, many years ago, we 
were taking the first shipment of kernels out to Titan. He had showed up with them, and I assumed that 
he was just another engineer-a good one, maybe, but I expected that. Five minutes of conversation with 
him told me that he had probably forgotten more about Kerr-Newman black holes-kernels-than I was 
ever likely to learn. I have degrees in Electrical Engineering and Gravitational Engineering, in my job I 
have to, but I'm really no gravity specialist. I felt like an idiot after our first talk. I made a few inquiries, 
and found that McAndrew was a full professor at the Penrose Institute, and probably the System's 


leading expert on space-time structure. 

When we got to know each other better, I asked him why he would give up his job for four months 
of the year, to ride herd on a bunch of kernels being shipped around the Solar System. It was a 
milk-run, with lots of time and very little to do. Most people would be bored silly. 

"I need it," he said simply. "It's very nice to work with colleagues, but in my line of business the real 
stuff is mostly worked out alone. And I can do experiments here that wouldn't be allowed back home." 

After that, I accepted his way of working, and took vicarious pride in the stream of papers that 
appeared from McAndrew at the end of each Titan run. He was no trouble on the trips. He spent most 
of his time in the Sections carrying the kernels, only appearing in the Control Stage for his meals-and 
frequently missing them. He was a tinkerer as well as a theorist. Isaac Newton was his idol. His work 
had paid off in higher shielding efficiencies, better energy extraction methods, and more sensitive 
manipulation of the charged kernels. Each trip, we had something new. 

I left the trim calculations with him, and he promised to check them over and give me his comments in 
an hour or two. I had to move along and check the rest of the cargo. 

"By the way," I said, elaborately casual as I turned to go. "We'll be having company for dinner on this 
trip. Bryson insists that Yifter should eat with us." 

He stood quietly for a moment, head slightly bowed. Then he nodded and ran his hand over his 
sandy, receding hair-line. 

"That sounds like Bryson," he said. "Well, I doubt if Yifter will eat any of us for breakfast. I'm not 
sure he'll be any worse than the rest of you. I'll be there, Jeanie." 

I breathed a small sigh of relief, and left him. McAndrew, as I knew from experience, was the 
Compleat Pacifist. I had wanted to be sure that he could stand the idea of meals with Yifter. 

Four hours later, all our checks were complete. I switched on the fields. The dull grey exterior of 
each Section turned to silver, shattering the sunlight and turning the Assembly to a cluster of brilliants. 
The cables linking the Sections were still in position, but now they were hanging loose. All stresses had 
been picked up by the balancing fields. In the Control Stage, I gradually turned on the propulsion units of 
each powered Section. Plasma was fed through the ergosphere of each kernel, picked up energy, and 
streamed aft. The relative positions of the Sections, Mossbauer-controlled to within fractions of a 
micrometer, held steady. We accelerated slowly away from L-5, and began the long spiral of a 
continuous-impulse orbit to Titan. 

My work was just about finished until crossover time. The computers monitored the drive feeds, the 
accelerations, and all the balance of the Sections. On this trip, we had three units without operating drive 
units: Section Two, where Yifter's guards were housed, just behind the Control Stage; Section Seven, 
where McAndrew had taken the kernel out of commission for his usual endless and mysterious 
experiments; and of course, the Control Stage itself. I had made the mistake of asking McAndrew what 
experiments he was planning for this trip. He looked at me with his innocent blue eyes and scribbled an 
answer full of twistor diagrams and spinor notation-knowing damn well that I wouldn't be able to follow 
it. He didn't like to talk about his work "halfcooked," as he put it. 

* * * 

I had been more worried than I wanted to admit about dinner on that first ship-evening. I knew we 
would all be itching to ask Yifter about the Lucies, but there was no easy way to introduce the subject 
into the conversation. How could we do it? "By the way, I hear that you killed a billion people a few 
months ago. I wonder if you would like to say a few words on the subject? It would liven up the 
table-talk at dinner." I could foresee that our conversation might be a little strained. 

As it turned out, my worries were unnecessary. The first impression that I'd had of Yifter, of a mild 
and amiable man, strengthened on longer exposure. It was Bryson, during dinner, who caused the first 
tricky moment. 

"Most of Earth's problems are caused by the United Space Federation's influence," he said as the 
robo-server, always on best form at the beginning of the trip, rolled in the courses. "If it weren't for the 
USF, there wouldn't be as much discontent and rioting on Earth. It's all relative, living space and living 
standards, and the USF sets a bad example. We can't compete." 


According to Bryson, three million people were causing all the problems for ten billion-eleven, before 
Yifter's handiwork. It was sheer nonsense, and as a USF citizen, I should have been the one to bridle; 
but it was McAndrew who made a growling noise of disapproval, down in his throat; and it was Yifter, 
of all people, who sensed the atmosphere quickest, and deftly steered the conversation to another 
subject. 

"I think Earth's worst problems are caused by the power shortage," he said. "That affects everything 
else. Why doesn't Earth use the kernels for power, the way that the USF does?" 

"Too afraid of an accident," replied McAndrew. His irritation evaporated immediately at the mention 
of his specialty. "If the shields ever failed, you would have a Kerr-Newman black hole sitting there, 
pumping out a thousand megawatts-mostly as high-energy radiation and fast particles. Worse than that, it 
would pull in free charge and become electrically neutral. As soon as that happened, there'd be no way 
to hold it electromagnetically. It would sink down and orbit inside the Earth. We couldn't afford to have 
that happen." 

"But couldn't we use smaller kernels on Earth?" asked Yifter. "They would be less dangerous." 

McAndrew shook his head. "It doesn't work that way. The smaller the black hole, the higher the 
effective temperature and the faster it radiates. You'd be better off with a much more massive black 
hole. But then you've got the problem of supporting it against Earth's gravity. Even with the best 
electromagnetic control, anything that massive would sink down into the Earth." 

"I suppose it wouldn't help to use a nonrotating, uncharged hole, either," said Yifter. "That might be 
easier to work with." 

"A Schwarzschild hole?" McAndrew looked at him in disgust. "Now, Mr. Yifter, you know better 
than that." He grew eloquent. "A Schwarzschild hole gives you no control at all. You can't get a hold of it 
electromagnetically. It just sits there, spewing out energy all over the spectrum, and there's nothing you 
can do to change it-unless you want to charge it and spin it up, and make it into a kernel. With the 
kernels, now, you have control." 

I tried to interrupt, but McAndrew was just getting warmed up. "A Schwarzschild hole is like a naked 
flame," he went on. "A caveman's device. A kernel is refined, it's controllable. You can spin it up and 
store energy, or you can use the ergosphere to pull energy out and spin it down. You can use the charge 
on it to move it about as you want. It's a real working instrument-not a bit of crudity from the Dark 
Ages." 

I shook my head, and sighed in simulated despair. "McAndrew, you have an unconsummated love 
affair with those blasted kernels." I turned to Yifter and Bryson, who had watched McAndrew's outburst 
with some surprise. "He spends all his waking hours spinning those things up and down. All the last trip, 
he was working the kernels in gravitational focusing experiments. You know, using the fact that a gravity 
field bends light rays. He insists that one day we won't use lenses for optics-we'll focus light using arrays 
of kernels." 

I made the old joke. "We hardly saw him on that trip. We were convinced that one day he'd get 
careless with the shields, fall into one of the kernels, and really make a spectacle of himself." 

They didn't get it. Yifter and Bryson looked at me blankly, while McAndrew, who'd heard it all ten 
times before, chuckled. I knew his simple sense of humor-a bad joke is always funny, even if it's the 
hundredth time you've heard it told. 

It's a strange thing, but after the first half-hour I had stopped thinking of Yifter as our prisoner. I could 
understand now why Bryson had objected to the idea of surrounding Yifter with armed guards. I'd have 
objected myself. He seemed the most civilized man in the group, with a warm personality and a very dry 
and subtle sense of humor. 

When Bryson left the table, pleading a long day and a lack of familiarity with a space environment, 
Yifter, McAndrew and I stayed on, chatting about the previous trips I had made to Titan. I mentioned 
the time I had taken the circus. 

"Do you know, I'd never seen most of those animals before," I said. "They were all on the list of 
endangered species. I don't think you could find them on Earth any more, except in a circus or a zoo." 
There was a moment of silence, then Yifter spoke. His eyes were mild and smiling, and his voice 


sounded dreamy and distant. 

"Endangered species," he said. "That's the heart of it. Earth has no room for failures. The weaker 
species, like weaker specimens of a species, must be eliminated. Only the strong-the mentally 
strong-may survive. The weak must be culled, for our own sake; whether that means one tenth, one half, 
or nine tenths of the total." 

There was a chilling pause. I looked at Yifter, whose expression had not changed, then at 
McAndrew, whose face reflected the horror that I was feeling. Yet behind all that, I could feel the 
unique power of the man. My mind was rejecting Yifter, but I still had a sense of well-being, of warmth 
in the pit of my stomach, as he was speaking. 

"We have made a beginning," went on Yifter quietly. "Just a beginning. Last time we were less 
successful than I had hoped. We had a breakdown in the distribution system for the drugs. I managed to 
eliminate the responsible individuals, but it was too late to correct the problem. Next time, God willing, it 
will be different." 

He rose to his feet, white hair shining like silver, face beatific. "Good night, Captain. Good night, 
Professor McAndrew. Sleep well." 

After he had left, McAndrew and I sat and looked at each other for a long time. Finally, he broke the 
spell. 

"Now we know, Jeanie. We should have guessed it from the beginning. Mad as a hatter. The man's a 
raving lunatic. Completely psychotic." 

That said most of it. McAndrew had used up all the good phrases. I nodded. 

"But did you feel the strength in him?" went on McAndrew. "Like a big magnet." 

I was glad that the penal colony was so far from Earth, and the avenues of communication so 
well-guarded. "Next time . . . it will be different." Our two-month trip suddenly seemed to have 
doubled in length. 

* * * 

After that single, chilling moment, there were no more shocks for some time. Our regular meal-time 
conversations continued, and on several occasions McAndrew voiced views on pacifism and the 
protection of human life. Each time, I waited for Yifter's reply, expecting the worst. He never actually 
agreed with Mac-but he did not come out with any statement that resembled his comments of the first 
ship-evening. 

We soon settled into the ship-board routine. McAndrew spent less and less time in the Control 
Stage, and more in Section Seven. On this trip, he had brought a new set of equipment for his 
experiments, and I was very curious to know what he was up to. He wouldn't tell. I had only one clue. 
Section Seven was drawing enormous energy from the other kernels in the rest of the Assembly. That 
energy could only be going to one place-into the kernel in Section Seven. I suspected that McAndrew 
must be spinning it up, making it closer to an "extreme" kernel, a Kerr-Newman black hole where the 
rotation energy matches the mass energy. I knew that couldn't be the whole story. McAndrew had spun 
up the kernels before, and he had told me that there was no direct way of getting a really extreme 
kernel-that would take an infinite amount of energy. This time, he was doing something different. He 
insisted that Section Seven had to be off-limits to everybody. 

I couldn't get him to talk about it. There would be a couple of seconds of silence from him, then he 
would stand there, cracking his finger joints as though he were snapping out a coded message to me. He 
could be a real sphinx when he chose. 

Two weeks from Earth, we were drawing clear of the main Asteroid Belt. I had just about concluded 
that my worries for the trip were over when the radar reported another ship, closing slowly with us from 
astern. Its spectral signature identified it as the Lesotho, a cruise liner that usually ran trajectories in the 
Inner System. It was broadcasting a Mayday, and flying free under zero drive power. 

I thought about it for a moment, then posted Emergency Stations throughout the Assembly. The 
computed trajectory showed that we would match velocities at a separation of three kilometers. That 
was incredibly close, far too close to be accidental. After closest approach, we would pull away 
again-we were still under power, accelerating outward, and would leave the Lesotho behind. 


I was still watching the displays, trying to decide whether or not to take the next step-shutting off the 
drives-when Bryson appeared, with Yifter just behind him. 

"Captain Roker," he said, in his usual imperious manner. "That's an Earth ship there, giving you a 
distress signal. Why aren't you doing anything about it?" 

"If we wait just a few minutes," I said. "We'll be within spitting distance of her. I see no point in 
rushing in, until we've had a good look at her. I can't think what an Inner System ship would be doing, 
free-falling out here beyond the Belt." 

That didn't cool him. "Can't you recognize an emergency when you see one?" he said. "If you won't 
do something productive with your people, I'll do something with mine." 

I wondered what he wanted me to do, but he walked away without saying anything more, down the 
stairs that led to the rear communication area of the Control Stage. I turned back to the displays. The 
Lesotho was closing on us steadily, and now I could see that her locks were open. I cut our propulsion 
to zero and switched off all the drives. The other ship was tumbling slowly, drive lifeless and aft nacelles 
crumpled. Even from this distance, I could see that she would need extensive repairs before she could 
function again. 

I was beginning to think that I had been over-cautious when two things happened. Yifter's guards, 
who had been housed behind the Control Stage in Section Two, began to float into view on the viewing 
screen that pointed towards the Lesotho. They were all in space armor and heavily weaponed. At the 
same time two suited figures appeared in the open forward lock of the other vessel. I cut in the suit 
frequencies on our main board. 

"-shield failure," said the receiver. "Twenty-seven survivors, and bad injuries. We must have 
painkillers, medical help, water, food, oxygen and power-packs." 

With that, one group of our guards outside began to move towards the two suited figures in the 
Lesotho's lock, while the remainder stayed close to the Assembly, looking across at the other ship. 
Subconsciously, I noted the number of our guards in each party, then gave them my full attention and did 
a rapid re-count. Twenty-five. All our guards. I swore and cut in the transmitter. 

"Sergeant, get half of those men back inside the Assembly shields. This is Captain Roker. I'm 
over-riding any other orders you may have received. Get the nearer party-" 

I was interrupted. The display screen flashed blue-white, then over-loaded. The whole Control Stage 
rang like a great bell, as something slapped hard on the outer shield. I knew what it was: a huge pulse of 
hard radiation and highly energetic particles, smashing into us in a fraction of a microsecond. 

Yifter had been floating within a couple of meters of me, watching the screens. He put his hand to the 
wall to orient himself as the Control Stage vibrated violently. "What was that?" 

"Thermonuclear explosion," I said shortly. "Hundred megaton plus. On the Lesotho." 

All the screens on that side were dead. I activated the standby system. The Lesotho had vanished. 
The guards had vanished with it, vaporized instantly. All the cables linking the parts of the Assembly, all 
the scanners and sensors that were not protected behind the shields, were gone. The Sections 
themselves were intact, but their coupling fields would have to be completely recalibrated. We wouldn't 
be arriving at Titan on schedule. 

I looked again at Yifter. His face was now calm and thoughtful. He seemed to be waiting, listening 
expectantly. For what? If the Lesotho had been a suicide mission, manned by volunteers who sought 
revenge on Yifter, they hadn't had a chance. They couldn't destroy the Assembly, or get at Yifter. If 
revenge were not the purpose, what was the purpose? 

I ran through in my mind the events of the past hour. With the drives switched off in the Assembly, 
we had an unprotected blind spot, dead astern. We had been putting all our attention on the Lesotho. 
Now, with the guards all dead, the Control Stage was undefended. 

It was quicker to go aft and take a look than to call Bryson or McAndrew and ask them what they 
could see from the rear viewing screens of the Control Stage. Leaving Yifter, I dived head-first down the 
stairway-a risky maneuver if there were any chance that the drive might come back on, but I was sure it 
couldn't. 

It took me about thirty seconds to travel the length of the Control Stage. By the time that I was 


halfway, I knew I had been thinking much too slowly. I heard the clang of a lock, a shout, and the 
sputtering crackle of a hand laser against solid metal. When I got to the rear compartment, it was all 
finished. Bryson, pale and open-mouthed, was floating against one wall. He seemed unhurt. McAndrew 
had fared less well. He was ten meters farther along, curled into a fetal ball. Floating near him I saw a 
family of four stubby pink worms with red-brown heads, still unclenching with muscle spasm. I could 
also see the deep burn on his side and chest, and his right hand, from which a laser had neatly clipped 
the fingers and cauterized the wound instantly as it did so. At the far end of the room, braced against the 
wall, were five suited figures, all well-armed. 

Heroics would serve no purpose. I spread my arms wide to show that I was not carrying a weapon, 
and one of the newcomers pushed off from the wall and floated past me, heading towards the front of 
the Control Stage. I moved over to McAndrew and inspected his wounds. They looked bad, but not 
fatal. Fortunately, laser wounds are usually very clean. I could see that we would have problems with his 
lung unless we treated him quickly. A lobe had been penetrated, and his breathing was slowly breaking 
the seal of crisped tissue that the laser had made. Blood was beginning to well through and stain his 
clothing. 

McAndrew's forehead was beaded with sweat. As the shock of his wound wore off, the pain was 
beginning. I pointed to the medical belt of one of the invaders, who nodded and tossed an ampoule 
across to me. I injected McAndrew at the big vein inside his right elbow. 

The figure who had pushed past me was returning, followed by Yifter. The face plate of the suit was 
now open, revealing a dark-haired woman in her early thirties. She looked casually at the scene, nodded 
at last, and turned back to Yifter. 

"Everything's under control here," she said. "But we'll have to take a Section from the Assembly. The 
ship we were following in caught some of the blast from the Lesotho, and it's no good for powered flight 
now." 

Yifter shook his head reprovingly. "Impatient as usual, Akhtar. I'll bet you were just too eager to get 
here. You must learn patience if you are to be of maximum value to us, my dear. Where did you leave 
the main group?" 

"A few hours drive inward from here. We have waited for your rescue, before making any plans for 
the next phase." 

Yifter, calm as ever, nodded approvingly. "The right decision. We can take a Section without 
difficulty. Most of them contain their own drives, but some are less effective than others." 

He turned to me, smiling gently. "Jeanie Roker, which Section is the best equipped to carry us away 
from the Assembly? As you see, it is time for us to leave you and rejoin our colleagues." 

His calm was worse than any number of threats. I floated next to McAndrew, trying to think of some 
way that we could delay or impede the Lucies' escape. It might take days for a rescue party to reach us. 
In that time, Yifter and his followers could be anywhere. 

I hesitated. Yifter waited. "Come now," he said at last. "I'm sure you are as eager as I am to avoid 
any further annoyance"-he moved his hand, just a little, to indicate McAndrew and Bryson-"for your 
friends." 

I shrugged. All the Sections contained emergency life-support systems, more than enough for a trip of 
a few hours. Section Two, where the guards had been housed, lacked a full, independent drive unit, but 
it was still capable of propulsion. I thought it might slow their escape enough for us somehow to track it. 

"Section Two should be adequate," I said. "It housed your guards in comfort. Those poor devils 
certainly have no need for it now." 

I paused. Beside me, McAndrew was painfully straightening from his contorted position. The drugs 
were beginning to work. He coughed, and red globules floated away across the room. That lung needed 
attention. 

"No," he said faintly. "Not Two, Yifter. Seven. Section Seven." 

He paused and coughed again, while I looked at him in surprise. 

"Seven," he said at last. He looked at me. "No killing, Jeanie. No-Killing vector." 

The woman was listening closely. She regarded both of us suspiciously. "What was all that about?" 


My mouth was gaping open as wide as Bryson's. I had caught an idea of what McAndrew was trying 
to tell me, but I didn't want to say it. Fortunately, I was helped out by Yifter himself. 

"No killing," he said. "My dear, you have to understand that Professor McAndrew is a devoted 
pacifist-and carrying his principles through admirably. He doesn't want to see any further killing. I think I 
can agree with that-for the present." 

He looked at me and shook his head. "I won't inquire what dangers and drawbacks Section Two 
might contain, Captain-though I do seem to recall that it lacks a decent drive unit. I think we'll follow the 
Professor's advice and take Section Seven. Akhtar is a very competent engineer, and I'm sure she'll 
have no trouble coupling the drive to the kernel." 

He looked at us with a strange expression. If it didn't sound so peculiar, I'd describe it as wistful. "I 
shall miss our conversations," he said. "But I must say goodbye now. I hope that Professor McAndrew 
will recover. He is one of the strong-unless he allows himself to be killed by his unfortunate pacifist 
fancies. We may not meet again, but I am sure that you will be hearing about us in the next few months." 

They left. McAndrew, Bryson and I watched the screens in silence, as the Lucies made their way 
over to Section Seven and entered it. Once they were inside, I went over to McAndrew and took him 
by the left arm. 

"Come on," I said. "We have to get a patch on that lung." 

He shook his head weakly. "Not yet. It can wait a few minutes. After that, it might not be necessary." 

His forehead was beading with sweat again-and this time it was not from pain. I felt my own tension 
mounting steadily. We stayed by the display screen, and as the seconds ticked away my own forehead 
began to film with perspiration. We did not speak. I had one question, but I was terribly afraid of the 
answer I might get. I think that Bryson spoke to both of us several times. I have no idea what he said. 

Finally, a pale nimbus grew at the rear of the Section Seven drive unit. 

"Now," said McAndrew. "He's going to tap the kernel." 

I stopped breathing. There was a pause of a few seconds, stretching to infinity, then the image on the 
screen rippled slightly. Suddenly, we could see stars shining through that area. Section Seven was gone, 
vanished, with no sign that it had ever existed. 

McAndrew took in a long, pained breath, wincing as his injured lung expanded. Somehow, he 
managed a little smile. 

"Well now," he said. "That answers a theoretical question that I've had on my mind for some time." 

I could breathe again, too. "I didn't know what was going to happen there," I said. "I was afraid all 
the energy might come out of that kernel in one go." 

McAndrew nodded. "To be honest, that thought was in my head, too. At this range, the shields 
would have been useless. We'd have gone like last year's lovers." 

Bryson had been watching the whole thing in confusion. We had been ignoring him completely. At 
last, pale and irritable, he spoke to us again. 

"What are you two talking about? And what's happened to the Section with Yifter in it? I was 
watching on the screen, then it just seemed to disappear." 

"McAndrew tried to tell us earlier," I said. "But he didn't want the Lucies to know what he was 
getting at. He'd been fiddling with the kernel in that Section. You heard what he said-no Killing vector. I 
don't know what he did, but he fixed it so that the kernel in Section Seven had no Killing vector." 

"I'm sure he did," said Bryson tartly. "Now perhaps you'll tell me what a Killing vector is." 

"Well, Mac could tell you a lot better than I can. But a Killing vector is a standard sort of thing in 
relativity-I guess you never had any training in that. You get a Killing vector when a region of space-time 
has some sort of symmetry-say, about an axis of spin. And every sort of black hole, every sort of kernel 
we've ever encountered before, has at least one symmetry of that type. So if McAndrew changed the 
kernel and made it into something with no Killing vector, it's like no kernel we've ever seen. Right, Mac?" 

He looked dreamy. The drugs had taken hold. "I took it past the extreme Kerr-Newman form," he 
said. "Put it into a different form, metastable equilibrium. Event horizon had disappeared, all the Killing 
vectors had disappeared." 

"Christ!" I hadn't expected that. "No event horizon? Doesn't that mean you get-?" 


McAndrew was still nodding, eye pupils dilated. "-a naked singularity. That's right, Jeanie, I had a 
naked singularity, sitting there in equilibrium in Section Seven. You don't get there by spinning-up-need 
different method." His speech was slurring, as though his tongue was swollen. "Didn't know what would 
happen if somebody tried to tap it, to use for a drive. Either the signature of space-time there would 
change, from three space dimensions and one time, to two space and two time. Or we might see the 
System's biggest explosion. All the mass coming out as radiation, in one flash." 

It was slowly dawning on Bryson what we were saying. "But just where is Yifter now?" he asked. 

"Gone a long way," I said. "Right out of this universe." 

"And he can't be brought back?" asked Bryson. 

"I hope not." I'd seen more than enough of Yifter. 

"But I'm supposed to deliver him safely to Titan," said Bryson. "I'm responsible for his safe passage. 
What am I going to tell the Planetary Coordinators?" 

I didn't have much sympathy. I was too busy looking at McAndrew's wounds. The fingers could be 
regenerated using the bio-feedback equipment on Titan, but the lung would need watching. It was still 
bleeding a little. 

"Tell them you had a very singular experience," I said. McAndrew grunted as I probed the deep cut 
in his side. "Sorry, Mac. Have to do it. You know, you've ruined your reputation forever as far as I'm 
concerned. I thought you were a pacifist? All that preaching at us, then you send Yifter and his lot all the 
way to Hell-and good riddance to them." 

McAndrew was drifting far away on his big dose of painkillers. He half-winked at me and made his 
curious throat-clearing noise. 

"Och, I'm a pacifist all right. We pacifists have to look after each other. How could we ever hope for 
peace with people like Yifter around to stir up trouble? There's a bunch more of them, a few hours travel 
behind us. Fix me up quick, Jeanie. I should be tinkering with the other kernels a bit-just in case the 
other Lucies decide to pay us a visit later . . ." 


SECOND CHRONICLE: Moment of Inertia 


"Now," said the interviewer, "tell us just what led you to the ideas for the inertia-less drive." 

She was young and vulnerable-looking, and I think that was what saved her from a hot reply. As it 
was, McAndrew just shook his head and said quietly-but still with feeling-"Not the inertia-less drive. 
There's no such thing. It's a balanced drive." 

She looked confused. "But it lets you accelerate at more than fifty gees, doesn't it? By making you so 
you don't feel any acceleration at all. Doesn't that mean you must have no inertia?" 

McAndrew was shaking his head again. He looked pained and resigned. I suppose that he had to go 
through this explanation twice a day, every day of his life, with somebody. 

I leaned forward and lowered the sound on the video unit. I had heard the story too often, and my 
sympathies were all with him. We had direct evidence that the McAndrew drive was anything but 
inertia-less. I doubt if he'll ever get that message across to the average person, even though he's most 
people's idea of the "great scientist," the ultimate professor. 

I was there at the beginning of the whole thing. In fact, according to McAndrew I was the beginning. 
We had been winding our way back from the Titan Colony, travelling light as we usually did on the 
inbound leg. We had only four Sections in the Assembly, and only two of them carried power kernels 
and drive units, so I guess we massed about three billion tons for ship and cargo. 

Halfway in, just after turnover point, we got an incoming request for medical help from the mining 
colony on Horus. I passed the word on to Luna Station, but we couldn't do much to help. Horus is in the 
Egyptian Cluster of asteroids, way out of the ecliptic, and it would take any aid mission a couple of 
weeks to get to them. By that time, I suspected their problem would be over-one way or another. So I 
was in a pretty gloomy mood when McAndrew and I sat down to dinner. 

"I didn't know what to tell them, Mac. They know the score as well as I do, but they couldn't resist 
asking if we had a fast-passage ship that could help them. I had to tell them the truth, there's nothing that 
can get out there at better than two and a half gees, not with people on board. And they need doctors, 
not just drugs. Luna will have something on the way in a couple of days, but I don't think that will do it." 

McAndrew nodded sympathetically. He knew that I needed to talk it out to somebody, and we've 
spent a lot of time together on those Titan runs. He's working on his own experiments most of the time, 
but I know when he needs company, too. It must be nice to be a famous scientist, but it can be lonely 
travelling all the time inside your own head. 

"I wonder if we're meant for space, Mac," I went on-only half-joking. "We've got drives that will let 
us send unmanned probes out at better than a hundred gees of continuous acceleration, but we're the 
weak link. I could take the Assembly here up to five gee-we'd be home in a couple of days instead of 
another month-but you and I couldn't take it. Can't you and some of your staff at the Institute come up 
with a system so that we don't get crushed flat by high accelerations? A thing like that, an inertia-less 
drive, it would change space exploration completely." 

I was wandering on, just to keep my mind off the problems they had out on Horus, but what I was 
saying was sound enough. We had the power on the ships, only the humans were the obstacle. 
McAndrew was listening to me seriously, but he was shaking his head. 

"So far as I know, Jeanie, an inertia-less drive is a theoretical impossibility. Unless somebody a lot 
brighter than I am can come up with an entirely new theory of physics, we'll not see your inertia-less 
drive." 

That was a pretty definitive answer. There were no people brighter than McAndrew, at least in the 
area of physics. If Mac didn't think it could be done, you'd not find many people arguing with him. Some 
people were fooled by the fact that he took time off to make trips with me out to Titan, but that was all 
part of his way of working. 

If you deduce from this that I'm not up at that rarefied level of thought, you're quite right. I can follow 
McAndrew's explanations-sometimes. But when he really gets going he loses me in the first two 
sentences. 


This time, his words seemed clear enough for anyone to follow them. I poured myself another glass of 
ouzo and wondered how many centuries it would be before the man or woman with the completely new 
theory came along. Sitting across from me, Mac had begun to rub at his sandy, receding hairline. His 
expression had become vacant. I've learned not to interrupt when he's got that look on his face. It means 
he's thinking in a way that I can't follow. One of the other professors at the Penrose Institute says that 
Mac has a mind that can see round corners, and I have a little inkling what he means by that. 

"Why inertia-less, Jeanie?" said McAndrew after a few minutes. 

Maybe he hadn't been listening after all. "So we can use high accelerations. So we can get people to 
go at the same speeds as the unmanned probes. They'd be flattened at fifty gee, you know that. We 
need an inertia-less drive so that we can stand that acceleration without being squashed to a mush." 

"But that's not the same thing at all. I told you that a drive with no inertia isn't possible-and it isn't. 
What you're asking for, now, it seems to me that we should be able . . ." 
His voice drifted off to nothing, he stood up, and without another word he left the cabin. I wondered 
what I'd started. 
If that was the beginning of the McAndrew drive-as I think it was-then, yes, I was there at the very 
beginning. 
* * * 

So far as I could tell, it wasn't only the beginning. It was also the end. Mac didn't talk about the 
subject again on our way in to Luna rendezvous, even though I tried to nudge him a couple of times. He 
was always the same, he didn't like to talk about his ideas when they were "half-cooked," as he called it. 

When we got to Luna, McAndrew went off back to the Institute, and I took a cargo out to Cybele. 
End of story, and it gradually faded from my thoughts, until the time came, seven months later, for the 
next run to Titan. 

For the first time in five years, McAndrew didn't make the trip. He didn't call me, but I got a brief 
message that he was busy with an off-Earth project, and wouldn't be free for several months. I 
wondered, not too seriously, if Mac's absence could be connected with inertia-less spaceships, and then 
went on with the cargo to Titan. 

That was the trip where some lunatic in the United Space Federation's upper bureaucracy decided 
that Titan was overdue for some favorable publicity, as a thriving colony where culture would be 
welcomed. Fine. They decided to combine culture and nostalgia, and hold on Titan a full-scale, 
old-fashioned Miss & Mister Universe competition. It apparently never occurred to the organizers-who 
must have had minds that could not see in straight lines, let alone around corners-that the participants 
were bound to take the thing seriously once it was started. Beauty is not something that good-looking 
people are willing to take lightly. I had the whole Assembly filled with gorgeous, jealous contestants, 
screaming managers, horny and ever-hopeful newshounds from every media outlet in the System, and 
any number of vengeful and vigilant wives, lovers and mistresses of both sexes. On one of my earlier 
runs I took a circus and zoo out to Titan, but that was nothing compared with this trip. Thank Heaven 
that the ship is computer-controlled. All my time was spent in keeping some of the passengers together 
and the rest apart. 

It also hadn't occurred to the organizers, back on Earth, that a good part of the Titan colony is the 
prison. When I saw the first interaction of the prisoners and the contestants I realized that the trip out to 
Titan had been a picnic compared with what was about to follow. I chickened out and went back to the 
ship until it was all over. 

I couldn't really escape, though. When it was all over, when the winners had finally been chosen, 
when the protests and the counter-protests had all been lodged, when the battered remnants of the more 
persistent prisoners had been carried back to custody, when mayhem was stilled, and when the colonists 
of Titan must have felt that they had enjoyed as much of Inner System culture as they could stand for 
another twenty or thirty years, after all that it was my job to get the group back on board again, and 
home to Earth without further violence. The contestants hated their managers, the managers hated the 
judges, the judges hated the news media, and everyone hated the winners. It seemed to me that 
McAndrew may have had advance information about the trip, and drawn a correct conclusion. 


I would like to have skipped it myself. Since I was stuck with it, I separated the Sections of the 
Assembly as much as I could, put everything onto automatic, and devoted myself to consoling one of the 
losers, a smooth-skinned armful from one of the larger asteroids. 

We finally got there. On that day of rejoicing, the whole ghastly gaggle connected with the contest left 
the Assembly, I said a lingering farewell to my friend from Vesta-a most inappropriate origin for that 
particular contestant-and settled back for a needed rest. 

It lasted for about eight hours. As soon as I called into the Com Center for news and messages, I got 
a terse summons on the com display: GO TO PENROSE INSTITUTE, L-4 STATION. MACAVITY. 

Not an alarming message, on the face of it, but it worried me. It was from McAndrew, and I doubt if 
three people knew that I had given him that nickname when I found he was a specialist on theories of 
gravity ("Old Possum's Book Of Practical Cats" didn't seem to be widely read among Mac's colleagues). 

Why hadn't he called me directly, instead of sending a com-link message? The fact that we were 
back from Titan would have been widely reported. I sat down at the terminal and placed a link to the 
Institute, person-to-person to McAndrew. 

I didn't feel any better when the call went through. Instead of Mac's familiar face, I was looking at the 
coal-black complexion of Professor Limperis, the head of the Institute. He nodded at me seriously. 

"Captain Roker, your timing is impressive. If we had received no response to Professor McAndrew's 
coded message in the next eight hours, we would have proceeded without you. Can you help?" 

He hesitated, seeing my confused expression. "Did your message tell you the background of the 
problem?" 

"Dr. Limperis, all I've had so far is half a dozen words-to go to the L-4 branch of the Institute. I can 
do that easily enough, but I have no idea what the problem is, or what use I could possibly be on it. 
Where's Mac?" 

"I wish to God I could answer that." He sat silent for a moment, chewing on his lower lip, then 
shrugged. "Professor McAndrew insisted that we send for you-left a message specifically for you. He 
told us that you were the stimulus for beginning the whole thing." 

"What whole thing?'' 

He looked at me in even greater surprise. "Why, the high acceleration drive-the balanced drive that 
McAndrew has been developing for the past year. McAndrew has disappeared testing the prototype. 
Can you come at once to the Institute?" 

The trip out to the Institute, creeping along in the Space Tug from Luna Station, was one of the low 
points of my life. There was no particular logic to it-after all, I'd done nothing wrong. But I couldn't get 
rid of the feeling that I'd wasted a critical eight hours after the passengers had left the Assembly. If I 
hadn't been obsessed with sex on the trip back, maybe I would have gone straight to the com-link 
instead of taking a sleep break. And maybe then I would have been on my way that much earlier, and 
that would have been the difference between saving Mac and failing to save him . . . 

You can see how my mind was running. Without any real facts, you can make bears out of bushes 
just as well in space as you can on Earth. All I had been told by Limperis was that McAndrew had left a 
week earlier on a test of the prototype of a new ship. If he was not back within a hundred and fifty 
hours, he had left that terse coded message for me, and instructions-orders might be a better word-to 
take me along on any attempted search for him. 

Dr. Limperis had been very apologetic about it. "I'm only quoting Professor McAndrew, you 
understand. He said that he didn't want any rescue party setting out in the Dotterel if you weren't part of 
it. He said"-Limperis coughed uncomfortably-"we had a real need for your common sense and natural 
cowardice. We'll be waiting for you here as soon as you can arrange passage. The least we can do for 
Professor McAndrew in the circumstances is to honor his wishes on this." 

I couldn't decide if I was being complimented or not. As L-4 Station crept into view on the forward 
screen, I peered at it on highest magnification, trying to see what the rescue ship looked like. I could see 
the bulk of the Institute structure but no sign of anything that ought to be a ship. I had visions of a sort of 
super-Assembly, a huge cluster of electromagnetically linked spheres. All I could see were living 
quarters and docking facilities, and, as we came in to dock, a peculiar construction like a flat, shiny plate 


with a long thin spike protruding from the center. It looked nothing like any USF ship, passenger or 
cargo. 

Limperis may have spent his whole life in pure research, but he knew how to organize for emergency 
action. There were just five people in our meeting inside the Institute. I had never met them in person, 
but they were all familiar to me through McAndrew's descriptions, and from media coverage. Limperis 
himself had made a life study of high-density matter. He knew every kernel below lunar mass out to a 
couple of hundred astronomical units-many of them he had visited, and a few of the small ones he had 
shunted back with him to the Inner System, to use as power supplies. 

Siclaro was the specialist in kernel energy extraction. The Kerr-Newman black holes were 
well-understood theoretically, but efficient use of them was still a matter for experts. When the USF 
wanted to know the best way to draw off power, for drives or for general use, Siclaro was usually called 
in. His name on a recommendation was like a stamp of approval that few would think to question. 

With Gowers there as an expert in multiple kernel arrays, Macedo as the System authority in 
electromagnetic coupling, and Wenig the master of compressed matter stability, the combined intellect in 
that one room in the Institute was overpowering. I looked at the three men and two women who had just 
been introduced to me, and felt like a gorilla in a ballet. I might make the right movements, but I wouldn't 
know what was going on. 

"Look, Dr. Limperis," I said, "I know what Professor McAndrew wants, but I'm not sure he's right." 
Might as well hit them with my worries at the beginning, and not waste everybody's time. "I can run a 
ship, sure-it's not hard. But I've no idea how to run something with a McAndrew drive on it. Any one of 
you could probably do a better job." 

Limperis was looking apologetic again. "Yes and no, Captain Roker. We could all handle the ship, 
any one of us. The concepts behind it are simple-a hundred and fifty years old. And the engineering has 
been kept simple, too, since we are dealing with a prototype." 

"Then what do you want me for?" I won't say I was angry, but I was uneasy and unhappy, and 
there's a fine line between irritation and discomfort. 

"Dr. Wenig will drive the Dotterel, he has handled it before in an earlier test. Actually, he handled the 
Merganser, the ship that Dr. McAndrew has disappeared in, but the Dotterel has identical design and 
equipment. Controlling the ship is easy-if everything behaves as we expected. If something goes 
wrong-and something must have gone wrong, or McAndrew would be back before this-then neither Dr. 
Wenig, nor any of the rest of us, has the experience that will be needed. We want you to tell Dr. Wenig 
what not to do. You've been through dangerous times before." He looked pleading. "Will you observe 
our actions, and use your experience to advise us?" 

Uninvited, I flopped down into a seat and stared at the five of them. "You want me to be a bloody 
canary!" 

"A canary?" Wenig was small and slight, with a luxuriant black mustache. He had a strong accent, 
and I think he was suspecting himself of a translation error. 

"Right. Back when people used to go down deep in the earth to mine coal, they used to take a 
canary along with them. It was more sensitive to poisonous gases than they were. When it fell off the 
perch, they knew it was time to leave. The rest of you will fly the ship, and watch for me to fall off my 
seat." 

They looked at each other, and finally Limperis nodded. "We need a canary, Captain Roker. None 
of us here knows how to sing at the right time. Will you do it?" 

I had no choice. Not after Mac's personal cry for help. I could see one problem-I'd be telling them 
everything they did was dangerous. When you have a new piece of technology, it is risky, whatever you 
do with it. 

"You mean you'll let me overrule all the rest of you, if I don't feel comfortable?" 

"We would." Limperis was quite firm about it. "But the question will not arise. The Merganser and 
the Dotterel are both two-person ships. We saw no point in making them larger. Dr. Wenig will fly the 
Dotterel, and you will be the only other person aboard. It just takes one person to handle the controls. 
You will be there to advise of hidden problems." 


I stood up. "Let's go. I don't think I can see danger any better than you can, but I may be wrong. If 
Mac's on his own out there, wherever he is, we'd better get moving. I'm ready when you are, Dr. 
Wenig." 

Nobody moved. Maybe McAndrew and Limperis were right about my antennae, because at that 
moment I had a premonition of new problems. I looked around at the uncomfortable faces. 

"Professor McAndrew isn't actually alone on the Merganser." It was Emma Gowers who spoke 
first. "He has a passenger with him on the ship." 

"Someone from the Institute?" 

She shook her head. "Nina Velez is with him." 

"Nina Velez? You don't mean President Velez's daughter-the one with AG News?" 

She nodded. "The same." 

I sat down again in my chair. Hard. Maybe the Body-beautiful run to Titan had been an easier trip 
than I had realized. 

* * * 

Wenig may have come to piloting second-hand, but he certainly knew his ship. He wanted me to 
know it, too. Before we left the Institute, we'd done the lot-schematics, models, components, power, life 
support, mechanicals, electricals, electronics, controls, and backups. 

When the ship was explained to me, I decided that McAndrew didn't really see round corners when 
he thought. It was just that things were obvious to him before they were explained, and obvious to other 
people afterwards. I had been saying "inertia-less" to Mac, and he had been just as often saying 
"impossible." But we hadn't been communicating very well. All I wanted was a drive that would let us 
accelerate at multiple gees without flattening the passengers. To McAndrew, that was a simple 
requirement, one that he could easily satisfy-but there was no question of doing away with inertia, of 
passengers or ship. 

"Take it back to basics," said Wenig, when he was showing me how the Dotterel worked. 
"Remember the equivalence principle? That's at the heart of it. There is no way of distinguishing an 
accelerated motion from a gravitational field force, right?" 

I had no trouble with that. It was freshman physics. "Sure. You'd be flattened just as well in a really 
high gravity field as you would in a ship accelerating at fifty gee. But where does it get you?" 

"Imagine that you were standing on something with a hefty gravity field-Jupiter, say. You'd experience 
a downward force of about two and a half gee. Now suppose that somebody could accelerate Jupiter 
away from you, downwards, at two and a half gee. You'd fall towards it, but you'd never reach it-it 
would be accelerating at the same rate as you are. And you'd feel as though you were in free fall, but so 
far as the rest of the Universe is concerned you'd be accelerating at two and a half gee, same as Jupiter. 
That's what the equivalence principle is telling us, that acceleration and gravity can cancel out, if they're 
set up to be equal and opposite." 

As soon as you got used to Wenig's accent, he was easy to follow-I doubt if anybody could get into 
the Institute unless he was more than bright enough to explain concepts in easy terms. 

I nodded. "I can understand that easily enough. But you've just replaced one problem with a worse 
one. You can't find any drive in the Universe that could accelerate Jupiter at two and a half gee." 

"We cannot-not yet, at any rate. Luckily, we don't need to use Jupiter. We can do it with something a 
lot smaller, and a lot closer. Let's look at the Dotterel and the Merganser. At McAndrew's request I 
designed the mass element for both of them." 

He went across to the window that looked out from the inside of the Institute to raw space. The 
Dotterel was floating about ten kilometers away, close enough to see the main components. 

"See the plate on the bottom? It's a hundred meter diameter disk of compressed matter, 
electromagnetically stabilized and one meter thick. Density's about eleven hundred and seventy tons per 
cubic centimeter-pretty high, but nothing near as high as we've worked with here at the Institute. Less 
than you get in anything but the top couple of centimeters of a neutron star, and nowhere near 
approaching kernel densities. Now, if you were sitting right at the center of that disk, you'd experience a 
gravitational acceleration of fifty gee pulling you down to the disk. Tidal forces on you would be one 


gee per meter-not enough to trouble you. If you stayed on the axis of the disk, and moved away from it, 
you'd feel an attractive force of one gee when you were two hundred and forty-six meters from the 
center of the disk. See the column growing out from the disk? It's four meters across and two hundred 
and fifty meters long." 

I looked at it through the scope. The long central spike seemed to be completely featureless, a slim 
column of grey metal. 

"What's inside it?" 

"Mostly nothing." Wenig picked up a model of the Dotterel and cracked it open lengthwise, so that I 
could see the interior structure. "When the drives are off, the living-capsule is out here at the far end, two 
hundred and fifty meters from the dense disk. Gravity feels like one gee, toward the center of the disk. 
See the drives here, on the disk itself? They accelerate the whole thing away from the center column, so 
the disk stays flat and perpendicular to the motion. The bigger the acceleration that the drives produce, 
the closer to the disk we move the living-capsule up the central column here. We keep it so the total 
force in the capsule, gravity less acceleration, is always one gee, toward the disk." 

He slid the capsule along an electromechanical ladder closer to the disk. "It's easy to compute the 
right distance for any acceleration-the computer has it built-in, but you could do it by hand in a few 
minutes. When the drives are accelerating the whole thing at fourteen gee, the capsule is held a little less 
than fifty meters from the disk. I've been on a test run in the Merganser where we got up to almost 
twenty gee. Professor McAndrew intended to take it up to higher accelerations on this test. To 
accelerate at thirty-two gee, the capsule must be about twenty meters from the disk to keep effective 
gravity inside to one gee. The plan was to take the system all the way up to design maximum-fifty gee 
thrust acceleration, so that the passengers in the capsule would be right up against the disk, and feel as 
though they were in free fall. Gravity and thrust accelerations will exactly balance." 

I was getting goose bumps along the back of my neck. I knew the performance of the unmanned med 
ships. They would zip you from inside the orbit of Mercury out to Pluto in a couple of days, standing 
start to standing finish. Once in a while you'd get a passenger on them-accident or suicide. The flattened 
thing that they unpacked at the other end showed what the human body thought of a hundred gee. 

"What would happen if the drives went off suddenly?" I said. 

"You mean when the capsule is up against the disk-at maximum thrust?" Wenig shook his head. "We 
designed a safeguard system to prevent that, even on the prototypes. If there were a sign of the drive 
cutting off, the capsule would be moved back up the column, away from the disk. The system for that is 
built-in." 

"Yeah. But McAndrew hasn't come back." I had the urge to get on our way. "I've seen built-in-safe 
systems before. The more foolproof you think something is, the worse the failure when it happens. Can't 
we get moving?" 

"Come on." Wenig stood up. "Any teacher will tell you, you can't get much into an impatient learner. 
I'll give you the rest of the story as we go. We'll head out along the same path as McAndrew did-that's 
plotted out in the records back here." 

"You think McAndrew went along with the nominal flight plan?" 

"We know he didn't." Wenig looked a lot less sure of himself. "You see, when the drives are on 
maximum the plasma round the living-capsule column interferes with radio signals. Fifty hours after they 
left the Institute, the Merganser was tracked from Triton Station. McAndrew came back into the Solar 
System, decelerating at fifty gee. He didn't cut the drive at all-just went right through the System and 
accelerated out again in a slightly different direction. We got the log, but we have no idea what he was 
doing. There was no way to get a signal to him or from him with the drive on." 

"So they got all the way up to the maximum drive! And they came back here. God, why didn't 
Limperis tell me that when we were in the first meeting?" I went to the locker and pulled out a suit. "He 
took it up all the way, fifty gee or better. Let's get after him. If he kept that up, he'll be halfway to Alpha 
Centauri by now." 

The living-capsule was about three meters across and simply furnished. I was surprised at the amount 
of room, until Wenig pointed out to me how equipment and supplies that could take higher accelerations 


were situated on the outside of the capsule, on the side away from the gravity disk. 

We had started with McAndrew's flight plan for only a few minutes when I took Limperis at his word 
that I'd be boss and changed the procedure. If we were to reach McAndrew, the less time we spent 
shooting off in the wrong direction, the better. He had come right through the System, and we ought to 
head in the direction that he was last seen to be heading. 

"I'll take us up to fifty gee," said Wenig. "That way, we'll experience the same perturbing forces as the 
Merganser did. All right?" 

"Christ, no." My stomach turned over. "Not all right. Look, we don't know what happened to Mac, 
but chances are it was some problem with the ship. If we do just what he did, we may finish up with the 
same trouble." 

Wenig took his hands off the controls and turned to me, palms spread. "But then what can we do? 
We don't know where they were going, all we can do is try and follow the same track." 

"I'm not sure. All I know is what we're not going to do-and we're not trying for top acceleration. 
Didn't you say you'd flown Merganser at twenty gee?" 

"Several times." 

"Then take us out along Mac's trajectory at twenty gee until we're outside the System. Then cut the 
drive. I want to use our sensors, and we won't be able to do that from the middle of a ball of plasma." 

Wenig looked at me. I know he was mentally accusing me of cowardice. "Captain Roker," he said 
quietly. "I thought we were in a hurry. We may be weeks following Merganser the way you are 
proposing." 

"Yeah. But we'll get there. Can Mac's support system last that long?" 

"Easily." 

"Then don't let's kick it around any more. Let's do it. Twenty gee, as soon as you can give it to us." 

* * * 

The Dotterel worked like a dream. At twenty gee acceleration relative to the Solar System, we 
didn't feel anything unusual at all. The disk pulled us towards it at twenty-one gee, the acceleration of the 
ship pulled us away from it at twenty gee, and we sat there in the middle at a snug and comfortable 
standard gravity. I couldn't even feel the tidal forces, though I knew they were there. We had poor 
communications with the Penrose Institute, but we'd known that and expected to make up for it when 
we cut the drive. 

Oddly enough, the first phase of the trip wasn't scary-it was boring. I wanted to get up to a good 
cruise speed before we coasted free. It gave me the chance to probe another mystery-one that seemed 
at least as strange as the disappearance of the Merganser. 

"What were you doing at the Institute, allowing Nina Velez aboard the ship?" 

"She heard that we were developing a new drive-don't ask me how. Maybe she saw the Institute's 
budget." Wenig sniffed. "I don't trust the security at the USF Headquarters." 

"And you let her talk her way in, and you forced McAndrew to take her with him on a test flight?" 

If I sounded mad, I felt madder. Mac's life meant more than the dignity of some smooth-assed 
bureaucrat in the Institute's front office. 

Dr. Wenig looked at me coldly. "I think you misunderstand the situation. Nina Velez was not forced 
onto Professor McAndrew by the "front office"-for one thing, we have no such thing. The Institute is run 
by its members. You want to know why Miss Velez is on board the Merganser? I'll tell you. 
McAndrew insisted that she go with him." 

"Bullshit!" There were some things I couldn't believe. "Why the hell would Mac let himself go along 
with that? I know him, even if you don't. Over his dead body." 

Wenig sighed. He was leaning on a couch across from me, sipping a glass of white wine-no hardship 
tours for him. 

"Four weeks ago I'd have echoed your comments exactly," he said. "Professor McAndrew would 
never agree to such a thing, right? But he did. Putting this simply, Captain Roker, it is a case of 
infatuation. A bad one. I think that-" 

He stopped, outraged. I had started to laugh, in spite of the seriousness of our situation. 


"What's so funny, Captain?" 

"Well." I shrugged. "The whole thing's funny. Not funny, it's preposterous. McAndrew is a great 
physicist, and Nina Velez may be the President's daughter, but she's just a young newswoman. Anyway, 
he and I-he wouldn't-" 

Now I stopped. I wondered if Wenig was going to get up and hit me, he looked so mad. 

"Captain Roker, I don't like your insinuation," he said. "McAndrew is a physicist-so am I. You may 
not be smart enough to realize it, but physics is a field of study, not a surgical operation. Castration isn't 
part of the Ph.D. exams, you know." His tone dripped sarcasm. I wouldn't have liked a two-month trip 
to Titan with young Dr. Wenig. 

"Anyway," he went on. "You have managed to jump to a wrong conclusion. It was not Professor 
McAndrew who suffered the initial infatuation. It was Nina Velez. She thinks he is wonderful. She came 
to do an interview, and before any of us knew what was going on she was in his office all day. All night, 
too, after the first week." 

I was wrong. I know that now, and I think I knew it then, but I was too peeved to make an 
immediate apology to Wenig. Instead, I said, "But if she was the one that wanted him, couldn't he just 
throw her out?" 

"Nina Velez?" Wenig gave a bark of laughter. "You've never met her, I assume? She's a President's 
daughter, and whatever Nina wants, Nina gets. She started it, but inside a couple of days she had 
Professor McAndrew behaving like a true fool. It was disgusting, the way he went on." 

(You're jealous, Wenig, I said, jealous of Mac's good luck-but I said it to myself.) 

"And she persuaded McAndrew to let her go out on the Merganser? What were the rest of you 
doing?" 

He reddened. "Professor McAndrew was not the only one behaving like a fool. Why do you think 
Limperis, Siclaro and I feel like murderers? The two women on the team, Gowers and Macedo, insisted 
that Nina Velez should not go near the ships. We overruled them. Now, Captain Roker, maybe you see 
why each of us wanted to come after McAndrew. We drew lots, and I was the winner. 

"And maybe you should think of one other thing. While you are looking at our motives, and laughing 
at them, maybe you ought to look at your own. You look angry. I think you are jealous-jealous of Nina 
Velez." 

It's a good thing that we had to follow our flight plan at that point, and prepare to cut the drive, or I 
don't know what I would have done to Dr. Wenig. I'm a shade taller than he is, and I outweigh him by 
maybe ten pounds, but he looked fit and wiry. It wouldn't have been a foregone conclusion, not at all. 

Our descent into savagery was saved by the insistent buzzer of the computer, telling us to be ready 
for the drive reduction. We sat there, furious and not looking at each other, as the acceleration was 
slowly throttled back and the capsule moved away from the disk to resume its free-flight position two 
hundred and fifty meters behind it. The move took ten minutes. By the time it was over we had cooled 
off. I managed a graceless apology for my implied insults, and Wenig just as uncomfortably accepted it 
and said that he was sorry for what he had been saying and thinking. 

I didn't ask him what he had been thinking-there was a hint that it was much worse than anything that 
he had said. 

We had cut the drive at a little more than one hundred astronomical units from the Sun and were 
coasting along at a quarter of the speed of light. The computer gave us automatic Doppler 
compensation, so that we could hold an accurate communication link back to the Institute, through 
Triton Station. Conversation wasn't easy, because the round-trip delay for signals was almost 
twenty-eight hours-all we expected to be able to do was send "doing fine" messages to Limperis and the 
others. 

Our forward motion was completely imperceptible, though I fancied that I could see a reddening of 
stars astern and a bluer burn to stars ahead of us. We were well beyond the edge of the planetary part 
of the System, out where only the comets and the kernels lived. I put all our sensors onto maximum gain 
and Wenig and I settled in to a quiet spell of close watching. He had asked me what we were looking 
for. I had told him the truth: I had no idea, of what or when. 


* * * 

We crept on, farther and farther out. I don't know if you can actually creep at a quarter of light 
speed, but that's the way it felt; blackness, the unchanging stars, and a dwarfed Solar System far behind 
us. 

Our eyes were all wide open: radio receivers, infrared scanners, telescopes, flux meters, radar and 
mass detectors. For two days we found nothing, no signal above the hiss and shimmer of the perennial 
interstellar background. Wenig was growing more impatient, and his tone was barely civil. He wanted us 
to get the drive back on high, and dash off after McAndrew-wherever that might be. 

He was fidgeting on his bunk and ignoring the scopes when I caught the first trace. 

"Dr. Wenig. What am I seeing? Can you tune that IR receiver?" 

He came alert and was over to the console in a single movement. After a few seconds of adjustment 
he shook his head and swore. "It's natural, not man-made. Look at that trace. We're seeing a hot 
collapsed body. About seven hundred degrees, that's why there's peak power in the five micrometer 
band. We can call back to Limperis if you like, but he's sure to have it in his catalog already. There must 
be lots of these within a few days flight of us." 

He left the display and slumped back on his bunk. I went over and stared at it for a couple of 
minutes. "Would McAndrew know that this is here?" 

That made him think instead of just brooding. "There's a good chance that he would. Collapsed and 
high-density matter is Doctor Limperis's special study, but McAndrew probably put a library of them 
into Merganser's computer before he left. He wouldn't want to run into something unexpected out here." 

"We have McAndrew's probable trajectory stored there too?" 

"We know how he left the System, where he was heading. If he cut the drive, or turned after he was 
outside tracking range, we don't have any information on it." 

"Never mind that. Give me the library access codes, and let me get at the input console. I want to see 
if Mac's path shows intersection with any of the high-density objects out here." 

Wenig looked skeptical. "The chances of such a close encounter are very small. One in millions or 
billions." 

I was already calling up the access sequence. "By accident? I'd agree with you. But McAndrew must 
have had some reason to fly back through the System, and make the slight course change that you 
recorded. I think he was telling us where he was going. And the only place he could have been going 
between here and Sirius would be one of the collapsed bodies out in the Halo." 

"But why?" Wenig was standing at my shoulder, fingers twitching. 

"Don't know that." I stood up. "Here, you do it, you must have had plenty of experience with Dotterel 
's computer. Set it for anything that would put Merganser within five million kilometers of a high-density 
body. That's as close as I think we can rely on trajectory intersection." 

Wenig's fingers were flying over the keys-he should have been a concert pianist. I've never seen 
anybody handle a programming sequence at that rate. While he was doing it the com-link whistled for 
attention. I turned to it, leaving Wenig calling out displays and index files. 

"It's Limperis," I said. "Problems. President Velez is starting to breathe down his neck. Wants to 
know what has happened to Nina. When will she be back? Why did Limperis and the rest of you let her 
go on a test trip? How can the Institute be so irresponsible?" 

"We expected that." Wenig didn't look up. "Velez is just blowing off steam. There's no way that any 
other ship could get out here to us in less than three months. Does he have anything useful to suggest?" 

"No. He's threatening Limperis with punitive measures against the Institute. Says he'll want a review 
of the whole organization." 

"Limperis is asking for our reply?" 

"Yes." 

Wenig keyed in a final sequence of commands and sat back in his seat. "Tell him Velez should go 
fuck himself. We've got enough to do without interference." 

I was still reading the incoming signals from Triton Station. "I think Dr. Limperis has already sent that 
message to the President's Office, in not quite those words. We'd better get Nina back safely." 


"I know that." Wenig hit a couple of keys and an output stream began to fill the scope. "Here it 
comes. Closest approach distances for every body within five hundred AU, assuming McAndrew held 
the same course and acceleration all the way out. I've set it to stop if we get anything better than a million 
kilometers, and display everything that's five million or closer." 

Before I could learn how to read the display, Wenig banged both hands down on the desk and 
leaned forward, 

"Look at that!" His voice showed his surprise and excitement. "See it? That's HC-183. It's 322 AU 
from the Sun, and almost dead ahead of us. The computer shows a fly-by distance for Merganser too 
small to compute-that's an underflow where we ought to see a distance." 

"Suppose that McAndrew decelerated as he got nearer to it?" 

"Wouldn't make much difference, he'd still be close to rendezvous-speeds in orbit are small that far 
out. But why would he want to rendezvous with HC-183?" 

I couldn't answer that, but maybe we were at least going to find Merganser. Even if it was only a 
vaporized trace on the surface of HC-183, where the ship hit it. 

"Let's get back with our drive," I said. "What's the mass of HC-183?" 

"Pretty high." Wenig frowned at the display. "We show a five thousand kilometer diameter and a 
mass that's half of Jupiter's. Must be a good lump of collapsed matter at the center of it. How close do 
you want to take us? And what acceleration for the drive?" 

"Give us a trajectory that lets us take a close look from bound orbit. A million kilometers ought to be 
enough. And keep us down to twenty gee or better. I'll send a message back to the Institute. If they 
have any more information on HC-183, we want it." 

* * * 

Wenig had been impatient before, when we weren't going anywhere in particular. Now that we had a 
target he couldn't sit still. He was all over our three-meter living-capsule, fiddling with the scopes, the 
computer, and the control console. He kept looking wistfully at the drive setting, then at me. 

I wasn't having any. I felt as impatient as he did, but when we had come this far I didn't want to find 
we'd duplicated all McAndrew's actions, including the one that might have been fatal. We smoothly 
turned after twenty-two hours, so our drive began to decelerate us, and waited out the interminable 
delay as we crept closer to the dark mass of HC-183. We couldn't see a sign of it on any of the sensors, 
but we knew it had to be there, hidden behind the plasma ball of the drive. 

When our drive went off and we were in orbit around the black mass of the hidden proto-planet, 
Wenig was at the display console for visible wavelengths. 

"I can see it," he shouted. 

My first feeling of relief and excitement lasted only a split second. There was no way we would be 
able to spot the Merganser from a million kilometers out. 

"What are you seeing? Infrared emission from HC-183?" 

"No, you noodle. I can see the ship-McAndrew's ship." 

"You can't be. We'd have to be right next to it to be able to pick it up with our magnifications." I spun 
my seat around and looked at the screen. 

Wenig was laughing, hysterical with relief. "Don't you understand? I'm seeing the drive, not 
Merganser itself. Look at it, isn't it beautiful?" 

He was right. I felt as though I was losing my reason. McAndrew might have gone into orbit about 
the body, or if he were unlucky he might have run into it-but it made no sense that he'd be sitting here 
with the drive on. And from the look of the long tail of glowing plasma that stretched across twenty 
degrees of the screen, that drive was on a high setting. 

"Give me a Doppler read-out," I said. "Let's find out what sort of orbit he's in. Damn it, what's he 
doing there, sight-seeing?" 

Now that it looked as though we had found them, I was irrationally angry with McAndrew. He had 
brought us haring out beyond the limits of the System, and he was sitting there waiting when we arrived. 
Waiting, and that was all. 

Wenig had called up a display and was sitting there staring at it in perplexity. "No motion relative to 


HC-183," he said. "He's not in an orbit around it, he's got the ship just hanging there, with the drive 
balancing the gravitational attraction. Want me to take us alongside, so we can use a radar signal? That's 
the only way he'll hear us through the drive interference." 

"I guess we'll have to. Take us up close to them." I stared at the screen, random thoughts spinning 
around my head. "No, wait a minute. Damn it, once we set up the computer to take us in there, it will do 
automatic drive control. Before we go in, let's find out what we're in for. Can you estimate the strength 
of HC-183's gravitational attraction at the distance that Merganser is at? Got enough data for it?" 

"Give me a second." Wenig's fingers flew over the console again. If he ever decided that he didn't 
want to work at the Penrose Institute, he'd make the best space-racer in the System. 

He looked at the output for a second, frowned, and said, "I think I must have made an error." 

"Why?" 

"I'm coming up with a distance from the surface of about nine thousand kilometers. That means the 
Merganser would be feeling a pull of fifty gee-their drive would be full on, as high as it's designed to go. 
It wouldn't make sense for them to hang there like that, on full drive. Want to go on down to them?" 

"No. Hold it where we are." I leaned back and closed my eyes. "There has to be a pattern to what 
Mac's been doing. He went right through the System back there with the drive full on, now he's hanging 
close in to a high-density object with the drive still full on. What the hell's he up to?" 

"You won't find out unless we can get in touch with him." Wenig was sounding impatient again. "I say 
we should go on down there. Now we know where he is it's easiest to just go and ask him." 

It was hard to argue with him, but I couldn't get an uneasy feeling out of the back of my head. Mac 
was holding a constant position, fifty gees of thrust balancing the fifty gee pull of HC-183. We couldn't 
get alongside him unless we were willing to increase Dotterel's drive to a matching fifty gee. 

"Give me five more minutes. Remember why I'm here. It's to keep you from doing anything too 
brave. Look, if we were to hang on our drive with a twenty gee thrust, how close could we get to the 
Dotterel?" 

"We'd have to make sure we didn't fry them with our drive," said Wenig. He was busy for a couple 
of minutes at the computer, while I tried again to make sense of the pieces. 

"We can get so we're about sixty thousand kilometers from them," said Wenig at last. "If we want to 
talk to them through the microwave radar link, the best geometry would be one where we're seeing them 
side-on. We'd have decent clearance from both drives there. Ready to do it?" 

"One minute more." I was getting a feeling, a sense that everything that McAndrew had done had 
been guided by a single logic. "Look, I asked you what would happen if the drive failed when the 
life-capsule was up close to the mass disk, and you said the system would move the capsule back out 
again. But look at it the other way round now. Suppose the drive works fine-and suppose it was the 
system that's supposed to move the life-capsule up and down the column that wouldn't work? What 
would that do?" 

Wenig stroked at his luxuriant mustache. "I don't think it could happen, the design looked good. If it 
did, everything would depend where the capsule stuck." 

"Suppose it stuck up near the disk, when the ship was on a high-thrust drive." 

"Well, that would mean there was a big gravitational acceleration. You'd have to cancel it out with the 
drive, or the passengers would be flattened." He paused. "It would be a bugger. You wouldn't dare to 
turn the drive off-you'd need it on all the time, so that your acceleration compensated for the gravity of 
the disk." 

"Damn right. If you couldn't get yourself farther from the disk, you'd be forced to keep on 
accelerating. That's what happened to the Merganser, I'll bet my pension on it. Get the designs of the 
capsule movement-train up on the screen, and let's see if we can spot anything wrong with it." 

"You're an optimist, Captain Roker." He shrugged. "We can do it, but those designs have been 
looked at twenty times. Look, I see what you're saying, but I find it hard to swallow. What was 
McAndrew doing when he came back through the system and then out again?" 

"The only thing he could do. He couldn't switch the drive off, even though he could turn the ship 
around. He could fly off to God knows where in a straight line-that way we'd never have found him. Or 


he could fly in bloody great circles, and we'd have been able to see him but never get near to him for 
more than a couple of minutes at a time-there's no other manned ship that could match that fifty gee 
thrust. Or he could do what he did do. He flew back through the System to tell us the direction he was 
heading, out to HC-183. And he balanced here on his drive tail, and sat and waited for us to get smart 
enough to figure out what he was doing." 

I paused for breath, highly pleased with myself. Out of a sphere of trillions of cubic miles, we had 
tracked the Merganser to its destination. Wenig was shaking his head and looking very unhappy. 

"What's wrong," I said cockily. "Find the logic hard to follow?" 

"Not at all. A rather trivial exercise." He looked down his nose at me. "But you don't seem able to 
follow your own ideas to a conclusion. McAndrew knows all about this ship. He knows it can 
accelerate at the same rate as Merganser. So your idea that he couldn't fly around in big circles and wait 
for us to match his position can't be right-the Dotterel could do that." 

He was right. 

"So why didn't Mac do that? Why did he come out all this way?" 

"I can only think of one answer. He's had the chance to look at the reason the life capsule can't be 
moved back along the axis, so the drive mustn't be switched off. And he thinks that this ship has the 
same problem." 

I nodded. "See now why I wouldn't let you take the Dotterel all the way up to fifty gee?" 

"I do. You were right, and I would have taken us into trouble if you hadn't been along. Now 
then"-Wenig looked gloomier than ever at some new thought-"let's take the logic a step farther. 
McAndrew is hanging down there near HC-183 in a fifty gee gravity field. We can't get there to help him 
unless we do the same, and we're agreed that we dare not do that, or we'll end up with the same 
difficulty that he has, and we won't be able to turn off the drive." 

I looked out of the port, toward the dark bulk of HC-183 and the Merganser, hovering on its plume 
of high-temperature plasma. Wenig was right. We daren't go down there. 

"So how are we going to get them out?" 

Wenig shrugged, "I wish I could tell you. Maybe McAndrew has an answer. If not, they're as 
inaccessible as if they were halfway to Alpha Centauri and still accelerating. We've got to get into 
communication with them." 

* * * 

When I was about eleven years old, just before puberty, I had a disturbing series of dreams. Night 
after night, for maybe three months, I seemed to wake on the steep face of a cliff. It was dark, and I 
could barely see handholds and toeholds in the rock. 

I had to get to the top-something was hidden below, invisible behind the curve of the black cliff face. 
I didn't know what it was, but it was awful. 

Every night I would climb, as carefully as I could; and every night there would come a time when I 
missed a handhold, and began to slide downwards, down into the pit and the waiting monster. 

I woke just as I reached the bottom, just as I was waiting for the first sight of my pit beast. 

I never saw it. Puberty arrived, sex dreams replaced my fantasy. I forgot all about the cliff face, the 
terror, the feeling of force that could not be resisted. Forgot it totally-except that dream memories never 
disappear completely, they lie at some deep submerged level of the mind, until something pulls them out 
again. 

And here I was again, back on the same cliff face, sliding steadily to my fate, powerless to prevent it. 
I woke up with my heart rate higher by thirty beats a minute, with cold perspiration on my forehead and 
neck. It took me a long time to return to the present, to banish the bygone fall into the pit. 

I finally forced myself up to full consciousness and looked at the screen above me. The purple blaze 
of a plasma drive danced against the black backdrop of HC-183 and its surrounding star field. It hung 
there, falling forever but suspended on the feathery stalk of the drive exhaust. I lay there for about ten 
minutes, just watching, then looked across at Wenig. He was staring at me, his eyes unblinking. 

"Awake at last," He made a sort of coughing noise, something that I think was intended to be a laugh. 
"You're a cool one, Captain Roker. I couldn't sleep with that hanging there"-he jerked his thumb at the 


screen-"even if you doped me up with everything in the robodoc." 

"How long did I sleep?" 

"About three hours. Ready to give up now?" 

I was. It had been my idea, an insistence that we ought to try and get some sleep before we did the 
next phase of our maneuver around HC-183. Wenig had opposed it, had wanted to go on at once, but I 
thought we'd benefit from the rest. So I was wrong. 

"I'm ready." My eyes felt as though they'd been filled with grit, and my throat was dry and sore, but 
talking about that to Wenig wouldn't do much for McAndrew or Nina Velez. "Let's get into position and 
try the radar." 

While Wenig juggled us over to the best position, sixty thousand kilometers from HC-183 and about 
the same distance from the Merganser, I wondered again about my companion. They had drawn lots to 
come with me, and he had won. The other four scientists back at the Institute seemed a little naive and 
unworldly, but not Wenig. He was tough and shrewd, and I had seen the speed of those hands, dancing 
over the keyboard. Had he done a bit of juggling when they drew lots, a touch of 
hand-faster-than-the-eye? 

I thought of his look when he spoke about Nina. If McAndrew was infatuated, perhaps Wenig 
shared the spell. Something strong was driving him along, some force that could keep him awake and 
alert for days on end. I wouldn't know if I was right or not unless we could find a way to haul Merganser 
back out of the field. The ship still hovered over its pendant of blue ionized gases, motionless as ever. 

"How about this?" Wenig interrupted my thoughts. "I don't think I can get the geometry any better 
than it is now." 

We were hanging there too, farther out from the proto-planet than the Merganser but close enough 
to see the black disk occulting the star field. We could beam short bursts of microwaves at our sister 
ship and hope there was enough signal strength to bore through the sheaths of plasma emitted by the 
drives. It would be touch and go-I had never tried to send a signal to an unmanned ship on high-drive, 
but our signal-to-noise ratio stood right on the borderline of system acceptance. As it was, we'd have to 
settle for voice-links only. 

I nodded, and Wenig sent out our first pulses, the simple ship ID codes. We sent it for a couple of 
minutes, then waited with our attention fixed on the screen. 

After a while Wenig shook his head. "We're not getting through. It wouldn't take that long to respond 
to our signal." 

"Send it with reduced information rate and more redundancy. We have to give McAndrew enough to 
filter out the noise." 

He was still in send mode when the display screen began to crawl with green patterns of light. 
Something was coming in. The computer was performing a frequency analysis to pick out the signal 
content from the background, smoothing it, and speeding it up to standard communication rate. We 
were looking at the Fourier analysis that preceded signal presentation. 

"Voice mode," said Wenig quietly. 

"Merganser." The computer reconstruction of McAndrew's voice was slow and hollow. "This is 
McAndrew from the Merganser. We're certainly glad to hear from you, Dotterel. Well, Jeanie, what 
kept you?" 

"Roker speaking." I leaned forward and spoke into the vocal input system-too fast, but the computer 
would take care of that at the other end. "Mac, we're hanging about sixty kay out from you. Is 
everything all right in Merganser?" 

"Yes." 

"No," broke in another voice. "Get us out of here. We've been stuck in this damned metal box for 
sixteen days now." 

"Nina," said Wenig. "We'd love to get you out-but we don't know how. Didn't Dr. McAndrew tell 
you the problem?" 

"He said we couldn't leave here until the ship you are on came for us." 

Wenig grimaced at me and turned away from the input link. "I ought to have realized that. McAndrew 


hasn't told her the problem with the drives-not all of it." 

"Maybe he knows an answer." I faced back to the microphone. "Mac, as we see it we shouldn't put 
the Dotterel up as high as fifty gee thrust. Correct?" 

"Of course." McAndrew sounded faintly surprised at my question. "Why do you think I went to such 
lengths to get to this holding position out here? When you go to maximum setting for the drive, the 
electromechanical coupling for moving the life-capsule gets distorted, too." 

"How did we miss it on the design?" Wenig sounded unconvinced. 

"Remember the last-minute increase in stabilizing fields for the mass plate?" 

"It was my recommendation-I'm not likely to forget it." 

"We recalculated the effects on the drive and on the exhaust region, but not the magnetostrictive 
effects on the life-support column. We thought they were secondorder changes." 

"And they're not? I ought to be drawn and quartered-that was my job!" Wenig was sitting there, fists 
clenched and face red. 

"Was it now? Och, your job, eh? And I've been sitting here thinking all this time it was my job." For 
someone in a hopeless position thirty billion miles from home, McAndrew sounded amazingly cool. 
"Come on now, we can sort out whose doing it was when we're all back at the Institute." 

Wenig looked startled, then turned to me again. "Go along with him on this-I'm sure he's doing it for 
Nina's sake. He doesn't want her worried." 

I nodded-but this time I was unconvinced. Mac must have something hidden away inside his head, or 
not even Nina Velez would justify his optimistic tone. 

"What should we do, Mac?" I said. "We'd get the same effects if we were to accelerate too hard. 
We can't get down to you, and you can't get up to us without accelerating out past us. How are we 
going to get you out of there?" 

"Right." The laugh that came over the com-link sounded forced and hollow, but that may have been 
just the tone that the computer filters gave it. "You might guess that's been on my mind too. The 
problem's in the mechanical coupling that moves the life-capsule along the column. It's easy enough to 
see, once you imagine that you've had a two millimeter decrease in column diameter-that's the effects of 
the added field on the mass plate." 

Wenig was already calling the schematics out onto a second display. "I'll check that. Keep talking." 

"You'll see that when the drive's up to maximum, the capsule catches on the side of the column. It's a 
simple ratchet effect. I've tried varying the drive thrust up and down a couple of gee, but that won't free 
it." 

"I see where you mean." Wenig had a lightpen out and was circling parts of the column for larger 
scale displays. "I don't see how we can do anything about it. It would take a lateral impact to free 
it-you'll not do it by varying your drive." 

"Agreed. We need some lateral force on us. That's what I'm hoping you'll provide." 

"What is all this?" It was Nina's voice again, and she sounded angry. "Why do you just keep on 
talking like that? Anybody who knew what he was doing would have us out by now-would never have 
got us into it in the first place if he had any sense." 

I raised an eyebrow at Wenig. "The voice of infatuation? I think the bloom's off the rose down there." 

He looked startled, then pleased, then excited-and then tried to appear nonchalant. "I don't know 
what McAndrew is getting at. How could we provide any help?" He turned to the input system. "Dr. 
McAndrew, how's that possible? We can't provide a lateral force on Merganser from here, and we 
can't come down safely." 

"Of course you can." McAndrew's voice sounded pleased, and I was sure he was enjoying making 
the rest of us try and work out his idea. "It's very easy for you to come down here." 

"How, Mac?" 

"In a free-fall trajectory. We're in a fifty gee gravity field because we're in a stationary position 
relative to HC-183. But if you were to let yourself fall in a free orbit, you'd be able to swing in right past 
us, and away again, and never feel anything but free fall. Agreed?" 

"Right. We'd feel tidal effects, but they'd be small." Wenig was calling out displays as he talked, 


fingers a blur over the computer console. "We can fly right past you, but we'd be there and away in a 
split second. What could we do in so short a time?" 
"Why, what we need." McAndrew sounded surprised by the question. "Just give us a good bang on 
the side as you go by." 
* * * 

It sounded easy, as McAndrew so glibly and casually suggested it. When we went into details, there 
were three problem areas. If we went too close, we'd be fried in the Merganser's drive. Too far off, and 
we'd never get a strong enough interaction. If all that was worked out correctly, we still had one big 
obstacle. For the capsule to be freed as Dotterel applied sideways pressure, the drive on the other ship 
would have to cut off completely. Only for a split second, but during that time McAndrew and Nina 
would feel a full fifty gee on them. 

That's not quite as bad as it sounds-people have survived instantaneous accelerations of more than a 
hundred gee in short pulses. But it's not a picnic, either. Mac continued to sound cheerful and casual, 
mainly for Nina Velez's benefit. But when he listed the preparations that he was taking inside Merganser, 
I knew he was dealing with a touch-and-go situation. 

After all the calculations (performed independently on the two ships, cross-checked and 
double-checked) we had started our free-fall orbit. It was designed to take us skimming past the 
Merganser, with a closest separation of less than two hundred meters. We daren't go nearer without 
risking crippling effects from their drive. We would be flying right through its region of turbulence. 

Four hours of discussion between McAndrew and Wenig-with interruptions from Nina and me-had 
fixed the sequence for the vital half-second when we would be passing the Merganser. The ships would 
exert gravitational forces on each other, but that was useless for providing the lateral thrust on the life 
capsule system that McAndrew thought was needed. We had to give a more direct and harder push 
some other way. 

Timing was crucial, and very tricky. 

Whatever we threw at the other ship would have to pass through the drive exhaust region before it 
could impact the life-capsule column. If the drive were on, nothing could get through it-at those 
temperatures any material we had would be vaporized on the way, even if it were there for only a 
fraction of a second. The sequence had to be: launch mass from Dotterel; just before it got there, kill 
drive on Merganser; hold drive off just long enough for the Dotterel to clear the area and for the mass 
to impact the Merganser support column; and back on with their drive, at once, because when the drive 
was off the Merganser's passengers would be feeling the full fifty gees of the mass plate's gravity. 

McAndrew and Wenig cut the time of approach of the two ships into millisecond pieces. They 
decided exactly how long each phase should last. Then they let the two on-board computers of the ships 
talk to each other, to make sure that everything was synchronized between them-at the rate things would 
be happening, there was no way that humans could control them. Not even Wenig, with his super-fast 
reflexes. We'd all be spectators, while the two computers did the real work and I nursed the abort 
switch. 

There was one argument. McAndrew wanted to use a storage tank as the missile that we would eject 
from our ship to impact theirs. It would provide high momentum transfer for a very brief period. Wenig 
argued that we should trade off time against intensity, and use a liquid mass instead of a solid one. 
Endless discussion and calculations, until Mac was convinced too. We would use all our spare water 
supply, about a ton and a half of it. That left enough for drinking water on a twenty gee return to the 
Inner System, but nothing spare for other uses. It would be a scratchy and smelly trip home for Dotterel 
's passengers. 

Drive off, we felt only the one-gee pull of our mass plate as we dropped in to close approach. On 
Merganser, McAndrew and Nina Velez were lying in water bunks, cushioned with everything soft on 
the ship. We were on an impact course with them, one that would change to a near-miss after we 
ejected the water ballast. It looked like a suicide mission, running straight into the blue furnace of their 
drive. 

The sequence took place so fast it was anti-climactic. I saw the drive cut off ahead of us and felt the 


vibration along the support column as our mass driver threw the ballast hard towards Merganser. The 
brief pulse from our drive that took us clear of them was too quick for me to feel. 

We cleared the drive region. Then there seemed to be a wait that lasted for hours. McAndrew and 
Nina were now in a ship with drive off, dropping towards HC-183. They were exposed to the full fifty 
gees of their mass plate. Under that force, I knew what happened to the human body. It had not been 
designed to operate when it suddenly weighed more than four tons. Membranes ruptured, valves burst, 
veins collapsed. The heart had never evolved to pump blood weighing hundreds of pounds up a gravity 
hill of fifty gees. The only thing that Mac and Nina had going for them was the natural inertia of matter. If 
the period of high gee were short enough, the huge accelerations would not have time to produce those 
shattering physical effects. 

Wenig and I watched on our screens for a long, long moment, until the computer on Merganser 
counted off the last microsecond and switched on the drive again. If the life-capsule was free to move 
along its column, the computer would now begin the slow climb out of HC-183's gravity well. No action 
was needed from the passengers. When we completed our own orbit we hoped we would see the other 
ship out at a safe distance, ready for the long trip home. 

And on board the ship? I wasn't sure. If the encounter had lasted too long, we might find no more 
than two limp and broken sacks of blood, tissue and bone. 
* * * 

It was another long day, waiting until we had been carried around in our orbit and could try to 
rendezvous the two ships. As soon as we were within radar range, Nina Velez appeared on the com 
screen. The drive was cut back, so we could get good visual signals. My heart sank when I saw the 
expression on her face. 

"Can you get over to this ship-quickly?" she said. 

I could see why all the professors at the Institute had lost their senses. She was small and slight, with 
a childlike look of trust and sad blue eyes. All a sham, according to everything I'd been told, but there 
was no way of seeing the strong personality behind the soft looks. I took a deep breath. 

"What's happening there?" I said. 

"We're back under low gee drive, and that's fine. But I haven't been able to wake him. He's 
breathing, but there's blood on his lips. He needs a doctor." 

"I'm the nearest thing to that in thirty billion miles." I was pulling a suit towards me, sick with a sudden 
fear. "I've had some medical training as part of the Master's License. And I think I know what's wrong 
with McAndrew. He lost part of a lung lobe a couple of years ago. If anything's likely to be 
hemorrhaging, that's it. Dr. Wenig, can you arrange a rendezvous with the mass plates at maximum 
separation and the drives off?" 

"I'll need control of their computer." He was pulling his suit on, too. I didn't want him along, but I 
might need somebody to return to the Dotterel for medical supplies. 

"What should I be doing?" Thank heaven Nina showed no signs of panic. She sounded impatient, 
with the touch of President Velez in her voice. "I've sat around in this ship for weeks with nothing to do. 
Now we need action but I daren't take it." 

"What field are you in now? What net field?" 

"One gee. The drive's off now, and we've got the life-capsule right out at the end of the column." 

"Right. I want to you stay in that position, but set the drive at one gee acceleration. I want 
McAndrew in a zero-gee environment to slow the bleeding. Dr. Wenig, can you dictate instructions for 
that while we are rendezvousing?" 

"No problem." He was an irritating devil, but I'd choose him in a crisis. He was doing three things at 
once, putting on his suit, watching the computer action for the rendezvous, and giving exact and concise 
instructions to Nina. 

Getting ourselves from one ship to the other through open space wasn't as easy as it might sound. We 
had both ships under one gee acceleration drives, complicated by the combined attraction of the two 
mass plates. The total field acting on us was small, but we had to be careful not to forget it. If we lost 
contact with the ships, the nearest landing point was back on Triton Station, thirty billion miles away. 


Nina in the flesh was even more impressive than she was over the video link, but I gave her little more 
than a cursory once-over. McAndrew's color was bad and even while I was cracking my suit open and 
hustling out of it I could hear a frightening bubbling sound in his breathing. Thank God I had learned how 
to work in zero gee-required part of any space medicine course. I leaned over him, vaguely aware of the 
two others intently watching. The robodoc beside me was clucking and flashing busily, muttering a faint 
complaint at McAndrew's condition and the zero-gee working environment. Standard diagnosis 
conditions called for at least a partial gravity field. 

I took the preliminary diagnosis and prepared to act on it while the doc was still making up its mind. 
Five cc's of cerebral stimulant, five cc's of metabolic depressant, and a reduction in cabin pressure. It 
should bring Mac up to consciousness if his brain was still in working order. I worried about a cerebral 
hemorrhage, the quiet and deadly by-product of super-high gees. Ten minutes and I would know one 
way or the other. 

I turned to Wenig and Nina who were still watching the robodoc's silent body trace. "I don't know 
how he is yet. We may need emergency treatment facilities ready for us as soon as we get back to the 
System. Can you go over to Dotterel, cut the drive and try to make contact with Triton Station? By the 
time you have the connection we should have the full diagnosis here." 

I watched them leave the ship, saw how carefully Wenig helped Nina to the transfer, and then I heard 
the first faint noise behind me. It was a sigh, with a little mutter of protest behind it. The most wonderful 
sound I ever heard in my life. I glanced over at the doc. Concussion-not too bad-and a little more 
bleeding than I wanted to see from the left lung. Hell, that was nothing. I could patch the lung myself, 
maybe even start the feedback regeneration for it. I felt a big grin of delight spreading like a heat wave 
over my face. 

"Take it easy, Mac. You're doing all right, just don't try and rush yourself. We've got lots of time." I 
secured his left arm so that he couldn't disturb the rib cage on that side. 

He groaned. "Doing fine, am I?" He suddenly opened his eyes and stared up at me, "Holy water, 
Jeanie, that's just like a medic. I'm in agony, and you say it's a little discomfort. How's Nina doing?" 

"Not a mark on her. She's not like you, Mac, an old bag of bones. You're getting too old for this sort 
of crap." 

"Where is she?" 

"Over on Dotterel, with Wenig. What's the matter, still infatuated?" 

He managed a faint smile. "Ah, none of that now. We were stuck on Merganser for more than two 
weeks, locked up in a three meter living sphere. Show me an infatuation, and I'll show you a cure for it." 

The com-link behind me was buzzing. I cut it in, so that we could see Wenig's worried face. 

"All right here," I said, before he had time to worry any more. "We'll be able to take our time going 
back. How are you? Got enough water?" 

He nodded. "I took some of your reserve supply to make up for what we threw at you. What should 
we do now?" 

"Head on back. Tell Nina that Mac's all right, and say we'll see you both back at the Institute." 

He nodded again, then leaned closer to the screen and spoke with a curious intensity. "We don't want 
to run the risk of having a stuck life capsule again. I'd better keep us down to less than ten gee 
acceleration." 

He cut off communication, without another word. I turned to McAndrew. "How high an acceleration 
before you'd run into trouble with these ships?" 

He was staring at the blank screen, a confused look on his thin face. "At least forty gee. What the 
devil's got into Wenig? And what are you laughing at, you silly bitch?" 

I came over to him and took his right hand in mine. "To each his own, Mac. I wondered why Wenig 
was so keen to get here. He wants his shot at Nina-out here, where nobody else can compete. What 
did you tell her-some sweet talk about her lovely eyes?" 

He closed his eyes again and smiled a secret smile. "Ah, come on Jeanie. Are you telling me you've 
been on your best behavior since I last saw you? Gi' me a bit of peace. I'm not soft on Nina now." 

"I'll see." I went across to the drive and moved us up to forty gee. "Wait until the crew on Titan hear 


about all this. You'll lose your reputation." 

He sighed. "All right, I'll play the game. What's the price of silence?" 

"How long would it take a ship like this to get out to Alpha Centauri?" 

"You'd not want this one. We'll have the next one up to a hundred gee. Forty-four ship days would 
get you there, standing start to standing finish." 

I nodded, came back to his side and held his hand again. "All right, Mac, that's my price. I want one 
of the tickets." 

He groaned again, just a bit. But I knew from the dose the doc had put into him that it wasn't a 
headache this time. 


THIRD CHRONICLE: All the Colors of the 
Vacuum 


As soon as the ship got back from the midyear run to Titan, I went down to Earth and asked 
Woolford for a leave of absence. I had been working hard enough for six people, and he knew it. He 
nodded agreeably as soon as I made the formal request. 

"I think you've earned it, Captain Roker, no doubt about that. But don't you have quite a bit of leave 
time saved up? Wouldn't that be enough?" He stopped staring out of the window at the orange-brown 
sky and called my records onto the screen in front of him. 

"That won't do it," I said, while he was still looking. 

Woolford frowned and became less formal. "It won't? Well, according to this, Jeanie, you've got at 
least . . ." He looked up. "Just how long do you want to take off?" 

"I'm not exactly sure. Somewhere between nine and sixteen years, I think." 

I would have liked to break the news more gently, but maybe there was no graceful way. 

* * * 

It had taken McAndrew a while to deliver on his promise. The design of the more advanced ship 
contained no new theory, but this time he intended that the initial tests would be conducted more 
systematically. I kept pushing him along, while he tried to wriggle out of the commitment. He had been 
full of drugs and painkillers at the time, he said-surely I didn't consider it fair, to hold him to what he'd 
been silly enough to promise then? 

Fair or not, I wouldn't listen. I had called him as soon as we were on the final leg of the Titan run. 

"Yes, she's ready enough to go." He had a strange expression on his face, somewhere between 
excitement and perplexity. "You've still got your mind set on going, then, Jeanie?" 

I didn't dignify that question with a reply. Instead I said, "How soon can I come out to the Institute?" 

He cleared his throat, making that odd sound that spoke to me of his Scots ancestry. "Och, if you're 
set on it, come as soon as you please. I'll have things to tell you when you get here, but that can wait." 

That was when I went down and made my request to Woolford for a long leave of absence. 
McAndrew had been strangely reluctant to discuss our destination, but I couldn't imagine that we'd be 
going out past Sirius. Alpha Centauri was my guess, and that would mean we would only be away about 
nine Earth years. Shipboard time would be three months, allowing a few days at the other end for 
exploration. If I knew McAndrew, he would have beaten the hundred gee acceleration that he projected 
for the interstellar prototype. He was never a man to talk big about what he was going to do. 

The Penrose Institute had been moved out to Mars orbit since the last time I was there, so it took me 
a couple of weeks of impatient ship-hopping to get to it. When we finally closed to visible range I could 
see the old test ships, Merganser and Dotterel, floating a few kilometers from the main body of the 
Institute. They were easy to recognize from the flat mass disc with its protruding central spike. And 
floating near them, quite a bit bigger, was a new ship of gleaming silver. That had to be the Hoatzin, 
McAndrew's newest plaything. The disc was twice the size, and the spike three times as long, but 
Hoatzin was clearly Merganser's big brother. 

It was Professor Limperis, the head of the Institute, who greeted me when I entered. He had put on 
weight since I last saw him, but that pudgy black face still hid a razor-sharp mind and a bottomless 
memory. 

"Good to see you again, Captain Roker. I haven't told McAndrew this, but I'm very glad you'll be 
going along to keep an eye on him." He gave what he once described as his "hand-clapping 
minstrel-show laugh"-a sure sign he was nervous about something. 

"Well, I don't know that I'll be much use. I'm expecting to be just a sort of passenger. Don't worry. If 
my instincts are anything to go by there won't be much danger in a simple stellar rendezvous and return." 

"Er, yes." He wouldn't meet my eye. "That was my own reaction. I gather that Professor McAndrew 
has not mentioned to you his change of target?" 


"Change of target? He didn't mention any target at all." Now my own worry bead was beginning to 
throb. "Are you suggesting that the trip will not be to a stellar rendezvous?" 

He shrugged and waved his hands, pointing along the corridor. "Not if McAndrew gets his way. 
Come along, he's inside at the computer. I think it's best if he is present when we talk about this further." 

Pure evasion. Whatever the bad news was, Limperis wanted me to hear it from McAndrew himself. 

We found him staring vacantly at a completely blank display screen. Normally I would never interrupt 
him when he looks as imbecilic as that-it means that he is thinking with a breadth and depth that I'll never 
comprehend. I often wonder what it would be like to have a mind like that. Humans, with rare 
exceptions, must seem like trained apes, with muddied thoughts and no ability for abstract analysis. 

Tough luck. It was time one of the trained apes had some of her worries put to rest. I walked up 
behind McAndrew and put my hands on his shoulders. 

"Here I am. I'm ready to go-if you'll tell me where we're going." 

He turned in his chair. After a moment his slack jaw firmed up and the eyes brought me into focus. 

"Hello, Jeanie." No doubt about it, as soon as he recognized me he had that same shifty look I had 
noticed in Limperis. "I didn't expect you here so soon. We're still making up a flight profile." 

"That's all right. I'll help you." I sat down opposite him, studying his face closely. As usual he looked 
tired, but that was normal. Geniuses work harder than anyone else, not less hard. His face was thinner, 
and he had lost a little more hair from that sandy, receding mop. My argument with him over that was 
long in the past. 

"Why don't you grow it back?" I'd said. "It's such a minor job, a couple of hours with the machines 
every few months and you'd have a full head of hair again." 

He had sniffed. "Why don't you try and get me to grow a tail, or hair all over my body? Or maybe 
make my arms a bit longer, so they'll let me run along with them touching the ground. Jeanie, I'll not 
abuse a bio-feedback machine to run evolution in the wrong direction. We're getting less hairy all the 
time. I know your fondness for monkeys"-a nasty crack about an engineering friend of mine on Ceres, 
who was a bit hairy for even my accommodating tastes-"but I'll be just as happy when I have no hair at 
all. It gets in the way, it grows all the time, and it serves no purpose whatsoever." 

McAndrew resented the time it took him to clip his fingernails, and I'm sure that he regarded his 
fondness for food as a shameful weakness. Meanwhile, I wondered who in the Penrose Institute cut his 
hair. Maybe they had a staff assistant, whose job it was to shear the absent-minded once a month. 

"What destination are you planning for the first trip out?" If he was thinking of chasing a comet, I 
wanted that out in the open. 

McAndrew looked at Limperis. Limperis looked at McAndrew, handing it back to him. Mac cleared 
his throat. 

"We've discussed it here and we're all agreed. The first trip of the Hoatzin won't be to a star system." 
He cleared his throat again. "It will be to pursue and rendezvous with the Ark of Massingham. It's a 
shorter trip than any of the star systems," he added hopefully. He could read my expression. "They are 
less than two light-years out. With the Hoatzin we can be there and docked with the Ark in less than 
thirty-five ship days." 

If he was trying to make me feel better, McAndrew was going about it in quite the wrong way. 

* * * 

Back in the twenties, the resources of the Solar System must have seemed inexhaustible. No one had 
been able to catalog the planetoids, still less analyze their composition and probable value. Now we 
know everything out to Neptune that's bigger than a hundred meters across, and the navigation groups 
want that down to fifty meters in the next twenty years. The idea of grabbing an asteroid a couple of 
kilometers across and using it how you choose sounds like major theft. But it hadn't merely been 
permitted-it had been encouraged. 

The first space colonies had been conceived as utopias, planned by Earth idealists who wouldn't learn 
from history. New frontiers may attract visionaries, but more than that they attract oddities. Anyone who 
is more than three sigma away from the norm, in any direction, seems to finish out there on the frontier. 
No surprise in that. If a person can't fit, for whatever reason, he'll move away from the main group of 


humanity. They'll push him, and he'll want to go. How do I know? Look, you don't pilot to Titan without 
learning a lot about your own personality. Before we found the right way to use people like me, I would 
probably have been on one of the Arks. 

The United Space Federation had assisted in the launch of seventeen of them, between ninety and 
forty years ago. Each of them was self-supporting, a converted asteroid that would hold between three 
and ten thousand people at departure time. The idea was that there would be enough raw materials and 
space to let the Ark grow as the population grew. A two-kilometer asteroid holds five to twenty billion 
tons of material, total life-support system for one human needs less than ten tons of that. 

The Arks had left long before the discovery of the McAndrew balanced drive, before the discovery 
of even the Mattin Drive. They were multi-generation ships, bumbling along into the interstellar void with 
speeds that were only a few percent of light speed. 

And who was on-board them when they left? Any fairly homogeneous group of strange people, who 
shared enough of a common philosophy or delusion to prefer the uncertainties of star travel to the known 
problems within the Solar System. It took courage to set out like that, to sever all your ties with home 
except occasional laser and radio communication. Courage, or an overpowering conviction that you 
were part of a unique and chosen group. 

To put that another way, McAndrew was proposing to take us out to meet a community about which 
we knew little, except that by the usual standards they were descended from madmen. 

"Mac, I don't remember which one was the Ark of Massingham. How long ago did it leave?" 

Even mad people can have sane children. Four of the Arks, as I recalled, had turned around and 
were on their way back to the System. 

"About seventy-five years ago. It's one of the earlier ones, with a final speed a bit less than three 
percent of light speed." 

"Is it one of the Arks that has turned back?" 

He shook his head. "No. They're still on their way. Target star is Tau Ceti. They won't get there for 
another three hundred years." 

"Well, why pick them out? What's so special about the Ark of Massingham?" I had a sudden thought. 
"Are they having some problem that we could help with?" 

We had saved two of the Arks in the past twenty years. For one of them we had been able to 
diagnose a recessive genetic element that was appearing in the children, and pass the test information 
and sperm filter technique over the communications link. The other had needed the use of an unmanned 
high-acceleration probe, to carry a couple of tons of cadmium out to them. They had been unlucky 
enough to choose a freak asteroid, one that apparently lacked the element even in the tiniest traces. 

"They don't report any problem," said Mac. "We've never had a response to any messages we've 
sent to them, so far as the records on Triton Station are concerned. But we know that they are doing all 
right, because every three or four years a message has come in from them. Never anything about the 
Ark itself, it has always been . . . scientific information." 

McAndrew had hesitated as he said that last phrase. That was the lure, no doubt about it. 

"What kind of information?" I said. "Surely we know everything that they know. We have hundreds 
of thousands of scientists in the System, they can't have more than a few hundred of them." 

"I'm sure you're right on the numbers." Professor Limperis spoke when McAndrew showed no 
inclination to do so. "I'm not sure it's relevant. How many scientists does it require to produce the work 
of one Einstein, or one McAndrew? You can't just sit down and count numbers, as though you were 
dealing with-with bars of soap, or poker chips. You have to deal with individuals." 

"There's a genius on the Ark of Massingham," said McAndrew suddenly. His eyes were gleaming. "A 
man or woman who has been cut off from most of physics for a whole lifetime, working alone. It's worse 
than Ramanujan." 

"How do you know that?" I had seldom seen McAndrew so filled with feeling. "Maybe they've been 
getting messages from somebody in the System here." 

McAndrew laughed, a humorless bark. "I'll tell you why, Jeanie. You flew the Merganser. Tell me 
how the drive worked." 


"Well, the mass plate at the front balanced the acceleration, so we didn't get any sensation of fifty 
gee." I shrugged. "I didn't work out the math for myself, but I'm sure I could have if I felt like it." 

I could have, too. I was a bit rusty, but you never lose the basics once you have them planted deep 
enough in your head. 

"I don't mean the balancing mechanism, that was just common sense." He shook his head. "I mean 
the drive. Didn't it occur to you that we were accelerating a mass of trillions of tons at fifty gee? If you 
work out the mass conversion rate you will need, you find that even with an ideal photon drive you'll 
consume the whole mass in a few days. The Merganser got its drive by accelerating charged particles 
up to within millimeters a second of light speed. That was the reaction mass. But how did it get the 
energy to do it?" 

I felt like telling him that when I had been on Merganser there had been other details-such as 
survival-on my mind. I thought for a few moments, then shook my head. 

"You can't get more energy out of matter than the rest mass energy, I know that. But you're telling me 
that the drives on Merganser and Hoatzin do it. That Einstein was wrong." 

"No!" McAndrew looked horrified at the thought that he might have been criticizing one of his senior 
idols. "All I've done is build on what Einstein did. Look, you've done a fair amount of quantum 
mechanics. You know that when you calculate the energy for the vacuum state of a system you don't get 
zero. You get a positive value." 

I had a hazy recollection of a formula swimming back across the years. What was it? h/4?w, said a 
distant voice. 

"But you can set that to zero!" I was proud at remembering so much. "The zero point of energy is 
arbitrary." 

"In quantum theory it is. But not in general relativity." McAndrew was beating back my mental 
defenses. As usual when I spoke with him on theoretical subjects, I began to feel I would know less at 
the end of the conversation than I did at the beginning. 

"In general relativity," he went on, "energy implies space-time curvature. If the zero-point energy is 
not zero, the vacuum self-energy is real. It can be tapped, if you know what you are doing. That's where 
Hoatzin draws its energy. The reaction mass it needs is very small. You can get that by scooping up 
matter as you go along, or if you prefer it you can use a fraction-a very small fraction-of the mass plate." 

"All right." I knew McAndrew. If I let him get going he would talk all day about physical principles. 
"But I don't see how that has anything to do with the Ark of Massingham. It has an old-fashioned drive, 
surely. You said it was launched seventy-five years ago." 

"It was." This was Limperis again, gently insistent. "But you see, Captain Roker, nobody outside the 
Penrose Institute knows how Professor McAndrew has been able to tap the vacuum self-energy. We 
have been very careful not to broadcast that information until we were ready. The potential for 
destructive use is enormous. It destroys the old idea that you cannot create more energy at a point than 
the rest mass of the matter residing there. There was nothing known in the rest of the System about this 
use until two weeks ago." 

"And then you released the information?" I was beginning to feel dizzy. 

"No. The basic equations for accessing the vacuum self-energy were received by laser 
communication. They were sent, with no other message, from the Ark of Massingham." 

Suddenly it made sense. It wasn't just McAndrew who was itching to get in and find out what there 
was on the Ark-it was everyone at the Penrose Institute. I could sense the excitement in Limperis, and 
he was the most guarded and politically astute of all the Members. If some physicist, working out there 
alone two light-years from Sol, had managed to parallel McAndrew's development, that was a 
momentous event. It implied a level of genius that was difficult to imagine. 

I knew Hoatzin would be on the way in a few days, whether I wanted to go or stay. But there was 
one more key question. 

"I can't believe that the Ark of Massingham was started by a bunch of physicists. What was the 
original composition of the group that colonized it?" 

"Not physicists." Limperis had suddenly sobered. "By no means physicists. That is why I am glad you 


will be accompanying Professor McAndrew. The leader of the original group was Jules Massingham. In 
the past few days I have taken the time to obtain all the System records on him. He was a man of great 
personal drive and convictions. His ambition was to apply the old principles of eugenics to a whole 
society. Two themes run through all his writings: the creation of the superior human, and the idea of that 
superior being as an integrated part of a whole society. He was ruthless in his pursuit of those ends." 

He looked at me, black face impassive. "From the evidence available, Captain, one might suggest 
that he succeeded in his aims." 
* * * 

Hoatzin was a step up from Merganser and Dotterel. Maximum acceleration was a hundred and 
ten gees, and the living-capsule was a four-meter sphere. I had cursed the staff of the Institute, publicly 
and privately, but I had got nowhere. They were obsessed with the idea of the lonely genius out there in 
the void, and no one would consider any other first trip for Hoatzin. So at least I would check out every 
aspect of the system before we went, while McAndrew was looking at the rendezvous problem and 
making a final flight plan. We sent a message to the Ark, telling them of our trip and estimated arrival 
time. It would take two years to get there, Earth-time, but we would take even longer. They would be 
able to prepare for our arrival however they chose, with garlands or gallows. 

On the trip out, McAndrew tried again to explain to me his methods for tapping the vacuum 
self-energy. The available energies made up a quasi-continuous "spectrum," corresponding to a large 
number of very high frequencies of vibration and associated wavelengths. Tuned resonators in the 
Hoatzin drive units selected certain wavelengths which were excited by the corresponding components 
in the vacuum self energy. These "colors," as McAndrew thought of them, could feed vacuum energy to 
the drive system. The results that had come from the Ark of Massingham suggested that McAndrew's 
system for energy extraction could be generalized, so that all the "colors" of the vacuum self-energy 
should become available. 

If that were true, the potential acceleration produced by the drive could go up by a couple of orders 
of magnitude. He was still working out what the consequences of that would be. At speeds that 
approached within a nanometer per second of light speed, a single proton would mass enough to weigh 
its impact on a sensitive balance. 

I let him babble on to his heart's content. My own attention was mostly on the history of the Ark of 
Massingham. It was an oddity among oddities. Six of the Arks had disappeared without trace. They 
didn't respond to signals from Earth, and they didn't send signals of their own. Most people assumed that 
they had wiped themselves out, with accidents, wars, strange sexual practices, or all three. Four of the 
Arks had swung back towards normalcy and were heading in again for the System. Six were still 
heading out, but two of them were in deep trouble if the messages that came back to Triton Station were 
any guide. One was full of messianic ranting, a crusade of human folly propagating itself out to the stars 
(let's hope they never met anyone out there whose good opinion we would later desire). Another was 
quietly and peacefully insane, sending messages that spoke only of new rules for the interpretation of 
dreams. They were convinced that they would find the world of the Norse legends when they finally 
arrived at Eta Cassiopeia, complete with Jotunheim, Niflheim, and all the assembly of gods and heroes. 
It would be six hundred years before they arrived there, time enough for moves to rationality or to 
extinction. 

Among this set, the Ark of Massingham provided a bright mixture of sanity and strangeness. They 
had sent messages back since first they left, messages that assumed the Ark was the carrier of human 
hopes and a superior civilization. Nothing that we sent-questions, comments, information, or 
acknowledgements-ever stimulated a reply. And nothing that they sent ever discussed life aboard the 
Ark. We had no idea if they lived in poverty or plenty, if they were increasing or decreasing in numbers, 
if they were receiving our transmissions, if they had material problems of any kind. Everything that came 
back to the solar system was science, delivered in a smug and self-satisfied tone. From all that science, 
the recent transmission on physics was the only one to excite more than a mild curiosity from our own 
scientists. Usually the Ark sent "discoveries" that had been made here long ago. 

Once the drive of the Hoatzin was up to full thrust there was no way that we could see anything or 


communicate with anyone. The drive was fixed to the mass plate on the front of the ship, and the 
particles that streamed past us and out to the rear were visible only when they were in collision with the 
rare atoms of hydrogen drifting in free space. We had actually settled for less than a maximum drive and 
were using a slightly dispersed exhaust. A tightly focused and collimated beam wouldn't harm us any, but 
we didn't want to generate a death ray behind us that would disintegrate anything in its path for a few 
light-years. 

Six days into the trip, our journey out shared the most common feature of all long distance travel. It 
was boring. When McAndrew wasn't busy inside his head, staring at the wall in front of him and 
performing the mental acrobatics that he called theoretical physics, we talked, played and exercised. I 
was astonished again that a man who knew so much about so much could know nothing about some 
things. 

"You mean to tell me," he said once, as we lay in companionable darkness, with the side port 
showing the eldritch and unpredictable blue sparks of atomic collision. "You mean that Lungfish wasn't 
the first space station. All the books and records show it that way." 

"No, they don't. If they do, they're wrong. It's a common mistake. Like the idea back at the beginning 
of flight itself, that Lindbergh was the first man to fly across the Atlantic Ocean. He was more like the 
hundredth." I saw McAndrew turn his head towards me. "Yes, you heard me. A couple of airships had 
been over before him, and a couple of other people in aircraft. He was just the first person to fly alone. 
Lungfish was the first truly permanent space station, that's all. And I'll tell you something else. Did you 
know that in the earliest flights, even ones that lasted for months, the crews were usually all men? Think 
of that for a while." 

He was silent for a moment. "I don't see anything wrong with it. It would simplify some of the 
plumbing, maybe some other things, too." 

"You don't understand, Mac. That was at a time when it was regarded as morally wrong for men to 
form sexual relationships with men, or women with women." 

There was what I might describe as a startled silence. 

"Oh," said McAndrew at last. Then, after a few moments more, "My God. How much did they have 
to pay them? Or was coercion used?" 

"It was considered an honor to be chosen." 

He didn't say any more about it; but I don't think he believed me, either. Politeness is one of the first 
things you learn on long trips. 

We cut off the drive briefly at crossover, but there was nothing to be seen and there was still no way 
we could receive messages. We were crowding light speed so closely that anything from Triton Station 
would scarcely be catching up with us. The Institute's message was still on its way to the Ark of 
Massingham, and we would be there ourselves not long after it. The Hoatzin was behaving perfectly, 
with none of the problems that had almost done us in on the earlier test ships. The massive disc of dense 
matter at the front of the ship protected us from most of our collisions with stray dust and free hydrogen. 
If we didn't come back, the next ship out could follow our path exactly, tracking our swath of ionization. 

During deceleration I began to search the sky beyond the Hoatzin every day, with an all-frequency 
sweep that ought to pick up signals as soon as our drive went to reduced thrust. We didn't pick up the 
Ark until the final day and it was no more than a point on the microwave screen for most of that. The 
image we finally built up on the monitor showed a lumpy, uneven ball, pierced by black shafts. Spiky 
antennas and angled gantries stood up like spines on its dull grey surface. I had seen the images of the 
Ark before it left the Solar System, and all the surface structures were new. The colonists had been busy 
in the seventy-seven years since they accelerated away from Ganymede orbit. 

We moved in to five thousand kilometers, cut the drive, and sent a calling sequence. I don't 
remember a longer five seconds, waiting for their response. When it came it was an anti-climax. A 
pleasant-looking middle-aged woman appeared on our screen. 

"Hello," she said cheerfully. "We received a message that you were on your way here. My name is 
Kleeman. Link in your computer and we'll dock you. There will be a few formalities before you can 
come inside." 


I put the central computer into distributed mode and linked a navigation module through the com-net. 
She sounded friendly and normal but I didn't want her to have override control of all the Hoatzin's 
movements. We moved to a position about fifty kilometers away from the Ark, then Kleeman appeared 
again on the screen. 

"I didn't realize your ship had so much mass. We'll hold there, and you can come in on a pod. All 
right?" 

We usually called it a capsule these days, but I knew what she meant. I made McAndrew put on a 
suit, to his disgust, and we entered the small transfer vessel. It was just big enough for four people, with 
no air lock and a simple electric drive. We drifted in to the Ark, with the capsule's computer slaved 
through the Hoatzin. As we got nearer I had a better feel for size. Two kilometers is small for an 
asteroid, but it's awfully big compared with a human. We nosed into contact with a landing tower, like a 
fly landing on the side of a wasp's nest. I hoped that would prove to be a poor analogy. 

We left the capsule open and went hand-over-hand down the landing tower rather than wait for an 
electric lift. It was impossible to believe that we were moving at almost nine thousand kilometers a 
second away from Earth. The stars were in the same familiar constellations, and it took a while to pick 
out the Sun. It was a bright star, but a good deal less bright than Sirius. I stood at the bottom of the 
tower for a few seconds, peering about me before entering the air lock that led to the interior of the Ark. 
It was a strange, alien landscape, with the few surface lights throwing black angular shadows across the 
uneven rock. My trips to Titan suddenly felt like local hops around the comfortable backyard of the 
Solar System. 

"Come on, Jeanie." That was McAndrew, all brisk efficiency and already standing in the air lock. He 
was much keener than I to penetrate that unfamiliar world of the interior. 
I took a last look at the stars, and fixed in my mind the position of the transfer capsule-an old habit 
that pays off once in a thousand times. Then I followed McAndrew down into the lock. 
* * * 

A few formalities before you can come inside. Kleeman had a gift for understatement. We found 
out what she meant when we stepped in through the inner lock, to an office-cum-schoolroom equipped 
with a couple of impressive consoles and displays. Kleeman met us there, as pleasant and rosy-faced in 
the flesh as she had seemed over the com-link. 

She waved us to the terminals. "This is an improved version of the equipment that was on the original 
ship, before it left your system. Please sit down. Before anyone can enter our main Home, they must 
take tests. It has been that way since Massingham first showed us how our society could be built." 

We sat at the terminals, back-to-back. McAndrew was frowning at the delay. "What's the test, 
then?" he grumbled. 

"Just watch the screen. I don't think that either of you will have any trouble." 

She smiled and left us to it. I wondered what the penalty was if you failed. We were a long way from 
home. It seemed clear that if they had been improving this equipment after they left Ganymede, they must 
apply it to their own people. We were certainly the first visitors they had seen for seventy-five years. 
How had they been able to accept our arrival so calmly? 

Before I could pursue that thought the screen was alive. I read the instructions as they appeared 
there, and followed them as carefully as possible. After a few minutes I got the knack of it. We had tests 
rather like it when I first applied to go into space. To say that we were taking an intelligence test would 
be an oversimplification-many other aptitudes were tested, as well as knowledge and mechanical skills. 
That was the only consolation I had. McAndrew must be wiping the floor with me on all the parts that 
called for straight brain-power, but I knew that his coordination was terrible. He could unwrap a set of 
interlocking, multiply-connected figures mentally and tell you how they came apart, but ask him to do the 
same thing with real objects and he wouldn't be able to start. 

After three hours we were finished. Both screens suddenly went blank. We swung to face each other. 

"What's next?" I said. He shrugged and began to look at the terminal itself. The design hadn't been 
used in the System for fifty years. I took a quick float around the walls-we had entered the Ark near a 
pole, where the effective gravity caused by its rotation was negligible. Even on the Ark's equator I 


estimated that we wouldn't feel more than a tenth of a gee at the most. 

No signs of what I was looking for, but that didn't mean much. Microphones could be disguised in a 
hundred ways. 

"Mac, who do you think she is?" 

He looked up from the terminal. "Why, she's the woman assigned to . . ." He stopped. He had caught 
my point. When you are two light-years from Sol and you have your first visitors for seventy-five years, 
who leads the reception party? Not the man and woman who recycle the garbage. Kleeman ought to be 
somebody important on the Ark. 

"I can assist your speculation," said a voice from the wall. So much for our privacy. As I expected, 
we had been observed throughout-no honor system on this test. "I am Kal Massingham Kleeman, the 
daughter of Jules Massingham, and I am senior member of Home outside the Council of Intellects. Wait 
there for one more moment. I will join you with good news." 

She was beaming when she reappeared. Whatever they were going to do with us, it didn't seem likely 
they would be flinging us out into the void. 

"You are both prime stock, genetically and individually," she said. "I thought that would be the case 
when first I saw you." 

She looked down at a green card in her hand. "I notice that you both failed to answer one small part 
of the inquiry on your background. Captain Roker, your medical record indicates that you bore one 
child. But what is its sex, condition, and present status?" 

I heard McAndrew suck in his breath past his teeth, while I suppressed my own shock as best I 
could. It was clear that the standards of privacy in the System and on the Ark had diverged widely in the 
past seventy-seven years. 

"It is a female." I hope I kept my voice steady. "Healthy, and with no neuroses. She is in first level 
education on Luna." 

"The father?" 

"Unknown." 

I shouldn't have been pleased to see that now Kleeman was shocked, but I was. She looked as 
distressed as I felt. After a few seconds she grabbed control of her emotions, swallowed, and nodded. 

"We are not ignorant of the unplanned matings that your System permits. But hearing of such things 
and encountering them directly are not the same." She looked again at her green card. "McAndrew, you 
show no children. Is that true?" 

He had taken his lead from me and managed a calm and literal reply. "No recorded children." 

"Incredible." Kleeman was shaking her head. "That a man of your talents should be permitted to go 
so long without suitable mating . . ." 

She looked at him hungrily, the way that I have seen McAndrew eye an untapped set of experimental 
data from out in the Halo. I could imagine how he had performed on the intellectual sections of the test. 

"Come along," she said at last, still eyeing McAndrew in a curiously intense and possessive way. "I 
would like to show you some of Home, and arrange for you to have living quarters for your use." 

"Don't you want more details of why we are here?" burst out Mac. "We've come nearly two 
light-years to get to the Ark." 

"You have been receiving our messages of the advances that we have made?" Kleeman's manner had 
a vast self-confidence. "Then why should we be surprised when superior men and women from your 
system wish to come here? We are only surprised that it took you so long to develop a suitably efficient 
ship. Your vessel is new?" 

"Very new." I spoke before McAndrew could get a word in. Kleeman's assumption that we were on 
the Ark to stay had ominous overtones. We needed to know more about the way the place functioned 
before we told her that we were planning only a brief visit. 

"We have been developing the drive for our ship using results that parallel some of those found by 
your scientists," I went on. I gave Mac a look that kept him quiet for a little while longer. "When we have 
finished with the entry preliminaries, Professor McAndrew would very much like to meet your physicists." 

She smiled serenely at him. "Of course. McAndrew, you should be part of our Council of Intellects. I 


do not know how high your position was back in your system, but I feel sure you have nothing as 
exalted-and as respected-as our Council. Well,"-she placed the two green cards she was holding in the 
pocket of her yellow smock-"there will be plenty of time to discuss induction to the Council when you 
have settled in here. The entry formalities are complete. Let me show you Home. There has never been 
anything like it in the whole of human history." 

Over the next four hours we followed Kleeman obediently through the interior of the Ark. 
McAndrew was itching to locate his fellow-physicists, but he knew he was at the mercy of Kleeman's 
decisions. From our first meeting with others on the Ark, there was no doubt who was the boss there. 

How can I describe the interior of the Ark? Imagine a free-space beehive, full of hard-working bees 
that had retained an element of independence of action. Everyone on the Ark of Massingham seemed 
industrious, cooperative, and intelligent. But they were missing a dimension, the touch of orneriness and 
unpredictability that you would find on Luna or on Titan. Nobody was cursing, nobody was irrational. 
Kleeman guided us through a clean, slightly dull Utopia. 

The technology of the Ark was simpler to evaluate. Despite the immense pride with which Kleeman 
showed off every item of development, they were half a century behind us. The sprawling, overcrowded 
chaos of Earth was hard to live with, but it provided a constant pressure towards innovation. New 
inventions come fast when ten billion people are there to push you to new ideas. In those terms, life on 
the Ark was spacious and leisurely. The colony had constructed its network of interlocking tunnels to a 
point where it would take months to explore all the passages and corridors, but they were nowhere near 
exhausting their available space and resources. 

"How many people would the Ark hold?" I asked McAndrew as we trailed along behind Kleeman. It 
would have taken only a minute or two to work it out for myself, but you get lazy when you live for a 
while with a born calculator. 

"If they don't use the interior material to extend the surface of the Ark?" he said. "Give them the same 
room as we'd allow on Earth, six meters by six meters by two meters. They could hold nearly sixty 
million. Halve that, maybe, to allow for recycling and maintenance equipment." 

"But that is not our aim," said Kleeman. She had overheard my question. "We are stabilized at ten 
thousand. We are not like the fools back on Earth. Quality is our aim, not mindless numbers." 

She had that tone in her voice again, the one that had made me instinctively avoid the question of how 
long we would be staying on the Ark. Heredity is a potent influence. I couldn't speak about Jules 
Massingham, the founder of this Ark, but his daughter was a fanatic. I have seen others like her over the 
years. Nothing would be allowed to interfere with the prime objective: build the Ark's population on 
sound eugenic principles. Kleeman was polite to me-I was "prime stock"-but she had her eye mainly on 
McAndrew. He would be a wonderful addition to her available gene pool. 

Well, the lady had taste. I shared some of that attitude myself. "Father unknown" was literally true 
and Mac and I had not chosen to elaborate. Our daughter had rights, too, and Jan's parentage would 
not be officially known unless she chose after puberty to take the chromosome matching tests. 

Over the next six days, McAndrew and I worked our way into the life pattern aboard the Ark. The 
place ran like a clock, everything according to a schedule and everything in the right position. I had a 
good deal of leisure time, which I used to explore the less-popular corridors, up near the Hub. 
McAndrew was still obsessed with his search for physicists. 

"No sense here," he growled to me, after a meal in the central dining area out on the Ark's equator. 
As I had guessed, effective gravity there was about a tenth of a gee. "I've spoken to a couple of dozen 
of their scientists. There's not one of them would last a week at the Institute. Muddled minds and bad 
experiments." 

He was angry. Usually McAndrew was polite to all scientists, even ones who couldn't understand 
what he was doing, still less add to it. 

"Have you seen them all? Maybe Kleeman is keeping some of them from us." 

"I've had that thought. She's talked to me every day about the Council of Intellects, and I've seen 
some of the things they've produced. But I've yet to meet one of them, in person." He shrugged, and 
rubbed at his sandy, receding hairline. "After we've slept I'm going to try another tack. There's a 


schoolroom over on the other side of the Ark, where I gather Kleeman keeps people who don't seem 
quite to fit into her ideas. Want to take a look there with me, tomorrow?" 

"Maybe. I'm wondering what Kleeman has in mind for me. I think I know her plans for you, she sees 
you as another of her senior brains." I saw the woman herself approaching us across the wide room, 
with its gently curving floor. "You'd like it, I suspect. It seems to be like the Institute, but members of the 
Council have a lot more prestige." 

I had immediate proof that I was right. Kleeman seemed to have made up her mind. "We need a 
commitment from you now, McAndrew," she said. "There is a coming vacancy on the Council. You are 
the best person to fill it." 

McAndrew looked flattered but uncomfortable. The trouble was, it really did interest him, I could tell 
that. The idea of a top-level brains trust had appeal. 

"All right," he said after a few moments. He looked at me, and I could tell what he was thinking. If we 
were going to be on our way back home soon, it would do no harm to help the Ark while he was here. 
They could use all the help available. 

Kleeman clapped her hands together softly; plump white hands that pointed out her high 
position-most people on the Ark had manual duties to keep the place running, with strict duty rosters. 

"Wonderful! I will plan for your induction tomorrow. Let me make the announcement tonight, and we 
can speed up the proceedings for the outgoing member." 

"You always have a fixed number of members?" asked McAndrew. 

She seemed slightly puzzled by his question. "Of course. Exactly twelve. The system was designed 
for that number." 

She nodded at me and hurried away across the dining area, a determined little woman who always 
got her way. Since we first arrived she had never ceased to tell McAndrew that he must become the 
father of many children; scores of children; hundreds of children. He looked more and more worried as 
she increased the number of his future progeny. 

The next morning I went on with my own exploration of the Ark, while McAndrew made a visit to 
the Ark's oddities, the people who didn't seem to fit Kleeman's expectations. We met to eat together, as 
usual, and I had a lot on my mind. I had come across an area in the center of the Ark where power 
supply lines and general purpose tube inputs increased enormously, but it did not seem to be a living 
area. Everything led to one central area, but one accessible only with a suitable code. I puzzled over it 
while I waited for McAndrew to appear. 

The whole Ark was bustling with excitement. Kleeman had made the announcement of McAndrew's 
coming incorporation to the Council of Intellects. People who had scarcely spoken to him before 
stopped us and shook his hand solemnly, wishing him well and thanking him for his devotion to the 
welfare of the Ark. While I drank an aperitif of glucose and dilute ascorbic acid, preparations for a big 
ceremony were going on around me. A new Council member was a big event. 

When I saw McAndrew threading his way towards me past a network of new scaffolding, I knew his 
morning had been more successful than mine. His thin face was flushed with excitement and pleasure. He 
slid into the seat opposite me. 

"You found your physicist?" I hardly needed to ask the question. 

He nodded. "Up on the other side, in a maximum gravity segment right across from here. He's-you 
have no idea-he's-" McAndrew was practically gibbering in his excitement. 

"Start from the beginning." I leaned across and took his hands in mine. 

"Yes. I went out on the other side of the Ark, where there's a sort of tower built out from the surface. 
We must have passed it on the way over from the Hoatzin but I didn't notice it then. Kleeman never 
took us there-never mentioned it to me." 

He reached out with one hand across the table, grabbed my drink and took a great gulp of it. "Och, 
Jeanie, I needed that. I've not stopped since I first opened my eyes. Where was I? I went on up to that 
tower, and there was nobody to stop me or to say a word. And I went on inside, farther out, to the very 
end of it. The last segment has a window all the way round, so when you're there you can see the stars 
and the nebulae wheeling round past your head." McAndrew was unusually stirred and his last sentence 


proved it. The stars were normally considered fit subjects only for theory and computation. 

"He was out in that last room," he went on. "After I'd given up hope of finding anybody in this whole 
place who could have derived those results we got back through Triton Station. Jeanie, he looks no 
more than a boy. So blond, and so young. I couldn't believe that he was the one who worked out that 
theory. But he is. We sat right down at the terminal there, and I started to run over the background for 
the way that I renormalize the vacuum self-energy. It's nothing like his way. He has a completely different 
approach, different invariants, different quantization conditions. I think his method is a good deal more 
easy to generalize. That's why he can get multiple vacuum colors out when we look for resonance 
conditions. 

"Jeanie, you should have seen his face when I told him that we probably had fifty people at the 
Institute who would be able to follow his proofs. He's been completely alone here. There's not another 
one who can even get close to following him, he says. When he sent back those equations, he didn't tell 
people how important he thought they might be. He says they worry more about controlling what comes 
in from the System, rather than what goes out from here. I'm awful glad we came. He's an accident, a 
sport that shows up only once in a couple of centuries-and he was born out here in the void! Did you 
know, he's taken all the old path integral methods, and he has a form of quantum theory that looks so 
simple, you'd never believe it if you didn't see it . . ." 

He was off again. I had to break in, or he would have talked without stopping, right through our meal. 
McAndrew doesn't babble often, but when he does he's hard to stop. 

"Mac, hold on. Something here doesn't make sense. What about the Council of Intellects?" 

"What about it?" He looked as though he had no possible interest in the Council of Intellects-even 
though the bustle that was going on all around us, with new structures being erected, was all to mark 
McAndrew's elevation to the Council. 

"Look, just yesterday we agreed that the work you're interested in here must have originated with the 
Council. You told me you hadn't met one person who knew anything worth discussing. Are you telling 
me now that this work on the vacuum energy doesn't come from the people on the Council?" 

"I'm sure it doesn't. I doubted that even before I met Wicklund, up there in the tower." McAndrew 
was looking at me impatiently, "Jeanie, if that's the impression I gave, it's not what I meant. A thing like 
this is almost always the work of a single person. It's not initiated by a group, even though a group may 
help to apply it to practice. This work, the vacuum color work, that's all Wicklund-the Council knows 
nothing of it." 

"So what does the Council do? I hope you haven't forgotten that you're going to join it later today. I 
don't think Kleeman would take it well if you said you wanted to change your mind." 

He waved an impatient arm at me. "Now, Jeanie, you know I've no time for that. The Council of 
Intellects is some sort of guiding and advising group, and I'm willing to serve on it and do what I can for 
the Ark. But not now. I have to get back over to Wicklund and sort out some of the real details. Did I 
mention that I've explained all about the drive to him? He mops up new material like a sponge. If we can 
get him back to the Institute he'll catch up on fifty years of system science development in a few months. 
You know, I'd better go and talk to Kleeman about this council of hers. What's the use of calling it a 
Council of Intellects, when people like Wicklund are not on it? And I'll have to tell her we want to take 
him back with us. I've already mentioned it to him. He's interested, but he's a bit scared of the idea. This 
is home to him, the only place he knows. Here, is that Kleeman over there by the scaffolding? I'd better 
catch her now." 

He was up and out of his seat before I could stop him. He hurried over to her, took her to one side 
and began to speak to her urgently. He was gesturing and cracking his finger joints, in the way that he 
always did when he was wound up on something. As I moved to join them I could see Kleeman's 
expression changing from a friendly interest to a solid determination. 

"We can't change things now, McAndrew," she was saying. "The departing member has already been 
removed from the Council. It is imperative that the replacement be installed as soon as possible. That 
ceremony must take place tonight." 

"But I want to continue my meetings with-" 


"The ceremony will take place tonight. Don't you understand? The Council cannot function without all 
twelve members. I cannot discuss this further. There is nothing to discuss." 

She turned and walked away. Just as well, McAndrew was all set to tell her that he was not about to 
join her precious council, and he was planning to leave the Ark without fathering hundreds, scores, or 
even ones of children. And he was taking one of her colonists-her subjects-with him. I took his arm 
firmly and dragged him back to our table. 

"Calm down, Mac." I spoke as urgently as I could. "Don't fly off wild now. Let's get this stupid 
council initiation rite out of the way today, and then let's wait a while and approach Kleeman on all this 
when she's in a more reasonable mood. All right?" 

"That damned, obstinate, overbearing woman. Who the hell does she think she is?" 

"She thinks she's the boss of the Ark of Massingham, and she is the boss of the Ark of Massingham. 
Face facts. Slow down now, and go back to Wicklund. See if he's interested in leaving when we leave, 
but don't push it too hard. Let's wait a few days, there's nothing to be lost from that." 

How naive can you get? Kleeman had told us exactly what was going on, but we hadn't listened. 
People hear what they expect to hear. 

I found out the truth the idiot's way. After McAndrew had gone off again, calm enough to talk to his 
new protege, I had about four hours to kill. The great ceremony in which McAndrew would become 
part of the Council of Intellects would not take place until after the next meal. I decided I would have 
another look at the closed room that I had seen on my earlier roaming. 

The room was still locked, but this time there was a servicewoman working on the pipes that led into 
it. She recognized me as one of the two recent arrivals on the Ark-the less important one, according to 
Ark standards. 

"Tonight's the big event," she said to me, her manner friendly. "You've come to take a look at the 
place your friend will be, have you? You know, we really need him. The Council has been almost 
useless for the past two years, with one member almost gone. Kleeman knew that, but she didn't seem 
happy to provide a new member until she met McAndrew." 

She obviously assumed I knew all about the Council and its workings. I stepped closer, keeping my 
voice casual and companionable. "I'll see all this for myself tonight. McAndrew will be in here, right? I 
wonder if I could take a peek now, I've never been inside before." 

"Sure." She went to the door and keyed in a combination. "There's been talk for a while of moving 
the Council to another part of Home, where there's less vibration from construction work. No sign of it 
happening yet, though. Here we go. You won't be able to go inside the inner room, of course, but you'll 
find you can see most things from the service area." 

As the door slid open I stepped through into a long, brightly-lit room. It was empty. 

My heart began to pound urgently and my mouth was as dry as Ceres. Strange, how the absence of 
something can produce such a powerful effect on the body. 

"Where are they?" I said at last. "The Council. You said they are in this room." 

She looked at me in comical disbelief. "Well, you didn't expect to find them sitting out in the open, did 
you? Take a look through the hatch at the end there." 

We walked forward together and peered through a transparent panel at the far end of the room. It 
led through to another, smaller chamber, this one dimly lit by a soft green glow. 

My eyes took a few seconds to adapt. The big, translucent tank in the center of the room slowly 
came into definition. All around it, equally spaced, were twelve smaller sections, all inter-connected 
through a massive set of branching cables and optic bundles. 

"Well, there they are," said the servicewoman. "Doesn't look right, does it, with one of them missing 
like this? It doesn't work, either. The information linkages are all built for a set of exactly twelve units, 
with a twelve-by-twelve transfer matrix." 

Now I could see that one of the small tanks was empty. In each of the eleven others, coupled to a set 
of thin plastic tubes and contact wires, was a complex shape, a dark-grey ovoid swimming in a bath of 
green fluid. The surfaces were folded and convoluted, glistening with the sticky sheen of animal tissues. 
At the lower end, each human brain thinned away past the brain stem to the spinal cord. 


I remember asking her just one question: "What would happen if the twelfth member of the Council of 
Intellects were not connected in today?" 

"It would be bad." She looked shocked. "Very bad. I don't know the details, but I think all the 
potentials would run wild in a day or two, and destroy the other eleven. It has never happened. There 
have always been twelve members of the Council, since Massingham created it. He is the one over 
there, on the far right." 

We must have spoken further, but already my mind was winging its way back to the dining area. I 
was to meet McAndrew one hour before the big ceremony. Incorporation, that was what Kleeman had 
called it, incorporation into the Council. De-corporation would be a better name for the process. But the 
Council of Intellects was well-named. After someone has been pared down, flesh, bone and organs, to a 
brain and a spinal column, intellect is all that can remain. Perhaps the thing that upset me more than 
anything in that inner room was their decision to leave the eyes intact. They were there, attached to each 
brain by the protruding stalks of their optic nerves. They looked like the horns of a snail, blue, grey or 
brown balls projecting from the frontal lobes. Since there were no muscles left to change the focal length 
of the eye lenses, they were directed to display screens set at fixed distances from the tanks. 

The wait in the dining area was a terrible period. I had been all right on the way back from the 
Council Chamber, there had been movement to make the tension tolerable, but when McAndrew finally 
appeared my nerves had become awfully ragged. He was all set to burble on about his physics 
discussions. I cut him off before he could get out one word. 

"Mac, don't speak and don't make any quick move. We have to leave the Ark. Now." 

"Jeanie!" Then he saw my face. "What about Sven Wicklund? We've talked again and he wants to go 
with us-but he's not ready." 

I shook my head and looked down at the table top. It was the worst possible complication. We had 
to move through the Ark and transfer across to the Hoatzin, without being noticed. If Kleeman sensed 
our intentions, Mac might still make it to the Council. My fate was less certain but probably even 
worse-if a worse fate is imaginable. It would be hard enough doing what we had to do without the 
addition of a nervous and inexperienced young physicist. But I knew McAndrew. 

"Go get him," I said at last. "Remember the lock we came in by?" 

He nodded. "I can get us there. When?" 

"Half an hour. Don't let him bring anything with him-we'll be working with a narrow margin." 

He stood up and walked away without another word. He probably wouldn't have agreed to go 
without Wicklund; but he hadn't asked me for any explanation, hadn't insisted on a reason why we had 
to leave. That sort of trust isn't built up overnight. I was scared shitless as I stood up and left the dining 
area, but in an obscure way I was feeling that warm glow you only feel when two people touch deeply. 
McAndrew had sensed a life-or-death issue, and trusted me without question. 

Back at our sleeping quarters I picked up the com-link that gave me coded access to the computer 
on the Hoatzin. We had to make sure the ship was still in the same position. I followed my own 
directive and took nothing else. Kal Massingham Kleeman was a lady whose anger was best 
experienced from a distance. I had in mind a light-year or two, but at the moment I was concerned only 
with the first couple of kilometers. I wanted to move out of the Ark in a hurry. 

The interior of the Ark was a great warren of connecting tunnels, so there were a hundred ways 
between any two points. That was just as well. I changed my path whenever I saw anyone else 
approaching, but I was still able to move steadily in the direction of our entry lock. 

Twenty minutes since McAndrew had left. Now the speaker system crackled and came to life. 

"Everyone will assemble in Main Hall Five." 

The ceremony was ready to begin. Kleeman was going to produce Hamlet without the Prince. I 
stepped up my pace. The trip through the interior of the Ark was taking longer than I had expected, and 
I was going to be late. 

Thirty minutes, and I was still one corridor away. The monitors in the passage ceiling suddenly came 
to life, their red lenses glowing. All I could do was keep moving. There was no way of avoiding those 
monitors, they extended through the whole interior of the Ark. 


"McAndrew and Roker." It was Kleeman's voice, calm and superior. "We are waiting for you. There 
will be punishment unless you come at once to Main Hall Five. Your presence in the outer section has 
been noted. A collection detail will arrive there at any moment. McAndrew, do not forget that the 
Council awaits you. You are abusing a great honor by your actions." 

I was at last at the lock. McAndrew stood there listening to Kleeman's voice. The young man by his 
side-as Mac had said, so blond, so young-had to be Sven Wicklund. Behind those soft blue eyes lay a 
brain that even McAndrew found impressive. Wicklund was frowning now, his expression indecisive. All 
his ideas on life had been turned upside down in the past days, and Kleeman's latest words must be 
giving him second thoughts about our escape. 

Without speaking, McAndrew turned and pointed towards the wall of the lock. I looked, and felt a 
sudden sickness. The wall where the line of suits should be hanging was empty. 

"No suits?" I said stupidly. 

He nodded. "Kleeman has been thinking a move ahead of you." 

"You know what joining the Council would imply?" 

He nodded again. His face was grey. "Sven told me as we came over here. I couldn't believe it at 
first. I asked him, what about the children Kleeman wanted me to sire? They would drain me for the 
sperm bank before they . . ." He swallowed. 

There was a long and terrible pause. "I looked out," he said at last. "Through the viewport there. The 
capsule is still where we left it." 

"You're willing to chance it?" I looked at Wicklund, who stood there not following our conversation 
at all. 

Mac nodded. "I am. But what about him? There's no Sturm Invocation for people here on the Ark." 

As I had feared, Wicklund was a major complication. 

I walked forward and stood in front of him. "Do you still want to go with us?" 

He licked his lips, then nodded. 

"Into the lock." We moved forward together and I closed the inner door. 

"Do not be foolish." It was Kleeman's voice again, this time with a new expression of alarm. "There is 
nothing to be served by sacrificing yourselves to space. McAndrew, you are a rational man. Come 
back, and we will discuss this together. Do not waste your potential by a pointless death." 

I took a quick look through the port of the outer lock. The capsule was there all right, it looked just 
the same as when we left it. Wicklund was staring out in horror. Until Kleeman had spoken, it did not 
seem to have occurred to him that we were facing death in the void. 

"Mac!" I said urgently. 

He nodded, and gently took Wicklund by the shoulders, swinging him around. I stepped up behind 
Wicklund and dug hard into the nerve centers at the base of his neck. He was unconscious in two 
seconds. 

"Ready, Mac?" 

Another quick nod. I checked that Wicklund's eyelids were closed, and that his breathing was 
shallow. He would be unconscious for another couple of minutes, pulse rate low and oxygen need 
reduced. 

McAndrew stood at the outer lock, ready to open it. I pulled the whistle from the lapel of my jacket 
and blew hard. The varying triple tone sounded through the lock. Penalty for improper use of any Sturm 
Invocation was severe, whether you used spoken, whistled, or electronic methods. I had never invoked 
it before, but anyone who goes into space, even if it is just a short trip from Earth to Moon, must receive 
Sturm vacuum survival programming. One person in a million uses it. I stood in the lock, waiting to see 
what would happen to me. 

The sensation was strange. I still had full command of my movements, but a new set of involuntary 
activities came into play. Without any conscious decision to do so I found that I was breathing hard, 
hyper-ventilating in great gulps. My eye-blinking pattern had reversed. Instead of open eyes with rapid 
blinks to moisten and clean the eyeball, my lids were closed except for brief instants. I saw the lock and 
the space outside as quick snapshots. 


The Sturm Invocation had the same effect an McAndrew, as his own deep programming took over 
for vacuum exposure. When I nodded, he swung open the outer lock door. The air was gone in a puff of 
ice vapor. As my eyes flicked open I saw the capsule at the top of the landing tower. To reach it we had 
to traverse sixty meters of the interstellar vacuum. And we had to carry Sven Wicklund's unconscious 
body between us. 

For some reason I had imagined that the Sturm vacuum programming would make me insensitive to 
all pain. Quite illogical, since you could permanently damage your body all too easily in that situation. I 
felt the agony of expansion through my intestines, as the air rushed out of all my body cavities. My mouth 
was performing an automatic yawning and gasping, emptying the Eustachian tube to protect my ear 
drums and delicate inner ear. My eyes were closed to protect the eyeballs from freezing, and open just 
often enough to guide my body movements. 

Holding Wicklund between us, McAndrew and I pushed off into the open depths of space. Ten 
seconds later, we intersected the landing tower about twenty meters up. Sturm couldn't make a human 
comfortable in space, but he had provided a set of natural movements that corresponded to a zero-gee 
environment. They were needed. If we missed the tower there was no other landing point within 
light-years. 

The metal of the landing tower was at a temperature several hundred degrees below freezing. Our 
hands were unprotected, and I could feel the ripping of skin at each contact. That was perhaps the worst 
pain. The feeling that I was a ball, over-inflated and ready to burst, was not a pain. What was it? That 
calls for the same sort of skills as describing sight to a blind man. All I can say is that once in a lifetime is 
more than enough. 

Thirty seconds in the vacuum, and we were still fifteen meters from the capsule. I was getting the first 
feeling of anoxia, the first moment of panic. As we dropped into the capsule and tagged shut the hatch I 
could feel the black clouds moving around me, dark nebulae that blanked out the bright star field. 

The transfer capsule had no real air lock. When I hit the air supply, the whole interior began to fill 
with warm oxygen. As the concentration grew to a perceptible fraction of an atmosphere, I felt 
something turn off abruptly within me. My eye blinking went back to the usual pattern, my mouth closed 
instead of gaping and gasping, and the black patches started to dwindle and fragment. 

I turned on the drive of the transfer vessel to take us on our fifty kilometer trip to the Hoatzin and 
glanced quickly at the other two. Wicklund was still unconscious, eyes closed but breathing normally. He 
had come through well. McAndrew was something else. There was blood flowing from the corner of his 
mouth and he was barely conscious. He must have been much closer to collapse than I when we 
dropped into the capsule, but he had not loosened his grip on Wicklund. 

I felt a moment of irritation. Damn that man. He had assured me that he would replace that damaged 
lung lobe after our last trip but I was pretty sure he had done nothing about it. This time I would see he 
had the operation, if I had to take him there myself. 

He began to cough weakly and his eyes opened. When he saw that we were in the capsule and 
Wicklund was between us, he smiled a little and let his eyes close again. I put the drive on maximum and 
noticed for the first time the blood that was running from my left hand. The palm and fingers were raw 
flesh, skin ripped off by the hellish cold of the landing tower. I reached behind me and pulled out the 
capsule's small medical kit. Major fix-ups would have to wait until we were on the Hoatzin. The 
surrogate flesh was bright yellow, like a thick mustard, but it took away the pain. I smeared it over my 
own hand, then reached across and did the same for McAndrew. His face was beginning to blaze with 
the bright red of broken capillaries, and I was sure that I looked just the same. That was nothing. It was 
the bright blood dribbling down his blue tunic that I didn't like. 

Wicklund was awake. He winced and held his hands up to his ears. There might be a burst eardrum 
there, something else we would have to take care of when we got to the Hoatzin. 

"How did I get here?" he said wonderingly. 

"Across the vacuum. Sorry we had to put you out like that, but I didn't think you could have faced a 
vacuum passage when you were conscious." 

His gaze turned slowly to McAndrew. "Is he all right?" 


"I hope so. There may be some lung damage that we'll have to take care of. Want to do something to 
help?" 

He nodded, then turned back to look at the ball of the Ark, dwindling behind us. "They can't catch us 
now, can they?" 

"They might try, but I don't think so. Kleeman probably considers anybody who wants to leave the 
Ark is not worth having. Here, take the blue tube out of the kit behind you and smear it on your face and 
hands. Do the same for McAndrew. It will speed up the repair of the ruptured blood vessels in your 
skin." 

Wicklund took the blue salve and began to apply it tenderly to McAndrew's face. 

After a couple of seconds Mac opened his eyes and smiled. "Thank you, lad," he said softly. "I'd talk 
more physics with you, but somehow I don't quite feel that I'm up to it." 

"Just lie there quiet." There was hero worship in Wicklund's voice. I had a sudden premonition of 
what the return trip was going to be like. McAndrew and Sven Wicklund in a mutual admiration society, 
and all the talk of physics. 

After we had the capsule back on board the Hoatzin I felt secure for the first time. We installed 
McAndrew comfortably on one of the bunks while I went to the drive unit and set a 
maximum-acceleration course back to the Solar System. Wicklund's attention was torn between his 
need to talk to McAndrew and his fascination with the drive and the ship. How would Einstein have felt 
in 1905, if someone could have shown him a working nuclear reactor just a few months after he had 
developed the mass-energy relation? It must have been like that for Wicklund. 

"Want to take a last look?" I said, my hand on the drive keyboard. 

He came across and gazed at the Ark, still set on its long journey to Tau Ceti. He looked sad, and I 
felt guilty. 

"I'm sorry," I said. "But I'm afraid there's no going back now." 

"I know." He hesitated. "You found Home a bad place, I could tell from what McAndrew said. But 
it's not so bad. To me, it was home for my whole life." 

"We'll talk to the Ark again. There may be a chance to come here later, when we've had more time 
to study the life that you lived. I hope you'll find a new life in the System." 

I meant it, but I was having a sudden vision of the Earth we were heading back to. Crowded, noisy, 
short of all resources. Wicklund might find it as hellish as we had found life on the Ark of Massingham. It 
was too late to do anything about it now. Fortunately, this sort of problem probably meant less to 
Wicklund than it would to most people. Like McAndrew, his real life was lived inside his own head, and 
all else was secondary to that private vision. 

I pressed the key sequence and the drive went on. Within seconds, the Ark had vanished from sight. 

I turned back and was surprised to see that McAndrew was sitting up in his bunk. He looked 
terrible, but he must be feeling better. His hands were yellow paws of surrogate flesh, his face and neck 
a bright blue coating of the ointment that Wicklund had applied to them. The dribble of blood that had 
come from his mouth had spread its bright stain down his chin and over the front of his tunic, mixing in 
with the blue fabric to produce a horrible purple splash. 

"How are you, Mac?" I said. 

"Not bad. Not bad at all." He forced a smile. 

"You know, it's not good enough. You promised me ages ago that you'd schedule a repair for that 
lung-and you didn't do it. If you think I'm prepared to keep dragging you around bleeding and bubbling, 
you're wrong. When we get back, you have that lung fixed properly-if I have to drag you to the medics 
myself." 

"Och, Jeanie." He gave a feeble shrug. "We'll see. It takes so much time away from work. Let's get 
on home, though, and we'll see. I've learned a lot on this trip, more than I ever expected. It's all been 
well worth it." 

He caught my skeptical look. "Honest, now, this is more important than you realize. We'll make the 
next trip out together, the way I promised you. Maybe next time we'll get to the stars. I'm sorry that you 
got nothing out of this one." 


I stared at him. He looked like a circus clown, all smears and streaks of different clashing colors. I 
shook my head. "You're wrong. I got something out of it." 

He looked puzzled. "How's that?" 

"I listen to you and the other physicists all the time, and usually I don't understand a word of it. This 
time I know just what you mean. Lie still, and you can see for yourself. I'll be back in a second." 

All the colors of the vacuum? That was McAndrew. If a picture is worth a thousand words, there are 
times when a mirror is worth more than that. I wanted to watch Mac's face when he saw his own 
reflection. 


FOURTH CHRONICLE: The Manna Hunt 


We had been working hard for two months, preparing for the first long trip. Neither McAndrew nor I 
would admit to feeling excited, but every day I could see the pleasure and anticipation just bubbling up in 
him. I doubt that I was any harder to read. 

It meant sixteen-hour work spells, day after day, checking every detail of the ship and mission. On an 
exploration that would take us away for four months of shipboard time and almost nine years of 
Earth-time, all the thinking had to be finished before we left the Institute. 

Finally the launch date was only four days away. 

That made the news of cancellation-when they plucked up the courage to tell us about it-hard to take. 

I had been over on the Hoatzin, checking the condition of the big massplate at the front of the ship. It 
took longer than I expected. By the time I flew my inspection pinnace on its ten thousand kilometer hop 
back to the Penrose Institute we were well into the sleep period. I hadn't expected anyone in the dining 
hall when I slipped in to dial a late meal-and certainly I didn't expect to find Professor Limperis in close 
conversation with McAndrew. 

"Working late-" I said. Then I saw their faces. Even Limperis, black as he was, looked drawn and a 
shade paler. 

I sat down opposite them. "What's happened?" 

McAndrew shrugged without speaking and jerked his head towards Limperis. 

"We've had a directive from USF Headquarters," said the older man. He seemed to be picking his 
words carefully. "Signed by Korata-right from the top. There was a meeting last week between the 
Food and Energy Council of Earth and the United Space Federation. They called me two hours ago. 
The Penrose Institute is instructed to support certain high priority Council activities. This requires that 
we-" 

"They've cancelled us, Jeanie," cut in McAndrew harshly. "The bastards. Without one word of 
discussion with anybody here. Our Alpha Centauri mission is dead-finito." 

I gawped at Limperis. He nodded in an embarrassed way. "Postponed, at least. With no new date 
set." 

"They can't do that." I was beginning to feel my own anger rising. "The Institute doesn't answer to the 
Food and Energy Council, how the hell can they claim to order you around? This is an independent 
organization. Tell them to go away and play with themselves. You have the authority to do that, don't 
you?" 

"Well . . ." Limperis looked even more embarrassed. "In principle, Captain Roker, it is as you say. I 
have the authority. But you know that's an oversimplification of the real world. We need political support 
as much as any other group-we rely partly on public funding. I like to pretend that we're pure research, 
answering to no one. In practice, we have our own political constituency in the Councils. I tried to 
explain this just now"-McAndrew grunted and glowered down at the table-"to point out why I can't 
really fight it without losing an awful lot. Three of our big supporters, Councilors who've done us big 
favors in the past, called me ten minutes after we got the first word. They want to use their credit on this 
one. The Alpha Centauri mission is off. The Council needs the use of the Hoatzin for other purposes." 

"No way." I leaned forward until our faces were only six inches apart. "That's our ship-we've slaved 
over it. If they think they can call in and take it away from me and Mac without even asking, and leave 
us-" 

"They want you, too, Jeanie." Limperis leaned back a bit. In my excitement I was spitting all over 
him. "Both of you. The orders are very clear. They want you and McAndrew and the ship." 

"And what the hell for?" 

"For a mission of their own." He looked more baffled than irritated now. "For a mission so secret 
they wouldn't tell me anything about it." 

* * * 

That was the first shock. The others dribbled in one by one as McAndrew and I made our way from 


the Penrose Institute to the headquarters of the Food and Energy Council. 

The Institute had been parked out near Mars orbit. With the Hoatzin, and its hundred gee drive, or 
even with one of the prototypes like Merganser at fifty gee, we could have been to Earth in half a day. 
But Professor Limperis still insisted that the McAndrew Drive should never be employed in the Inner 
System, and McAndrew himself backed that decision completely. We were stuck with a slow boat and 
a ten day journey. 

Surprise Number One came soon after we powered away from the Institute. I had assumed that we 
would be running a confidential mission for the Energy Department of the full Food and Energy Council. 
We had worked together on high-energy projects in the past, and I knew McAndrew was a real expert 
on the subject. But our travel documents instructed us to report to the Food Department. What did food 
programs need with a theoretical physicist, a spacecraft captain, and a high-acceleration ship? 

Three days from Earth we were hit with another surprise. The information came in as a brief, 
impersonal directive that could be neither amplified nor questioned. I would not be the captain of the 
new mission. Despite the fact that I had more experience with the McAndrew Drive than anyone else in 
the System, a Food Department official would give me my orders. I became even angrier when, two 
days from Earth, we learned the rest of it. McAndrew and I would serve as "special advisors" reporting 
to a crew from the Food and Energy Council. We would have about as much decision-making authority 
on the mission as the robochef. I had descended from captain to cabin boy. 

For me, maybe they could persuade themselves that it was a reasonable decision; some people have 
more deep space experience than I do (but not much more) and you could say that my talent is nothing 
more than tricks for staying alive and out of trouble. But McAndrew was another matter. To assign him 
a role as a simple information source suggested an ignorance or an arrogance beyond my belief. 

All right, so I'm a McAndrew fan; I won't deny it. When I got to Earth I would have words with the 
bureaucrats of the Food Department. 

I needed to talk it out with somebody, but Mac was no use. He wasn't interested in arguments on 
nontechnical subjects. Instead, he retreated as usual into his private world of tensors and twistors, and 
despite my own respectable scientific background I couldn't follow him there. For most of the journey he 
sat slack-jawed on his bunk, perfectly content, gazing at the blank wall and performing the invisible 
mental gymnastics that had earned him his reputation. 

That sort of thinking is beyond me. I spent the long hours brooding, and by the time we were led into 
the Council's offices I was loaded for bear. 

The Food Department enjoys a bigger staff and budget than anything else in System Government, 
and the opulence of its fittings was quite a contrast to the spartan furnishings of the Institute. We were 
conducted through four luxurious outer offices, each with its own secretaries and screening procedure. 
Ample working space spoke of prestige and power. The room we finally came to held a conference 
table big enough for forty people. 

A woman was seated alone at the massive desk. I looked at her elegant dress, beautifully made-up 
eyes and carefully coiffured hair, and I suddenly felt scruffy and out of place. Mac and I were dressed 
for space work, in one-piece beige coveralls and loafers. My hair had been cropped to a few 
centimeters long. His thin, straggly mop as usual dipped untidily over his high forehead. Neither of us 
was wearing a touch of make-up. 

"Professor McAndrew?" She stood up and smiled at us. I glowered back at her. "And Captain 
Roker, I assume. I must apologize for treating you in such cavalier fashion. You have had a long trip 
here, and no adequate explanation." 

Good disarming waffle, the sort you get from an experienced politician or the highest level of 
bureaucrat, but her smile was broad and friendly. She came forward and held out a pudgy hand. As I 
took it I made a closer inspection of her appearance: thirty-five years old, maybe, and a bit overweight. 
Perhaps this messy situation wasn't her fault. I restrained my scowl and muttered conventional words of 
greeting. 

She gestured us to sit down. 

"I am Anna Lisa Griss," she went on. "Head of Programs for the Food Department. Welcome to 


Headquarters. Other staff members will join us in a few minutes, but first I want to point out the need for 
secrecy. What you will learn here cannot be mentioned to anyone outside this room without my 
permission. I will come to the point at once. Look at this." 

She exuded an air of complete control. As she was speaking the lights dimmed and an image became 
visible on the screen at the far end of the room. It showed a column of calendar years, and alongside it 
two other columns of figures. 

"Total System food reserves, present and projected," said Griss. "Look at the trend-it's a log 
scale-then look particularly at the behavior thirty years from now." 

I was still trying to assimilate the first few numbers when McAndrew grunted and put his hand up to 
his face. 

"That's ridiculous," he said. "You're showing a factor of two drop in less than three decades. What's 
the basis for that projection?" 

If she felt surprise at his speed of response, she didn't show it. "We included population patterns, 
available acreages, plant yields, and capacity to manufacture synthetics. Would you like to see the details 
on any one of them?" 

McAndrew shook his head. "Never mind the details. That's disaster and starvation flashing on your 
screen." 

"It is. It's the reason that you are here." She brought the lights back up to what I regarded as a dim, 
conspiratorial level and dropped her voice to match. "You can imagine the effect when that projection 
becomes public knowledge, especially if no one can see any way out. Even though we're talking about 
many years in the future, we'd see stockpiling-probably food wars." 

I was feeling a growing anger. There had been rumors of a major future food shortage flying around 
the System for a long time. The Administration had denied every one, dismissing all gloomy forecasts as 
alarmist. 

"If you're correct in your projections, you can't keep this a secret," I said. "People have a right to 
know so they can work on solutions." 

McAndrew frowned at me, while Anna Lisa Griss gave me a quick probing glance (no smile now) 
and raised her dark eyebrows. The man's easy, her look said, but this one needs persuading. 

"The problem is clear enough," she agreed. "It has been known to my group for almost a decade. 
Fairly soon it may be obvious to everybody. But it's the possible solution I want to talk about now. And 
involving the general public wouldn't help a bit-there's no chance that they could provide new insights." 

I didn't like her superior manner, but in spite of my irritation I was becoming interested. "It has to be a 
supply-side answer," I said. "The population growth won't budge." 

"Obviously." She smiled again, a bit too broadly, and sneaked a look at her watch. "But think about 
that supply side. We'd like to increase the planted acreage, of course. But how? We're using every 
spare inch, unless we can move the lunar agricultural experiments to massive production-and nobody 
feels optimistic about that. Plant yields are as high as they will go-we're seeing bad effects of plant 
overbreeding already. No hope there. So what's left?" 

Before we could chance an answer or she could provide one, the door behind us opened. A skinny 
man with plastered-down grey hair entered and stood deferentially at the threshold. 

"Come in, Bayes." Anna Lisa Griss looked again at her watch. "You're late." 

"Sorry." He remained at the door, hesitating. 

"I began without you. Come in and sit down." She turned to face us without offering introductions. 
"There was one area still to be examined: alternative supplies of organic materials that might easily be 
converted to food. Six years ago, everyone thought that was a hopeless avenue. Now, with the 
Griss-Lanhoff Theory"-I could hear the capital letters in her voice as she proclaimed the name-"we have 
new hope." 

I was watching Bayes' face as she spoke. His lips tightened when Anna Lisa Griss pronounced the 
name of the theory, but he remained silent. 

McAndrew cleared his throat. 

"I'm afraid that I'm not as well up on the literature of food production as I ought to be," he said. 


"Lanhoff's a familiar name. If it's the same person, I knew him fairly well ten years ago, when he was 
working on porphyrin syntheses. What's he doing now?" 

"We don't know. Maybe you can help us to find out." She leaned forward and looked at us intently. 
"Lanhoff has disappeared-out in the Halo, testing our theory. Two weeks ago I learned that you have 
available a high-acceleration ship with an inertia-less drive." (I saw McAndrew wince and mutter "not 
inertia-less" to himself.) "We need the use of that, for a mission of the highest priority. We have to find 
out what happened to Lanhoff's project. Three days from now we must be on our way to the Halo." 

* * * 

It said something for the lack of efficiency of the Food Department that they would drag McAndrew 
and me all the way to Earth for a meeting, then shuttle us back to the Penrose Institute and the Hoatzin 
on a Government-owned ship less than four hours after we arrived. Anna Lisa Griss would follow to the 
Institute in another and even fancier vessel, but Bayes went with us to continue the briefing on the way. 
Without his boss around he lost his intimidated look and became a much cheerier person. 

"Let's start with Lanhoff's ideas," he said. "Though after listening to Anna back in her office it's 
apparently going to be called the Griss-Lanhoff Theory, at least while Lanhoff's not on the scene. I'll 
keep it short, but I'm not sure where to begin. In the Halo, I guess. Professor McAndrew, do you know 
anything about the Halo?" He cackled with laughter at his joke. 

Griss had asked McAndrew that same question when she was giving us our first briefing. I had 
watched Bayes' eyes bulge with astonishment. I felt the same way myself. McAndrew probably knew 
more about the Halo and the outer parts of the extended Solar System than anyone, living or dead-he 
had developed the entire theory that predicted the existence of the kernel ring, the broad belt of 
Kerr-Newman black holes that girdles the ecliptic at four hundred AU, ten times the distance of Pluto. 
And of course he had travelled out there himself, in the first test of the McAndrew balanced drive. I 
assumed that any scientist worth the name would know all about McAndrew and his work, but 
apparently Anna Lisa Griss proved me wrong. 

McAndrew laughed. He and Will Bayes had needed only ten minutes alone together to discover a 
mutual fascination with bad jokes, and they were getting along famously. I thought ahead to a long trip 
with the two of them and shuddered at the prospect. 

"Lanhoff wandered into our offices six or seven years back," went on Bayes after he had had a good 
giggle at his own wit. "He'd been analyzing the results of Halo remote chemistry probes. Didn't you do 
some of that yourself, a few years ago?" 

McAndrew rubbed at his sandy, receding hairline. "Och, just a little bit. I wanted to find power 
kernels, not low-density fragments, but as part of the survey we sneaked in a look at some other stuff as 
well. Most of the Oort cloud's so poorly surveyed, you know, it's a crime not to explore it whenever you 
have the chance. But I never looked out more than a few hundred AU-it was before we had the drive, 
and probes were too expensive. I'm sure Lanhoff had all my results to work with when he started." 

"He certainly knew your work," said Bayes. "And he remembered you well. You made quite an 
impression on him. He's an organic chemist, and he had been looking at all the data on the Halo, and 
plotting body chemical composition as a function of distance from the Sun. He has a special algorithm 
that allows him to look at the fractional composition of each object-I think it came from Minga's team. 
You probably don't remember Minga, he never published much himself. I met him once or twice, way 
back . . . no, maybe I'm thinking of Rooney. You know, he was the one who did the high-energy work, 
I think it was for the Emerald Project, wasn't it? Yes, I think so . . ." 

It's probably a kindness if I edit Will Bayes' briefing of McAndrew and me. He tried hard enough, 
but everything he said reminded him of something else, and that something else had to be explained, too, 
and all the people involved in it reminded him or other people, and what they had done. Regression, ad 
infinitum. 

We didn't mind too much, with a two-day journey before we were back at the Institute, but I must 
say I thought a bit more kindly of Anna Griss before the trip was over. Staff meetings with Bayes must 
be hell. 

Boiling Will's verbiage down to a minimum, it was a simple story: Lanhoff had done a systematic 


chemical analysis of the cometary Halo, from its beginnings beyond the Edgeworth-Kuiper Belt, all the 
way to the fading outer edge nearly half a light-year away, where the Sun's gravitational hold is so weak 
that the frozen bodies drift around in orbits with periods of millions of years. 

That's the Oort cloud, a great ball of loosely-held matter centered on the Sun. There are several 
hundred billion comets out there, ranging from near-planet-sized monsters a few hundred kilometers 
across to snowballs no bigger than your fist. Chapman's Rule applies as well to the cometary Halo as it 
does to the asteroid belt: for every object of given diameter, there are ten objects with one-third of that 
diameter. 

The Halo has been described and studied since the middle of the twentieth century, but Lanhoff's 
interests were different. He divided the solar vicinity into regions of different distances and inclinations to 
the plane of the ecliptic, and he looked at the percentage of different organic materials within each orbital 
regime. Naturally, with a trillion objects to work with he could only look at a tiny sample of the total, but 
even so the analysis took him eight years. And he found something new and surprising. In a part of the 
Halo about 3200 AU from the Sun, running out to maybe 4,000 AU, the complexity of chemical 
compounds increases enormously. Instead of simple organic molecules like cyanogen, formaldehyde, 
and methane, his program told him he was finding higher compounds and complex 
polymers-macromolecules like polysaccharide chains. 

"Like what?" At that point in the discussion I had interrupted Will Bayes' rambling. Organic chemistry 
is low on the list of educational priorities for controlling a spacecraft. 

"Organic polymers," said McAndrew thoughtfully. He had been frowning hard as Bayes talked of the 
chemical composition. "Chains of glucose molecules, to make starches and cellulose." He turned back to 
Bayes. "Did Lanhoff find any evidence of porphyrins, or nitrogen compounds like purines and 
pyrimidines?" 

Bayes blinked. "You seem to know all about this already. Did Anna already brief you? Lanhoff's 
work is all supposed to be a big secret." 

I had some sympathy with him. Briefing McAndrew is an unrewarding experience. At the end he 
seems to know everything you know and be able to explain it and apply it better. Now Mac was 
shaking his head and looking puzzled. 

"She didn't mention any of this to us. But I knew most of it years ago. Not the particular place in the 
Halo where we might find complex organic materials, but at least the fact that they might be there. It's 
not a new theory at all. Hoyle suggested it more than a hundred years ago. I just don't understand why 
there's anything secret about it. A finding like this one ought to be available to anyone." 

"There's a reason. Wait until you know Anna Griss a bit better and you'll understand." Bayes was 
looking outside for his first glimpse of the Hoatzin, which was now only a couple of hundred kilometers 
away. "She's the hardest worker I know, but she's super-ambitious. She wants to run the whole Council 
someday-tomorrow, if she had her way. When Lanhoff came to her with his proposal, the first thing she 
did was hit it with a classified label." 

"Didn't anyone argue with her?" I said. 

"No. Try it. It's not something you'll do more than once. There were a few mutterings, that was all. 
Anna offered some positive incentives, too. She thinks this will make her famous, and push everybody in 
the Department ten rungs up the management ladder." 

"Just because we've got a bit more information about the composition of the Halo? Not much chance 
of that." McAndrew snorted his disbelief. 

"No." Bayes was still peering out of the port. "Lanhoff persuaded her that he had the only answer to 
the System food problem. All he needed was money and a ship, and USF permission to make some 
orbit changes to a few bodies out in the Halo. Good God!" He turned back from the scope. "There's the 
oddest-looking ship out there. Surely we're not proposing to chase after Lanhoff in that thing?" 

* * * 

Lanhoff's suggestion sounded reasonable until you sat down to think about it. Out in the Halo, off 
where the Sun was nothing more than an extra-bright star, mountains of matter drift through space, 
moving to the tug of a faint gravitational current. Most of them are frozen or rocky fragments, water ice 


and ammonia ice bonding metals and silicates. But swarms of them, in a toroidal region three hundred 
billion miles from Earth, are made of more complex organic molecules. If Lanhoff were correct, we 
would find an endless supply of useful compounds there-all the prebiotic materials from which foodstuffs 
are easily made. They needed only warmth and a supply of the right enzymes to serve as catalytic 
agents. Cellulose, polypeptides, carotenoids, and porphyrins could be transformed to sugars, starches, 
proteins, and edible fats. The food supply of the whole solar system would be assured for a million years. 

Now sit down and think about it again. How do you seed a hundred million worlds and turn them to 
giant candymountains, when the nearest of them is so far away. How do you heat them; how do you get 
them back where they will be useable? 

If you are Arne Lanhoff, none of those questions will deter you. The enzymes you need are available 
in small amounts in the inner system; once a body has been seeded and heat is available from a fusion 
reactor, enzyme production can proceed at an explosive pace. It will suffice to begin with just a few 
hundred thousand tons of the right enzymes, and make the rest where the supply of raw materials is 
assured. The types of enzymes needed to split polymer chains are well known, but the only sort of ship 
that can carry this much load is a boost-and-coast vessel with a maximum short-duration acceleration of 
only two-tenths of a gee. So be it. Plan on a trip out to the Halo that will take a couple of years, and 
allow another year or two to trundle around from one cometary body to the next, seeding and 
performing necessary orbital adjustments. The continuous-thrust engines that will be attached to each 
body add another two million tons to the ship's initial payload. So be it. Fusion heaters to warm the 
frozen interiors will add a million more. Don't worry about it. For a project of this size and importance, 
the Food and Energy Council will find the money and equipment. 

McAndrew had shaken his head when Will Bayes described the plan to place the seeded bodies into 
radial orbits, thrusting in toward the Sun. "Man, do you realize what it will take to stop one of them? 
We'll be trying to catch a billion tons travelling at two thousand kilometers a second." 

"Arne Lanhoff knew that before he left. He was planning just enough drive to bring them to the Inner 
System in twenty years. By that time they'll be warmed and transformed in content." Bayes smiled 
contentedly. "He felt sure that you'd find ways to catch them and slow them. It's the sort of thing your 
group finds challenging." 

"Challenging! He's insane." But two minutes later McAndrew was miles away, working on his new 
puzzle. Arne Lanhoff knew his man rather well. 

The ship that had left the Inner System four years ago did so with no fanfares or publicity. The Star 
Harvester was a massive set of linked cargo spheres with electromagnetic coupling. Each Section had 
an independent drive unit powered by its own kernel. It was quite similar to the Assembly that I pilot on 
the Earth-Titan run, and I was glad to know that I'd have no trouble handling it if the need arose. 

That need might well arise. The Food Department had received regular communications from the Star 
Harvester crew during the long trip out-two years Earth-time, and the ship was too slow to make it 
noticeably shorter in shipboard time. Lanhoff had finally reached his first suitable target, a 
fifteen-kilometer chunk of ice and organics. He had officially named the body Cornucopia, planted the 
enzyme package, the fusion furnace, and the drive, and then started it on the long drop in towards the 
Sun. Without the drive it would fall for millennia. With a little continuous-thrust assistance Cornucopia 
would be crossing the orbit of Jupiter sixteen years from now. By that time it would be a fertile mass of 
the raw materials of nutrition, enough to feed the entire solar system for five years. 

"No problems. Complete success in all phases," read Arne Lanhoff's message as they moved on to 
the next selected target, a mere five hundred million miles away. 

The mission had operated perfectly for another five targets-each one named, processed, and directed 
toward the Inner System. Ambrosia; Harvest Festival; Persephone; Food of the Gods; and Demeter 
. 

Then the pattern was broken. The seventh target had been reached ninety days ago. After an initial 
message announcing contact with the body Manna, a huge organic fragment sixty kilometers in length 
and incredibly rich in complex compounds, Star Harvester became inexplicably silent. A query beamed 
to it from Triton Station fled off on its nineteen-day journey, and an automatic signal of message receipt 


finally returned. But no message originated in the ship's transmission equipment. Arne Lanhoff and his 
crew of four had vanished into the void, three hundred billion miles from home. 

* * * 

Our troubles didn't wait until we were out in the Halo. As soon as Anna Lisa Griss arrived on board 
the Hoatzin, only six hours before our scheduled departure time, we had a problem. She looked around 
the living quarters disbelievingly. 

"You mean we're supposed to stay in this little space-all of us? It can't be more than three meters 
across." 

"Nearer to four." I paused in my run-through of firing sequence checks. "We left information about 
that with you before we came here-didn't you look at it?" 

"I looked at the size of the ship, and the column for the living quarters was hundreds of meters long. 
Why can't we use all of it?" 

I sighed. She had the authority to commandeer the Hoatzin but had never bothered to learn the first 
thing about how it operated. 

"The living-capsule moves up and down that column," I said. "Farther from or closer to the mass 
disk, depending on the ship's acceleration. We can put the supplies outside the capsule area, but if we 
want to live in a one-gee environment we're stuck with this part-it's not bad, plenty of space for four 
people." 

"But what about my staff?" She gestured at the five people who had followed her into the Hoatzin. I 
realized for the first time that they might be more than merely carriers of luggage. 

"Sorry." I tried to sound it. "This ship is rated for a four-person crew, maximum." 

"Change it." She gave me the full force of her imperial manner. I suddenly understood why Will Bayes 
chose not to argue with her. 

I stared back at her without blinking. 

"I can't. I didn't make that rule-check with the USF back at Lunar Base if you like, but they'll confirm 
what I'm telling you." 

She took her lower lip between her teeth, turned her head to survey the cabin, and finally nodded. "I 
believe you. Damnation. But if there is a four-man limit we still have a problem. I need Bayes and I want 
my own pilot. And I need McAndrew. You'll have to stay behind." 

She didn't look at me this time. I took a deep breath. I didn't want to do it, but if we were going to 
bang heads we might as well get it over with. Now was as good a time as any. 

"I suggest that you discuss this with McAndrew," I said. "Better talk to your pilot, too, while you're at 
it. I think you'll find that Mac will refuse to go along without me-just as I wouldn't go without him. This is 
not a conventional vessel. Ask your own pilot how many hours of experience he has with the 
McAndrew Drive. Mac and I have essential experience and skills for the successful performance of this 
mission. Take your pick. Both, or neither." 

My voice sounded trembly. Instead of replying she turned to head for the steps to the lower level of 
the living-capsule. 

"Prepare us for departure," she said over her shoulder as she went. Her voice was so calm that I was 
shocked by my own tension. "I will talk to Bayes. He must assume additional duties on this project." She 
turned again when just her head and shoulders were visible. "Did you ever consider taking a job down 
on Earth? You have abilities that are wasted out here in the middle of nowhere." 

I swivelled my chair to face the console screen and wondered what sort of victory I had won-if any. 
Anna Lisa Griss was wise in the ways of political infighting, while I was a raw novice. But I was damned 
if I'd give up my place on this trip without a struggle. The ship was easy to handle, but I'd never admit 
that to Anna Griss. 

Will Bayes came in to stand beside me while I was still having trouble getting my attention back to the 
status reports. 

"Now you've done it," he said. "What did you say to her? I've never seen her in such a weird mood. I 
can't read her at all. She just told Mauchly and the rest of her staff to get back to Headquarters-no 
explanation. And I've been given double duty for the duration." 


I ran the trajectory parameters out onto the screen, jabbing viciously at the buttons. Then I gave him 
a quick sideways glance. "I had to make a choice. Which would you rather have: Anna Lisa Griss in a 
peculiar mood, or a ship run by people who don't know the McAndrew Drive from a laser-sail?" 

He grunted and stared gloomily at the screen. "That's not an easy decision. You've never seen Anna 
when she's really annoyed. I have. Let me tell you, it's not something I want to go through again." He 
leaned forward. "Hey, Jeanie. Surely that's not the plot of our flight out you've got on the display there." 

"It certainly is." I rotated axes so that all coordinates were in ecliptic spherical polars and stored the 
result. "Don't you like it?" 

"But it looks so simple." He moved his finger along the screen. "I mean, it's just a straight line. Not a 
real trajectory at all. What about the Sun's gravitational field? And you're not making any allowance for 
the movement of Manna while we're flying out there." 

"I know." I loaded the flight profile to main memory and as I did so the knot in my stomach seemed 
to loosen. "That's why I'll be piloting this ship, Will, rather than one of your buddies. We'll be 
accelerating away from the Sun at a hundred gee, agreed? Did you know that the Sun's acceleration on 
us here near Mars orbit is only one three hundred thousandth of that? It has tiny effects on our motion." 

"But what about Manna's movement in its orbit while we're on the way there? You've ignored that as 
well." 

"For two reasons. First, Manna is so far out that it's not moving very fast in its orbit-only half a 
kilometer a second. More important, we don't know how far Lanhoff's team went in processing Manna. 
Is the body in its original orbit, or did they start it moving in toward the Sun?" 

"I've no idea." 

"Nor have I. The only thing we can do is fly out there and find out." 

I looked at the clock. Time to get moving. "Better say your goodbyes," I went on. "There'll be plenty 
of chances for us to talk to each other in the next couple of weeks. Probably too many. Two hours from 
now we'll be on our way. Then we'll be deaf to outside signals until we're out in the Halo and turn off the 
drive." 

"Is that so?" He looked intrigued. "But what about orders that come-" 

"Bayes." Anna Griss was calling softly from below. 

Will was gone before I could swivel my chair. 

* * * 

I don't envy the life of the Downsiders, ten billion of them crawling over each other looking for a little 
breathing space. But there are certain experiences available on Earth and nowhere else in the Solar 
System. 

For instance, I'm told that, during the great circular storms that sweep from the Earth tropics to the 
northern latitudes, there is an area at the very center-the "eye of the hurricane" as the Downsiders call 
it-where the wind drops to perfect stillness and the sky overhead turns to deep blue. That's something 
I'd like to see, just once. 

The eye of the hurricane. That was the area of the living-capsule surrounding McAndrew during the 
Hoatzin's flight out to rendezvous with Manna. 

With me, Anna Griss was in constant battle. 

"What are you talking about, no messages?" she said. "I have to be in daily contact with 
Headquarters." 

"Then I'll have to switch off the drive," I explained. "We can't get signals through the plasma shell." 

"But that will slow us down! I told Headquarters that we'd only be away for one month-and it's a 
two-week trip each way even if we keep the drive on all the time." 

We were standing by the robochef and I was programming the next meal. It took a few seconds for 
her last statement to penetrate. 

"You told Headquarters what? That we'll only be away for a month?" 

"That's right. Three days should be long enough to find out what's happening to Star Harvester. You 
said that yourself, and McAndrew agreed." 

I turned to face her, noticing again the care she took to make her appearance as well-groomed and 


attractive as possible. 

"Three days should be long enough, sure it should. But you'll be away for a lot more than a month. 
The trip is two weeks each way in shipboard time. It's twenty-five days each way in Earth-time. 
There's no possible way you can get back home in a month." 

Her face flushed red and her eyes glowed-she looked more attractive than ever. "How can that 
happen?" 

"I don't know, but it's standard physics. Ask McAndrew." (I knew well enough, but I'd had more 
than I wanted of this conversation.) 

It was like that all the time. We found it hard to agree on anything, and it became clear as soon as we 
were on the way that Anna Griss was used to delegating and not to doing. Poor old Will Bayes did triple 
duty. Luckily there was not too much that could be done without a communications link to Earth-except 
shout at Will and keep him on the run. 

Yet McAndrew-I thought at first I was imagining it-McAndrew was the eye of the hurricane. When 
she was within two yards of him, Anna Griss became all sweetness and light. She humbly asked him 
questions about the drive and about time dilation; she deferred to his opinions on everything from diet to 
Dostoevski; and she hung first on his word and then on his arm, blinking her eyelashes at him. 

It was sickening. 

And McAndrew-the great lout-he lapped it up. 

"What's she doing?" I said to Bayes when the other two were out of earshot. "She's making a fool of 
herself." 

He winked at me. "You think so, and I think so-but does he think so? Before we left she told me to 
get a full dossier about him and bring it on this trip. She's been reading it, too. You have to know Anna. 
What she wants, she gets. Wouldn't look bad for her personal records, would it, to have a five-year 
cohab contract with the most famous scientist in the System?" 

"Don't be silly. She doesn't even like him." 

"She does, you know." He stepped closer and lowered his voice. "I know Anna. She has appetites. 
She wants him, and I think she'd like a cohab contract." 

I snorted. "With Mac? That's ridiculous! He belongs to-to science." And I fully believed it, until one 
morning I found myself applying a pheromonal amplifier behind my ears, and dressing in a new 
lime-green uniform that fitted a lot closer than my standard garb. 

And McAndrew-the great lout-he never noticed or said one word. 

While this was going on, we were hurtling outward away from the Sun. With our acceleration at a 
hundred gee, the living-capsule was snuggled in close to the massplate. The plate's gravitational 
attraction just about balanced the body force on us produced by the ship's acceleration, leaving us in a 
comfortable and relaxing half-gee environment. The tidal forces caused by the gravity gradient were 
noticeable only if you looked for them. McAndrew's vacuum drive worked flawlessly, as usual, tapping 
the zero point energy-"sucking the marrow out of spacetime," as one of Mac's colleagues put it. 

"I don't understand," I'd once said to him. "It gets energy out of nothing." 
McAndrew looked at me reproachfully. "That's what they used to say in 1910, when mad scientists 
thought you might get energy from the nucleus of an atom. Jeanie, I thought better of you." 
All right, I was squelched-but I didn't understand the drive one bit better. 
* * * 

At the halfway mark we rotated the ship to begin deceleration and I cut the drive while we did it. 
Anna Griss had an opportunity to send her backlog of messages, and finally gave Will Bayes a few hours 
of peace. I was amused to see that her communications gave the impression that she was running 
everything on the Hoatzin. Her increased absence from Headquarters she attributed to delays on the 
trip. If the level of scientific expertise in the Food Department matched her own, she would probably get 
away with it. 

For me, this should have been the best part of the mission, the reason I remain in space and never 
look for a Downside job. With the drive off we flew starward in perfect silence. I stayed by the port, 
watching the wheel of heaven as the ship turned. 


The Hoatzin was within five percent of light-speed. As we performed our end-over-end maneuver, 
the colors of the starscape Doppler-shifted slowly from red to blue. I caught a last glimpse of Sol and its 
attendants before the massplate shielded them from view. Jupiter was visible through the optical 
telescope, a tiny point of light a fifth of a degree away from the Sun's dazzling disk. Earth was gone. Its 
reflected photons had been lost on their hundred-and-fifty-billion mile outward journey. 

I turned the telescope ahead, in a hopeless search for Manna. It was a speck in the star-sea, as far 
ahead of us as the Sun was behind. We would not detect its presence for another two weeks. I looked 
for it anyway. Then the shield came on to protect us from the sleet of hard radiation and particles caused 
by our light-chasing velocity. The stars blinked out. I could pay attention again to events inside the 
Hoatzin. 

With little else to occupy her attention, Anna delegated her chores to Will Bayes and concentrated 
everything on charming McAndrew. Will and I received the disdain and the dog work. I sat on my anger 
and bided my time. 

As for Mac, he had disappeared again inside his head. We had loaded a library of references on 
Lanhoff and the organic materials of the Halo into the computer before we left the Institute. He spent 
many hours absorbing that information and processing it in the curiously structured personal computer he 
carries inside his skull. I knew better than to interrupt him. After just a couple of futile attempts to divert 
him, Anna learned the same lesson. No doubt about it: she was quick. No scientist, but when it came to 
handling people she did instinctively what I had taken years to learn. Instead of social chit-chat, she 
studied the same data that McAndrew had been analyzing and asked him questions about it. 

"I can see why there ought to be a lot of prebiotic organic stuff out in the Halo," she said during one 
of our planned exercise sessions. She was dressed in a tight blue leotard and pedaling hard at the 
stationary cycle. "But I never did follow Lanhoff's argument that there may be primitive life there, too. 
Surely the temperature's far too cold." 

It was still the "Griss-Lanhoff" Theory for official records, but with us Anna had dropped her 
pretence of detailed knowledge of Lanhoff's ideas. She had been the driving force to carry his ideas to 
practical evaluation. We all knew it; for the moment that was enough for her. I had no doubt that we 
would see another change when we arrived back in the Inner System. 

McAndrew was idly lifting and lowering a weighted bar. He hated exercise, but he grudgingly went 
along with general USF orders for spaceborne personnel. 

"It is cold in the Halo," he said. "Just a few degrees above absolute zero, in most of the bodies. But it 
may not be too cold." 

"It's much too cold for us." 

"Certainly. That's Lanhoff's point. We know only about the enzymes found on Earth. They allow 
chemical reactions to proceed in a certain temperature regime. Why shouldn't there be other 
life-supporting enzymes that can operate at far lower temperatures?" 

Anna stopped pedaling, and I paused in my toe-touching. "Even at the temperatures here in the 
Halo?" she said. 

"I think so." McAndrew paused in his leisurely bar-lifting. "Lanhoff argues that with plenty of complex 
organic molecules and with a hundred billion separate bodies available, a lot of things might develop in 
four billion years. He expected to find life somewhere out here-primitive life, probably, but recognizable 
to us. He was prepared to find it, and the Star Harvester was equipped to bring back samples." 

We dropped the subject there, but it went running on in my mind while Anna took McAndrew off to 
program an elaborate meal. I could hear her giggling from the next room, while visions of a Halo 
civilization ran wild through my brain. Life had appeared there, evolved to intelligence. The Halo society 
had been disturbed by the arrival of our exploring ship. Lanhoff was a prisoner. His ship had been 
destroyed. The Inner System and the Halo would go to war . . . 

All complete rubbish. I knew that even as I fantasized, and McAndrew pointed out why when we 
discussed it later. 

"We got the way we are, Jeanie, because life on Earth is one long fight for limited resources. Our 
bloody-mindedness all started out as food battles, three billion years ago. The Halo isn't like that



everything will be part of the food supply. How much evolving would we have done if it rained soup 
every day and the mountains of Earth had been made of cheese? We'd still be single-celled organisms, 
happy as clams." 

It sounded plausible. McAndrew was so bright that you tended not to question him after a while. But 
an hour or two later I was worrying again. It occurred to me that Mac was a physicist-when it came to 
biology he was way outside his field. And something had happened to Lanhoff and his ship. What could 
it have been? 

I didn't mention it again, but I worried and fretted, while McAndrew and Anna Griss talked and 
laughed in the sleeping area and Will Bayes sat next to me in the control area, miserable with his own 
thoughts. He was so dominated by Anna that I often lost sight of him as an independent person when she 
was around. Now I found out what made him tick-security. 

Poor Will. Looking for security he had joined the safest, most stable organization in Earth's 
government: the Food Department. That was the place for a solid, Earthbound, risk-free job. He had no 
desire for adventure, no wish to travel more than a mile from his little apartment. He had been in space 
only once before, as part of a meeting between the Council and the United Space Federation. Now he 
was embarked on a mission so far from home that he might survive even if the Sun went nova. 

How had it happened? He didn't know. It didn't occur to him to blame Anna. He sat about, uncertain 
and unhappy. I kept him company, my own worry bump throbbing randomly until at last it was time to 
throttle the drive and begin final search and rendezvous. Manna should be less than ten million 
kilometers ahead of us. 

* * * 

"QUERY DISTANCE FOR STAR HARVESTER APPROACH? DEFAULT VALUE: ZERO." 

Our computer began talking to us while we were still scanning ahead for first visual contact. No 
matter what had happened to the vessel's crew, Star Harvester's guidance and control system was still 
working. Automatic communication for identification and position-matching had begun between the two 
ships as soon as drive interference was low enough to permit signal transfer. 

"Fifty thousand kilometers." I didn't want an immediate rendezvous. "Manual control." 

"FIFTY THOUSAND KILOMETERS. CONTROL TRANSFERRED." 

"We'll see nothing from that distance." Anna was impatiently watching the hi-mag viewing screen. 
"We're wasting time. Take us in closer." 

We could now see the rough-cut oblong of Manna on the imaging radar. A bright cluster of point 
reflections at one end had to be the Star Harvester's assembly of sections. I suddenly had a new feel 
for the size of the body we were approaching. Lanhoff's ship was of the largest class in the USF fleet. 
Next to Manna it looked like specks of dust. 

"Didn't you hear me?" Anna spoke more loudly. "I don't want a view from a million miles away-take 
us in closer. That's an order." 

I turned to face her. "I think we should be cautious until we know what's going on. We can do a lot 
of overall checking from this distance. It's safer." 

"And it wastes time." Her voice was impatient. "I'm the senior officer on this ship. Now, do as I say, 
and let's get in closer." 

"Sorry." I couldn't delay this moment any longer. "You're the senior officer while we're in free flight, I 
agree. But when we're in a rendezvous mode with another ship, the pilot automatically has senior 
decision authority. Check the manuals. I have final say on our movements until we're on the way back to 
Earth." 

There was a long pause while we sat eyeball to eyeball. Anna's face took on a touch of higher color 
on the cheeks. McAndrew and Will Bayes held an uncomfortable silence. 

"You've had this in mind all along, haven't you?" Anna said softly. Her voice was as cold as Charon. 
"Damn you, you counted on this. You're going to waste everybody's time while you play at being the 
boss." 

She went through to the other communications department, and I heard the rapid tapping of keys. I 
didn't know if she was making an entry into the log, or merely calling out the section of the Manual that 


defines the transfer of authority to the pilot during approach and rendezvous. I didn't care. Super-caution 
has always paid off for me in the past. Why change a winning hand, even for Anna Griss? I concentrated 
my attention on the incoming data streams. 

Half an hour later Anna came back and sat down without speaking. I was uncomfortably aware of 
her critical attention over my shoulder. I gestured to the central display screen, where the second series 
of remotely sensed observations from Manna were now appearing. The computer automatically 
checked everything for anomalies. One new set was displayed in flashing red for our attention. 

"That's why I didn't want to rush. I don't think we've been wasting time at all. Mac, look at those 
radioactivity readings. What do you think of them?" 

The computer had done its preliminary analysis, taking the ratio of radioactivity measurements from 
Manna to typical Halo bodies and to the general local background. McAndrew frowned at the 
smoothed values for a few seconds, then nodded. 

"Uh-uh. They're high. About six hundred times as big as I would expect." 

I took a deep breath. "So I think we know what happened to Lanhoff. One of the fusion units must 
have run wild when they were installing it. See now why I'm cautious, folks?" 

Anna Griss looked stunned. "Then the crew all got a fatal overdose of radiation?" 

"Looks like it." I had proved my point, but not in a way that gave me any satisfaction. I felt sick 
inside. When a fusion plant blows, there's no hope for the crew. 

"No, Jeanie." McAndrew was frowning and rubbing at his sandy hairline. "You're jumping to 
conclusions. I said the radioactivity was six hundred times as big as it should be, and it is. But it's still 
low-you could live in it for years, and it wouldn't do you much harm. If a fusion plant had gone, the 
reading from Manna would be a hundred thousand times what we're measuring." 

"But what else could give us abnormally high values?" 

"I've no idea." He looked at me apologetically. "And we'll never know from this distance. Seems to 
me that Anna's right. We may have to get in a lot closer for a good look if we really want to find out." 

Perhaps the idea that Lanhoff and his crew were almost certainly dead was hitting Anna hard for the 
first time. At any rate, there was no triumph in her expression as she watched me ease us gingerly 
forward until we were only ten thousand kilometers from the planetoid. We went slowly, all our sensor 
input channels wide open. I set the control system to hold us at a constant distance from the surface of 
Manna. 

"That's as far as I'm willing to take us," I said. "We're a long way from home, and I won't risk our 
only way of getting back. Any closer look will have to be done with the transfer pod. Mac, I've not had 
time to watch the inputs. Is there anything about the ship or about Manna that's looking out of line?" 

He had been muttering to himself over by a display screen. Now he frowned and pressed a sequence 
of control keys. 

"Maybe. While you were busy I did a complete data transfer from Star Harvester's computer to 
ours. Lanhoff and his crew stopped feeding in new inputs a hundred and fifteen days ago-that's when the 
signals to Oberon Station cut off-but the automatic sensors kept right on recording. See, here's the very 
first radioactivity reading from Manna when they arrived, and there's one taken just a few minutes ago. 
Look at 'em. Identical. And now look at this. This is the thermal profile of a cross-section through 
Manna's center." 

A multi-colored blob filled the screen. It was a set of concentric ellipses, color coded to run from a 
dark red in its center portion to a violet on the outer boundary. 

"Different colors represent different temperatures." McAndrew touched a button, and a dark ellipse 
appeared around the red and orange portions at the center of the image. "I've just put in the contour for 
zero degrees Celsius. See? Significant, eh?" 

"See what?" said Anna. She was sitting close to McAndrew, their shoulders touching. 

"The inside-inside the curve. It's warmer than the melting-point of ice. If Manna has a water-ice core, 
it must be liquid. There's a couple of kilometers of frozen surface, then that liquid interior." 

"But we're out in the Halo," I protested. "We're billions of miles from a source of heat. Unless-did 
Lanhoff already put one of his fusion plants in there?" 


"No." McAndrew shook his head. His eyes were sparkling. "The temperature distribution inside was 
like this before Lanhoff arrived. You're right, Jeanie, it looks impossible-but there it is. Manna is three 
hundred degrees warmer than it has any right to be." 

There was a long silence. Finally Will Bayes cleared his throat. "All right, I'll be the dummy. How can 
that happen?" 

McAndrew gave a little bark of excitement. "Man, if I had a definite answer to that I wouldn't hold 
out on you. But I can make a good guess. There has to be a natural internal source of heat, something 
like uranium or thorium deep inside. That's consistent with the high radioactivity value, too." He turned to 
me. "Jeanie, you have to get us over there, so we can take a good look at the inside." 

I hesitated. "Will it be safe?" I said at last. "If it's uranium and water-you can make a nuclear reactor 
from them." 

"Yes-if you try really hard. But it wouldn't happen in nature. Be reasonable, Jeanie." 

He was looking at me expectantly, while Anna sat silent. She liked to see him putting the pressure on 
me for a change. 

I shook my head. "If you want to go over there and explore, I won't try to stop you. But my job is 
the safety of this ship. I'm staying right here." Logic was all on my side. But even as I spoke I felt that I 
was giving the coward's answer. 

* * * 

From a distance of fifty kilometers, Manna already filled the sky ahead, a black bulk against the star 
field. Star Harvester hung as a cluster of glittering spheres near one end of the planetoid. It steadily 
grew in size on the screen as the pod moved in, one of its television cameras sending a crisp image back 
to my observing post on the Hoatzin. I could see the dozen Sections and the narrow connectors 
between them, hollow tubes that were flexible now but electromagnetically stiffened when the drive went 
on. 

"Approaching outermost cargo sphere," said McAndrew. I could see him on the screen that showed 
the inside of the pod, and a third image showed and recorded for me the pod control settings exactly as 
he saw them himself. 

"Everything still appears perfectly normal," he went on. "We'll make our entry of Star Harvester 
through the Control Section. What is it, Anna?" 

He turned to where she was monitoring another sensor, one for which I was not receiving coverage. 

"Cut in Unit Four." I said quickly. 

At my command the computers sent the image Anna and Will were watching to fill the center screen. 
I saw a long shaft that extended from a cargo hold of Star Harvester and drove down to penetrate the 
rough surface of Manna. The camera tracked its length, switching to deep radar frequencies to generate 
an image where the shaft plunged below the planetoid's surface. 

"Is that a drilling shaft?" I asked. "It looks as though they were getting ready to put a fusion plant in 
the middle of Manna." 

"Wouldn't make sense." McAndrew spoke in an abstracted grunt, and I saw him rubbing at the 
balding spot on the back of his head. "Lanhoff knew quite well that Manna has a liquid core-he had the 
same computer base to look at as we do. With that core he didn't need a fusion plant at all. The interior 
would be warm enough already for his enzymes to thrive." 

"Was he looking for radioactive material?" I asked; but I could answer that question myself. "It 
wouldn't make sense. He could locate them the same way we did, from remote measurement. So why 
would he drill into the core?" 

"I'll tell you why," said Anna suddenly. "That's the way Arne always was. Anytime he saw something 
that he didn't understand he wanted to investigate-he couldn't resist it. I'll bet he drilled to the core to 
take a closer look at something he'd detected in there-something he couldn't examine closely enough 
from outside." 

The pod had been creeping in nearer and nearer to the hatches on the Control Section. I suddenly 
realized that once the three of them went inside I would be blind. 

"Mac, as soon as you get in there, turn on all the monitors and tell the computer to send the signals 


back to me here on the Hoatzin." I raised my voice. "And one of you has to stay in the Control Section 
if you go down to the surface. D'you hear me?" 

He nodded vaguely, but he was already moving toward the hatch. Anna followed him. The last thing I 
saw before the camera could no longer keep them in view was Will Bayes' face as he turned to take a 
last worried look around the pod. 

* * * 
Deserted, but in perfect working order; that was the conclusion after a thorough examination of the 
Control Section of Star Harvester. 
I had followed on the remote monitors as the other three made their inspection, step by step, and I 
could not fault them for lack of caution. 
"We'll not find Lanhoff and his crew here," said McAndrew finally, when they were back in the main 
control room. "They must have gone down into the interior of Manna. Look at this." 

A computer-generated profile of the shaft leading down from the ship to the surface appeared on the 
screen in front of me. It penetrated the frozen outer crust and terminated in an airlock leading to the 
liquid core. In the graphics display the broad shaft looked like a hair-thin needle piercing an egg. I was 
astonished again by the size of the planetoid. Its liquid core held half a million cubic kilometers of liquid. 
Maybe we would never find Lanhoff and the other crew members. 

"We know they went down there," went on McAndrew, as though he was reading my thoughts. He 
held up a big clear container full of a cloudy yellow fluid. "See? They brought back samples. I'll send you 
the analysis, but I can tell you now that the results are just what Lanhoff predicted." 

"It's high-level organic materials," added Anna. She was looking at me in triumph. "I told you we had 
to come here to find anything useful. This is just as we expected, but even more concentrated than I 
hoped. We've found a mother lode. The whole inside of Manna is like a rich soup-one of us could 
probably drink it for dinner and feel well-fed." 

Will Bayes was staring at it dubiously, as though he expected Anna to tell him to go ahead and take a 
swig. "There's things living in it," he said. 

My old fears came running back. "Mac, be careful how you handle that. If there are organisms there . 
. ." 

"Just single-celled ones." McAndrew was excited. "Lanhoff thought he might find primitive life here, 
and he was quite right." 

"And it's DNA-based," added Anna. "The same as we are." 

I looked more closely at the yellow broth. "So the old theories must be right? Life came to Earth from 
outside." 

"That's the real significance of what they found on Manna," said McAndrew. "Life didn't originate on 
Earth. It began out here in the Halo, or somewhere even farther out, and drifted in to Earth-maybe in the 
head of a comet, or as smaller meteorites. But see the difference; down on Earth we've had pressures to 
make us evolve away from a single cell form. Here, there's heat from the radioactive materials in the 
middle of the planetoid, and there's food galore. There's no reason for evolution as we know it. That's 
why I don't share your worries, Jeanie, about going down to the interior. There's no evolutionary reason 
for predators on Manna. We won't find sharks and tigers here. It's the Garden of Eden." 

Anna nodded her agreement and squeezed his arm. They were both so excited, I wondered if I were 
the irrational one. The more enthusiastic they became, the more uneasy I felt. No sharks and tigers, 
maybe-but wouldn't there still be natural selection, even if it went on very slowly? 

Shades of Malthusian Doctrine: the number of organisms would follow an increasing geometric 
progression, and the food resources were finite. Eventually there would have to be a balance, a steady 
state where dying organisms were just replaced by new ones; and then natural selection ought to take 
over, with competition between different forms. I didn't have that logic explicitly in mind, all I knew was 
that something seemed wrong. And I knew that Mac was no biologist. I stared at the screen and shook 
my head. 

"So what happened to Lanhoff and his crew?" I said. 

There was a long, uneasy silence. 


"Quite right, Jeanie," said McAndrew at last. "We still have no answer to that. But we're going to find 
one. Will can stay here, and Anna and I will go down there now." 

"No." My pulse began to race. "I won't allow it. It's too dangerous." 

"We don't agree," said Anna softly. "You heard McAndrew, he says we should look down there-and 
we'll go in our suits, so we'll be well protected." 

Fools rush in where angels fear to tread. Anna Griss knew how to survive in an Earthbound 
bureaucratic free-for-all, but she was a long way from her home ground. And if she was relying on 
Mac's instincts to save their skins . . . 

"No." My voice cracked. "Didn't you hear me? I absolutely forbid it. That's an order." 

"Is it?" Anna didn't raise her voice. "But you see, we're not in the spacecraft rendezvous mode now, 
Captain Roker. The Star Harvester is tethered to the planetoid. That means I command here, not you." 
She turned to McAndrew. "Come on, let's make sure we're fully prepared. We don't want to take any 
risks." 

Before I could speak again she reached forward to the monitor. I suddenly found that I was looking 
into a blank screen. 
* * * 
It took me a long five minutes to patch in a substitute communications link between the computers of 

the Hoatzin and the Star Harvester. 

When the auxiliary screen came alive I saw Will Bayes fiddling with the control bank. 

"Where are they, Will?" 

He turned quickly. "They're on the way down to the surface. Jeanie, I couldn't stop them. I said they 
shouldn't go, but Anna wouldn't take any notice of me. And she has Mac convinced, too." 

I knew McAndrew-he hadn't taken any convincing at all. Show him an interesting intellectual 
problem, and preservation of life and limb came a poor second to curiosity. 

"Don't worry about that, Will. Link me to the computer on board the transfer pod." 

"What are you going to do?" 

"Go after them. Maybe Mac is right, and they'll be fine, and in no danger. But I want to be the 
rearguard and trail along behind them, just in case." 

Will could have probably flown the pod to pick me up in an emergency, and I knew that the 
computer could have done it with a single rendezvous command from me. But Will and the computer 
would have followed the book on permissible rates of acceleration and docking distances. I took remote 
control of the pod myself, overrode the computer, broke every rule in the manual, and had the pod 
docked at the Hoatzin in less than fifteen minutes. Going back to the Star Harvester we beat that time 
by a hundred seconds. 

Will was waiting at the main lock with his suit on. "Something has gone wrong," he said. "They told 
me they would send a signal every ten minutes, but it's been over twenty since the last one. I was going 
to go down and see what's happening." 

"Did you see any weapons on board when you were looking over the ship earlier?" 

"Weapons?" Will frowned. "No. Lanhoff had no reason to carry anything like that. Wait a minute, 
though, what about a construction laser? That can be pretty dangerous, and there are plenty of those in 
Section Six." 

"Get one." I was preparing the transfer pod for a rapid departure from Star Harvester if we needed 
it. One time in a thousand, a precaution like that pays off. 

"I'll get two." 

Will was off along the tube between the Sections before I could argue with him. I didn't want him 
with me in the middle of Manna-I wanted him available to help me out if I ran into trouble myself. 

What was I expecting? I had no idea, but I felt a lot better when I had my suit firmly closed and a 
portable construction laser tucked under one arm. Will and I went together to the entrance of the long 
tunnel that led down to the interior of Manna. 

"Right. No farther for you." I looked at the peculiar way he was holding the laser, and wondered 
what would happen if he had to use it. "You stay here, at the head of the shaft. I'll send you a signal 


every ten minutes." 

"That's what Anna said." His words echoed after me as I dropped away down the broad shaft. 

The illumination came only from the light on my suit. Seen from the inside, the shaft out of the cargo 
hold dropped away in front of me like a dark, endless tunnel. Manna's gravity was negligible, so there 
were none of the Earth dangers of an accelerated fall. But I had to take care to remain clear of the side 
of the tunnel-it narrowed as we went deeper into the planetoid's crust. I drifted out to the center of the 
shaft, turned on the coupling between the suit's conducting circuits and the pulsed field in the tunnel wall, 
and made a swift, noiseless descent. 

The three kilometer downward swoop took less than a minute. All the way to the airlock at the 
bottom I watched carefully for any sign that McAndrew and Anna had met trouble there. Everything was 
normal. 

The drilling mechanism at the end of the shaft was still in position. Normally the shaft could extend 
itself through hard, frozen ice at a hundred feet an hour. When they came to the liquid interior, however, 
Lanhoff had arrested the progress of the drill and installed the airlock. It was a cylindrical double 
chamber about six meters across, with a movable metal wall separating the two halves. 

I cycled through the first part of the lock, closed the wall, and went forward to the second barrier. I 
hesitated in front of it. The wall was damp with a viscous fluid. The airlock had been used recently. Anna 
and McAndrew had passed through here to the liquid core of the planetoid. If I wished to find them I 
must do the same. 

Was there a port? I wanted to take a good look at the interior of Manna before I was willing even to 
consider going through into it. 

The only transparent area was a tiny section a few inches across, where a small panel had been 
removed and replaced by a thin sheet of clear plastic. Lanhoff must have arranged it this way, to make 
an observation point before he would risk a venture beyond the lock. Despite his curiosity referred to by 
Anna, it suggested that he was a cautious man-and it seemed to increase the odds against me. I was 
diving blind, and in a hurry. 

I drifted across and put the faceplate of my suit flat against the transparent plate. The only illumination 
in the interior was coming from my suit, and because it had to shine through the port I was confused by 
back-scattered light. I held my hand to shield my eyes, and peered in. 

My first impression was of a snowstorm. Great drifting white flakes swam lazily across the field of 
view. As I adjusted to the odd lighting, the objects resolved themselves to white, feathery snowballs, 
ranging in size from a grape to a closed fist. The outer parts were in constant vibration, providing a 
soft-edged, uncertain shimmer as they moved through the pale yellow fluid of Manna's interior. 

Even as I watched, the number and density of the white objects was increasing. The snowfall became 
a blizzard. And floating far away from me, almost at the limit of vision, I saw two great white shapes. 
They were travesties of the human form, bloated and blurred outlines like giant snowmen. Every second 
they grew bigger, as more and more snowballs approached and adhered to their surfaces. They were 
swelling steadily, rounding to become perfect spheres. 

I shivered in my suit. Alien. The figures looked totally alien, but I knew what I had found. At their 
centers, unable to see, move, or send messages, were McAndrew and Anna. As I watched I thought of 
the guardian white corpuscles in my own blood-stream. The feathery balls were like them, busy 
leukocytes crowding around to engulf and destroy the foreign organisms that dared to invade the body 
of Manna. 

How could I rescue them? They were in no danger for the first few minutes, but the snowballs would 
muffle the escape of heat from the suits. Unless the clinging balls were cleared away, Anna and 
McAndrew would soon die a blind and stifling death. 

My first instinct was to open the lock and plunge through to the interior. Another look at the feathery 
snowballs changed my mind about that. They were thicker than ever, drifting up from the deep interior of 
the planetoid. If I went out there they would have me covered in less than a minute. The laser that I had 
brought with me was useless. If I used it in water, it would waste its energy turning a small volume close 
to me to steam. 


And I had no other weapon with me. 

Return to the Star Harvester, and look for inspiration there? It might be too late for McAndrew and 
Anna. 

I went across to the side of the lock. There was a dual set of controls for the drilling shaft there, 
installed so that drilling progress could be monitored and modified on the spot. If I started the drill, the 
fluid ahead would offer little resistance. The tunnel would extend further into the liquid, far enough to 
enclose the area where the two misshapen spheres were floating. So if I opened the lock first, then 
activated the drill . . . 

The timing would be crucial. Once the lock was open, liquid would be drawn into the evacuated area 
around me. Then I would have to operate the drill unit so that the open lock moved to enclose the two 
swollen masses of snowballs, close the lock again, and pump the liquid out. But if I was too slow, the 
blizzard of snow would close in on me, too, and I would be as helpless as McAndrew and Anna. 

Delay wouldn't help. I pressed the lever that opened the lock, moved to the side of the chamber, and 
started the drill extender. 

Liquid rushed in through the opening aperture. I struggled to move forward against its pressure, 
fighting my way back to the lock control. 

There was a swirling tide of white all around me. Feathered balls hit my suit and stuck to it, coating 
the faceplate in an opaque layer. Within thirty seconds I could not see anything, and my arms and legs 
were sluggish in their movements as I clung to the lock lever. 

I had not anticipated that I would become blind so quickly. Were McAndrew and Anna already 
swept into the chamber by the advancing drill and the opened lock? I had no way of knowing. I waited 
as long as I dared, then heaved at the lever. My arm moved slowly, hampered by the mass of 
snow-spheres clinging to it. I felt the control close, and sensed the muffled roar of the pump. I tried to 
thrash my arms, to shake off the layers that clogged their movement. It was useless. Soon I was unable 
to move at all. I was in darkness. If the snowballs could tolerate vacuum, McAndrew and Anna and I 
would go the same way as Lanhoff; we'd be trapped inside our suits, our communication units useless, 
until the heat built up to kill us. 

It was a long, long wait (only ten minutes, according to the communications link on board the ship-it 
felt like days). Suddenly there was a lightening of the darkness in front of my faceplate. I could move my 
arms again. The feather balls were falling off me and being pumped out through the airlock. 

I turned around, peering through the one clear spot on my faceplate. There were two spherical blobs 
with me in the chamber, and they were gradually taking on human shapes. After another five minutes I 
could see parts of their suits. 

"Anna! Mac! Turn around." 

They clumsily rotated to face me. I saw them staring out of the faceplates, white-faced but undeniably 
alive. 

"Come on. Let's get out of here." 

"Wait." McAndrew was taking a bag from the side of his suit, opening it, and scooping up samples of 
liquid and snowballs. I decided that he was terminally crazy. 

"Don't fool with that, Mac-let's get out of here." 

What was the danger now? I didn't know, and I wasn't going to wait to find out. I reached out, 
grabbed his arm, and began to haul him back through to the other chamber. We were still sloshing in a 
chaos of fluid and floating feather balls. 

Anna grabbed at my arm, so I was towing both of them. I could hear her teeth chattering. 

"God," she said. "I thought we were dead. I knew it, it was just like being dead, no sound, nothing to 
see, not able to move." 

"I know the feeling," I grunted-they were a weighty pair. "How did you get caught? I mean, why 
didn't you get back into the airlock as soon as the snowballs arrived?" 

We were scooting back up the tunnel as fast as we could, McAndrew still clinging to his bucket of 
specimens. 

"We didn't see any danger." Anna was gradually getting control of herself, and her grip on my arm 


had loosened. "When we first came through the lock there were maybe half a dozen of those fuzzballs in 
sight. McAndrew said we ought to get a specimen before we left, because they were a more complex 
life-form than any that Lanhoff had reported. And then they started to arrive in millions, from all 
directions. Our suits were covered before we could get away-we didn't have a chance." 

"But what are they-and what were they doing?" I said. 

We had reached the top of the tunnel and entered the cargo sphere. There was no sign of Will 
Bayes-it occurred to me that I hadn't sent him a single signal of any kind since I left. He must be frantic. I 
hit the switch that would fill the chamber with air. For some reason I was keener to get out of that suit 
than I had ever been. 

McAndrew placed his container on the floor and we all began to work our way free, starting with the 
helmets. 

"What were they doing? Now that's a good question," he said. "While we were stuck in the middle of 
them down there, I had time to give it some thought." 

Well, that sounded right. When McAndrew stops thinking, he'll be dead. 

"Lanhoff and I made a big goof," he went on, "and for him it was a fatal one. We both argued that the 
food supply here was so plentiful that there'd be no pressure to evolve. But we forgot a basic fact. An 
organism needs more than food to survive." 

"What else? You mean moisture?" I had my suit off, and air had never tasted so good. 

"Moisture, sure. But as well as that it needs warmth. Here on Manna, the evolutionary pressure is to 
get near a heat source. If you're out too far from the center, you become part of the frozen outer layer. 
Those snowballs normally live down near the middle, getting as close as they can to the radioactive 
fragments that provide the warmth." 

Anna was out of her suit. Now that we were safe, she was making a tremendous effort to gain her 
self-possession, Her shivering had stopped and she was even patting at her damp and tangled hair. She 
peered curiously down at the container of feathered snowballs. They were still moving slowly around in 
the yellow liquid. 

"The radioactivity must speed up their rate of evolution, too," she said. "And I was thinking they 
wanted to eat us." 

"I doubt that we're very appetizing, compared with their free soup," said McAndrew. "No, if there 
hadn't been so many of them they'd have been harmless enough. But when we came along, they sensed 
the heat given off by our suits, and they tried to cuddle up to us. They didn't want to eat us, all they were 
after was a place by the fireside." 

Anna nodded. "This is going to create a sensation when we get back to Earth. We'll have to take a 
lot of specimens back with us." 

She was reaching down towards the open container. One of the snowballs had fully opened and was 
a delicate white mass of feathery cilia. She put out her forefinger as though she intended to touch it. 

"Don't do that!" I shouted. 

Maybe she was not even considering any such thing, but my loud command made her stiffen. She 
looked up at me angrily. 

"You saved us, Captain Roker, and I appreciate that. But don't forget who is in charge of this 
expedition. And don't try to order me around-ever." 

"Don't be a fool," I said. "I wasn't ordering you around-I was speaking for your own good. Don't you 
have any idea what might be dangerous?" 

My own tone must have betrayed my impatience and anger. Anna stiffened, and her color went from 
white to red. 

"McAndrew has pointed out that these lifeforms would have been quite harmless if there had not 
been so many of them," she said. And then she reached forward into the container and deliberately 
touched the expanded snowball with her forefinger. She looked up at me. "Satisfied? They're perfectly 
harmless." 

Then she screamed. The ball was clinging to her finger as she withdrew it, and the cilia had enveloped 
it as far as the second joint. 


"It won't come off!" She began shaking her hand desperately. "It hurts." 

I swung my helmet hard at her finger, and the edge caught the ball near its middle. It was jarred loose 
and flew across the chamber. Anna stood and looked ruefully at her hand. The finger was reddened and 
swollen. 

"Damnation. It stings like hell." She turned accusingly to McAndrew and held forward her injured 
hand. "You fool. You told me they're harmless, and now look at my finger. This is your fault." 

We all stared at her hand. The swelling on her forefinger seemed to be getting bigger and redder. 

McAndrew had been standing there with a startled and perplexed expression on his face. Before I 
could stop him he picked up the laser that I had laid on the floor, aimed it at Anna, and pressed the 
switch. There was a crackle from the wall behind Anna, and the smoke of burned tissue. Her arm had 
been neatly severed above the elbow, and the wound cauterized with a single sweep of the instrument. 

Anna looked at the stump with bulging eyes, groaned, and started to fall sideways to the floor. 

"Mac!" I grabbed for the laser. "What the hell are you doing?" 

His face was pale. "Come on," he said. "Let's get her to the robodoc. This isn't too serious-she'll have 
to wait to regenerate it until we get home and find a biofeedback machine, but we can't help that." 

"But why did you do it?" 

"I made one bad mistake, back there outside the air lock," We were hurrying back through the ship, 
supporting Anna between us. 

"I don't want to make another one," he went on. "Lanhoff's notes on the single-celled organisms 
inside Manna pointed out that they didn't have a sexual method of reproduction, but they have 
something that resembles the plasmids down on Earth-they swap sections of DNA with each other, to 
get the mixing of offspring characteristics. I wondered about that when I read it, because it suggests a 
mechanism for speeding up an evolutionary process. But I skipped on past it, because I was so sure 
there would be no evolutionary pressures at work inside Manna." 

We were almost at the Control Section of Star Harvester. Unless Will had gone mad and flown off 
in the transfer pod, we were only twenty minutes away from the Hoatzin's robodoc. Anna was coming 
out of her faint, and groaning a little. 

"Mac, I still don't see it. Why does the evolution method of the creatures inside Manna mean you 
had to burn off Anna's arm?" 

"If they do swap tissue regularly, their immune reaction systems have to recognize and tolerate the 
exchange. But we're not made like that-Anna's immune reaction system might mop up the materials that 
the snowball transferred to her bloodstream, but more likely the stuff would have killed her. I daren't 
take the chance." 

We had come to the hatch that led to the transfer pod. Will Bayes stood there. For a fraction of a 
second he looked relieved, then he took in the whole scene. We were all pale and panting. I was 
dragging Anna along while she lay in a near-faint with only a stump of a right arm; and McAndrew, 
wild-eyed and lunatic, was bounding along behind us, still brandishing the laser. 

Will backed away in horror, his hands held in front of him. "Come on, man, don't just stand there," 
said McAndrew. "Get out of the way. We've got to get Anna over to our ship and let the doc have a go 
at her. The sooner the better." 

Will took a hesitant step to one side. "She's not dead, then?" 

"Of course she's not dead-she'll be good as new once she's been through a regeneration treatment. 
We'll have to keep her sedated for the trip back, but she'll be all right." 

I went to the controls of the pod, ready to take us back to the Hoatzin. It hadn't occurred to me that 
Anna would be quieted down now for the return trip, but I wouldn't be the one to complain. 

"You mean we're actually going home?" asked Will. His tone suggested that he had never expected 
to see Earth again. 

"Just for a while." McAndrew had settled Anna as comfortably as he could, and now he was looking 
disconsolately around him for the bucket of lifeform samples that we had left behind in the Control 
Section of Star Harvester. 

"We'll be back, Will, don't you worry," he said. "Anna was quite right: when Lanhoff found Manna 


he stumbled across a real treasure trove. We've hardly scratched the surface. As soon as we can get 
organized, there'll be another party from the Food Department. And I'm sure we'll all be here with it." 
My attention was mainly on the controls, so I'm not sure that I heard Will's low mumble correctly. 
But I think he was saying something about a transfer to the Energy Department. 


FIFTH CHRONICLE: The Hidden Matter 
of McAndrew 


The message was concise and clear: 

Dear Captain Roker, 
The Institute is sending a party to explore a region approximately half a light-year from Sol, for the 
purpose of verifying dark matter conjectures in current cosmological theories. Our projected departure 
date is six days hence. Knowing of your experience with Hoatzin-class ships employing the balanced 
drive, we wonder if you might be available to serve as a crew member for Project Missing Matter. If 
you are interested in so serving, I invite you to contact me or Dr. Dorian Jarver, at the above address. 

Sincerely, 

Arthur Morton McAndrew, 

Research Scientist, 

Penrose Institute. 

Clear, but also totally baffling. It was no surprise that McAndrew wanted to test obscure scientific 
theories. That was his stock-in-trade. People who knew physics as I would never know it told me that 
McAndrew was better than anyone else alive, a name to be mentioned in the same breath as Newton 
and Einstein. 

It was also predictable that he might be heading far out of the Solar System. He had done that 
whenever he thought there was something interesting to look at, or just when he needed a little time and 
space for serious solitary thinking. "I have to have it, Jeanie," he'd said to me, a score of times. "It's very 
nice to work with colleagues, but in my line of business the real stuff is mostly worked out alone." 

Nor was it odd that I was learning about the trip so late-a couple of times he had hared off on wild 
sorties far outside the Solar System, and I had been forced to chase after him and drag him out of 
trouble. 

But now for the mysteries: He had never, in all the many years since first we met, sent a letter to 
"Captain Roker," or signed himself with his full name. I was always "Jeanie" when he wrote to me, while 
he signed as "Mac" or "Macavity"-my private Old Possum-ish name for him, because like Macavity the 
Mystery Cat, McAndrew did things that seemed to break the law of gravity. 

Second, he didn't write when he was planning an expedition. There would be a random call, at any 
hour of the day or night. He was thinking of making a trip, he'd say vaguely. Would I perhaps like to go 
along? 

Third-a detail, but one that chafed my ego-I was invited to go on the Project Missing Matter 
expedition as a crew member. Mac knew that I'd served as ship's captain, and only as captain, for 
fifteen years. 

Fourth, the whole tone of the letter was too stilted and officious to be genuine McAndrew. He 
couldn't sound that formal if he tried. 

And one more mystery, to round out the set. Who the devil was Dorian Jarver? I thought I knew all 
the key scientists at the Penrose Institute. 

That question was fifth on the list, and the least important until I tried to call McAndrew for an 
explanation. Then instead of the old direct-access lines into individual offices at the Penrose Institute, I 
found myself dumped to a Message Center where my call was at once rerouted from McAndrew to 
Dorian Jarver. Director Jarver is unavailable, said a polite voice. Please leave your name, and he will 
return the call as soon as possible. 

I hung up without waiting to learn if the voice at the other end was live or recorded. Director Jarver? 
What had happened to my old friend Professor Limperis, the blackest man alive, who had run the 
Institute since long before my first visit? 

Finding the answer to that was not difficult. I tapped one of the general data bases and queried for 


the staff file of the Penrose Institute. Professor Limperis was listed, sure enough-but as professor 
emeritus and ex-Director. The new director was Dr. Dorian Jarver, former head of the Terran science 
applications group, and-bad sign-nephew of Councilor Griss, head of Terran Food and Energy. 

Anna Lisa Griss, that was, a lady whose arm McAndrew had once, with the best of possible 
intentions, cut off with a power laser out in the Oort cloud. It would have been regrown, long since; but I 
doubted that the memory had faded with the scar. 

I followed an old McAndrew principle, and went to a publications data base. Dorian Jarver was 
there, with eight or nine decent-sounding physics papers credited to him; but they were not recent. The 
newest one was eleven years old. The new director of the Penrose Institute appeared to be an 
ex-physicist. 

McAndrew was anything but an ex-physicist. Why would he cite his own name and Jarver's as 
someone I might contact? 

When I received the message from McAndrew I was on the tail end of a routine run home from 
Titan. As soon as the Assembly I had been piloting was tucked away and all its Sections placed in a 
stable parking orbit, I signed off and headed straight for the Penrose Institute aboard one of the 5-gee 
mini-versions of the McAndrew balanced drive. 

"I invite you to contact me or Dr. Dorian Jarver," the letter had said. Contact can surely include a 
visit. 

The outline of the Institute at last appeared as a lumpy and spiky double-egg during my final 
approach. I examined it closely. It would wander around the Inner Solar System depending on research 
needs, anywhere between Mercury and the Belt, but its facilities shouldn't change. They hadn't. As we 
docked I could see the Dotterel and the Merganser moored in the external hoists. They were the first 
prototypes using the McAndrew balanced drive (which everyone else, to Mac's intense annoyance, 
insists on calling the McAndrew inertia-less drive). Those early ships were no longer in use. They had 
been replaced by a more advanced design, embodied in the Hoatzin. I could see its bulky massplate 
and longer central spike off in the distance. It appeared slightly grubby and battered-looking, as befitted 
the first and only ship to visit both the Ark of Massingham and the Oort cloud. 

The changes began inside, as soon as I passed through the lock. In the old Institute the visitor found 
herself wading at once through a junkyard of obsolete equipment waiting for disposal. It would have 
been quite an obstacle course in an emergency, but nobody had ever seemed worried about that. 

Now I found myself in a clean and uncluttered chamber. The walls were painted white, the floor was 
polished grey, and in the middle of the room sat something that the Institute had surely never seen before: 
a long desk, two receptionists, and in front of them, a sign-in terminal and a tray of badges. 

The woman behind the desk went on fiddling with a great bank of controls in front of her, all 
flickering lights and low humming, but the man glanced up at me inquiringly. 

"I'm here to see McAndrew," I said, and started towards the corridor on the left. I'd been here 
scores of times, and I knew where Mac hung out, in a cluttered room that made even the old entry to the 
Institute look elegant. Mac didn't throw away junk equipment. He kept it in his office. 

"Not that way, ma'am," said the man politely. "Professor McAndrew is the other way now. You will 
need an escort. And if you'd first please check in . . ." 

McAndrew's voice was starting to whisper in my ear. By the time that I had signed in, stated my 
identity, had my ID independently checked with a DNA mapper, been assigned a badge, and refused 
refreshments (how long did they expect me to be in the reception area?) Mac's voice was shouting at 
me. "Help, Jeanie," it screamed. "Help, help, help!" 

This wasn't the Penrose Institute that I had known, the place of casual procedure and superb science 
where Mac had worked for half his life. It had become a clone of a thousand Earthside technology 
offices. 

And it got worse. When I, checked and signed and badged, was led away towards the new working 
offices, I still did not reach McAndrew. "In a few minutes," said my guide, in answer to my question. 
"But first, the Director." 

I was ushered into a new chamber, starkly clean and sparsely furnished. My guide left at once and I 


looked around. There was no desk, no terminal. Over in one corner on an angular white chair sat an 
equally angular and thoughtful man, fingertips touching in front of his face. 

"Captain Roker," he said, and stood up. He smiled, very white teeth in a thin-lipped, worried 
countenance. "I'm Dorian Jarver, the Director of the Penrose Institute. I must say I didn't expect a visit 
until you'd heard more about the project. But it's a blessing that you're here, because now we can all do 
our best to persuade you." 

"I'm persuaded already." I realized that was true, and had been since I saw that ritzy new entrance 
foyer. "I'm reporting for duty right now." 

"For the expedition described in Professor McAndrew's letter to you? But the mission and your role 
in it are not yet fully defined." 

"You can define that later. I'm here, and I'm ready to start." 

Dorian Jarver must have been surprised at both my arrival and my instant acceptance. "I'm delighted 
to hear that," he said, though he didn't sound it. "You come to us with the highest recommendations. And 
I have to admit that I've been a little worried about this proposed expedition. It could be dangerous, and 
Professor McAndrew is too valuable to risk. He's one of our most priceless assets." 

No matter what else he didn't know, he obviously understood McAndrew. It could be dangerous, 
because Mac would charge into Hell itself if he saw some intriguing scientific fact sitting in the innermost 
circle. He was too valuable to risk. But Jarver's final word was disturbing to me. Not a scientist, not a 
human being. An asset. 

"You have been to the Institute before?" added Jarver. 

I nodded. I didn't know what Mac had told him about me, but I suspected that the new director had 
no idea how close we were. 

"Then you'll have noticed the changes here. The Council had been worrying about the Institute for 
quite a while. When Director Limperis retired and I came in, the Council insisted that from now on 
operations would have to be organized rather differently." 

He talked about those changes for the next few minutes. Better equipment and facilities for the 
scientists. Bigger and cleaner offices. More attention by support staff to routine maintenance functions. 
Removal of the need for top scientists to waste their time on calls and letters and incoming requests for 
information, trivia that could be handled just as well by junior staff. 

It all sounded terrific. But McAndrew's strangely awkward letter stuck in my head. I wanted to see 
him, and make sure that he was all right. 

With my mind on McAndrew as Jarver went on talking, I didn't think that I was saying much in reply. 
But it must have been enough for the director, because after another few minutes he seemed to lose 
interest in the conversation, nodded, and said, "Now, Captain Roker, I'm sure you'll be wanting to hear 
more about the expedition itself. Project Missing Matter will be testing some of the most fundamental 
ideas in cosmology; of course, you'll get that better from McAndrew than you'll ever get it from me." 

As we stood up I thought that I had Dorian Jarver pegged. I had seen him before, many times. Not 
the man himself, but the type. The upper levels of Terran government were full of them: competent, 
hard-working men and women, who started out as scientists, found that they were never going to be 
better than average, and at an early age substituted management and administration for research. Jarver 
had changed over the years from scientist to calculating bureaucrat. 

Well, I've been wrong before. Let's call that my first mistake on Project Missing Matter. 

The director led me to an office down at the far end of the corridor and opened the door. It was big, 
far bigger than McAndrew's old, cluttered den. It had the same antiseptic look as the rest of the new 
Institute. But even Jarver couldn't do much about the appearance of the occupant. 

McAndrew was lolling in an easy chair, staring vacantly at the wall. His shoes were off, his feet were 
bare and grubby. His thinning, sandy hair was standing up in little wispy spikes as though he had been 
running his hands through it, which he tended to do when he was thinking, and I could see from the 
redness of his finger and toe joints that he had been pulling them and cracking them, in the way that I 
hated. 

He glanced up as we came in, swinging his chair casually in our direction. 


"Jeanie Roker," he said. He didn't stand up, and he didn't seem in the least surprised at my 
unexpected arrival. I glanced at Jarver out of the corner of my eye. If Mac wanted to convince the 
director that he hardly knew me, he should have acted quite differently. 

"Professor McAndrew," said Jarver to me. It could have been an introduction, or possibly an 
apology. "If you'll excuse me, Captain Roker, I'll leave the two of you to discuss the expedition. I'll meet 
with you again later." 

As soon as he was gone I bent over and gave McAndrew a six-month separation hug. The hell with 
formal handshakes. He hugged me right back, then I flopped into the seat opposite and said, "Mac. 
What the hell is going on here?" 

"You saw it already." His face took on a gloomy, give-up expression that I didn't like at all. "New 
offices, new procedures, all the other folderol. Now tell me, did I need a new office?" 

"Does it matter that much? You can work as well in here as you could in your old place, and it's nice 
to visit and sit on something softer than an optical scalar calibrator. And Jarver's right, the Institute was 
getting a bit run-down. It looks good now. You're becoming crabby in your old age." 

He glared at me. "If that were the whole of it, I might agree with you . . . but it's not. You had that 
letter. Didn't it make you wonder a bit?" 

"Why d'you think I'm here?" 

I don't believe he heard me. "Due procedure," he said, "that's what they call it. But it's beyond that. 
No messages or memos or papers or letters go out from here without stamps of official approval on 
them. You saw how my letter to you sounded after they'd done messing with it. All the incoming mail is 
opened, too-personal as well as professional-before we get to see it. Spoken messages are just as bad. 
Incoming and outgoing calls are all logged and recorded. Did you see that blasted bank of equipment in 
the front area, with administrative staff snooping on everything? I'm telling you, it's like being in a bloody 
prison." 

"Mac, you're overreacting. Jarver is used to running things Earth-style. They're hot on procedure. It'll 
take him a while to learn Institute ways. You and your buddies will sort him out." 

"Will we now?" McAndrew snorted. "Me and my buddies will sort him out, will we-when Emma 
Gowers and Wenig and Lucky Macedo have already resigned and left." 

That was a shocker. I knew all three, and there wasn't one who didn't make me feel, without their 
ever intending it, about as bright as a chimps' tea-party drop-out. 

"Mac, that proves my point. If Jarver's losing high-caliber people like that, he must know that he 
won't last another three months. Unless he's too dumb even to realize what he's driving away?" 

I saw a change in McAndrew's expression. He's the system's most honest man, even when it 
undermines his own arguments. Now he looked guilty. 

"That's maybe the worst of it," he said. "Jarver's not stupid at all. He got the job here, likely, because 
he's a relative of Anna Griss. She's no lover of the Institute after what I did to her. But Jarver didn't 
come here wanting to destroy the place. He's a good physicist, see, with a real sense for what's 
important." 

"That's not what I thought when I looked at his publication record. Not many papers to his credit, 
and all written a long time ago." 

"Jeanie." McAndrew stared at me with the disappointed expression of a man whose dog has slipped 
back into non-housebroken ways. "How many times have I told you, a publication record tells you 
nothing. Any clod can spew out words and equations, year in and year out, and push them into print. 
Papers don't count for anything, unless other people use 'em. You should have looked at the Citation 
Index, to see how often Jarver's work is given as a reference by other people. If you'd done that, you'd 
have seen hundreds of them. He's not publishing now, true enough, but when he did, he was good." 

Poor old McAndrew. I was beginning to see the real problem. Here was a new director who did 
everything that Mac disliked, a man whom he would love to hate and disparage. But he couldn't do that. 
Jarver was a good physicist, and therefore almost beyond censure. 

"But if he's that bright, you ought to be able to work with him. Persuade him." 

"Damn it, I have persuaded him. That's what the new expedition is all about. I've got Jarver 


convinced that we have to go out a long way from Sol. Then we stop, and sit still, and do our 
measurements, and learn more than anyone has ever known about the distribution of missing matter." 

I had to find out more about that, but this wasn't the time for it. Half a light-year from Sol was a long 
trip, even with a hundred gees of continuous acceleration and the relativity squeeze that our high speed 
would provide us. We'd have weeks to talk about missing matter, Mac's experiments, and everything 
else in the Universe. But it would be nice to know why we had to go out there at all. 

"Why not do your experiments here at the Institute?" 

"Because it's too damned noisy near in." McAndrew became more like his old self as the 
conversation turned closer to physics. I decided there was hope-maybe he wasn't a broken man after 
all. "It's the Sun's fault," he went on. "Sol generates such an infernal din, gravitationally and in almost 
every electromagnetic wavelength you can think of, that you can't do a decently sensitive experiment 
closer than half a light-year. It's like listening for a pin drop, when somebody's banging a bass drum right 
next to your ear. We have to go out, out where the interstellar medium is nice and quiet." 

"But that's exactly what you will be doing. You'll be flying out on the Hoatzin, and as far from the 
Institute as you want to be. So why aren't you pleased?" I had a horrible thought. "Unless you're telling 
me that Jarver proposes to go along with us." 

"No, no, no." McAndrew went right back to being gloomy. "He says he'd like to, but he's far too 
busy running the Institute. He's not going. But he's sending his aunt's pet bully-boys, Lyle and Parmikan, 
along to keep an eye on things and report back. Now that's what really has me going, Jeanie. That's the 
reason I sent you the letter." 

I got very annoyed with McAndrew. He was taking a perfectly natural decision, from Jarver's point 
of view, and blowing it up out of all proportion. 
Of course, this was before I met Van Lyle and Stefan Parmikan. 
* * * 

The doubtful pleasure of that meeting was not long delayed. It came the same afternoon, when 
McAndrew dragged me along to the weekly seminar, a tradition of the Penrose Institute for as long as I 
had been visiting it. 

The old meeting room, with its poor air circulation and white plastic hard-backed chairs, had 
vanished. In its place was a hall with tiers of plushy seats running in banks up towards the rear. It could 
hold maybe three hundred. The seminars that I remembered might draw fifty if they were on a really hot 
subject. 

Today there were no more than thirty people in the room. McAndrew and I took seats at the end of 
the last occupied row. I tried to recognize the people I knew from the look of the backs of their heads. I 
did pretty well, over half the audience. Wenig and Gowers and Macedo might be gone, but most of the 
other old-timers at the Institute hadn't given up yet. 

The lecturer, Siclaro-another Institute perennial-was already in position and raring to go. 

"The first ten-thousandth of a second after the Big Bang is far more interesting than the entire rest of 
the history of the Universe." That was his first sentence. I couldn't tell you what his second sentence was. 
I didn't expect to understand the seminar, you see, because I never had in the past. But I might still 
enjoy it. Like the psychologist at the burlesque show I concentrated on the audience, examining the 
newcomers to try to guess their specialties and how good they were at them. 

A futile exercise, of course. Emma Gowers, the System's top expert on multiple kernel arrays, looks 
and dresses like a high-class whore. Wenig could be her pimp, and McAndrew himself resembles an 
accountant in need of a haircut and a good meal. 

You just can't tell. Brains won't correlate with appearance. 

Over to the far left of our row sat a group of three. I saw Dorian Jarver. He was leaning forward, 
intent on the presentation. To his immediate right were two men of particular interest to me-because they 
too were taking no notice of the lecture and showing a lot of interest in the audience. I nudged 
McAndrew, just as someone hurried in from the back of the room and leaned over to whisper in Jarver's 
ear. He sighed, shook his head, and followed the woman quickly out of the hall. 

"What?" said McAndrew at last. He had missed the whole episode with Jarver. 


"Those two men. Who are they?" 

He snorted. "Them two? Van Lyle. Stefan Parmikan." 

I stared with redoubled curiosity. Van Lyle (I found out later which was which) was a big, 
broad-shouldered fellow with curly blond hair and a handsome, craggy profile. He made no pretence of 
listening to the lecture, but he observed the audience with open interest. At his side the little, 
round-shouldered figure of Stefan Parmikan was far more discreet. To a casual observer he was 
following everything that Siclaro said-but every few seconds his head would turn for a moment and his 
eyes would flicker over everyone. When they met mine he at once turned away. 

"Mac," I said. And paused. 

He had slipped away from my side. I saw him down by the lecturer's podium next to Siclaro, one 
hand pointed at the screen. 

"You know the problem," he was saying. "We all believe that the amount of matter in the universe is 
just enough to keep it expanding forever. That gives asymptotically flat spacetime, an idea we have half 
a dozen good theoretical reasons for wanting to believe. But the bright matter-the stuff we can see-only 
accounts for maybe a hundredth of what's needed to close spacetime. So, where's the rest of it? 
Where's the missing matter? 

"I agree with Siclaro, it's the devil to answer that question from any experiments we've been able to 
do so far. I wouldn't propose to try. But we've designed a whole new set of crucial experiments that we 
can do if we are far out from Sol, where there's not so much interference." 

He was getting into a discussion of the hidden matter, the reason for taking the Hoatzin on its 
light-year round-trip. But I couldn't listen to him, because I was no longer alone. The two men next to 
Jarver had slid quietly across from the other side of the room and were now by my side. 

"Captain Roker?" said the blond-haired man. "I wanted to say hello. I hear we're going to be 
shipmates." 

He gazed sincerely into my eyes, took my hand in his big, meaty paw, and held on a few seconds 
longer than necessary. 

"Pleased to meet you," added his companion, leaning across and taking my hand in turn. "I'm Stefan 
Parmikan. I've heard a lot about you." His smile was a wet, shapeless version of Van Lyle's intimate grin. 
And instead of riveting me like Lyle, his brown eyes would look anywhere but into mine. 

"You heard about me?" I was surprised. McAndrew is closer than a clam. "From whom?" 

"The boss. Councilor Griss." 

His limp grip was like a lump of wet gristle, much worse than Van Lyle's intimate clutch; but that 
wasn't what bothered me. 

Suddenly, I could put it all together. So far my thinking had managed to get everything wrong. Anna 
Lisa Griss could push her relatives into high places, and no one would be surprised by that. Nepotism 
never changes. She had arranged for Dorian Jarver to take over the Penrose Institute. 

But it was her bad luck that Jarver happened to be genuine, a conscientious scientist with a real feel 
for physics and science. She couldn't change his nature. What she could do, though, and had done, was 
to install as his assistants her chosen few: people with no feeling for science, who would follow the 
Councilor's style of operation and do exactly what she said. She had told them to mold the Institute to 
her own taste, to change it to a copy of the standard Terran bureaucracy that she understood and 
controlled so well. 

And they were doing it. I was now convinced that the real author of the message to me had not been 
McAndrew. Lyle or Parmikan had structured it, with Anna Griss behind them. Mac had asked for my 
help, but she had been the manipulator. She wanted me on board the Hoatzin, for a trip that she would 
control, through Van Lyle and Stefan Parmikan, from beginning to end. 

What made me so sure? There's one point that I neglected to mention about the run-in that we had 
with Anna Griss out in the Oort cloud. McAndrew had cut off her arm, which was bad enough but 
maybe forgivable since he thought he was doing it to save her life. But before that I had stared her down, 
overridden her authority, and asserted my own position as ship's captain. She had been forced to accept 
it. But knowing Anna, I knew that would never be forgiven, or forgotten. Not even when she had taken 


an eye for an eye-or an arm for an arm. 

I heard the door at the back of the room open. Jarver was coming back in, and Lyle and Parmikan 
dutifully hurried back to his side. I shivered, and sat up straight in my seat. Something creepy had 
brushed by me in the past few minutes, and I didn't yet know what it was. 

"So that's it," McAndrew was saying from the podium. "The two best candidates for the missing 
material needed to flatten the universe are hot dark matter-probably energetic neutrinos with a small rest 
mass, generated soon after the Big Bang; or maybe cold dark matter, particles like the axions needed 
for charge-parity conservation, or the photinos and other more massive objects required by 
supersymmetry theories. 

"So which should we believe in, the hot or the cold? We don't know. They both have problems 
describing the way that the galaxies formed. 

"Worse than that, we aren't measuring nearly enough of either kind of matter. Add everything 
together, and we still have less than half the mass density needed to make a flat universe. We must be 
badly underestimating either the cold dark matter or the hot. 

"Which? Theory still can't provide the answer. Most of the events that decide all this began happening 
in the first 10-35 seconds after the origin of the universe, when we weren't around to do experiments; 
when even the laws of physics may not have been the same. 

"We may never know the composition of the missing matter, until we can put our instruments in the 
right place for observation-deep in interstellar space." 

He halted. Siclaro nodded his appreciation, and Mac came ambling back to his seat. 

Naturally, he had missed the whole interaction with Lyle and Parmikan. He'd have missed it even if it 
had happened under his nose, because he never saw anything when he was talking about physics. He 
had temporarily forgotten his annoyance at the changes to the Institute, and he seemed quite pleased 
with life. 

I wasn't. I had been brought to the Institute so that McAndrew and I could fly half a light-year from 
home with Lyle and Parmikan. Anna Griss had engineered my arrival. It was inconceivable that the 
surprises were all over. 

What little goodies were in store when Anna's bully-boys and I were flying far off in the Hoatzin? 

* * * 

I lost track of that question in the busy days before departure. The Hoatzin was primed and ready, 
but I hadn't performed my engine inspection or any of the other preparations that I like to do. I went 
over the ship, checking everything, and found nothing worse than a slight imbalance in the drive that 
would have meant a mid-course correction at ship turn-around, a quarter of a light-year from Sol. 

Neither Lyle nor Parmikan gave me any trouble. In fact, I hardly saw them until the four of us 
assembled for final check-in and departure. Then Stefan Parmikan rolled up with about ten times as 
much baggage as he was allowed. 

He objected strongly when I told him to take it away. "All that space." He pointed outside, to the 
Hoatzin with its hundred meter mass disk and the four hundred meter axle sticking out like a great grey 
spike from its center. "There's oceans of room for my stuff." 

How could a man reach adulthood today, and know so little about the McAndrew balanced drive? 

"The disk you're pointing at is solid compressed matter," I said. "Density is twelve hundred tons per 
cubic centimeter, and surface gravity is a hundred and ten gees. If you want to strap your luggage on the 
outside of that, good luck to you." 

"What about the axle? I can see that it's hollow." 

"It is. And it has to stay that way, so the living-capsule can move up and down it. Otherwise we 
couldn't balance the gravitational and inertial accelerations. Either we move the capsule in closer to the 
disk as we increase the acceleration, or you tell me how we're going to survive a hundred gees." When 
he still didn't show much sign of understanding me, I waved my hand. "The total living accommodation of 
the Hoatzin is that four-meter sphere. I'm not going to spend the next month falling over your stuff. And 
I'm not going to waste time arguing. That luggage isn't going with us. That's final. Get it out of here, so 
we can prepare to board." 


Parmikan glowered and grumbled, and finally dragged it away. When he reappeared an hour later 
with a much smaller package I hustled everyone onto the Hoatzin as quickly as possible to avoid any 
more hold-ups. Maybe I wasn't as thorough as I should have been inspecting luggage. But I suspect it 
would have done no good if I had been. There must be a definite threat before you start opening 
people's personal effects. I was anticipating rudeness and arguments and possible discipline problems, 
but not danger. 

Let's call that my second mistake in Project Missing Matter. 

Once we were under way I felt a lot better. With the drive on the perimeter of the mass disk turned 
on, the Hoatzin is surrounded by a sheath of highly relativistic plasma. Signals won't penetrate it. 
Communications with Anna Griss, or anyone else back in the Solar System, were blocked. That suited 
me fine. 

By the end of the first twenty-four hours at full drive we were doing well. We were up to a quarter of 
light-speed, heading out from Sol at right angles to the plane of the ecliptic and already at the distance of 
Neptune. We had settled into a typical shipboard routine, each person giving the others as much space 
as possible. You do that when you know you have to spend a long time packed together into a space no 
bigger than a fair-sized kitchen. 

And then, unexpectedly, our communications silence caused trouble. 

The Hoatzin had been pleasantly quiet for hours. McAndrew had donned a suit, one of the new 
transparent models so light that you could sit in high vacuum and hardly realize you had a suit on at all. 

He was going outside. Most people would be terrified at the prospect of leaving the capsule when the 
drive is on-if for any reason it turned off, the capsule would automatically spring out to the far end of the 
axle, to hold the interior field at one gee. But anyone not firmly secured to the capsule would fall at a 
hundred gee acceleration towards the mass disk. A quick end, and a messy one. 

It never occurred to McAndrew that his inventions might fail. He had happily gone outside, for a 
status check of one of the new mass detectors that he would be using when we reached our destination 
in the middle of nowhere. We were heading for the region of lowest matter density known, out beyond 
the limits of the Oort cloud where we would find less than one atom per hundred cubic meters. 

I was looking at the outside display screens, partly to scan the plume of plasma behind the Hoatzin 
for any sign of drive variability, and partly, to tell the truth, because I wanted to keep my eye on 
McAndrew. He doesn't believe the balanced drive can give trouble, despite the fact that its very first use 
nearly killed him. 

While I had my attention on the screens, Stefan Parmikan crept up behind me. I didn't know he was 
there until I heard a soft, sibilant voice in my ear. "I am required to send a report to the Council every 
day, and be able to receive messages from them." 

I jerked around. Parmikan's face was only a foot from mine. It was probably not his fault, but why 
was his mouth always so wet-looking? 

"But Professor McAndrew tells me that we cannot send messages to Terra when the drive is turned 
on," he continued. 

"Quite right. To Terra, or anywhere else. The signals can't get through." 

"In that case, the drive must be turned off once every shipboard day." 

"Forget it." I was a bit brusque, but Lyle and Parmikan seemed to have come along on the expedition 
without learning a thing about the ship, the drive, or anything else. And Parmikan didn't sound like he 
was asking-he was telling. "We lose a couple of hours every time we turn power on and off," I went on. 
"And you'd have the living-capsule going up and down the axle like a yo-yo, to balance the change in 
acceleration from a hundred gee to zero. And anyway, once we're a long way out the signal travel time is 
so long the messages would be useless." 

"But it is technologically feasible to turn off the drive, and to send and receive messages?" 

"It is. And practically ridiculous. We won't do it." 

Parmikan smiled his wet smile, and for once he appeared to be genuinely pleased about something. 

"We will, Ms. Roker. Or rather, you will. You will turn the drive off once a day, for communication 
with Earth." 


He drew a yellow document from his pocket, stamped prominently with the Council seal, and handed 
it to me. 

Not Captain Roker. Ms. Roker. It took only a few seconds to scan the paper and understand what 
it was. I was holding Parmikan's appointment as captain of the Hoatzin for this mission. In all the 
excitement of preparing for our departure I had completely forgotten the original letter to me. An 
invitation to serve as crew member on the expedition, not captain. For the days before our departure I 
had instinctively and naturally assumed the senior position. And Lyle and Parmikan had been sly enough 
to go along with me, even addressing me as "Captain Roker" until we were on our way and it was too 
late to do anything about it. 

"Well, Ms. Roker? Do you question the authority assigned by this document?" 

"I question its wisdom. But I accept its validity." I scanned down the rest of the page. Parmikan's 
command extended from the time we left the Penrose Institute until the moment when we docked on our 
return. No loopholes. "I agree, you're the captain. I don't see anything here defining my duties, though, 
or saying that I'll agree to them. So if you want to turn the drive off yourself, without my help . . ." 

Stefan Parmikan said nothing, but his sliding brown eyes met mine for one triumphant split-second. 
He reached into his pocket, pulled out a tiny playback unit, and turned it on. 

"I'm reporting for duty right now," said a voice. It was my own. 

"For the expedition described in Professor McAndrew's letter to you? But the mission and your role 
in it are not yet fully defined." That was Dorian Jarver. 

"You can define that later. I'm here, and I'm ready to start." 

There was a pause, as that section of the recording ended. Then Jarver's voice came again: "In 
accordance with Captain Jean Pelham Roker's earlier statement, this serves to define her duties on the 
Hoatzin mission identified as Project Missing Matter. Ms. Roker will serve as a general crew member, 
taking her orders and assignments from Captain Stefan Parmikan and from Senior Officer Van Lyle." 

Set-up. But my own fault completely. I had felt bad vibrations the moment I met Parmikan and Lyle. 
Then I had gone right ahead and ignored my own instincts. Let's call that my third mistake. 

McAndrew was climbing back in through the tiny airlock. I turned to him. "Mac, suppose we turned 
the drive off every day for a minute or two, long enough to send a burst mode message back to Earth. 
Allowing for the time we need to power the drive down and back up, how much would that add to our 
total trip?" 

He stared at me for a moment, then his jaw dropped and his face took on a strange half-witted 
vacancy. That was fine. It just meant that he was off in his own world, thinking and calculating. I had 
given up trying to understand what went on inside McAndrew's head when he was solving a problem. 
Even though what I had asked him was straightforward and I could have done the calculation myself 
given a little time, I would bet money that he was not using any technique I'd have chosen. As one of the 
Institute members told me years ago, McAndrew has a mind that sees round corners. 

"Five days," he said after a few seconds. "Of course, that's shipboard days. Two months Terran, 
allowing for time squeeze." 

"Quite acceptable," said Parmikan. "Ms. Roker, please work out the necessary arrangements and 
bring them to me." 

He turned and headed off for the private area of his own bunk, leaving me to fume and curse. And 
then, after a few minutes, to sit down and work out the best times for a regular interruption to the drive. I 
had to work it into other activities, so that Parmikan would make his daily call with minimum disruption 
to ship routine. 

McAndrew came to me when I was almost finished. "Jeanie, I didn't catch on to what he wanted 
when you asked me that, or I'd have said it was hard to do. You don't have to take this sort of guff from 
him." 

"I do." I picked up the results of my efforts, aware that Van Lyle had been watching me all the time I 
was working. "You know the first rule of space travel as well as I do: Like it or not, you can only have 
one captain. Parmikan is the captain of the Hoatzin." 

I carried the schedule I had generated across to Parmikan's curtained rest area. The little private 


spaces allotted to each of us were intentionally set as far apart from each other as possible, around the 
perimeter of the living capsule. I rapped on the curtain rail. "This is my recommended schedule," I said, 
when Parmikan's head poked through. I held it out to him, but he did not take it. 

"Is it a simple procedure?" he asked. 

"I believe so. I've done my best to make it as simple as possible." 

"Good. Then you should have no trouble carrying it out. Notify me when the drive is off, and we are 
ready for our first communication opportunity with Terra. By then I'll have another assignment for you." 

His head vanished back through the curtain. I had an insight into Parmikan's style of command. He 
would give all the orders. I would do all the work. This was Anna Lisa Griss's revenge for my asserting 
my authority over her. I would have to obey Parmikan's every random whim for two months. 

I was still naive enough to think that would be enough to satisfy her. My fourth mistake, was that? I'm 
beginning to lose count. 

I stayed angry at being ordered around, until I remembered Lyle and Parmikan's general ignorance of 
shipboard matters. Then I thought, Hey, it's better like this. How would you feel if Parmikan took over 
the controls himself? And I went away to set up the program to power down the drive at regular 
intervals. 

Except that McAndrew had heard my exchange with Parmikan, and he was feeling sorry for me. He 
insisted that he would do the tedious job of changing the drive program schedule. I let him. It was quite 
safe to do so, because Mac's such a perfectionist on this sort of thing that he sometimes makes me feel 
sloppy. 

But Mac is only devious in scientific matters. He didn't catch something in the Hoatzin's overall 
mission profile that I would have noticed at once. 

I discovered it much later, and almost too late. Call that my fifth mistake, and let's stop counting. 

To me, the interruptions to our outward progress were a useless nuisance. I have no idea what was 
sent or received by Parmikan and Lyle in their daily communications. I was specifically excluded from 
them, and in any case Parmikan had me far too busy with a hundred other things to worry much about 
messages-he had an absolute genius for thinking up demeaning and pointless tasks. I do know, though, 
that the person sending or receiving at the other end was not Dorian Jarver. The link was set up to a 
location on Terra, not to the Penrose Institute. 

And McAndrew, being McAndrew, contrived to turn the periods when the drive was off into an 
opportunity. He decided that he could use those few dead minutes every day to perform his first 
experiments. One morning right after breakfast I went to the rear of the living capsule to escape from 
Van Lyle-he, and his probing eyes, followed me everywhere. I found McAndrew sitting beside his 
instrument panel, frowning at the wall. 

"Problems?" 

He shrugged, and scratched at the back of his balding head. "I'd have said no. Everything passes the 
internal checks. But look at this." He pulled up a display. "I've got the most sensitive mass detectors 
ever, lined up on our final destination. All the other instruments confirm that there's absolutely nothing out 
there. But see these." 

He pointed to small blips in the output level of the instruments. 

"Noise?" I suggested. "Or the result of our high velocity? Or maybe a local effect, something on the 
Hoatzin?" He had told me that his new instruments were supernaturally sensitive to disturbance. 

"No, they're definitely external, and far-off. And regular. That's just the signals I'd be getting if 
massive objects were flying, evenly spaced, across my field of view. Except there's nothing there. It's a 
total mystery." 

"Then you'll just have to be patient. We're already past turn-around. In twelve days we'll be there, 
and you'll be able to see for your-" 

"Crewman Roker!" It was Parmikan's voice, ringing through the living capsule. "Come here 
immediately. I have a task that must be performed at once." 

I took a deep breath, and held it. Another fun-filled day was beginning. Twelve more to go, before 
we came to rest in the most perfect nothingness known to humans, half a light-year from the Sun. 


* * * 

With the whole habitable space of the Hoatzin only four meters across, I knew before we left the 
Institute that we'd be living close. But given the lack of privacy, there was one form of closeness I had 
never expected. 

The surprise came late in the evening on the twenty-third day out, when Mac was in the shielded rear 
of the living capsule muttering over his still-anomalous instrument readings. The blips were growing. With 
Parmikan's consent Mac had gradually changed our course, angling the ship's direction of travel towards 
the strongest source of signal. We would arrive a tenth of a light-year away from our original destination, 
but as McAndrew pointed out, the choice of that had been more or less arbitrary. Any place where the 
matter density was unusually low would serve his purpose equally well. 

By eleven o'clock Stefan Parmikan was asleep. I was sitting cross-legged on my bunk, listening to an 
Institute lecture from my talking library. It was "Modern Physics for Engineers," by Gowers, Siclaro, and 
McAndrew, a course designed to be less high-powered than the straight two-hundred-proof Institute 
seminar presentations. There were three other series available, of rapidly descending levels of difficulty. 
They each had official names, but inside the Institute they were known as "Physics for Animals," "Physics 
for Vegetables," and "Physics for Football Players." 

I had brought all four, just in case, but I was holding my own with "Physics for Engineers." I was 
finally gaining a clearer idea of just why we had to charge off half a light-year from Sol. 

Something was absent from the Universe, something that the best brains around thought had to be 
there: Missing matter. 

The "bright stuff"-visible matter-isn't nearly enough to make the Universe hover on the fine line 
between expanding forever, and collapsing back one day to the Big Crunch. That's what the theorists 
want, but there's only about one percent of the mass needed in the bright stuff. You can pick up a factor 
of ten or so from matter that's pretty much the same as visible matter, but happens to be too cold to see, 
and that's all. 

This leaves you about a factor of ten short on mass. And there you stick. You have to start laying 
bets on other, less familiar materials. 

Neutrinos moving up close to the speed of light-hot dark matter-are one candidate. There are scads 
of neutrinos around, generated soon after the Big Bang but damnably difficult to find by experiment. 
Neutrinos don't interact much with ordinary matter. They'd slip through light-years of solid lead, if you 
happened to have light-years of lead available. They're a candidate for the missing matter, but they're 
not the front runner. They don't give a Universe with the right lumpy structure, and anyway they come up 
short on total mass. 

The other candidates are much slower and heavier than neutrinos. They're the cold dark matter 
school, axions and photinos and gravitinos, and they don't give the right lumpiness to the Universe, 
either. Even adding them to the neutrino mass, the whole thing still came up too small. McAndrew was 
saying, in effect, we've gone as far as theories can go. Let's get out there, where the experiments have a 
chance to succeed, and measure how much hot dark matter and cold dark matter is around. Then we'll 
know where we stand. 

It was all fairly new to me. I was concentrating deeply, struggling with the theories of 
WIMPs-Weakly Interacting Massive Particles-when I was interrupted. 

For the past three days I had been aware of Van Lyle hanging around me. I became a lot more 
aware of him when two arms suddenly went around me from behind, and two hands clasped my breasts. 

"Hey, Jeanie," Lyle's voice whispered in my ear. "You've got lovely tits. It's going to be nice and quiet 
for a while. Want to get friendly?" 

I jerked forward along the bunk, untangling my legs and trying to pull myself free. He was hanging on 
tight. That hurt. 

"Get your damned hands off me." I wanted to say something a lot worse, but I knew we were going 
to be cooped up in the same space for another few weeks, no matter what. I had been trained to avoid 
onboard confrontations, and I wanted to stay cool and end this politely. 

I swung around to face him and pushed myself away. 


"Oh, don't be like that." He was grinning, a big, smarmy God's-gift-to-women grin. "Come on. 
Lighten up. We could have some real fun." 

He reached out towards my breast again, and I pushed his hand away. "Quit that, Lyle! I tell you, I'm 
not having any." 

"You haven't tried it. Lots of women could tell you, you won't be disappointed. Want to have a look 
at my testimonials?" And then, as I pushed his groping hand away again, this time when it reached 
towards my crotch, "Hey, Jeanie, you're strong. I just love strong women." 

"You do, do you?" I'd had it. "This strong enough for you?" 

I swung with all my body behind it as his face came forward, and got him with my fist right on the 
bridge of his nose. 

It hurt like hell-hurt me, I mean. I didn't care how much it hurt him. But I don't think he enjoyed it, 
because as the blood spurted out of his flattened nose and splashed all over my bunk, he let out a 
terrible howl that brought McAndrew running. 

Just as well, because by that time I was upright, off my bunk, and all set to kick Lyle in the balls at 
least ten times as hard as I'd punched his nose. McAndrew got in the way before I could do it. He 
leaned close to Van Lyle, a rag in his hand to mop up blood. 

"What happened?" 

Lyle produced only a horrible snorting noise. 

"Tripped as he was coming in here," I said, "and banged his face on the edge of the bunk. Get the 
medical kit." 

McAndrew glanced at the bunk as Stefan Parmikan finally appeared. I knew that Mac was doing an 
instant height and angle match, and rejecting it. But he never said a thing. Nor did Lyle, unless you count 
the groans when Parmikan was moving his broken nose around in an attempt to achieve a reasonably 
straight result. 

We fixed the nose, more or less, and sedated Lyle. Parmikan went back to bed. During the sleep 
period, McAndrew leaned over the edge of my bunk and whispered to me. "Jeanie? I know you're 
awake. Are you all right?" 

"I'm just fine." I didn't want him as furious as I was. 

"He didn't bang himself on the bunk, did he? He made advances to you, and you hit him." 

"What makes you think that?" Mac's insights were supposed to be into Nature, but not human nature. 

"He was talking about you two days ago, when you weren't present. He said he wanted to take you 
to bed. Get a piece, he said." 

"And you were there? Why for God's sake didn't you stop him? Tell him that you and I are lovers, 
have been for years." 

There was a long, worried pause. "It wouldn't have been right, talking about you like that. And 
Jeanie, I don't own you, you know." 

McAndrew, McAndrew. If I weren't so fond of you, I'd wring your scrupulous Puritan neck. 

"But you know what?" he went on, "I'm afraid that it's going to make for a more difficult working 
atmosphere during the experiments." 

It's a good thing it was dark, so I couldn't take a shot at his nose, too. 

* * * 

The first twenty-three days of the trip out had seemed pretty bad. I learned the next morning that the 
remaining five were going to be a lot worse-and then after that we had the period of McAndrew's 
experiments to look forward to, followed by a four-week return journey to the Institute. 

The pattern was established on the twenty-fourth day. Van Lyle was back on his feet early. The 
bruise from his broken nose had mysteriously spread, to give him two purple-black eyes. With a white, 
rigid plaster across the middle of his face, he resembled a vengeful owl as he staggered out of his bunk. 
He glared around him. 

"The inside of this capsule is dirty. It must be cleaned." 

"It's not bad," I said. "It's just the way you'd expect the ship to look after three weeks." 

"I'll be the judge of that." Lyle picked up a dish of soggy cereal, inverted it, and deliberately dropped 


it to the floor. "Get to work. This cabin first, then my quarters. I'll be back to inspect your progress this 
afternoon." 

I held myself in-just. When Stefan Parmikan appeared ten minutes later, I had all the cleaning 
equipment out of the ceiling racks and ready for use. 

He looked, not at me but past me. "What do you think you are doing?" 

"Getting ready to clean the cabin. Following Officer Lyle's instruction." 

"Very well. You can do that later. I need you to explain the procedure for ship automatic course 

tracking to me." 
Unbelievable. Could it be that Stefan Parmikan was at last taking an interest in the way that the 
Hoatzin worked? I rose to follow him, but he turned and pointed to the cleaning equipment. 
"Put those away first, back in the ceiling racks. I'm not going to spend the whole day falling over your 
stuff. And I'm not going to waste time arguing. You can get everything out again later." 
It didn't help to recognize that Parmikan was quoting my own words, about the luggage of his that I 
had refused to allow aboard. 
I began to put away the cleaning equipment, and thought favorably of Fletcher Christian. 
* * * 

No one on the Hoatzin seemed happy for the next five days. Parmikan and Lyle constantly tried to 
push me over the edge, and were constantly disappointed. They came close, but I certainly wasn't going 
to give them the pleasure of knowing how close. 

And McAndrew, who should have been as happy as a pig because the time of his experiments had 
arrived, had become intense and introverted. The Hoatzin had homed in close to his strongest 
anomalous signal, but it did not seem to have resolved his problem. 

"Look at this, Jeanie," he said, during one of my rare breaks from slavery. I had just checked that the 
ship had achieved its final location and velocity, and confirmed that we were at rest again relative to Sol. 
"These are real-time signals, happening right this minute. I've got instruments focused on a region only 
two light-seconds from here. You can see the visual display of it on the left half of the screen." 

I looked. Other than a triangle of three bright reference stars, the visible wavelength display was 
blank. 

"Nothing there," I said. 

"Quite right. And now, the input from the mass detectors. They're set up to scan the same field, and 
I've got them in imaging mode focused for two light-seconds away." McAndrew popped the mass 
detector result on the right, as a split-screen display. 

I stared. I expected to see nothing on the right side of the screen, either, and that's exactly what I 
saw. The region two light-seconds from us, where McAndrew's mass detection instruments were 
focused, was empty of matter-more empty, in fact, than any other known region. 

"Well," I began to say. And then something impossible happened. The left-hand screen at visible 
wavelengths continued to show nothing but distant reference stars; but the screen displaying the mass 
imaging system inputs showed an object floating steadily across it, from top to bottom. The blob was 
clean-edged and irregular in shape, its outline like a fat, curved and pimpled cigar. It took maybe ten 
seconds from the first appearance on the top of the screen to its leisurely disappearance from the lower 
boundary. It must be moving at just a few miles a second relative to the Hoatzin. 

"Mac, you've got the displays set up wrong. Those have to be showing different fields of view." 

"They're not, Jeanie. I've checked a dozen times. They're showing the same part of the sky." 

"Rerun it. Let me see it again." 

"I don't need to. Wait twenty seconds, and you'll see another one. About one a minute." 

We waited. At last a second shape, apparently identical to the first, came floating across the mass 
detector screen. And again the visible wavelength screen remained blank. 

"Ultra-violet," I said. "Or infrared, or microwave . . ." 

"I've checked them all. Nothing, from radiation or particle sensors. Only the signal from the mass 
detectors." 

"So they're black holes. Kernels. They have to be." 


"That's exactly what I thought, when we were a ways off and the signal was just a fuzzy blob with no 
structure. But just you look at the shape of that"-a third shape like a thick, warty banana was crossing 
the screen-"when you know as well as I do that any black hole has to have at least rotational symmetry. 
Those things have no axis of symmetry at all. And another thing. I did an active test. I sent a particle 
stream off to intercept one of those objects. If it were a black hole, you'd get a return radiation signal as 
the particles were gravitationally caught. But I got nothing. The particles went right on through as though 
there wasn't anything there at all." 

I had a strange, prickly feeling up the back of my neck. We were observing nothing, a vacuum 
specter, a lost memory of matter. By a knight of ghosts and shadows, I summoned am to tourney, 
ten leagues beyond the wide world's end . . . Except that in our case, ten leagues had grown to half a 
light-year. 

"Mac, they're impossible. They can't exist." 

"They do, though." McAndrew's eyes were gleaming. I realized that I had mistaken his emotion. It 
wasn't frustration. It was immense, pent-up excitement and secret delight. "And now I've seen them in 
more detail, I know what they are." 

"What, then?" 

"I'll tell you-but not until we get a chance for a real close-up look. Come on, Jeanie." 

He headed straight for Parmikan's private quarters, banged on the wall, and pulled the curtain to one 
side without waiting for an invitation. Parmikan and Lyle were both inside, heads close together. They 
had kept to themselves completely since the previous day, after an unusually long message to or from 
Earth. They jerked apart as McAndrew barged through. 

"We want to move the Hoatzin a bit," he said without preamble. "And I have to go outside. I'd like 
Captain Roker to go with me." 

If he was asking permission, calling me "Captain Roker" to Stefan Parmikan was the worst way to go 
about getting it. I expected an instant refusal. Instead a rapid glance passed between the two men, then 
Parmikan turned to McAndrew. 

"What do you mean, move the ship?" 

"Just a smidgeon, a couple of light-seconds. There's something I need to look at as part of my 
experiments. As soon as we're in the right position I need to take a couple of mass detectors outside 
with me and examine a structure. It will take a few hours, that's all. But it's a two-person job, and I'll 
need help." 

I certainly didn't expect that Lyle or Parmikan would volunteer for the job of helper, but equally I 
didn't expect that they'd agree to my doing it-if I were outside, how could they give me disgusting 
chores? But Parmikan nodded his head at once. 

"Right," said McAndrew. His diffident manner had vanished. "Jeanie, while I get the equipment ready 
I want you to take the Hoatzin to encounter one of the anomalies. Put us smack in the middle, and set 
us to hold at zero relative velocity." 

I didn't argue. But as he went off to the rear of the living-capsule, I did exactly half of what he had 
requested. A small, watchful region of my brain was awakening, from a slumber it must have been in 
ever since I decided to reply to McAndrew's letter by flying straight to the Institute. Now I closed in on 
one of the objects and set us to zero relative velocity-but I kept our ship a couple of kilometers clear 
rather than providing McAndrew's requested encounter. He might know exactly what he was dealing 
with, and be sure that it was safe. Until I had that knowledge, too, I was going to regard any region of 
empty space occupied by a mystery as possibly dangerous. 

As I was completing my task I noticed a minor oddity in the operations of the Hoatzin's computer. 
The program was functioning flawlessly, but as I directed each change in position or speed, a status light 
indicated that an extra data storage was being performed. The response time was a fraction of a second 
longer than usual. 

I'd probably have caught it when at Parmikan's insistence we switched the drive on and off every 
day, but Mac had programmed all those changes as a favor to me. And if McAndrew had been ready to 
go outside at once, I might have ignored it now. Instead, I took a look to see where the generated data 


were being stored. 

I found a Dummy's Delight. 

The data I was creating were being placed in a trajectory control program of a type much despised 
by professionals. It was the sort of thing that anyone could use and no one ever did, because it was 
guaranteed to be inefficient. In a Dummy's Delight, for every move made by the ship the inverse move 
was generated and stored. If the program were then executed, the ship would return to its point of origin 
along whatever convoluted trajectory it may have taken to fly out. 

The program's only advantage was simplicity. One push of a button, and all need for piloting went 
away. 

But there was no way that we would fly back along our original trajectory-there were much more 
efficient thrust patterns. And I certainly hadn't given the command to place the required data into the 
Dummy's Delight before the Hoatzin left the Penrose Institute. 

Had Mac done it? And if so, why? 

My wariness node had started to work overtime. On impulse I wiped from memory the whole 
Dummy's Delight sequence, and left a message on the control screen: AUTOMATIC RETURN 
PROGRAM TO TERRA HAS BEEN ERASED BY CAPTAIN ROKER. It seemed reasonable when 
I did it, but I started to have second thoughts as I hurried to join McAndrew. He had his mass detector 
survey instruments working as free-standing units and was already in his suit. 

"Mac." I waited until I had my own suit on, and was absolutely sure that we could not be overheard 
by Van Lyle or Stefan Parmikan. "Did you set up a Dummy's Delight in the Hoatzin's computer?" 

He was busy, guiding the bulky detectors into the lock. "Now why would I do a daft thing like that?" 
he said, and vanished into the lock himself. 

Why would he do a thing like that? I asked myself. Why would anyone do it?-unless they suspected 
that no competent pilot, like me or McAndrew, would be around to fly the Hoatzin on its return journey 
to Sol. 

Paranoid? You bet. It's the only way to fly. 

* * * 

I emerged from the lock into that great forever silence that fills all the space between the stars. Sol 
was dwindled, indistinguishable from dozens of others. I picked it out from its position, not its superior 
brightness. The region I floated in appeared totally empty and featureless, despite the suit's vision 
enhancement systems. Particles were fewer here, the vacuum a little harder. But the human observer 
would never know the difference. 

I glanced back at Sol. Look at the situation any way you liked; if I blew it and something went 
wrong, it was a long walk home. 

I propelled myself gently away from the ship and towards McAndrew. He was staring at his mass 
detector readings in great irritation. 

"Jeanie, you've made a mistake. We're kilometers away from the source." 

"We certainly are. Two kilometers, to be exact. I know you can see right through it and it looks like 
nothing's there, but I want to approach this particular nothing very carefully." 

He gave the patient sigh of a long-suffering martyr. "Ah, Jeanie. There's no danger here, the way 
you're thinking. I know just what this is." 

"Maybe. But you haven't told me." 

"I will, though, right now. It's shadow matter." And then, seeing my stare, "I'm surprised you've not 
heard of it." 

"I know, Mac. I'm a constant disappointment to you. But I haven't. So tell me." 

"It's wonderful. Right out of supersymmetry theory. Soon after the Big Bang-about 10-43 seconds 
after it, actually, before anything else we know about happened-gravity decoupled from everything else. 
Sort of like the way that radiation decoupled from matter, but the gravity decoupling happened much 
earlier. So then you had a symmetry breaking, a sort of splitting, and two types of matter were created: 
ordinary matter and shadow matter. Just like matter and anti-matter-except that matter and shadow 
matter can't interact by strong nuclear forces, or radiation, or the weak nuclear force. They can only 


interact by gravitational influence. You'd never detect shadow matter by firing particles at it. We proved 
that for ourselves. The particles feel the gravitational force, but that's tens of orders of magnitude too 
weak to do anything noticeable." 

I stared at nothing, in the direction that the mass detectors were pointing. "You're saying that 
whatever is out there is as real as we are-but we can't see it?" 

"Can't see it, never will be able to see it. Seeing depends on interaction with radiation. The only way 
to learn what we've found is through these." He pointed at the mass detectors. "We're safe enough, as I 
said. But we have to do some detailed mapping. Who knows what that is out there? It could be a 
shadow matter star-we don't have any idea how big a star might be in that universe, or what the laws of 
force are. Or maybe we're detecting a set of interstellar shadow matter spaceships, or a column of 
shadow matter ants marching in a shadow matter superworld. 

"You think I'm joking, but I'm not. It could be anything. The only way we'll get any idea what we've 
found is by plotting structure. That's why I need you-it's a two-person job, to make transects." 

We're safe enough, he had said. But maybe only while we were outside the Hoatzin. 

"Mac, before we start your work we've got to talk. I think we have a bad problem." I told him about 
the Dummy's Delight on the ship's computer. 

He frowned through his suit visor. "But why would they waste data storage on a thing like that?" 

"So they could get home, even if something happened to both of us." I took the last mental step, the 
one I had been resisting. "Mac, we're not intended to return from this trip. The plan is for us to vanish 
while we're out here. If the drive of the ship were turned on now, who'd ever know what had happened 
to us?" 

He turned to stare at the Hoatzin. "They wouldn't dare." 

"Not now they wouldn't. I wiped the program they were relying on to fly them back. So they need 
us." Or one of us. But I didn't say that. "We're safe enough for the moment." 

"But what about when we go back inside? We can't stay out here forever." 

"I don't have an answer for you. We've got enough air for six or seven hours. We have to think of 
something-soon." 

* * * 

We had to think of something. But we didn't succeed. My mind stayed blank. McAndrew is a 
superbrain, but not when it comes to this sort of problem. After half an hour floating free not far from the 
ship, he shook his head. 

"It's got me beat. But this is silly. There's no point in sitting here doing nothing. We might as well get 
on with the measurements." 

He placed one mass detector in my care, with its inertial position sensor tuned to the Hoatzin as 
reference, and started to steer me under his direction from one fixed place to another, while he moved 
himself in constant relative motion. He apparently knew exactly what he wanted. That was just as well. 
My own thoughts were all on the situation aboard the ship. What would we do when our air ran low? 

I worried that problem with no result while McAndrew made four straight-line passages, right through 
the middle of the kilometer-wide region that he described as shadow matter. The mass detectors 
confirmed that something was there. I saw absolutely nothing. 

On the fifth passage through, McAndrew paused halfway. He called to me to move closer, while he 
carried his own detector through a complicated spiral in space. At the end of it he left his mass detector 
where it was, flew across to me, and examined the recording on my instrument. 

"Well, I'm damned," he said. "Jeanie, I think you were right. Stay there." And leaving me mystified 
and feeling about as intelligent as a marker post, he flew away. This time he moved his mass detector 
through an even more complex path in space, pausing often and proceeding very cautiously. 

"I've still no idea what this is, overall," he said when he came back. "But I'll tell you one thing for sure. 
There are structures in shadow space that I've never met in our spacetime." 

"Right about what?" I asked. "You just said I was right. But what was I right about?" 

"That we ought not to set the ship in the middle of that, without knowing more about it. I'm seeing 
evidence of gravitational line singularities, or something very like them, running across the shadow matter 


region. You don't find those in our universe. If we had flown in too close to one of them, we might have 

found ourselves in trouble." 

"You mean we're not in trouble now? With Lyle and Parmikan waiting for us." 

"I've been thinking about that, too." He came close, and his face was earnest and unshaven within his 
visor. "I think you're overreacting. There's no evidence at all that Lyle and Parmikan even knew there 
was a Dummy's Delight set up in the Hoatzin's computer. And certainly there's no evidence they mean 
us any harm. But anyway," he went on, before I could interrupt, "one thing's for sure: When we go back 
in the lock, I should enter first while you stay outside. I know both of them, they respect me, and they'll 
not do anything to hurt me." 

McAndrew is a pathetically bad liar. I didn't argue with him. But when we were a few meters from 
the lock I said, "You've got it backwards. I'm the one they won't hurt, because they need a pilot to get 
home. And you don't know how to work our only weapon. Don't stand too near the hatch of the lock." 

I dived for the airlock, pulled myself inside, and swung it closed in one movement, leaving Mac to 
bang on the outside. While the lock was filling with air I did a little work of my own. It required that 
three separate safety procedures be overridden, so it took a few minutes. At last I moved forward to 
open the inner lock door, then jumped back at once to stand by the outer one. 

I didn't know what I was expecting. Lyle and Parmikan, going about the normal business of the ship, 
with a stack of messy chores ready for me? Or waiting to complain that I had for no reason at all wiped 
out a program that one of them had set up in the computer, for a wholly innocent purpose? 

What I hadn't expected was a projectile weapon, held in Van Lyle's hand and pointed right at my 
belly-button. I rammed my left fist down on the lock control, as the thought flashed through my head that 
there should have been a more thorough luggage inspection when we boarded the Hoatzin. 

I moved as fast as I could, but they had been ready and waiting. I was too slow. Lyle pressed the 
trigger. 

As he did so two things happened. Parmikan smacked at Lyle's hand and screamed, "Don't kill her! 
We need her to get us back." That saved me, spoiling Lyle's aim. In the same moment the outer lock 
door, its final safety trigger broken by the force of my fist, blew outward in a rush of air. 

I flew out with it, knowing that my last-ditch plan to fight back had failed. I was hit. And my secret 
weapon was useless, because Lyle and Parmikan were already wearing suits. 

I felt the fainting weakness that comes with a sudden drop of blood pressure. Then my suit resealed, 
and a few seconds later McAndrew was grabbing at me to halt my spin. He had followed me as I 
emerged in that crystal cloud of cooling air. 

I felt pain for the first time, and looked down. Half the calf of my left leg was missing. The automatic 
tourniquet had cut in and tightened below the knee. The flow of blood from the wound had already 
stopped. I would live-if we somehow survived the next few minutes. 

Which didn't seem likely. Lyle and Parmikan had emerged from the lock, and Lyle still had his gun. 
He raised it. And shot me again. 

Or he would have done, had he been the least bit familiar with freefall kinematics and momentum 
conservation. Instead the recoil of his gun sent him rolling into a backward somersault, while the bolt 
itself flew who knows where. 

Before Lyle could sort himself out and fire again, McAndrew was dragging me away, using his suit 
propulsion system at maximum setting to carry both of us along. One nice thing about Mac, he didn't 
need much data to form a conclusion. 

"Don't try a long shot." That was Parmikan to Lyle, over the suit radio. "She's injured. Get in close. 
Then we finish him and grab her. But don't kill her-she's taking us home." 

"I won't kill her." That was Lyle, the white plaster on his nose vivid through the suit's visor. "Not 'til 
I'm done with the bitch. She'll wish she was dead before that." 

They were coming after us, knowing that we had no place to hide. It was our misfortune to find 
ourselves, weaponless and pursued, in the emptiest quarter of known space. Nowhere to run to, and 
soon we would be out of air. 

McAndrew was retreating anyway, dragging me along with him, but not in a simple, straight-line run. 


We were zigzagging up and across and sideways, rolling all over the sky; which made good sense if you 
were trying to evade being shot, and no sense at all when your enemy had just declared that he would 
not shoot until he got close. 

Then we stopped dead. Mac glanced all around him, sighting for Parmikan and Lyle, the two mass 
detectors just where we had left them, and the shape of the Hoatzin, further off. He lifted us a few 
meters upward, and halted again. 

"Here we are, then," he muttered. "And here we stay." 

Lyle and Parmikan hadn't moved while Mac and I had been corkscrewing our way around in space. 
Now they started towards us. Soon I could see their faces, white in the reflected glow of the visors' 
built-in instruments. 

Still McAndrew didn't move. The feeling of distance and unreality that had swamped me the moment 
I was shot started to fade. At last I was scared. But when I started my propulsion system, ready to take 
off again away from the advancing men, Mac held out his hand to stop me. 

"No, Jeanie. Hold by, and don't move." 

They were closing on us. Parmikan was two or three meters in the lead. Lyle still held the gun, but he 
had learned his lesson. He would not fire again until he was at point-blank range, too close to be thrown 
off in his aim by the effects of free-fall rotation. 

"Mac!" We couldn't stand still and be slaughtered like sheep. I swung to argue with him, and saw the 
expression on his face. He was agonized and biting his lower lip. "Mac, come on. We can't just give in." 

But he was shaking his head at me. "I'm sorry, Jeanie," he said. "This isn't me. I can't go through with 
it. No matter what happens next, I have to give them a chance." And he lifted his arm towards Lyle and 
Parmikan. "Don't come any closer. Stay right there. You are in terrible danger." 

That stopped them-for a second or two. They stared all around, and saw nothing. Lyle snorted 
through his broken nose, while Parmikan laughed aloud for the first time since I had met him. 

"Don't try that on us, McAndrew," he said. "We weren't born yesterday. If you stand still, I promise 
you'll get yours clean and quick." 

He was moving forward again. My suit's vision enhancement showed the grin on his shapeless mouth. 
He looked as happy as I had ever seen him. And then the clean white of his suit was broken by a thin 
black line that ran across Stefan Parmikan from hip to hip, about two inches below his navel. 

He stared down at himself as the line widened. He started to scream, and tried to back up. 

It was too late. His motion carried him forward. As it did so he shrank, shortening and squeezing in 
towards his hips. The thin black line became a rolling tunnel of red and purple across his whole body. 
Twisted internal organs were moving into it from above and below. Then Parmikan had passed all the 
way through. 

The scream ended. A pair of legs, still held together at the top, came floating on towards us. Separate 
from it moved a torso, cleanly severed. Blood gouted out and froze as a fine icy spray. 

Lyle, a few meters behind, had enough time to stop. He paused, still holding the gun. 

"Hand that over." I summoned what little energy I had and spoke over the suit radio before 
McAndrew had time to react. And then, when Lyle hesitated, I said, "Hand it over right now. Or get 
just the same as he did." 

He hardly seemed to be listening. His eyes were following the horror of Parmikan's severed body. 
But he nodded and released the gun, which floated gently away from him. 

It's a measure of how far gone I was that I actually started out towards it, until McAndrew grabbed 
me. 

"You stay where you are, too," he said. "And Lyle, don't move a millimeter until we come around and 
get you. There's other gravitational line singularities through this whole volume." 

We began to move again, McAndrew hauling me along like ballast in a strange helical path that 
wound its way towards Van Lyle. Finally McAndrew was able to reach out and snag the gun. 

"All right." He waved it at Lyle, then towards the Hoatzin. "We've got a clear run from here to the 
ship. You start that way. And remember that I understand freefall ballistics a lot better than you do. I 
won't miss." 


The three of us drifted slowly back to the lock, but McAndrew would not let Van Lyle enter. He 
handed me the gun. "You first, Jeanie. Can you fix the lock so it works?" 

"I think so." I moved inside. "I just have to reset the safety interlocks." 

I made it sound trivial, and it should have been. But I kept half blacking-out before I was done and 
able at last to refill the interior of the Hoatzin with air. 

It seemed forever before the lock cycled again. I wondered and stayed tense. I had the gun. Suppose 
Lyle had taken advantage of that and overpowered McAndrew? 

I dropped those worries when Lyle emerged from the inner lock. His manner and bearing were of a 
crushed man with no fight left in him. I made him take his suit off, but I kept my own on until McAndrew 
finally came through the lock. 

He didn't give Lyle a look. He came straight across to me and examined my injured leg. 

"I'm sorry, Jeanie," he said, as he helped me ease out of my suit. "I know I put us in danger, warning 
them the way I did. If Parmikan had stopped in time we might have been killed. But I couldn't let them 
go on moving into that line singularity, without giving them at least a chance to stop. I just couldn't do 
that. You'd have done the same thing, wouldn't you?" 

"Of course I would." 

Like hell. If it had been up to me, Lyle would be floating around in two halves, the same as Stefan 
Parmikan. But then, compared with McAndrew I'm a barbaric, vengeful throwback. "Don't worry about 
it, Mac. What you did was the right thing." 

I winced, as the suit came free from my calf and caught on crusted blood. "So whose idea was it, 
Van Lyle?" I said. "Who decided that on this expedition, McAndrew and I wouldn't be going back?" 

He had been sitting slumped over, staring at the floor. He looked up, opened his mouth to speak, 
then changed his mind. He shook his head. 

I didn't blame him. When we arrived home he would be charged and surely convicted; but nothing 
the system authorities could do to him was half as bad as Anna Lisa Griss's vengeance if he betrayed her. 

McAndrew had gone across to the capsule's medical center and was returning with two spray 
syringes. "I'm going to put you under, Jeanie, while I dress your leg," he said. "You'll have to wait until 
we're home for a full repair. But first, to be safe . . ." 

He went to Van Lyle and pressed the loaded syringe against the back of the stooped man's neck. 
Lyle tried to stand up, with a startled expression on his face. It was already too late. 

"Better if we keep him under all the way back," Mac said, as after a few struggling seconds Lyle slid 
forward and fell face-down on the floor. "That way we don't have to worry." 

I wasn't worrying. I was going to be next, and physically I was ready for it. My calf was beginning to 
throb mercilessly. Still I held up my hand in protest. "Mac, wait a minute. We shouldn't head back until 
you've finished your experiments. And you've hardly started." 

He moved behind me. "Don't be daft, Jeanie. I can come here anytime. And I surely will. There's big 
questions to be answered. I need to map the structure of those shadow matter objects in more detail. 
And now we've got another candidate for the hidden matter. How much is cold dark matter, how much 
hot dark matter, how much shadow matter?" 

The cool nozzle of the syringe touched the back of my neck, and the spray diffused through my skin. 
I felt the effect at once as a pleasant, relaxing warmth that spread through my whole body. 

"Mac," I said, as the capsule of the Hoatzin began to blur around me. "You saved us, but I don't 
know how you did it. How did you know where to go, to put that gravity singularity right between us 
and those two?" 

"Easy enough," he said. "I had the measurements from the mass detectors. That made it a standard 
problem of inverse potential theory: Given the field, where are the masses needed to generate it? I 
already felt sure that there were line singularities of shadow matter, ones that would 
work-gravitationally-on anything in our universe that encountered them. But just where were they? I 
worked that out while you were inside the lock, playing your fun and games with Lyle and Parmikan. Of 
course, I had to make simplifying assumptions and hope they wouldn't affect the answer. And it would 
have been really nice to have a computer. But there was no time for that. I did what I could." 


I did what I could. What he had done, in the few minutes before I was blown out of the lock in a 
gust of freezing air, was to solve, mentally, a problem that would have taken me half a day to set up, and 
a computer to solve. And he had done it while knowing that the next half hour might end his own life. 

Cold Dark Matter, Hot Dark Matter, Shadow Matter. The words spun through my mind as the 
world darkened, and McAndrew's earnest face faded before my eyes. Cold Dark Matter, Hot Dark 
Matter, Shadow Matter. 

Which one had dominated our past, to create the present structure of the Universe? 

I had no idea. All I knew for sure as I slid into unconsciousness was that the future of our Universe 
was going to be dominated by cool grey matter; the sort that McAndrew and a few rare others like him 
have between their ears. 


SIXTH CHRONICLE: The Invariants of 
Nature 


"I must say it was a surprise to me that you came here at all," Van Lyle said pleasantly. "You really 
have to hand it to the Director. Anna Griss predicted all of this, you know-the effect of the 
announcement, McAndrew's arrival, and then yours. Very perceptive of her. But, then, isn't that exactly 
why she has the job of Administrator, and we do not?" 

He was standing in front of a huge pair of metal doors, checking a set of dials built into the frame. On 
the other side of them lay the processing vats, where all organic tissues-muscles, bones, nails, skin and 
hair-were dissolved to basic biotic molecules. Warning signals were splashed all over the chamber, and 
on both the doors: CONTROLLED ACCESS-DANGER, CORROSIVE GASES AND 
LIQUIDS-DO NOT PROCEED WITHOUT PROTECTIVE SUITS-OFFICIAL DEPARTMENT 
REPRESENTATIVES ONLY PERMITTED BEYOND THIS POINT. 

Van Lyle turned to me questioningly. "Impressive, wouldn't you say? Don't be coy, Captain. I'd really 
like to hear your opinions on all this." 

I rolled my eyes at him. I was sitting upright in a metal wheelchair. My wrists and elbows were bound 
to the chair arms with broad fiber tape, the sort that is hard to unstick and just about impossible to 
break. My lower legs were lashed to the chair's metal struts with the same material. A broad sticky strip 
of it covered my face, from just below my nose to the point of my chin. 

"Ah, I see the problem," Lyle went on. "But are you ready to talk nicely now, and not make a fuss?" 

I nodded-one of the few degrees of freedom available to me. 

Van Lyle nodded back. "Very good! And just in case you feel tempted to change your mind, let me 
point out that it would be quite pointless. This part of the installation is all automated. No one is here but 
the two of us." 

He came across to me and touched one end of the tape that covered my mouth. But instead of pulling 
it loose, he paused to run his fingers along one side of my nose, and back down the other. 

"What a nice, shapely adornment," he said. "Not at all like mine, eh? Before we finish, we'll have to 
do something about that." 

I hadn't realized until that moment just how much he hated me. His nose was bent and slightly 
flattened, detracting from his rugged blond good looks. The mouth beneath the crooked nose twisted 
with anger as he ripped the tape away from my mouth. 

I worked my lips against each other, wincing. A layer of skin had been torn away by the 
super-adhesive tape, along with every fine hair on my face. I felt a trickle of blood down my chin. 

The less discussion of noses, though, the better. I had broken Van Lyle's, half a light-year away from 
Sol, when he wouldn't take his lecherous hands off me. That had been long ago, but unfortunately he 
didn't seem willing to forget it. 

"You know McAndrew," I said. "All it took was the right word, and he was ready to head for Earth. 
Nothing that I said could stop him from coming." 

"So I understand." Lyle nodded. "But you, Jeanie-surely you're much more sophisticated than that? I 
would have bet money against you following him down here." 

Van Lyle's calling me Jeanie made my flesh crawl, but he was right. I didn't have the excuse that Mac 
had, the siren song, the magic words that had left him helpless: a new invariant of nature. 

"You don't understand," I said. "I've spent half my life chasing after Mac when he got into trouble. By 
now it's second nature. But usually it's to some place halfway to the stars-not a trip down to Earth." 

I had no real interest in telling any of this to Van Lyle, true as it might be. I was merely stalling, 
postponing the moment when he would tape my mouth again and carry out the next stage of the 
proceedings. I had little doubt what that was going to be. Lyle hadn't hauled me down to this processing 
plant, far offshore and a hundred meters beneath the surface of the sea, just to show off the advanced 
technology of Earth's Food Department. 


It was also a very bad sign that he had mentioned the name of Anna Griss. In the past he had always 
refused to admit that he worked for her. 

I wondered what he was waiting for now. It shows how desperate I was feeling, but I actually hoped 
he might be planning another shot at raping me. Let him do anything-anything that might provide enough 
time for help to arrive, or give me a thin chance of resistance. That was better than being strapped in the 
wheelchair, able only to move my head and trunk from side to side. 

I didn't have much hope. This wasn't my environment, it was theirs. I might have an edge in deep 
space, but down on Earth, Van Lyle and Anna Griss held home field advantage. 

And suddenly I had no hope at all. Because I heard the steel doors at the back of the chamber open, 
the ones through which I had been wheeled in. There was the squeak of unoiled bearings, and a few 
seconds later another wheelchair was rolled alongside mine. 

McAndrew sat in it, his legs and arms tied to the chair's metal struts, not by sticky tape but by thick, 
knotted cords. His mouth was not covered. 
He stared across at me miserably. "I'm sorry, Jeanie," he said. "I really am. This is all my fault, every 
bit of it." 
I tried to smile at him, and winced at raw, stripped skin. My lips began to bleed again. "Don't feel 
bad, Mac," I mumbled. "If it's your fault, it's my responsibility." 
* * * 

It had started at the Penrose Institute, over a month ago. I had been on the way home after a routine 
Europan delivery run. Orbital geometries happened to be favorable, so it was the most natural thing in 
the world for me to drop in on McAndrew. The Institute, after a disastrous couple of years of 
bureaucratic rule, was once more under the steady but informal guiding hand of old Dr. Limperis, 
dragged out of retirement to put things right. I wanted to see how everything was going, and renew old 
acquaintances. 

I headed straight for Mac's working quarters. He was not there. Instead, Emma Gowers was loafing 
in his favorite chair and staring at a display. 

"Off in the communications center," she said. "He'll be back in a few minutes. You might as well wait 
here." She was as blond, beautiful and blowzy as ever. And presumably as brilliant. She was the 
Institute's resident expert on multiple kernel arrays. 

"Is he all right?" I asked. Mac usually had to be dragged out of his own office, unless he was off 
somewhere running an experiment. 

"Oh, he's fine." Emma pushed her mass of blond hair higher on her head. "But you know McAndrew. 
He's got another pet project going. You can hardly talk to him any more." 

I nodded. It was the most natural thing in the world to find McAndrew in the grip of a new scientific 
obsession. He would be delighted to see me, I knew that. But he might also be only vaguely aware of 
my presence. 

I sat down next to Emma. "What is it this time?" 

"There's talk of a new fundamental invariant. I'm skeptical, frankly, but he's a believer-at least enough 
to want to check it out for himself." 

"Educate me, Emma. What do you mean, a fundamental invariant?" 

Simple explanations were not Dr. Gowers' forte. She frowned at me. "Oh, you know. Things that 
don't change under transformation. Like the determinant of a linear system under orthogonal rotation, or 
the Newtonian equations of motion with a Galilean transformation, or Maxwell's equations with a 
Lorentz transformation." 

It's an odd thing about Emma Gowers. Her own taste in men is for primitive specimens, dim and hairy 
objects who apparently decided to stop evolving somewhere in the early Pleistocene. Yet she insisted on 
assuming that McAndrew and I were on the same intellectual plane, just because we were long-time 
intimates. 

"Uh?" I wanted to say; but I was saved from new admissions of stupidity and ignorance by 
McAndrew's own bustling arrival. 

"Using my chair and my data banks again, Emma," he said. "Out, out, out." And then to me, as 


though we had not been separated for months, "Jeanie, this is perfect timing." 

Most people think that I tolerate behavior in McAndrew that I would never stand in any other human 
being, just because he's a genius. He is that, the best combination of theorist and experimenter to arise in 
physics since Isaac Newton-at least, that's what those few equipped to make the evaluation all tell me. 
But genius has nothing to do with my own tolerance of Mac, or his of me. 

I can't do better than to say that we click. We are very different, but we touch at just enough points 
to make us stick. 

McAndrew puts it differently. "A hydrogen bond," he has said to me, often enough to make it 
irritating. "Not an ionic bond, that's all set and rigid, or even a covalent bond, where things are actually 
shared. No. We're a hydrogen bond, loose and fluid and easy-going." 

I'll just say that we like each other. And if he thinks I'm so dim that everything he says to me about 
science has to be deliberately "dumbed down," and if I think he is so wrapped up in abstractions that he 
ought not to be allowed outside in the real world without a keeper-well, that's acceptable to both of us. 

This time he responded to my hug, but in an automatic and absent-minded way. "If you're heading 
inward," he went on, "as I suspect you are, then I'll hitch a ride with you." 

The space structure that houses the Penrose Institute is mobile, and at the time of my visit it was again 
drifting free, well outside the orbit of Mars. But inward? Mac's interests usually lay well beyond the 
edge of the Solar System. 

"To Earth," he explained. And, as my eyebrows rose, "Och, don't worry, I'm not asking you to come 
with me. Drop me off at a libration point, Jeanie. That will do fine." 

He knew my aversion to Earth, overcrowded and noisy and smelly. But I had always thought that he 
shared it, and he and I had other good reasons to avoid going there. One of Earth's most powerful 
people was Anna Griss, former head of Earth's Food Department, and now Administrator of the full 
Food and Energy Council. Mac had cut off her arm with a power laser, out in the Oort cloud. It had 
been done with the best of intentions, and it had saved her life; but I knew Anna. She would not have 
forgotten, or forgiven. 

As for me, I had been a target for her hatred since the same trip, perhaps even more so, because I 
had challenged her authority-and proved her wrong. 

It's no surprise that there are people like Anna Griss in the world. There always have been. Go back 
fifty thousand years, to a time when most of us were just grubbing along, looking for a decent bush of 
ripe berries or a fresher lump of meat. A few, like McAndrew, were busy inventing language or 
numbers, or painting the walls of the cave. And some, just a handful but too many in every generation, 
were seeking an edge over the rest of us: Water access, or mating rules, or restricted entry to heaven. 
No matter how few they were, Anna Griss would have been one of them. 

So McAndrew knew very well what I was driving at when I stared at him and said, "Earth? Do you 
think that's a good idea?" 

"It's a must," he said. "I'm going to visit the Energy Council. To be specific, I'm going to the 
laboratory of Ernesto Kugel, where there is evidence that something wonderful has been discovered: a 
new Invariant of Nature." 

You could hear the capital letters. 

"Told you so," said Emma Gowers. And she stood up, tugged her short dress down as close to her 
dimpled knees as it would go, and swept out. 

If McAndrew's words were designed to impress me, they failed. 

"Mac," I said. "With me, three invariants and a dollar will get you a cup of coffee." 

"You're a barbarian, Jeanie," he said amiably. "I'm just using the term that Kugel used: a new 
invariant of nature. Would it help if I rephrased that, and said that he claims to have found an 
important new conservation law?" 

It did help, because I have been around McAndrew for a long time. But it didn't help much. 

"New, how?" I asked. "I mean, I know that energy is conserved, and momentum is conserved-" 

"In a closed system." 

"In a closed system, fine. But how can there be a new conservation law?" 


"Well, that's where things get interesting. Now and again, physicists realize that certain things that they 
used to think of as independent are actually different aspects of the same thing. For example, a few 
hundred years ago, heat and motion and light used to be thought of as quite separate entities. But then, 
after lots of work by people like Rumford and Joule and Kelvin, scientists realized that those separate 
things were all forms of energy. And though different types of energy can be converted, one to another, 
they decided that the total could never be changed. That was the principle of conservation of energy. 

"Starting with the work of chemists like Lavoisier, people also observed that mass is conserved, too, 
in every form of physical and chemical reaction. So you had conservation of energy, and you had 
conservation of mass. But the big breakthrough came in 1905, when Einstein showed that mass and 
energy are equivalent, and that their total is the thing that is conserved, rather than either one. And he 
also showed that it didn't matter which reference frame you use for the measurements. The 
energy-momentum four-vector is invariant. That single principle helped to unify the whole field of physics. 

"The same thing happened with angular momentum. For a while it looked as though it wasn't 
conserved in nuclear reactions. But then workers in quantum theory found that an internal angular 
momentum had to be added to the picture for many particles-spin-and after that angular momentum 
became a fully conserved quantity. That, too, was a terrific generalizing idea. Did you know that in 1931 
Pauli deduced the existence of a new particle, the neutrino, just because the principles of conservation of 
energy and of angular momentum required that it exist?" 

"I did know that, Mac"-once-"and you haven't answered my question. I realize very well that there 
are conservation principles. But how can there possibly be a new one?" 

"I can give you two possible answers to that. The first is that the physical laws of the universe, as we 
already know them, admit some conserved quantity that we simply haven't recognized yet." 

"Isn't that unlikely?" 

"You might think so, after all the time and effort we've put into searching for that sort of invariance 
principle, for the past hundred and fifty years, with nothing to show for it. But there's another possible 
answer, one that at first doesn't sound much more likely. It could be that Ernesto Kugel's lab has 
discovered a new fundamental form of physical law." 

McAndrew was starting to make sense to me, which should have been a tipoff right there that 
something was about to go wrong. Usually, the longer that we talk, the more confused I become. 

"You mean, a new force? Something like discovering gravity for the first time?" 

"That will do nicely. We happen to have been aware of gravity for as long as humans existed, and 
we've had theories of it for over five hundred years. We've known the electromagnetic force for three 
centuries, and the strong and weak forces that govern nuclear interactions for just a couple. But gravity is 
actually a very weak force, something we only feel because very large bodies are involved. Suppose that 
we had evolved as tiny creatures, no bigger than fleas, in the middle of an energetic plasma? Then gravity 
wouldn't have much immediate effect on our lives. We'd have learned about electromagnetism early, but 
we might still not know about gravity." 

I was finally getting the head-swirling buzz that usually accompanied a McAndrew explanation. "But 
we didn't evolve smaller than fleas, in the middle of a plasma." 

"No. But different environments make it easy to detect different forces." 

"But less than a year ago you were telling me that the place to look for new laws of nature is out in 
deep space where we've never been, out where the sun and planets don't interfere with observations." 

"I did say that. But suppose I'm wrong. Wouldn't that be exciting, Jeanie? A new law of nature, 
sitting there under our noses all this time, and detectable down on the surface of Earth." 

And there you had it. Most people hate to learn that they are wrong. Not McAndrew. When he's 
proved wrong, he's ecstatic. It means he's learned something new, and that's his main reason for 
existence. 

But I still hated the idea that he'd be going to Earth. "This Ernesto Kugel. If he's in the Energy 
Department, that means he works for Anna Griss." 

"So?" 

"Do you know him?" 


"Not personally. But I know his work, very well. Ernesto Kugel built the Geotron." 

Capital letters again. I resisted the urge to be distracted by that. "Is he the sort of person you believe 
might make a fundamental new discovery?" 

"Oh, no." 

"Well . . ." 

"Not him. He's an engineer-and a first-rate one-but he's no physicist. Someone in his lab would have 
done the work. Someone I don't know. Kugel would probably put his own name on the report just to 
make people pay attention." 

"But surely you don't think that some total unknown would have come up with a big scientific 
breakthrough?" 

"Jeanie, the big breakthroughs always come from some total unknown. And genius can pop up 
anywhere. Kugel got lucky." 

"Maybe. But Kugel works for Anna Griss, and she hates your guts. Don't you remember what you 
did to her?" 

"Ah, away with you." He ran his fingers through his thinning hair. "Jeanie, I'm sure that's all long 
forgotten. The invitation to visit Kugel's lab was approved by Anna. She signed off on it." 

"Did she?" I said. "Well, of course that makes everything fine, doesn't it?" 

I should have known better. Irony is totally wasted on McAndrew. 

He beamed at me. "I knew you'd see it my way when you had the facts, Jeanie. How soon can we 

leave?" 
* * * 
I think my inner voices are pretty good when it comes to warning of trouble. The problem is, I don't 
always listen to them. 

This time I allowed another event to occupy my mind when I ought to have been worrying about 
McAndrew's visit to Earth. In my own defense, I must say that the intrusion came from outside. When 
the linked spheres of the Assembly were halfway to Earth, with Mac and me cozy in the Control 
Section, I received a message from Hermann Jaynsie at the United Space Federation Headquarters. 

It was long and wordy, because Hermann is long and wordy, but I can boil it down. It said, in 
essence, "What the devil did you do, Captain Roker, on your last cargo haul from the Jovian system to 
Earth? We thought we had a deal with them for four billion tons of vegetable foodstuffs, grown in our 
Europan ocean farms. Now Earth is telling us they don't want to take delivery of any more shipments." 

The lightspeed round-trip travel time to USF Headquarters was seven minutes, so I couldn't exactly 
chitchat back and forth. But I did send him a pretty long reply, which again can be boiled down to, 
"Damned if I know, Hermann. They seemed happy enough with what I dropped off last time." 

My livelihood wasn't hurt by the cancellation of a food supply contract with Earth; but my ego was, 
and I spent a good deal of time fuming. Was it Anna Griss, getting at me in a remarkably indirect way? I 
knew she was capable of subtle malice. But I still looked for a more logical explanation. I couldn't see 
even Anna risking Earth's food supply just to get at me. 

* * * 

I had no intention of going to Earth, or wasting another minute thinking of Ernesto Kugel and his 
mysterious invariant. So when we arrived at the Colony drop-off point, where the Assembly would be 
moored until its next trip out, McAndrew and I went our own ways. He headed down on a shuttle, as 
excited as a child on his way to a birthday party. I mothballed the ship, and handed it over to the local 
USF maintenance crew. 

That took me three days. And then on the fourth morning, without thinking about what I was doing, I 
found myself aboard a shuttle vessel. 

Heading for Earth. 

I had been given a number to reach McAndrew, and I forwarded a message to tell him that I was on 
the way, and when and where I would arrive. I didn't ask, but I rather hoped he might be waiting for me. 

He wasn't. And it was one of life's less pleasant experiences to pass through entry formalities, search 
for Mac's face, and see Van Lyle waiting for me on the other side of the barrier. 


"Captain Jeanie Roker." He reached out and took my hand. "It's been a while." 

I shook his hand, but my feelings must have showed on my face, because he laughed and said, "Don't 
say anything. You did what you did, and I thoroughly deserved it. Let bygones be bygones." 

But he touched his fingertips to his bent nose. 

I said, "McAndrew-" 

"Is having too much fun, Captain, to tear himself away from the Geotron facility. He asked me to 
come to the port, and take you there to join him." 

It sounded awfully plausible. But I couldn't put the past behind me as easily as he claimed to have 
done. "Professor McAndrew asked you to come and meet me?" 

Instead of answering, Lyle took a palm-sized phone from his pocket and tapped in a string of 
numbers. "Four one seven," he said into the unit. After a few seconds' pause he handed me the phone. 

I found myself staring into the tiny screen at a familiar high-cheekboned face. His wispy hair was 
sticking up in little random spikes, and his color was a fraction ruddier than usual. I couldn't see his 
fingers, but I could bet that he was cracking the joints. 

"Jeanie," he said, as soon as he saw me. "I didn't expect to hear from you until you arrived at the 
Geotron. What's wrong? Are you having problems getting underwater?" 

Underwater? But it was McAndrew, without a doubt. McAndrew live, healthy, unrestrained, and by 
the look of it having the time of his life. He actually did not sound too thrilled by the news of my arrival. 

"No problems," I said. "I touched down just a few minutes ago." 

"Right then. I'll have to go. We're very busy here." And his picture promptly vanished. The phone link 
disconnected. 

That was the genuine McAndrew, without a doubt, and he was clearly all right. The smart thing to 
have done at that point would have been to apologize to Van Lyle for my rudeness, plead prior job 
commitments off Earth, and turn right around and head back to space. Instead I handed the little phone 
back, sighed, and said, "Before I make a complete fool of myself, tell me one thing. What is a Geotron, 
and where is a Geotron?" 

Van Lyle stared at me. I think I had actually managed to surprise him. 

"You're asking me what a Geotron is?" 

"I am." 

"But didn't Professor McAndrew explain to you?" 

"He would have done-if I had given him half a chance." 

"Well . . . I'm not a scientist, as you know very well." 

"Nor am I. That ought to make things easier for both of us." We started walking toward a sleek 
high-speed aircar, as Van Lyle said, "Well, you know what neutrinos are, don't you?" 

"Yes. They're elementary particles, with no charge, and a tiny rest mass. Their discovery was 
predicted by Pauli in 1931, because they were needed to preserve the laws of conservation of energy 
and angular momentum." 

That was gross intellectual dishonesty, and I knew it. But Lyle didn't. He looked quite impressed. 

"Right," he said. "All they have are spin and energy. And they don't interact much with ordinary 
matter, uness they have very high energy. That makes them the devil to detect. A free neutrino can 
easily pass right through the Earth. But sometimes that can be an advantage. Like if you want to do 
down-deep exploration. And you decide to build a Geotron." 

He explained the rest of it as we took off and he flew us west at Mach Ten. The staff of Earth's Food 
and Energy Council had done all the easy exploration of Earth's interior that they could do-which meant 
prospecting to about twenty kilometers down. Now they were forced to search deeper, or else be 
dependent on off-planet resources. The Geotron was nothing more than a huge kind of X-ray machine, 
for examining the inner structure of the Earth. But instead of X-ray radiation, which would penetrate no 
more than a few feet, the machine generated tight beams of high-energy neutrinos. They could be sent in 
any direction. They passed right through the middle of the Earth, scattering off structures in the interior, 
and emerged at points around the world where their numbers were measured. Then a very fancy set of 
computer programs took the information on the detected neutrinos and used that to deduce the interior 


structures that they had encountered in their path from the Geotron to the detection chambers. 

"Looking for primordial methane, as the primary target," Lyle explained. "Pockets of compressed 
methane left over from the time of the Earth's formation, and still trapped deep inside." 

"To use as fuel?" 

"Lord, no. Methane's far too valuable an organic material to burn-even if the laws permitted it. We 
use it for complex hydrocarbon synthesis." 

"Have you been finding any?" 

"More than you would believe." 

It occurred to me that I had an explanation to offer Hermann Jaynsie for Earth's lack of interest in the 
food supply contracts. There would never be a shortage of nitrogen on Earth, with an atmosphere that 
was nearly eighty percent that gas. If they now had enough hydrocarbons, and enough energy, elemental 
food synthesis would be a snap. 

The most surprising thing was Van Lyle's willingness to tell all this to me, an outsider. Didn't Earth's 
Food and Energy Council care any more who knew what? Or were there missing pieces that were not 
being mentioned? 

"I understand the Geotron," I said. "But what was that about being underwater?" 

"Well, you don't think we'd put it on land, do you? Solid surface is too precious. We put it on the 
seabed." And then, when I looked puzzled. "Captain Roker, just how big do you think the Geotron is?" 

"I've no idea." 

"Then I'll tell you. The main ring is forty kilometers across." 

Forty kilometers. A long day's walk. Or in this case, a long day's swim. 

"So it was built on the Malvinas' continental shelf," he went on. "Where there's a lot of available 
seabed, and the water is only fifty to a hundred meters deep." 

"Malvinas?" 

"Off the east coast of Patagonia. We'll be there in half an hour. Then you can see it for yourself." 

In the next few minutes I learned that the Malvinas' coastal zone was now Earth's hottest 
development area, site not only of the Geotron but also of the world's most modern food facilities and 
genetic laboratories; all, naturally, off-shore, in the shallow seas that ran for hundreds of kilometers east 
of the mainland. 

And while Lyle talked, I struggled to remember where Patagonia was. Southern hemisphere? 
Definitely. South America? Probably. It occurred to me that although I could quote the size and 
approximate orbital parameters for every major body from Mercury to the edge of the Oort cloud, I did 
not know the geography of Earth. 

We were flying near the edge of the atmosphere. I stared up at the familiar black sky, with the 
brightest stars showing, then turned my eyes down to wisps of white cloud, with far below them the alien 
sea. 

I felt, as usual when I was on Earth, a long way from home. 

* * * 

Our descent to the Geotron did nothing to ease my feeling of alienation. I had not realized that our 
aircar was amphibious, until we were skimming a few feet above long, rolling waves. We touched down, 
planing across the surface in a cloud of spray. Lyle took his hands off the controls. 

And instead of bobbing on the rollers, we kept descending. After a few moments of panic, while the 
water level rose past the windows and plunged us into a green gloom, I realized that the aircraft was not 
only an amphibian, it was also a submersible. I could hear the thrum of engines aft, and see the yellow 
beams of light that lit the way ahead and behind us for many meters. 

"Lights for passenger viewing only," explained Lyle. "Just so you can enjoy the sights. I haven't been 
controlling the craft since we touched down on the waves. We'll be homed in to the Geotron facility 
automatically-sonic control, of course, not radio. Radio signals won't travel through water." 

"How far is it?" 

"Just a couple of kilometers. There was no point in landing too far away, but the final approach is 
interesting." 


We had been angling steadily downward. The natural sunlight was vanishing, breaking to cloudy 
patches of darkening green. Shoals of silver-green fish and what looked like endless thousands of purple 
squids darted through the beams of our headlights. Then they too were gone, and I had my first sight of 
Earth's sea-floor, a smooth grey-brown carpet of fine sediments that swirled up like an ominous mist 
behind us in the wake of our propulsion jets. 

That alien fog made me uneasy. I was much comforted when the huge silver wall of the outer Geotron 
ring appeared ahead, and we moved to an underwater docking. That felt quite familiar to me. An inward 
pressure of seawater replaced the space environment's outward pressure against vacuum, but the same 
sort of locks were needed. And once we were inside, we could have been in any controlled one-gravity 
environment between the Vulcan Nexus and the Hyperion Deep Vault. 

Van Lyle led the way through the set of connected chambers that formed the control nexus for the 
Geotron. Other maintenance areas were spaced all around the rim of the main rings, a couple of 
kilometers apart. After a final up-and-down ride over the top of the inner ring, we were finally spilled by 
a moving stairway into a big square room, partitioned off into dozens of small work cubicles. 

McAndrew sat in one of them with a man and a woman in their early twenties. His shoes and socks 
were off and he was staring at a listing that filled the whole of the cubicle wall. He looked well, was 
obviously unrestrained, and gave every impression of a man totally at home and thoroughly enjoying 
himself. 

"There he is," said Lyle. "I was wondering, why does he take his shoes and socks off when he's 
working?" 

"In case he needs to count to more than ten." But I didn't know the real answer, any more than Lyle 
did, and I had known Mac for a long time. At least he wasn't cracking his toe joints at the moment. 

We walked forward. Mac saw me first, and stood up. "Jeanie! This is Merle Thursoe and Tom 
O'Dell. We're setting up a really great experiment." 

He nodded to me, almost dismissively, and turned back to the display. Then something-maybe my 
snort of anger-must have told him that this wouldn't quite do for someone who had come so far to see 
him. 

"Tom, Merle," he said, "would you carry on without me for a few minutes?" And then, turning back to 
me and standing up, "Jeanie, I don't think you know Ernesto Kugel. Come on. You have to meet him." 

He walked me right through the complicated center of the room, to a cubicle no bigger or better 
furnished than any of the others. Sitting at a desk there, facing outward, was a serious little man wearing 
a formal black suit, white shirt, and dark blue neckerchief. A matching blue rose adorned his lapel. 

"Director Ernesto Kugel." McAndrew was at his most formal. "May I present Captain Jeanie Roker." 

Kugel stood, came around his desk, and bowed, giving me a splendid view of the top of a hairless 
scalp as smooth and white and round as an ostrich egg. His whole head was free of hair, except for the 
neatly trimmed black moustache on his upper lip. I decided that nature could never have created the 
effect. Ernesto Kugel had worked on it. 

I was all set to dislike the man, when he straightened up and took my hand. 

"I am delighted to meet you, Captain Roker," he said, in a deep, smooth voice. "Professor 
McAndrew told me that you are most competent. What he did not mention is that you are also elegant 
and beautiful." 

I stared at him. "Does that line work often?" 

He gazed back, unblinking and unashamed, his brown eyes as bright and lively as a bird's. "Not so 
often." He suddenly smiled, and it transformed his face. "But let us say, it works often enough." 

"And I suppose that joking about it works, too?" 

"Sometimes. Most times. And if it does not"-he shrugged-"what harm has been done? God made two 
sexes, Captain Jeanie-and luckily that was exactly the right number." 

I suddenly found it impossible to dislike him at all. We stood grinning at each other, until McAndrew 
said, "I want a word in private. Just the three of us." 

"Of course." Kugel nodded his head toward the cubicle. "But this is as private as we get. I believe it 
is bad if I hide myself away from where the real work is done. Bad for my staff-and worst of all for me." 


Kugel waved to us to sit down. His desk was as neat and organized as Mac's was usually messy. 

McAndrew didn't waste any time. "Ernesto, I could explain our discussions to Captain Roker-to 
Jeanie. But I would feel much more comfortable if you were to do that." 

"Of course." Kugel leaned toward me, and spoke in his low, confidential voice. "You should sleep 
with him, you know. You two should have children." 

I turned on McAndrew. "You brought me in here, just to hear a proposition on your behalf? You 
ought to be old enough to handle your own public relations." 

"That's not what I meant!" Mac waved at the other man. "Keep going, Ernesto." 

"Of course." Kugel was chuckling to himself. "What I mean, Captain Jeanie, is that the man standing 
before you, Arthur Morton McAndrew, is a great genius. His genes, and your genes, should be 
preserved and cherished. I knew his reputation long before he came here, but now I realize that he is 
one of the immortals." 

"But I'm not fit to carry Dr. Kugel's coat, when it comes to large-scale engineering," McAndrew 
added. Praise of his abilities makes him terribly uncomfortable. 

I sighed. It was obviously a mutual admiration society. Apparently I had travelled the distance from 
Moon to Earth, just to hear the two of them compliment each other. 

"But to be specific," Kugel said, after a long pause in which they sat nodding and smiling. "Before 
Professor McAndrew's arrival, I and my staff had operated the Geotron for three months. In all that 
time, we had observed an inexplicable loss of neutrinos. We know how many the machine produces. 
And we know how many we are finding, in each of our mobile detectors. From that it is a simple 
calculation to estimate the total number escaping over the whole of the Earth's surface. There were too 
few of them, less than we were creating-and not by a number within the reasonable bounds of statistical 
error. There were far too few. For a long time we thought that it must be a matter of phase changes, or 
instrument calibration. Finally we decided that could not be the case. 

"We had no explanation. Until two of my brightest young staff, Thursoe and O'Dell, became 
involved." 

"Jeanie met them both," McAndrew said. 

"Then you must know, Captain, that both of them are far brighter than I. They proposed a specific 
physical reason for the absence of neutrinos, arguing by analogy to the conserved vector current theory 
of Feynman and Gell-Mann. That would imply the existence of a new kind of weak force, and a new 
physical invariant. It was speculative, but I thought it looked very interesting. I mentioned the work and 
the theory in my weekly report of activities to the Food and Energy Council. I did not expect that it 
would receive external circulation-until the sudden arrival of Professor McAndrew's request to visit the 
Geotron facility, and review the evidence." 

He turned to Mac. "Now I think that you should continue." 

"Well . . ." McAndrew became uneasy. "I don't like to criticize other people's work, you know, and 
the O'Dell and Thursoe theory is highly ingenious; but it did occur to me that there could be a simpler 
explanation." 

"You knew it," Kugel said flatly. "Knew it before you ever left the Penrose Institute." 

"No. Everything depended on the experimental results." McAndrew turned back to me. "You see, 
Jeanie, the Geotron had been operating at a very precise and very high neutrino energy, a domain that to 
my knowledge had not been explored before in any detail. It seemed to me that the explanation for the 
loss of neutrinos could be something as simple as resonance capture. Certain materials, common in 
Earth's interior, may have a very high capture cross-section for neutrinos of the Geotron energy. And 
that could account for the observed difference between production and detection. It would also be a 
most important scientific discovery, because such a resonance is not predicted by current theories." 

"Mph," I said. It meant, Mac, I have now heard more than I wish to know about lost neutrinos. 

But McAndrew, as it turned out, was close to the end. "And there's a very simple way to tell if I'm 
right," he said. "In less than twelve hours we can do an experiment with a modulated Geotron energy, far 
from possible resonance, and get an instant neutrino count. That's what O'Dell, Thursoe, and I have 
been working on. And we are just about ready for final set up." 


As I said, I've known McAndrew for a long time; long enough to interpret what he had just told me: 
he was all ready to do a neat physics experiment, and for the next half day nothing in heaven or earth 
would budge him from the Geotron facility. 

That conviction was at once reinforced by Ernesto Kugel. 

"You are of course welcome to remain here during the experiment," he said to me placatingly. "On 
the other hand, one of the Administrator's own staff members suggests that you might find a visit to our 
new food production plant, a few kilometers away, much more intriguing. He would be happy to serve 
as your escort." 

"More than happy." And dead on cue, Van Lyle was standing at the entrance to the cubicle. "Ready 
when you are, Captain Roker." 

It was all fine-and all just a little bit too pat. 

"I need to go to the bathroom," I said, "before we leave." 

"Sure." 

Inside the stall I sat down on the toilet seat, put my head in my hands, and thought. 

I was uncomfortable. What was the source of my discomfort? Nothing that I could put a name on, 
except that maybe the leopard had changed his spots a little too completely. This Van Lyle was not the 
Van Lyle I had known. 

But what then were the dangers? Nothing that I could think of. 

I was being paranoid. I went back out. I gave McAndrew a farewell hug, while Ernesto Kugel 
looked on approvingly. But as I was doing it I whispered in Mac's ear, "I'm going to look at the food 
production center with Van Lyle. If I'm not back in twelve hours, you come after me." 

McAndrew is not good at this sort of thing. "What?" he said loudly. 

"You heard." I did not raise my voice. "See you soon-I hope." 

Earth is an amazing place. It's a spent force, a used-up relic, a crusted dinosaur that the rest of the 
System looks back on and shakes its head. 

But it doesn't know that-or at least it won't admit it. 

The Malvinas' food production facility was astonishing. On the seabed, powered by abundant fusion 
energy and with nothing but the raw elements as working material, the production center was making 
foodstuffs as good as any I'd tasted through the whole system. No wonder that Earth, with a ten 
thousand year supply of primordial methane promised by Ernesto Kugel, wanted to renege on supply 
contracts. It had little interest in what it saw as extortion from the Outer System. 

Earth looked like-dare I say it?-the planet of the future. 

Maybe it was that, the total unreality of the experience, that made me lower my guard. Lyle and I 
were walking through a chamber where vat after vat of synthesized milk and beef extract stood in 
ferment. 

"We'll visit the organic recycling center next," he said. "But first, smell this." We paused in front of an 
open container, much smaller than the others. "It is Roquefort cheese. Synthesized, but you'd never 
know it. Lean over, stick your head in, and take a good sniff. Then I'll give you a taste." 

I leaned over the tub. And I passed out cold, without ever knowing that I had gone. 

* * * 

When I came to I was in a wheelchair, bound but not yet gagged. Lyle was standing at my side. 

"Ah, there you are, Jeanie," he said in a cheerful voice. "Back with us at last. Are you ready for 
action?" 

My head reeled, and a cloying smell was still in my nostrils. How long had I been out? I didn't know, 
but it felt like an age. McAndrew might arrive at any moment. I had to think, and I had to survive until 
that happened. 

"I don't know what you're up to," I said, "but I know it won't work. They'll come after me." 

"Will they now?" Lyle cocked his head politely. "Don't take this wrong, Jeanie, but I think you are 
mistaken. Though I have to say that I am looking forward to the appearance of Professor McAndrew. 
The show wouldn't be the same without him. I also think it would be better for the time being if your 


mouth were taped, just in case." And a minute later, "I must say it was a surprise to me that you came 
here at all." 

That, I think, is just where we came in. And a couple of minutes later it was Mac's arrival in a second 
wheelchair, pushed by Anna Griss herself, that sent me to a final misery. 

"Mac," I whispered, after he had been rolled up alongside me. I was already full of an awful 
suspicion. "Where are the others?" 

"Others?" He frowned at me, high forehead wrinkling. "Others? I came by myself." 

McAndrew had done what I asked him to do-literally. He had come after me. Alone. 

Well, at least there were few illusions left. And when Anna Griss came forward to stand in front of us, 
there were none. She was, as ever, elegantly dressed, carefully made up, and totally self-confident. She 
stared at us for a few seconds without speaking. At me, I would suggest, with a total cold hatred; at 
McAndrew, as at a wayward child who despite the best of advice has gone terribly and incorrigibly 
wrong. 

"It took a while, didn't it?" she said. "How long has it been since the Oort cloud? But it finally worked 
out all right. I knew it would." 

"You won't get away with this, you know," I said. "People know where McAndrew is. They know 
where I am." 

"I'm sure they do," said Anna Griss. "But accidents happen, don't they? A tour of the recycling 
facility, an unfortunate entry into a clearly forbidden area . . ." 

"You're a monster." 

"Thank you. But I don't think I need to listen to that sort of thing. And I don't need to watch it." She 
turned to Lyle. "Put the gag back on the mouthy one. She talks too much. Then finish both of them. 
Before you do that, I need one more word with you. I'll be outside." 

Typical Anna. She wouldn't watch, she wouldn't listen; so if there ever were an investigation, for any 
reason, she could proclaim her innocence. Hear no evil, see no evil. 

She left. But Van Lyle was still there, and he was more than enough. He walked forward, sticky tape 
in his hand, and stood in front of me. 

"It will be nice to hear you scream, Jeanie," he said quietly. "I won't be able to give you all that you 
deserve, the thing I'd really like to give you. We don't have time for that. But I can't wait to hear you 
grovel. I want to hear you beg, Jeanie." 

"Maybe you will." I made my voice quiver. "And maybe you won't." He was moving closer. "But if 
you tape my mouth, you'll never hear anything from me. Ever. So go ahead." 

He hesitated. "You'll beg all right," he said, "and you'll grovel. Trust me, Jeanie. You'll plead, and 
you'll beg, and you'll scream. Just you wait." 

He left the room. But he had not taped my mouth. 

Mac's wheelchair stood right next to mine. "Don't move," I said, and I leaned as far over to the left as 
I could. I could get my mouth down to the cords that bound his right hand-just. 

Undoing knots in thick cord may sound easy. It isn't, especially when you can't see what you're 
doing, you're in a desperate hurry, and you have to work only with your mouth. The lips are very 
sensitive organs, but we are visual animals. I felt with my tongue and lips, tugged and twisted with my 
teeth, and was convinced that I was getting nowhere. 

I forced myself to remain calm, to be patient, to pull gently instead of tearing and biting. McAndrew 
did not move, even when my teeth were catching more of his flesh than the cords. 

It took forever before I felt the first loosening, a knot responding to my quivering mouth. But then it 
came faster. The second knot seemed easy. At last Mac's right hand was free. 

"Right," he grunted. "I'll have us out in a minute." He reached across to his other hand, with the loose 
bonds still on his right wrist. As he worked on his left hand, I craned my head around to watch for the 
return of Van Lyle. 

"Getting it," Mac said at last. But his legs were still tied when I saw the door opening. 

"No more," I whispered. The two of us sat frozen as Van Lyle walked again in front of us. Mac had 
left the cords around both wrists, and his forearms rested on the arms of the wheelchair. It looked as 


though he was securely tied, hand and foot. As for me, I was still taped like a trussed chicken, arms and 
legs. 

"So, Jeanie," Lyle said. "You don't know if you'll ask for mercy, eh? Well, I ought to tell you that Dr. 
Griss left the final steps in my hands. How you go is completely up to me-and to you. Quick and easy, 
or slow and hard. Do you think you can persuade me to be nice to you? Let's find out." 

He moved behind me and pushed my wheelchair forward. Then he came past me, to the panel that 
controlled the great double doors. 

"Take a look at this, Jeanie." 

The doors slid open. Pungent fumes rose from the pit that was revealed before me, searing my throat. 
I saw a great pond of dark liquid, just beyond the doors and a few feet down. 

"Ten seconds in there," Lyle said conversationally, "and you'd be choking. Half a minute, and your 
skin would start to peel off. But we don't have to rush everything like that. You can be dipped in and out 
like a bit of beef fondue, a toe or a foot or a hand at a time, as often and as slow as I choose to do it. 
Would you like to beg now, Jeanie? Or would you like to take your trial dip this very minute? Or maybe 
you would like me to be really merciful, and knock you unconscious first?" 

I could hardly move, but I jerked and screamed and writhed against the tapes, making as much noise 
as I possibly could. Lyle laughed delightedly. Between us we were making a frightful din. How much of 
my screaming was genuine panic? I don't know, but I'm sure a good deal of it was, because my chair 
was rolling steadily closer to the edge without being pushed. There was a small lip at the very brink of 
the pit, but it might not be enough to halt the forward motion. 

I was an arm's length from death-the chair nearing the edge-Van Lyle walking by my side and peering 
at my face, savoring my expression. 

Then, from behind-at last-came the squeak of unoiled wheels. 

Before Van Lyle could move, McAndrew was on him. Mac had freed his legs and was out of the 
wheelchair. Smarter than I would have been, he came forward in one silent rush, pushing the wheelchair 
in front of him like a ram. The edge of the seat caught Lyle behind the thighs at knee level. He fell 
backward into a sitting position. Before he could cry out he was at the edge. He and the chair went right 
on over. There was a scream and a great splash. McAndrew halted at the brink, staring down. 

"Mac!" I screamed. I was still rolling. 

He half-turned and threw himself in front of my wheelchair, stopping it with his own body. At the very 
edge, we both peered into the pit. 

Lyle had gone in flat and facedown. He rose to the surface in a cloud of steam, screaming and 
clawing at his eyes. As we watched, his hair and skin began to smoke and frizzle. His arms waved and 
thrashed down on either side of him. Then he went under again. 

The vat was more corrosive than Lyle had suggested. Twice more he rose, howling in agony. But the 
liquid must have reached his lungs. By the time he went under for the last time he was silent, a 
dark-green mass that was already losing its human form. 

And while Van Lyle was dying, McAndrew kept tearing at the tapes that held me. I think it was the 
only thing that kept him from plunging in himself to try to help. 

The tapes were strong, and Mac's hands were trembling. It was two more minutes before I could 
stand up, advance shakily to the brink, and peer down into the choking green fumes. I saw a dark vat, 
with sluggish ripples moving across the surface. About ten feet away from the edge floated an 
amorphous rounded lump. 

"Don't look," McAndrew said. "He's dead." 

"Of course he is. But it was his own damned fault." 

I don't know how angry I sounded, but Mac winced. "Come on, Jeanie," he said. "It's over now. 
Let's get out of here." 

"It's not." And then, when he stared at me. "It's not over. Not yet. Come on, Mac. I may need help." 

I ran back, through the sequence of chambers that threaded the food production facility like beads on 
a necklace. Anna Griss sat at a table in the third one, calmly reading. She had just enough time to cry out 
in surprise before I reached her. 


I lashed out and caught her with my fist high on the left cheek. While she was still reeling backward, 
partly stunned, I grabbed her in a neck lock. 

"Come on, Mac. Help me. Back to the vats." 

He wasn't much use, but it didn't matter. My own adrenaline level was so high, I could easily have 
carried her all the way myself. She was faintly struggling when I thrust her into the remaining wheelchair. 
The sticky tape that had held me was no good any more, but the cords that had bound Mac were 
enough to tie her. 

I wheeled her to the very edge, so that the acrid corrosive vapors filled her throat and mine. 

"That's Van Lyle down there." I pointed to the sodden green hulk, floating almost submerged. 
"You're going after him." 

"Ohmygod. No, no." She was panting, shaking her head with its newly disordered hair and smudged 
make-up. "Don't push me over. Don't kill me. Please." 

"You were ready enough to see us killed. Here you go, Anna Griss." I tilted the chair far forward, so 
that all that held her from the vat were her bonds. "This is what people get who mess around with me. 
You're dead." 

I put my face close to hers. She was too frightened for tears, but her staring eyes were watering in the 
poisonous fumes. 

"Say your prayers," I whispered. "Say goodbye." 

"No. Oh, please." She was straining back, away from the deadly vat. "Don't. I'll do anything. 
Anything!" 

"Jeanie!" cried McAndrew. 

"Shut up, Mac. This is between me and her." 

I moved the chair back a couple of feet and walked around in front of it to gaze into her eyes. "Look 
at me, Anna Griss. I'm not going to kill you-this time. But one more problem with you and you're dead. 
Do you understand? If the sight or sound or smell of you crosses my path again, ever, I'll come after 
you. And I'll get you. Don't ever doubt that. I'll get you." 

She did not speak, but she nodded. I turned to McAndrew. 

"I think she has the message. If she annoys either of us again, she'll be pig feed. Come on, Mac." 

"You can't just leave her! She might go over the edge." 

"If she goes, she goes." I grabbed his arm. "No big loss. But you and I are leaving. Come on." 

He kept turning to look at her, but he allowed me to lead him away. I did not look back. 

"You wouldn't have, would you?" he said at last, when we had walked through half a dozen 
chambers. "You wouldn't have killed her, no matter what she did." 

It was obvious what he wanted to hear. "No. I wouldn't have killed her." 

"Then why did you do all that, threatening her?" 

"Because I had to. I might as well ask, why did you push Van Lyle over." 

"But he was going to kill you! I didn't think-I just did it. Like you when you were screaming, going 
toward the pit. You just did it. What a bit of luck that was, Lyle leaving your mouth untaped! Otherwise 
you'd not have been able to scream, and when I ran at him he would have heard me coming." 

I don't usually care what credit I get. But that was a bit too much. 

"Mac," I said. "Listen to me. I'm going to tell you something about the invariants of nature. You have 
yours for physics and mathematics, determinants and momentum and conserved vector currents. And I 
have mine-the invariants of human nature: Love, and jealousy, and fear, and hate. Van Lyle was a cruel, 
sadistic bastard. He was like that when we first met him, he was like that out in the Oort cloud, and he 
was still like that until the moment he died. He couldn't change his nature. I deliberately told him that I 
wouldn't be able to beg and scream and grovel with my mouth taped. After that there was absolutely no 
way he'd muzzle me-no matter what Anna Griss told him to do. He wanted to see my terror, and hear 
my screams. And so I had the chance to free you." 

McAndrew is an innocent soul. He was shocked silent by what I said. Finally he sighed, and 
muttered, "Maybe you're right. But I don't see why you did that to Anna Griss." 

"I had to-because in her own way, she's no different from him. She has her own invariants: power, 


and control, and fear. Anna won't hold back on revenge to be nice to anyone. She'll go on, as far as she 
can go, until she's stopped. You and I have just stopped her. But we could never have done that by 
persuasion, or logic. She had to look death in the face for herself, and stare right down his black gullet." 

"She could still cause us trouble. She could come after us, on Earth or off it." 

"She could, but she won't. She'd like to get us, but she'll remember that pit. Anna understands power. 
If her people tried and failed again, she knows I'll come after her. The pleasure of finishing me isn't worth 
the risk." 

"Are you sure?" 

"Yes, I am. Mac, trust me. If I don't question your spinors and twistors and calibration of optical 
scalars, you shouldn't second guess me on Anna Griss." 

"So you think it's safe to go back to the Geotron, and see how the experiments came out? I left 
before the results were in, you see, because of what you said to me." 

He was returning to normal. Which is to say, totally abnormal. 

I sighed. "Sure. We can go to the Geotron." 

That sounded like the end of it, but it wasn't. We were in the submersible, cruising back to Ernesto 
Kugel's lab, while I wondered what story I was going to tell. Probably I'd say nothing. I'd pretend I had 
a nice pleasant tour, and leave it to Anna Griss to tell it otherwise. 

Then McAndrew started up again. 

"Jeanie. You really wouldn't have killed her, would you? No matter what." 

I reached out and stroked his cheek. "Of course not. But can we drop it now? You and I ought to be 
celebrating our survival. Maybe we ought to act on Ernesto Kugel's suggestion-his first one." 

It came out as flat and artificial as it sounds, and it didn't fool McAndrew for one moment. He gave 
me a wary, weary look, and leaned back in his seat. But it did accomplish my objective. It shut off a line 
of conversation that I was afraid to pursue. 

Because one thing I've learned in life is that a person never knows her own invariants. I thought I 
knew the answer to McAndrew's question, but I wasn't positive. That terrible rage, the all-consuming 
fury that I felt when Anna Griss was poised on the edge of the pit . . . if she had been a little more 
resistant, just a little tougher and more defiant-then who knows what I would have done? 

Not I. 

But one thing I did know for sure. I was not going to discuss that sort of thing with McAndrew. Ever. 

He's a dear, and he's super-smart, and in almost every way I can think of he is wonderful. But he's 
also like most people who spend their lives studying the nature of the Universe. 

He can only take a tiny little bit of reality. 


SEVENTH CHRONICLE: Rogueworld 

The laws of probability not only permit coincidences; they absolutely insist on them. 

I was sitting in the pilot's chair with McAndrew at my shoulder. Neither of us had spoken for a long 
time. We were in low polar orbit, sweeping rapidly across the surface of Vandell with all pod sensors 
wide open. I don't know what McAndrew was thinking, but my mind was not fully on the displays. Part 
of me was far away-one and a quarter light-years away, back on Earth. 

Why not? Our attention here was not necessary. The surveillance sensors were linked to the 
shipboard main computer, and the work was done automatically. If anything new turned up we would 
hear of it at once. But nothing new could happen-nothing that mattered. 

For the moment, I needed time to myself. Time to think about Jan; to remember her seventeen years, 
as a baby, as a slender child, as a fierce new intelligence, as a young woman; time to resent the chain of 
circumstance that had brought her and Sven Wicklund here, to die. Somewhere below these opalescent 
clouds, down on the cold surface of the planet, our sensor systems were seeking two corpses. Nothing 
else mattered. 

I knew that McAndrew shared my sorrow, but he handled it in a different way. His attention was 
focused on the data displays, in a concentration so intense that my presence didn't matter at all. His eyes 
lacked all expression. Every couple of minutes he shook his head and muttered to himself: "This makes 
no sense-no sense at all." 

I stared at the screen in front of me, where the dark vortex had again appeared. It came and went, 
clearly visible on some passes, vanished on others. Now it looked like a funnel, a sooty conical channel 
down through the glowing atmosphere, the only break in the planet's swirling cloud cover. We had 
passed right over it twice before, the first time with rising hopes; but the sensors had remained quiet. It 
was not a signal. It had to be a natural feature, something like Jupiter's Red Spot, some random 
coincidence of twisting gas streams. 

Coincidence. Again, coincidence. "The laws of probability not only permit coincidences; they 
absolutely insist on them." 

I couldn't get McAndrew's words out of my head. 

* * * 

He had spoken them months ago, on a day that I would never forget. It was Jan's seventeenth 
birthday, the first time of choice. I was down on Earth, choking on the dense air, meeting with the new 
head of External Affairs. 

McAndrew was at his office at the Penrose Institute. We were both trying to work, but I for one 
wasn't succeeding too well. I wondered what was going through Jan's head, waiting for graduation from 
the Luna System. 

"Naturally, there will have to be some changes," Tallboy was saying. "That's to be expected, I'm sure 
you'll agree. We are reviewing all programs, and though I am sure that my predecessor and I"-for the 
third time he had avoided using Woolford's name-"agree on overall objectives, we may have slightly 
different priorities." 

Dr. Tallboy was a tall man, with a lofty brow and a keen, intellectual eye. Although we had shaken 
hands and muttered the conventional greetings a couple of times before, this was our first working 
meeting. 

I pulled my wandering attention back to him. "When will the program review be finished?" 

He shook his head and smiled broadly (but there were no laugh lines around his eyes). "As I'm sure 
you know very well, Captain Roker, these things take time. There has been a change of Administration. 
We have many new staff to train. There have been new Budget cuts, too, and the Office of External 
Affairs has suffered more than most. We will continue all the essential programs, be assured of that. But 
it is also my mandate to expend public funds wisely, and that cannot be done in haste." 

"What about the Penrose Institute's experimental programs?" I said-a bit abruptly, but so far Tallboy 
had offered nothing more than general answers. I knew I couldn't afford to seem impatient, but my 


meeting wouldn't last much longer. 

He hesitated, then sneaked a quick look at the crib sheets of notes in front of him on the desk. It 
didn't seem to help, because when he looked up the fine and noble brow was wrinkled in perplexity. 

"I'm thinking particularly of the Alpha Centauri expedition," I prompted him. "Dr. Tallboy, a quick 
go-ahead on that means a great deal to us." 

"Of course." He was nodding at me seriously. "A great deal. Er, I'm not completely familiar with that 
particular activity, you understand. But I assure you, as soon as my staff review is completed . . ." 

Our meeting lasted fifteen more minutes, but long before that I felt I had failed. I had come here to 
push for a decision, to persuade Tallboy that the program should go ahead as planned and approved by 
Woolford; but bureaucratic changes had changed everything. Forget the fact that McAndrew and I had 
been planning the Alpha Centauri expedition for a year; forget the fact that the Hoatzin had been 
provisioned, fuelled, and inspected, and the flight plans filed long since with the USF. Forget the masses 
of new observational equipment that we had loaded onto the ship with such loving care. That had been 
under the old Administration. When the new one came in everything had to start again from scratch. And 
not one damned thing I could do about it. 

I did manage to extract one promise from Tallboy before he ushered me out with polite assurances of 
his interest and commitment to the Institute's work. He would visit the Institute personally, as soon as his 
schedule permitted. It wasn't anything to celebrate, but it was all I could squeeze out of him. 

"He'll visit here in person?" said McAndrew-I had run for the phone as soon as I cleared the Office 
of External Affairs. "Do you think he'll do it?" 

I nodded. "I didn't leave it up to him. I saw his secretary on the way out, and made sure that we're in 
the book. He'll do it." 

"When?" McAndrew had been in Limperis' office when I called, and it was the older man who leaned 
forward to ask the question. 

"Eight days from now. That was the first gap in his schedule. He'll spend most of the day at the 
Institute." 

"Then we're home free," said McAndrew. He was cracking his finger joints-a sure sign of high 
excitement. "Jeanie, we can put on an all-day show here that'll just blow him away. Wenig has a new 
E-M field stabilizer, Macedo says she can build a cheap detector for small Halo collapsars, and I've got 
an idea for a better kernel shield. And if we can ever get him to talk about it, Wicklund's cooking up 
something new and big out on Triton Station. Man, I'm telling you, the Institute hasn't been this 
productive in years. Get Tallboy here, and he'll go out of his mind." 

Limperis shot a quick sideways glance at McAndrew, then looked back at the screen. He raised his 
eyebrows. I could read the expression on that smooth, innocent-looking face, and I agreed with him 
completely. If you wanted a man to quantize a nonlinear field, diagonalize a messy Hamiltonian, or dream 
up a delicate new observational test for theories of kernel creation, you couldn't possibly do better than 
McAndrew. But that would be his downfall now. He could never accept that the rest of the world might 
be less interested in physics than he was. 

Limperis started that way, but years of budget battles as head of the Institute had taught him to play in 
a different league, "So what do you think, Jeanie?" he said to me, when Mac had finished babbling. 

"I don't know." I shrugged. "I couldn't read Tallboy. He's an unknown quantity. We'd better look up 
his background, see if that gives us some clue to what makes him tick. As it is, you'll have to try it. Show 
him everything you've got at the Institute, and hope for the best." 

"What about the expedition?" 

"Same for that. Tallboy acted as though he'd never heard of Alpha Centauri. The Hoatzin's just 
about ready to go, but we need Tallboy's blessing. External Affairs controls all the-" 

"Call from Luna," cut in a disembodied voice. "Central Records for Professor McAndrew. Level 
Two priority. Will you accept interrupt, or prefer reschedule?" 

"Accept," said McAndrew and I together-even though it wasn't my call. It had to be from Jan. 

"Voice, tonal, display or hard copy output?" 

"Voice," replied McAndrew firmly. I was less sure of that. He had done it so that I could receive the 


message, too, but we would have to witness each other's disappointment if it was bad news. 

"Message for Arthur Morton McAndrew," went on the neutral voice. "Message begins. January 
Pelham, ID 128-129-001176, being of legal age of choice, will file for parental assignment as follows: 
Father: Arthur Morton McAndrew, ID 226-788-44577. Mother: Jean Pelham Roker, ID 
547-314-78281. Name change filed for January Pelham Roker McAndrew. Parental response and 
acceptance is required. Reply via Luna free circuit 33, link 442. Message ends." 

I had never seen McAndrew look so pleased. It was doubly satisfying to him to have me on the line 
when the word came through-I was sure that the Communications Group were trying to track me now 
through Tallboy's office, not knowing I was tapped into Mac's line. 

"What's the formal date for parental assignment?" I asked. 

There was a two second pause while the computer made confirmation of identity from my voiceprint, 
sent that information over the link from L-4 to Luna, decided how to handle the situation, and connected 
us all into one circuit. 

"Message for Jean Pelham Roker. Message begins: January Pelham, ID 128-" 

"No need to repeat," I said. "Message received. Repeat, what is the formal date for parental 
assignment?" 

"Two hundred hours U.T., subject to satisfactory parental responses." 

"That's too soon," said McAndrew. "We won't have enough time for chromosomal confirmation." 

"Chromosomal confirmation waived." 

On the screen in front of me McAndrew blushed bright with surprise and pleasure. Not only had Jan 
filed for us as official parents as soon as legally permitted, she had done so without knowing or caring 
what the genetic records showed. The waiver was a definite statement: whether or not McAndrew was 
her biological father would make no difference to her; she had made her decision. 

For what it was worth, I could have given my own assurance. Some evidence is just as persuasive to 
me as chromosomal mapping. No one who had seen that blind, inward look on Jan's face when she was 
tackling an abstract problem would ever doubt that she was McAndrew's flesh and blood. I had cursed 
that expression a hundred times, as McAndrew left me to worry alone while he disappeared on a 
voyage of exploration and discovery inside his own head. 

Never mind; McAndrew had his good points. "Parental acceptance by Jean Pelham Roker," I said. 

"Parental acceptance by Arthur Morton McAndrew," said Mac. 

Another brief pause, then: "Acceptance received and recorded. Formal assignment confirmed for two 
hundred hours U.T. Arrange location through Luna link 33-442. Hard copy output follows. Is there 
additional transfer?" 

"No." 

"Link terminated." While the computer initiated hard copy output to the terminal at the Institute, I did 
a little calculation. 

"Mac, we have a problem-Jan's acceptance ceremony is set for the same time as Tallboy's visit." 

"Of course." He looked surprised that I hadn't seen it immediately. "We can handle it. She'll come out 
here. She'll want to visit-she hasn't been to the Institute since Wicklund went out to Triton Station." 

"But you'll be too tied up with Tallboy to spend much time with her. What rotten luck." 

McAndrew shrugged, and it was enough to start him talking. "Whenever a set of independent events 
occur randomly in time or space, you'll notice event-clusters. They're inevitable. That's all there is to 
coincidences. If you assume that event arrival times follow a Poisson distribution, and just go ahead and 
calculate the probability that a given number will occur in some small interval of time, you'll find-" 

"Take him away," I said to Limperis. 

He slapped McAndrew lightly on the shoulder. "Come on. Coincidence or not, this is a day for 
celebration. You're a father now, and thanks to Jeanie we've got Tallboy coming out here to see the 
show." He winked at me. "Though maybe Jan will change her mind when she hears Mac talk for a few 
hours, eh, Jeanie? Poor girl, she's not used to it, the way you are." 

McAndrew just grinned. He was riding too high for a little gentle joshing to have any effect. "If you 
pity the poor lass at all," he said. "It should be for the Philistine space-jock of a mother she'll be getting. 


If I wanted to talk to Jan about probability distributions, she'd listen to me." She probably would, too. 
I'd seen her math profiles. 
Limperis was reaching out to cut the connection, but Mac hadn't quite finished. "You know, the laws 
of probability not only permit coincidences," he said. "They-" 
He was still talking when the screen went blank. 
* * * 

I had no more official business down on Earth, but I didn't head out at once. Limperis was quite right, 
it was a time for celebration; you didn't become a parent every day. I went over to the Asgard 
restaurant, up at the very top of Mile High, and ordered the full panoramic dinner. In some ways I 
wasted my money, because no matter what the sensories threw at me I hardly noticed. I was thinking 
back seventeen years, to the time when Jan was born, so small she could put her whole fist in the old 
silver thimble that McAndrew's friends gave her as a birthgift. 

It was a few years later that I realized we had something exceptional on our hands-Jan had breezed 
through every test they could give her. I felt as though I had a window to McAndrew's own past, 
because I was sure he had been the same way thirty years earlier. The mandatory separation years 
hadn't been bad at all, because McAndrew and I had spent most of them on long trips out, where the 
Earth-years sped by in months of shipboard time. But I was very glad they were over now. In a few 
more days, McAndrew, Jan and I would be officially and permanently related. 

By the time I finished my meal I probably wore the same foolish smile as I had seen on Mac's face 
before Limperis cut the video. Neither or us could see beyond the coming ceremony to a grimmer future. 
* * * 

The next few days were too busy for much introspection. The Penrose Institute had been in free 
orbit, half a million miles out, but to make it more convenient for Tallboy's visit Limperis moved us back 
to the old L-4 position. In a general planning meeting we decided what we would show off, and how 
much time could be spared for each research activity. I'd never heard such squabbling. The 
concentration of brain power found at the Institute meant that a dozen or more important advances were 
competing for Tallboy's time. Limperis was as impartial and diplomatic as ever, but there was no way he 
could smooth Macedo's feelings when she learned that she would have less than ten minutes to show off 
three years of effort on electromagnetic coupling systems. And Wenig was even worse-he wanted to be 
in on all the presentations, and still have time to promote his own work on ultra-dense matter. 

At the same time McAndrew was having problems of quite a different kind with Sven Wicklund. That 
young physicist was still out on Triton Station, where he had gone complaining that the Inner System was 
all far too crowded and cluttered and he needed some peace and quiet. 

"What the devil's he up to out there?" grumbled McAndrew. "I need to know for the Tallboy briefing, 
but a one-way radio signal out to Neptune takes four hours-even if he wanted to talk, and he doesn't. 
And I'm sure he's on to something new and important. Blast him, what am I supposed to report?" 

I wasn't sympathetic. To me it seemed no more than poetic justice. McAndrew had annoyed me and 
others often enough in the past, when he refused to talk about his own ideas while they were in 
development-"half-cooked," to use his phrase. Apparently Sven Wicklund was just the same, and it 
served Mac right. 

But the Institute needed all the impressive material they could find, so Mac continued to send long 
and futile messages needling Wicklund to tell him something-anything-about his latest work. He got 
nowhere. 

"And he's the brightest of the lot of us," said McAndrew. Coming from him that was a real 
compliment. His colleagues were less convinced. 

"No, I don't think so," said Wenig when I asked him. "Anyway, it's a meaningless question. The two 
of them are quite different. Imagine that Newton and Einstein had lived at the same time. McAndrew's 
like Newton, as much at home with experiment as theory. And Wicklund's all theory, he needs help to 
change his pants. But it's still a fool question. Which is better, food or drink?-that makes as much sense. 
The main thing is that they're contemporaries, and they can talk to each other about what they're doing." 
Except that Wicklund refused to do so, at least at this stage of his work. 


McAndrew finally gave up the effort to draw him out and concentrated on matters closer to home. 

My own part in planning the show for Tallboy was a minor one. It had to be. My degrees in 
Gravitational Engineering and Electrical Engineering wouldn't get me in as janitor at the Institute. My job 
was to concentrate on the Hoatzin. Until we started work (budget permitting) on a more advanced 
model, this ship carried the best available version of the McAndrew drive. It could manage a hundred 
gee acceleration for months, and a hundred and ten gee for as long as the crew were willing to forego 
kitchen and toilet facilities. 

The Office of External Affairs officially owned the Hoatzin and the Institute operated her, but I 
secretly thought of the ship as mine. No one else had ever flown her. 

I had faint hopes that Tallboy might like a demonstration flight, maybe a short run out to Saturn. We 
could be there and back in a couple of days. The ship was all ready, for that and more-if he approved it, 
we were all set for the Alpha Centauri probe (forty-four days of shipboard time; not bad, when you 
remember that the first manned trip to Mars had taken more than nine months). We could be on our 
interstellar journey in a week or two. 

All right, I wasn't being realistic; but I think everyone at the Institute nourished the secret dream that 
their project would be the one that caught Tallboy's imagination, occupied his time, and won his 
approval. Certainly the amount of work that went into preparation supported my idea. 

The timing was tight but manageable. Jan would arrive at the Institute at 09:00, with the official 
parental assignment to take place at 09:50. Tallboy's grand show-and-tell began at 10:45 and went on 
for as long as he was willing to look and listen. Jan was scheduled to leave again at 19:50, so I had 
mixed feelings about Tallboy's tour. The longer he stayed, the more impressed he was likely to be, and 
we wanted that. But we also wanted to spend time with Jan before she had to dash back to Luna for 
graduation and sign-out. 

In the final analysis everything went off as well-and as badly-as it could have. At 09:00 exactly Jan's 
ship docked at the Institute. I was pleased to see that it was one of the new five-gee mini-versions of the 
McAndrew Drive, coming into use at last in the Inner System. My bet was that Jan had picked it just to 
please him. You don't need the drive at all for pond-hopping from Luna to L-4. 

The parental assignment ceremony is traditionally conducted with a lot of formality. It was against 
custom to step out of the docking area as soon as the doors were opened, march up to the father-to-be, 
and grab him in a huge and affectionate hug. McAndrew looked startled for a moment, then swelled red 
as a turkeycock with pleasure. I got the same shock treatment a few moments later. Then instead of 
letting go Jan and I held each other at arm's length and took stock. 

She was going to be taller than me-already we were eye to eye. In three years she had changed from 
a super-smart child to an attractive woman, whose bright grey eyes told me something else: if I didn't 
take a hand, Jan would twist McAndrew round her little finger. And she knew I knew it. We stood 
smiling at each other, while a dozen messages passed between us: affection, pride, anticipation, sheer 
happiness-and challenge. Mac and I were getting a handful. 

We gave each other a final hug, then she took my hand and Mac's and we went on through to meet 
with Limperis and the others. The official ceremony would not begin for another half hour, but we three 
knew that the important part was already completed. 

"So what about your graduation present?" asked McAndrew, as we were waiting to begin. I had 
wondered about it myself. It was the first thing that most new children wanted to talk about. 

"Nothing expensive," said Jan. "I think it would be nice just to make a trip-I've seen too much of 
Luna." Her tone was casual, but the quick sideways look at me told another story. 

"Is that all?" said Mac. "Och, that doesn't sound like much of a present. We thought you'd be wanting 
a cruise pod, at the very least." 

"What sort of trip?" I asked. 

"I'd like to visit Triton Station. I've heard about it all my life, but apart from you, Jeanie, I don't know 
of anyone who's ever been there. And you never talk about it." 

"I don't think that's a good idea at all," I said. The words popped out before I could stop them. 

"Why not?" 


"It's too far out-too isolated. And there'll be nothing at all for you to do there. It's a long way away." I 
had reacted before I had rational arguments, and now I was waffling. 

Jan knew it. "A long way away! When the two of you have been light-years out. You've been on 
trips thousands of times as far as Triton Station." 

I hesitated and she bore in again. "You're the one who told me that most people stick around like 
moles in their own backyard, when the Halo's waiting for them and there's a whole Universe to be 
explored." 

What could I say? That there was one rule for most people, and another for my daughter? Triton 
Station is in the backyard, in terms of interstellar space; but it's also out near the edge of the old Solar 
System, too far away for Inner System comforts. An excellent place for a message relay between the 
Halo and the Inner System, that's why it was put there in the first place. But it's small and spartan. And 
the station isn't down on Neptune's satellite, the way that most people think. It's in orbit around Triton, 
with just a small manned outpost on the surface of the satellite itself for supplies, raw materials, and 
cryogenics research. There are a few unmanned stations bobbing about in the icy atmosphere of 
Neptune itself, 350,000 kilometers away, but nobody in her right mind ever goes to visit them. 

The sixty Station personnel are a strange mixture of dedicated researchers and psychological loners 
who find the Inner System and even the Titan Colony much too crowded for them. Some of them love it 
there, but as soon as the 100-gee balanced drive is in general use, Triton Station will be only a day and a 
half flight away and well within reach of a weekend vacation. Then I suppose the disgusted staff will 
curse the crowds, and decide its time to move farther out into the Halo seeking their old peace and quiet. 

"You'll be bored," I said, trying another argument. "They're more antisocial than you can imagine, and 
you won't know anybody there." 

"Yes, I will. I know Sven Wicklund, and we always got along famously. He's still there, isn't he?" 

"He is, blast him," said McAndrew. "But as to what he's been up to out there for the past six months . 
. ." 

His voice tailed away and the old slack-jawed, half-witted look crept over his face. He was rubbing 
his fingers gently along his sandy, receding hairline, and I realized where his thoughts were taking him. 

"Don't be silly, Mac. I hope you're not even considering it. If Wicklund won't tell you what he's 
doing, you don't imagine he'll talk to Jan about it, do you, if she's just at Triton Station for a short visit?" 

"Well, I don't know," began McAndrew. "It seems to me there's a chance-" 

"I feel sure he'll tell me," said Jan calmly. 

Unfortunately, so was I. Wicklund had been bowled over by Jan when she was only fourteen and 
didn't have a tenth of her present firepower. If she could lead him around then with a ring through his 
nose, today with her added wiles it would be no contest. 

"Let's not try to decide this now," I said. "The ceremony's starting, and then we have to get ready to 
meet Tallboy. Let's talk about it afterwards." 

"Oh, I think we can decide it easily enough now," said McAndrew. 

"No, that's all right," said Jan. "It can wait. No hurry." Sorry, Jeanie, said her smile at me. Game, set 
and match. 

After that I found it hard to keep my mind on Tallboy's visit. Luckily I wasn't on center stage most of 
the time, though I did tag along with the tour, watching that high forehead nodding politely, and his long 
index finger pointing at the different pieces of equipment on display. I also had a chance to talk to 
everyone when they completed their individual briefings. 

"Impressive," said Gowers when she came out. She had been first one up, describing her theories and 
experiments on the focusing of light using arrays of kernels. A tough area of work. To set up a stable 
array of Kerr-Newman black holes called for solutions to the many-body problem in general relativity. 
Luckily there was no one in the System better able to tackle that-Emma Gowers had made a permanent 
niche for herself in scientific history years before, when she provided the exact solution to the general 
relativistic two-body problem. Now to test her approximations she had built a tiny array of shielded 
kernels, small enough that all her work was done through a microscope. I had seen Tallboy peering in 
through the eyepiece, joking with Emma as he did so. 


"So he seems sympathetic?" I said. 

"More than that." She took a deep breath and sat down. She was still hyper after her presentation. "I 
think it went very well. He listened hard and he asked questions. I was only scheduled for ten minutes, 
and we took nearly twenty. Keep your fingers crossed." 

I did, as one by one the others went in. When they came out most of them echoed her optimism. 
Siclaro was the only questioning voice. He had described his system for kernel energy extraction, and 
Tallboy had given him the same attentive audience and nodded understandingly. 

"But he asked me what I meant by `spin-up,' " Siclaro said to me as we stood together outside the 
main auditorium. 

"That's fair enough-you can't expect him to be a specialist on this stuff." 

"I know that." He shook his head in a worried fashion. "But that came at the end of the presentation. 
And all the time I was talking, he was nodding his head at me as though he understood everything-ideas 
a lot more advanced than simple spin-up and spin-down of a Kerr black hole. But if he didn't know 
what I meant at the end, how could he have understood any of the rest of it?" 

Before I had time to answer, my own turn arrived. I came last of all, and though I had prepared as 
hard as anyone I was not a central part of the show. If Tallboy had to leave early I would be cut. If he 
had time, I was to show him over the Hoatzin, and make it clear to him that we were all ready for a long 
trip, as soon as his office gave us permission. 

His energy level was amazing. He was still cordial and enthusiastic after seven hours of briefing, with 
only one short food break. We took a pod, just the two of us, and zipped over to the Hoatzin. I gave 
him a ten-minute tour, showing how the living area was moved closer to the mass disk as the 
acceleration of the ship was increased, to provide a net one-gee environment for the crew. He asked 
numerous polite general questions: how many people could be accommodated in the ship, how old was 
it, why was it called the inertia-less drive? I boggled a little at the last one, because McAndrew had 
spent large parts of his life explaining impatiently to anyone who would listen that, damn it, it wasn't 
inertia-less, that all it did was to balance off gravitational and inertial accelerations. But I went over it one 
more time, for Tallboy's benefit. 

He listened closely, nodded that deep-browed head, and watched attentively as I moved us a little 
closer to the mass disk, so that we could feel the net acceleration on us increase from one to 
one-and-a-half gees. 

"One more question," he said at last. "And then we must return to the Institute. You keep talking 
about accelerations, and making accelerations balance out. What does that have to do with us, with how 
heavy we feel?" 

I stared at him. Was he joking? No, that fine-boned face was as serious as ever. He stood there 
politely waiting for my answer, and I felt that sinking feeling. I'm not sure what I told him, or what we 
talked about on the way back to the Institute. I handed him on to McAndrew for a quick look at the 
Control Center, while I hurried off to find Limperis. He was in his office, staring at a blank wall. 

"I know, Jeanie," he said. "Don't tell me. I had to sit in on every briefing except yours." 

"The man's an idiot," I said. "I think he means well, but he's a complete, boneheaded moron. He has 
no more idea than Wenig's pet monkey what goes on here in the Institute." 

"I know. I know." Limperis suddenly showed his age, and for the first time it occurred to me that he 
was long past official retirement. "I hoped at first that it was just my paranoia," he said. "I wondered if I 
was seeing something that wasn't there-some of the others were so impressed." 

"How could they be? Tallboy had no idea what was going on." 

"It's his appearance. That sharp profile. He looks intelligent, so we assume he must be. But take the 
people here at the Institute. Wenig looks like a mortician, Gowers could pass as a dumb-blonde hooker, 
and Siclaro reminds me of a gorilla. And each of them a mind in a million. We accept it that way round 
easily enough, but not in reverse." 

He stood up slowly. "We're like babies out here, Jeanie; each of us with our own playthings. If 
anybody seems to be interested in what we're doing, and nods their head now and again, we assume 
they understand. At the Institute, you interrupt if you don't follow an argument. But that's not the way 


Earthside government runs. Nod, and smile, and don't rock the boat-that's the name of the game, and it 
will take you a long way. You've seen how well it works for Dr. Tallboy." 

"But if he doesn't understand a thing, what will his report say? The whole future of the Institute 
depends on it." 

"It does. And God knows what will happen. I thought his background was physics or engineering, the 
way he kept nodding his head. Did you know his degree is in sociology and he has no hard scientific 
training at all? No calculus, no statistics, no complex variables, no dynamics. I bet the real quality of our 
work won't make one scrap of difference to his decision. We've all wasted a week." He sniffed, and 
muttered, "Well, come on. Tallboy will be leaving in a few minutes. We must play it to the end and hope 
he leaves with a positive impression." 

He was heading for the door with me right behind when McAndrew hurried in. 

"I've been wondering where you two had gone," he said. "Tallboy's at the departure dock. What a 
show, eh? I told you we'd do it, we knocked him dead. Even without Wicklund's work, we showed 
more new results today than he'll have seen in the past ten years. Come on-he wants to thank us all for 
our efforts before he goes." 

He went bounding away along the corridor, full of enthusiasm, oblivious to the atmosphere in 
Limperis' office. We followed slowly after him. For some reason we were both smiling. 

"Don't knock it," said Limperis. "If Mac were a political animal he'd be that much less a scientist. He's 
not the man to present your budget request, but do you know what Einstein wrote to Born just before he 
died? `Earning a living should have nothing to do with the search for knowledge.' " 

"You should tell that to Mac." 

"He was the one who told it to me." 

There didn't seem much point in hurrying as we made our way to the departure dock. Tallboy had 
seen the best that we could offer. And who could tell?-perhaps McAndrew's enthusiasm would be more 
persuasive than a thousand hours of unintelligible briefings. 

The mills of bureaucracy may or may not grind fine, but they certainly grind exceeding slow. Long 
before we had an official report from Tallboy's office, the argument over Jan's visit to Triton Station was 
over. 

I had lost. She was on her way to Neptune. She had finagled a ride on a medium-acceleration supply 
ship, and anytime now we should have word of her arrival. And McAndrew couldn't wait-Wicklund was 
still frustratingly coy about his new work. 

By a second one of those coincidences that McAndrew insisted were inevitable, Tallboy's 
pronunciamento on the future of the Penrose Institute zipped in to the Message Center at the same time 
as Jan's first message from Triton Station. I didn't know about her spacegram until later, but Limperis 
directed the Tallboy message for general Institute broadcast. I was outside at the time, working near the 
Hoatzin, and the news came as voice-only on my suit radio, 

The summary: Siclaro's work on kernel energy extraction would proceed, and at a higher level (no 
surprise there, with the pressure from the Food and Energy Council for more compact power sources); 
Gowers would have her budget reduced by forty percent, as would Macedo. They could continue, but 
with no new experimental work. McAndrew had his support chopped in half. And poor Wenig, it 
seemed, had fared worst of all. The budget for compressed matter research was down by eighty percent. 

I wasn't worried about McAndrew. If they cut his research budget to zero, he would switch to 
straight theory and manage very well with just a pencil and paper. But everyone else would suffer. 

And me? Tallboy wiped me out at the very end of the report, almost as an afterthought: experimental 
use of the Hoatzin was to be terminated completely, and the ship decommissioned. There would be no 
expedition to Alpha Centauri or anywhere else beyond the Halo. Worst of all, the report referred to 
"previous unauthorized use of the balanced drive, and high-risk treatment of official property"-a direct 
knock at me and McAndrew. We had enjoyed free use of the ship under the previous Administration, 
but apparently Woolford had never thought to put it in writing. 

I switched my suit to internal propulsion and headed back for the Institute at top speed. McAndrew 
knew I was outside, and he met me at the lock waving a long printout sheet. His mop of sandy hair was 


straggling into his eyes, and a long streak of orange stickiness ran down the front of his shirt. I guessed 

he had been at dinner when the report came in. 

"Did you see it?" he said. 

"Heard it. I was on voice-only." 

"Well? What do you think?" 

"Horrible. But I'm not surprised. I knew Tallboy hadn't understood a thing." 

"Eh?" He stood goggling at me. "Are you trying to be funny? It's the most exciting news in years. I 
knew she'd find out. What a lass!" 

I may not be as smart as McAndrew but I'm no fool. I can recognize a breakdown in 
communications when I see one. When Mac concentrates, the world isn't there any more. It seemed to 
me odds-on that he had been thinking of something else and hadn't registered the Tallboy decision. 

"Mac, stand still for a minute"-he was jiggling up and down with excitement-"and listen to me. The 
report from External Affairs is here, on the future of your programs." 

He grunted impatiently. "Aye, I know about it-I heard it come in." He dismissed the subject with a 
wave of his hand. "Never mind that now, it's not important. This is what counts." 

He shook the printout, stared at part of it, and went off into a trance. I finally reached out, removed it 
from his hand, and scanned the first few lines. 

"It's from Jan!" 

"Of course it is. She's on Triton Station. Do you realize what Wicklund's done out there?" 

With Mac in this kind of mood, I'd never get his mind on to Tallboy. "No. What has he done?" 

"He's solved it." He grabbed the spacegram back from me. "See, it's right here, can't you read? Jan 
didn't get the details, but she makes it clear enough. Wicklund has solved Vandell's Fifth Problem." 

"Has he really?" I gently took the paper back from him. If it was news from Jan, I wanted to read it in 
full. "That's wonderful. It only leaves one question." 

He frowned at me. "Many questions-we'll have to wait for more details. But which one are you 
thinking of?" 

"Nothing you can't answer. But what in Heaven is Vandell's Fifth Problem?" 

He stared at me in disgust. 

* * * 

I got an answer-eventually. But before I had that answer we had been on a rambling tour of three 
hundred years of mathematics and physics. "In the year 1900-" he began. 

"Mac!" 

"No, listen to me. It's the right place to begin." 

In the year 1900, at the second International Congress of Mathematicians in Paris, David Hilbert 
proposed a series of twenty-three problems to challenge the coming century. He was the greatest 
mathematician of his day, and his problems drew from a wide range of topics-topology, number theory, 
transfinite sets, and the foundations of mathematics itself. Each problem was important, and each was 
tough. Some were solved early in the century, others were shown to be undecidable, a few hung on for 
many decades; but by the year 2000 most of them had been wrapped up to everyone's reasonable 
satisfaction. 

In the year 2020, the South African astronomer and physicist Dirk Vandell had followed Hilbert's 
precedent, and posed a series of twenty-one problems in astronomy and cosmology. Like Hilbert's 
problems they covered a wide range of topics, theoretical and observational, and every one was a 
skull-cruncher. 

McAndrew had solved Vandell's Eleventh Problem when he was a very young man. From that work 
had emerged the whole theory for the existence and location of the kernel ring, the torus of 
Kerr-Newman black holes that circles the sun ten times as far out as Pluto. Nine years later, Wenig's 
partial solution of the Fourteenth Problem had given McAndrew the clue that led him to the 
vacuum-energy drive. Now, assuming that Jan's report was correct, the Fifth Problem had fallen to 
Wicklund's analysis. 

"But why is it so important?" I asked McAndrew. "The way you describe it, I don't see practical 


uses. It's just a way of amplifying an observed signal without amplifying background noise-and it only 
applies when the original signal is minute." 

He shook his head in vigorous disagreement. "It has a thousand applications. Vandell already 
proposed one when he first set the problem, and I'm sure Wicklund will tackle it as soon as his 
experimental equipment is working. He'll use the technique to look for solitaries-rogue planets." 

Rogue planets. 

With those last two words, McAndrew brought the explanation along to the point where it made 
sense to me. I could draw on my own formal training in classical celestial mechanics. 

The possible existence of rogues went back a long way, farther than 1900. Probably all the way to 
Lagrange, who in his analysis of the three-body problem set up a mathematical framework to look at the 
motion of a planet moving in the gravitational fields of a binary star system. By 1880, that case was 
known to be "stable against ejection." In other words, the planet could have close approaches to each of 
the stars, and might suffer extremes of temperature, but it would never be completely expelled from the 
stellar system. 

But suppose you have a system with three or more stars in it? That's not at all uncommon. Then the 
situation changes completely. A planet can pick up enough energy through a series of gravitational 
swing-bys past the stellar components to hurl it right out of the system. Once this happened it would 
become a sun-less world, travelling alone through the void. Even if it later encountered another star, the 
chance of capture was minute. The planet would be a solitary, a rogue world. Astronomers had 
speculated for centuries about the existence and possible numbers of such planets, but without a scrap of 
observational evidence. 

Vandell had defined the problem: An Earth-sized planet shines only in reflected light. If it gives 
off radiation in the thermal infrared or microwave regions, the signal is swamped by the stellar 
background. Devise a technique that will permit the detection of a rogue planet as small as the 
Earth. 

Now it seemed that Wicklund had done it, and McAndrew was happy as a pig, while everybody else 
at the Institute gloomed about in reaction to Tallboy's effects on their work. 

I sympathized with them. Rogue planets are fine, but I could see no way in which they could make 
any practical difference to me. Mac and Sven Wicklund could have my share of them. I spent a lot of 
time over on the Hoatzin wondering what to do next. I didn't belong at the Penrose Institute, the only 
thing I offered there was the ability to pilot the long trips out. Once that was over, I might as well go 
back to the Titan run. 

Jan's next message back gave me mixed feelings, but at least it cheered me up. 

"Not much to do out here," she wrote-she was the only person I have ever met who could chat in a 
spacegram. "You were right, Jeanie. Wicklund's as bad as McAndrew, totally wrapped up in the work 
he's doing and won't take much notice of me. And the rest of them hate company so much they run and 
hide when we meet in the corridors. I've been spending a lot of time over on Merganser. I got the 
impression from you that she's an old hulk, but she's not. She may be an antique, but everything's still in 
good working shape. I've even been spinning-up the drive. If I can talk Wicklund into it maybe we can 
go off on a little bit of a trip together. He needs a rest (from physics!)." 

That brought back some exciting memories. Merganser was one of the two original prototypes of the 
balanced drive, and McAndrew and I had ironed the bugs out of her personally. She was limited to a 
50-gee acceleration, but still in good working order. I'd fly her anywhere. Mac seemed much less happy 
when he read the letter. 

"I hope she knows what she's doing," he said. "That ship's not a toy. Do you think it's safe?" 

"Safe as anything in the System. Jan won't have any trouble. We used the Merganser for training 
before they mothballed her, don't you remember?" 

He didn't, of course. He carries physics and mathematics in his head at an astonishing level of detail, 
but useful everyday information is another matter. He nodded at me vaguely, and wandered off to send 
more messages to Wicklund (who had to date provided no replies). 

We heard from Jan again, just as the explicit order was coming in from Tallboy's office to 


decommission Hoatzin and remove the supplies for the Alpha Centauri mission. 

I screwed up Tallboy's order into a tight ball and threw it across the room. 

Then I sat down to read what Jan had to say. 

No preamble this time: "Wicklund says it works! He's already found three rogues, and expects a lot 
more. They must be a lot more common than anybody thought. Now sit back for the big news: there's 
one only a light-year away! Isn't it exciting?" 

Well, maybe-less so to me than to Mac, I was sure of that. I assumed that solitary planets would be 
rather rare, so one closer than the nearest star was a bit surprising. But it was her next words that shot 
me bolt upright and sent a tingle through my spine. 

"Merganser is working perfectly, all ready for a trip. I've persuaded Wicklund to take her out for a 
look at Vandell-that's his name for the planet. I'm sure you don't approve, so I won't ask. Lots of love, 
and see you when we get back." 

Even as I screamed inside, I wasn't completely surprised. She was McAndrew's daughter all right-it 
was exactly the harebrained sort of thing he would have done. 
* * * 

Mac and I both played it very cool. That boneheaded pair, we said to each other. We might have 
guessed it, the follies of youth. They'll be in trouble when they get back, even though the Merganser is 
an old ship that Triton Station can do what they like with. 

But deep inside we both had other feelings. Wicklund had sent the coordinates of Vandell to us 
before they left, and as Jan said it was close, less than a light-year and a quarter away. Easily in 
Merganser's range, and a lure that any scientist worth his salt would find hard to resist, even without 
Jan's coaxing. Where had it come from, what was it made of, how long since it had been ejected from its 
parent star?-there were a hundred questions that could never be answered by remote observations, not 
even with the super-sensitive methods that Wicklund had developed. 

But it was those same questions that made me so uneasy. If I've learned one thing wandering around 
inside and outside the Solar System, it's this: Nature has more ways of killing you than you can imagine. 
When you think you've learned them all, another one pops up to teach you humility-if you're lucky. If 
not, someone else will have to decide what did you in. 

For a week after Jan's message I monitored the messages closely that came in from the outer relay 
stations. And every day I would ride over to the Hoatzin and potter about there, sometimes with Mac, 
sometimes alone. I was supposed to be working on the decommissioning, but instead I would sit in the 
pilot's chair, check all the status flags, and think my own thoughts. Until finally, ten days after Jan and 
Wicklund had left, I went over to visit the Hoatzin late one sleep period. 

And found that the lock had been cycled since I left. 

McAndrew was sitting in the pilot's chair, staring at the controls. I came quietly up behind him, patted 
him on the shoulder, and slipped into the copilot's seat. He turned toward me, straggly eyebrows raised. 

"It's now or never," he said at last. "But what about Tallboy? What will he do to the Institute?" 

I shrugged. "Nothing. Not if we make it clear that it's our fault." 

I reached out and called for a destination reading. When I left, the coordinates had all been set to 
zero. Now they carried precise values. 

"Do you think that anyone else suspects?" I said. "I checked the experimental logs in your lab today, 
and they were all current up to this afternoon-and you're always months behind. If I noticed that, maybe 
one of the others will." 

He looked surprised. "Why should they? We've been careful not to talk about this when anyone else 
could hear." 

There was no point in telling Mac that he was probably the world's worst person you'd want to keep 
a secret. I tapped him on the shoulder. "No point in worrying about it once we're on our way. Come on, 
Mac, move over-you're sitting in my chair. And think positively. We'll have a nice, long trip, just the two 
of us." 

He stood up, rubbing at the back of his head the way he always did when he was embarrassed. 
"Och, Jeanie," he said. But he was smiling to himself as we changed seats. 


The calculations were elementary, and I could do them as well as he could. The Merganser would 
reach the rogue planet in about sixty days of shipboard time if they kept close to maximum acceleration 
all the way. We could be there in thirty-five days of shipboard time, but that would pick up only ten days 
of inertial time. We would reach Vandell a couple of days after them. For me, that was two days too late. 

Our drive wake left an ionization track across the whole width of the Solar System. Mac checked 
that there were no ships directly behind for us to burn a hole through, and while he was doing it I had a 
new idea and sent a message back to External Affairs. I said that we were about to perform a brief 
high-gee test of the Hoatzin's drive before we took her in and decommissioned her. With luck, Tallboy's 
group would assume we had been the unhappy victims of a nasty accident, shooting out of the Solar 
System on a one-way journey when some control element of the drive unit had failed. Limperis and 
friends at the Institute wouldn't believe that, not as soon as they checked our destination coordinates-but 
they would never tell their suspicions to Tallboy. Maybe they could even get some mileage from our 
disappearance, pointing out the need for more funds for reliability and system maintenance. Limperis 
could play that game with his eyes closed. 

Perhaps everything would work out fine-until McAndrew and I came back. Then the truth would 
come out, and we'd be roasted for sure. 

Neither of us could get too worried about that possibility. We had other things on our minds. As we 
raced out along the invisible scintillation of the Merganser's drive, Mac dumped the data bank for 
information about Vandell's rogueworld. He didn't get much. We had coordinates relative to the Sun, 
and velocity components, but all they did was make sure we could find our way to the planet. Wicklund 
had been able to put an upper limit on its diameter using long base line interferometry, and estimated that 
we were dealing with a body no bigger than Earth. But we were missing the physical variables-no mass, 
internal structure, temperature, magnetic field, or physical composition, not even an estimate of rotation 
rate. Mac fumed, but at least I'd have a lot more information for him as soon as we got close. In the 
week before we left the Institute, I had put on board the Hoatzin every instrument that wasn't nailed 
down, anything that might tell us something useful about Vandell without having to go down there and set 
foot on its surface. 

* * * 

At a hundred gees acceleration you head out of the Solar System on a trajectory that's very close to 
a straight line. The gravitational accelerations produced by the Sun and planets are negligible by 
comparison, even in the Inner System. We were bee-lining for a point in the constellation Lupus, the 
Wolf, where Vandell lay close in apparent position to an ancient supernova fragment. That explosion had 
lit up the skies of Earth more than a millennium ago; an interesting object, but we wouldn't be going even 
a thousandth of the way out to it. Wicklund was right; Vandell's rogueworld sat in Sol's backyard. 

Without a complicated trajectory to worry about, I went round and round with a different problem. 
When the drives were on, both the Merganser and the Hoatzin were blind to incoming messages, and 
drowned out any of their own transmissions. Thus we had a chance to get a message to Sven Wicklund 
and Jan only when their drive was turned off, while they were coasting free to rubberneck or study the 
starscape scenery from a slightly different point of view. Even though they might not be listening for an 
incoming signal when the drive was off, their computer would, and should notify them of anything 
important. 

But now see my problem: to send a message, we had to switch our drive off, and that would delay 
our arrival a little bit every time we did it. Our signal would then take days or weeks to reach the 
Merganser-and to receive it, their ship had to have its drive off at just the right time. DON'T LAND 
was all I wanted to say. But how would I know when to switch off our drive and send an urgent 
message, so it would get to them just when their drive was not operating? 

I wrestled with that until my brains began to boil, then handed it over to McAndrew. He pointed out 
that we had knowledge of the occasions when their drive had been switched off, from the gaps in their 
drive wake. So making a best prediction was a straightforward problem in stochastic optimization. He 
solved it, too, before we had been on our way for a week. But the solution predicted such a low 
probability of successful contact that I didn't even try it-better to leave our drive on full blast, and try to 


make up some of their lead. 

With the shields on to protect us from the sleet of particles and hard radiation induced by our 
light-chasing velocity, we had no sense of motion at all. But we were really moving. At turnover point we 
were within one part in ten thousand of light speed. 

If I haven't said it already, I'll say it now: the 100-gee balanced drive is nice to have, but it's a son of 
a bitch-you travel a light-year in just over a month of shipboard time. Two months, and you've gone fifty 
light-years. Four shipboard months, and you're outside the Galaxy and well on your way to Andromeda. 

I calculated that two hundred days would put you at the edge of the Universe, 18 billion light-years 
out. Of course, by the time you got there, the Universe would have had 18 billion more years to expand, 
so you wouldn't be at the new edge. In fact, since the "edge" is defined as the place where the velocity of 
recession of the galaxies is light-speed, you'd still be 18 billion light-years away from it-and that would 
remain true, no matter how long you journeyed. Worse still, if you arranged a trajectory that brought you 
to rest relative to the Earth, when you switched off the drive the Galaxies near you would be rushing 
away almost at light speed . . . 

An hour or two of those thoughts, and I felt a new sympathy for Achilles in Zeno's old paradox, 
trying to catch the tortoise and never quite getting there. 

Travel for a year, according to McAndrew, and you'd begin to have effects on the large-scale 
structure of space-time. The vacuum zero-point energy tapped by the drive isn't inexhaustible; but as to 
what would happen if you kept on going . . . 

An academic question, of course, as Mac pointed out. Long before that the massplate would be 
inadequate to protect the drive, and the whole structure would disintegrate through ablative collision with 
intergalactic gas and dust. Very reassuring; but Mac's intrigued and speculative tone when he discussed 
the possibility was enough to send shivers up my spine. 

The position fixes we needed to refine Wicklund's original position and velocity for Vandell 
rendezvous were made by our computer during the final three days of flight. Those observations and 
calibrations were performed in microsecond flashes while the drive was turned off, and at the same time 
we sent out burst mode messages, prepared and compressed in advance, to the Merganser's projected 
position. We told them when to send a return signal to us, but no counter-message came in. There was 
nothing but the automatic "Signal received" from their shipboard computer. 

One day before rendezvous we were close enough to throttle back the drive. We couldn't see 
Vandell or Merganser yet, but the ships' computers could begin talking to each other. It took them only 
a few seconds to collect the information I was interested in, and spit out a display summary. 

No human presence now on board. Transfer pod in use for planetary descent trajectory. No 
incoming signals from pod. 

I keyed in the only query that mattered: When descent? 

Seven hours shipboard time. 

That was it. We had arrived just too late. By now Jan and Sven Wicklund would be down on the 
surface of Vandell. Then another part of the first message hit me. No incoming signals from pod. 

"Mac!" I said. "No pod signal." 

He nodded grimly. He had caught it too. Even when they were down on the surface, there should be 
an automatic beacon signal to fix the pod's position and allow compensation for Doppler shift of 
communication frequency. 

"No pod signal," I said again. "That means they're-" 

"Aye." His voice was husky, as though there was no air in his lungs. "Let's not jump to conclusions, 
Jeanie. For all we know . . ." 

But he didn't finish the sentence. The pod antenna was robust. Only something major (such as impact 
with a solid surface at a few hundred meters a second) would put it out of action. I had never known a 
case where the pod's com-link died and the persons within it lived. 

We sat side by side in a frozen, empty silence as the Hoatzin brought us closer to the rogue planet. 
Soon it was visible to our highest resolution telescopes. Without making a decision at any conscious 
level, I automatically set up a command sequence that would free our own landing pod as soon as the 


drive went off completely. Then I simply sat there, staring ahead at Vandell. 

For much of our trip out I had tried to visualize what a planet would be like that had known no 
warming sun for millions or billions of years. It had floated free-for how long? We didn't know. Perhaps 
since our kind had descended from the trees, perhaps as long as any life had existed on Earth. For all 
that time, the planet had moved on through the quiet void, responsive only to the gentle, persistent tug of 
galactic gravitational and magnetic fields, drifting along where the stars were no more than distant 
pinpricks against the black sky. With no sunlight to breathe life onto its surface, Vandell would be cold, 
airless, the frozen innermost circle of hell. It chilled me to think of it. 

The planet grew steadily in the forward screens. As the definition of the display improved, I suddenly 
realized why I couldn't relate the picture in front of me to my mental images. Vandell was visible, at 
optical wavelengths. It sat there at the center of the screen, a small sphere that glowed a soft, living pink 
against the stellar backdrop. As I watched the surface seemed to shimmer, with an evanescent pattern of 
fine lines running across it. 

McAndrew had seen it too. He gave a grunt of surprise, cupped his chin in his hands, and leaned 
forward. After two minutes of silence he reached across to the terminal and keyed in a brief query. 

"What are you doing?" I asked, when after another two minutes he showed no sign of speaking. 

"Want to see what's in Merganser's memory. Should be some images from their time of first 
approach." He grunted and shook his head. "Look at that screen. There's no way Vandell can look like 
that." 

"I was amazed to see it at visible wavelengths. But I'm not sure why." 

"Available energy." He shrugged, but his gaze never left the display. "See, Jeanie, the only thing that 
can provide energy to that planet's surface is an internal source. But nothing I've ever heard of could give 
this much radiation at those frequencies, and sustain it over a long period. And look at the edge of the 
planet's disk. See, it's less bright. That's an atmospheric limb darkening, if ever I've seen one-an 
atmosphere, now, on a planet that should be as cold as space. Doesn't make any sense at all. No sense 
at all." 

We watched together as Merganser's data bank fed across to our ship's computer and through the 
displays. The screen to our left flickered through a wild pattern of colors, then went totally dark. 
McAndrew looked at it and swore to himself. 

"Explain that to me, Jeanie. There's the way that Vandell looked in the visible part of the spectrum 
when Jan and Sven were on their final approach-black as hell, totally invisible. We get here, a couple of 
days later, and we find that." He waved his arm at the central display, where Vandell was steadily 
increasing in size as we moved closer. "Look at the readings that Wicklund made as they came into 
parking orbit-no visible emissions, no thermal emissions, no sign of an atmosphere. Now see our 
readings: the planet is visible, above freezing point, and covered in clouds. It's as though they were 
describing one world, and we've arrived at a completely different one." 

Mac often tells me that I have no imagination. But as he spoke wild ideas went running through my 
mind that I didn't care to mention. A planet that changed its appearance when humans approached it; a 
world that waited patiently for millions of years, then draped a cloak of atmosphere around itself as soon 
as it had lured a group of people to its surface. Could the changes on Vandell be interpreted as the result 
of intention, a deliberate and intelligent act on the part of something on the planet? 

While I was still full of my furious fancies, a high-pitched whistle from the navigation console 
announced that the balanced drive had turned off completely. We had reached our rendezvous position, 
two hundred thousand kilometers from Vandell. I was moving away from the control panel, heading 
towards our own transfer pod, before the sound had ended. At the entrance I stopped and turned, 
expecting that McAndrew would be close on my heels. But he hadn't left the displays. He had called 
back the list of Vandell's physical parameters, showing mass, temperature, mean diameter, and rotation 
rate, and was staring at it blindly. As I watched he requested a new display of Vandell's rotation rate, 
which was small enough to be shown as zero in the standard output format. 

"Mac!" 

He turned, shook his head from side to side as though to banish his own version of the insane ideas 


that had crowded my mind when I saw the change in Vandell, and slowly followed me to the pod. At the 
entrance he turned for a last look at the screens. 

There was no discussion of our move into the pod. We didn't know when, or even quite how, but we 
both knew that we had to make a descent to the surface of Vandell. Somehow we had to recover the 
bodies that lay beneath the flickering, pearly cloud shrouding the rogue world. 

* * * 

In another time and place, the view from the pod would have been beautiful. We were close enough 
now to explain the rosy shimmer. It was lightning storms, running back and forth across the clouded 
skies of Vandell. Lightning storms that shouldn't be there, on a world that ought to be dead. We had 
drained Merganser's data banks as we went round and round in low orbit. Not much new had come to 
light, but we had found the last set of instrument readings returned to the main computer when the other 
landing pod had made its approach to Vandell's surface: Atmospheric pressure, zero. External 
magnetic field, less than a millionth of a gauss. Temperature, four degrees absolute. Surface 
gravity, four-tenths of a gee. Planetary rotation rate, too small to measure. 

Then their pod had touched down, with final relative velocity of only half a meter a second-and all 
transmissions had ceased, instantly. Whatever had killed Jan and Sven Wicklund, direct impact with the 
surface couldn't be the culprit. They had landed gently. And if they hadn't been killed by collision when 
they landed . . . 

I tried to ignore the tiny bud of hope that wanted to open in my mind. I had never heard of a pod 
being destroyed without also killing anyone inside it. 

Our instruments had added a few new (and odd) facts to that earlier picture. The "atmosphere" we 
were seeing now was mainly dust, a great swirling storm across the whole of Vandell, littered by lightning 
flashes through the upper part. It was hot, a furnace breath that had no right to exist. Vandell was 
supposed to be cold. Goddammit, it should be drained of every last calorie of heat. McAndrew had told 
me so, there was no way the planet could be warm. 

Round and round, orbit after orbit; we went on until I felt that we were a fixed center and the whole 
universe was gyrating around us, while I stared at that black vortex (it came and went from one orbit to 
the next, now you see it, now you don't) and McAndrew sat glued to the data displays. I don't think he 
looked at Vandell itself for more than ten seconds in five hours. He was thinking. 

And me? The pressure inside was growing-tearing me apart. According to Limperis and Wenig, I'm 
cautious to a fault. Where angels fear to tread, I not only won't rush in, I don't want to go near the place. 
That's one reason they like to have me around, to exercise my high cowardice quotient. But now I 
wanted to fire our retro-rockets and get down there, down onto Vandell. Twice I had seated myself at 
the controls, and fingered the preliminary descent sequence (second nature, I could have done that in my 
sleep). And twice McAndrew had emerged from his reverie, shook his head, and spoken: "No, Jeanie." 

But the third time he didn't stop me. 

"D'ye know where you're going to put her down, Jeanie?" was all he said. 

"Roughly." I didn't like the sound of my voice at all. Too scratchy and husky. "I've got the 
approximate landing position from Merganser's readings." 

"Not there." He was shaking his head. "Not quite there. See it, the black tube? Put us down the 
middle of that funnel-can you do it?" 

"I can. But if it's what it looks like, we'll get heavy turbulence." 

"Aye, I'll agree with that." He shrugged. "That's where they are, though, for a bet. Can you do it?" 

That wasn't his real question. As he was speaking, I began to slide us in along a smooth descent 
trajectory. There was nothing to the calculation of our motion, we both recognized that. Given our 
desired touchdown location, the pod's computer would have a minimum fuel descent figured in fractions 
of a second. 

I know McAndrew very well. What he was saying-not in words, that wasn't his style-was simple: It's 
going to be dangerous, and I'm not sure how dangerous. Do you want to do it? 

I began to see why as soon as we were inside the atmosphere. Visibility went down to zero. We 
were descending through thick smoke-like dust and flickering lightning. I switched to radar vision, and 


found I was looking down to a murky, surrealistic world, with a shattered, twisted surface. Heavy winds 
(without an atmosphere?-what were winds?) moved us violently from side to side, up and down, with 
sickening free-fall drops arrested by the drive as soon as they were started. 

Thirty seconds to contact, and below us the ground heaved and rolled like a sick giant. Down and 
down, along the exact center of the black funnel. The pod shook and shivered around us. The automatic 
controls seemed to be doing poorly, but I knew I'd be worse-my reaction times were a thousandfold too 
slow to compete. All we could do was hold tight and wait for the collision. 

Which never came. We didn't make a featherbed landing, but the final jolt was just a few centimeters 
a second. Or was it more? I couldn't say. It was lost in the continuing shuddering movements of the 
ground that the pod rested on. The planet beneath us was alive. I stood up, then had to hold onto the 
edge of the control desk to keep my feet. I smiled at McAndrew (quite an effort) as he began an 
unsteady movement towards the equipment locker. 

He nodded at me. Earthquake country. 

I nodded back. Where is their ship? 

We had landed on a planet almost as big as Earth, in the middle of a howling dust storm that reduced 
visibility to less than a hundred yards. Now we were proposing to search an area of a couple of hundred 
million square miles-for an object a few meters across. The needle in a haystack had nothing on this. 
Mac didn't seem worried. He was putting on an external support pack-we had donned suits during the 
first phase of descent. 

"Mac!" 

He paused with the pack held against his chest and the connectors held in one hand. "Don't be daft, 
Jeanie. Only one of us should be out there." 

And that made me mad. He was being logical (my specialty). But to come more than a light-year, and 
then for one of us go the last few miles . . . Jan was my daughter too-my only daughter. I moved 
forward and picked up another of the packs. After one look at my face, Mac didn't argue. 

At least we had enough sense not to venture outside at once. Suited up, we completed the systematic 
scan of our surroundings. The visual wavelengths were useless-we couldn't see a thing through the 
ports-but the microwave sensors let us look to the horizon. And a wild horizon it was. Spikes of sharp 
rock sat next to crumbling mesas, impenetrable crevasses, and tilted blocks of dark stone, randomly 
strewn across the landscape. 

I could see no pattern at all, no rule of formation. But over to one side, less than a mile from our pod, 
our instruments were picking up a bright radar echo, a reflection peak stronger than anything that came 
from the rocky surface. It must be metal-could only be metal-could only be Jan's ship. But was it intact? 
Lightning-fused? A scoured hulk? A shattered remnant, open to dust and vacuum? 

My thoughts came too fast to follow. Before they had reached any conclusion we had moved to the 
lock, opened it, and were standing on the broken surface of Vandell. McAndrew automatically fell 
behind to let me take the lead. Neither of us had any experience with this type of terrain, but he knew 
my antennae for trouble were better than his. I tuned my suit to the reflected radar signal from our pod 
and we began to pick our way carefully forward. 

It was a grim, tortuous progress. There was no direct path that could be taken across the rocks. 
Every tenth step seemed to bring me to a dead end, a place where we had to retrace our steps halfway 
back to our own pod. Beneath our feet, the surface of the planet shivered and groaned, as though it was 
ready to open up and swallow us. The landscape as our suits presented it to us was a scintillating 
nightmare of blacks and grays. (Vision in nonvisible wavelengths is always disconcerting-microwave 
more than most). 

Around us, the swirling dust came in shivering waves that whispered along the outside of our helmets. 
I could detect a definite cycle, with a peak every seven minutes or so. Radio static followed the same 
period, rising and falling in volume to match the disturbance outside. 

I had tuned my set to maximum gain and was transmitting a continuous call signal. Nothing came back 
from the bright radar blip of the other pod. It was now only a couple of hundred yards ahead but we 
were approaching agonizingly slowly. 


At fifty yards I noticed a lull in the rustle around us. I switched to visible wavelengths, and waited 
impatiently while the suit's processor searched for the best combination of frequencies to penetrate the 
murk. After half a second the internal suit display announced that there would be a short delay; the 
sensors were covered with ionized dust particles that would have to be repelled. That took another ten 
seconds, then I had an image. Peering ahead on visible wavelengths I thought I could see a new shape in 
front of us, a flat oval hugging the dark ground. 

"Visible signal, Mac," I said over the radio. "Tell your suit." 

That was all I could say. I know the profile of a pod, I've seen them from every angle. And the 
silhouette ahead of us looked wrong. It had a twisted, sideways cant, bulging towards the left. I 
increased pace, stumbling dangerously along smooth slabs and around jagged pinnacles, striding 
recklessly across a quivering deep abyss. Mac was following, ready to help me if I got in trouble-unless 
he was taking worse risks himself, which was certainly not beyond him. I could hear his breath, loud on 
the suit radio. 

It was their pod. No doubt at all. And as I came closer I could see the long, gaping hole in one side. 
It takes a lot to smash a transfer pod beyond repair, but that one would never fly again. Inside it would 
be airless, lifeless, filled only with the choking dust that was Vandell's only claim to an atmosphere. 

And the people inside? Would Jan or Sven have thought to wear suits before descent? It would 
make a difference only to the appearance of the corpses. Even with suits, anything that could kill their 
signal beacon would kill them too. 

I took my final step to the pod, stooped to peer in through the split in the side, and stopped 
breathing. Somewhere deep inside me, contrary to all logic, there still lived a faint ghost of hope. It died 
as I looked. Two figures lay side by side on the floor of the pod, neither of them moving. 

I groaned, saw Mac coming to stand beside me, and switched on my helmet light for a better view or 
the interior. Then I straightened up so fast that my head banged hard on the pod's tough metal. 

They were both wearing suits, their helmets were touching-and as the light from outside penetrated 
the interior of the pod, they swung around in unison to face me. They were both rubbing at their suit 
faceplates with gloved hands, clearing a space in a thick layer of white dust there. 

"Jan!" My shout must have blasted Mac rigid. "Sven! Mac, they're alive!" 

"Christ, Jeanie, I see that. Steady on, you'll burst my eardrums." He sounded as though he himself 
was going to burst, from sheer pleasure and relief. 

We scrambled around to the main hatch of the pod and I tried to yank it open. It wouldn't move. 
Mac lent a hand, and still nothing would budge-everything was too bent and battered. Back we went to 
the hole in the ship's side, and found them trying to enlarge it enough to get out. 

"Stand back," I said. "Mac and I can cut that in a minute." 

Then I realized they couldn't hear me or see me. Their faceplates were covered again with dust, and 
they kept leaning together to touch helmets. 

"Mac! There's something wrong with their suits." 

"Of course there is." He sounded disgusted with my stupidity. "Radio's not working-we already knew 
that. They're communicating with each other by direct speech through the helmet contact. Vision units 
are done for, too-see, all they have are the faceplates, and the dust sticks and covers them unless they 
keep on clearing it. The whole atmosphere of this damned planet is nothing more than charged dust 
particles. Our suits are repelling them, or we'd see nothing at visible wavelengths. Here, let me in there." 

He stuck his head through the opening, grabbed the arm of Jan's suit, and pulled us so that we were 
all four touching helmets. We could talk to each other. 

And for that first ten minutes that's what we did: talk, in a language that defies all logical analysis. I 
would call it the language of love, but that phrase has been used too often for another (and less 
powerful) emotional experience. 

Then we enlarged the hole so they could climb out. At that point I thought that we had won, that our 
troubles and difficulties were all over. In fact, they were just starting. 
* * * 
Their pod was in even worse shape than it looked. The battering from flying boulders that had ruined 


the hull should have left intact the internal electronics, computers, and communications links, components 
with no moving parts that ought to withstand any amount of shaking and violent motion. But they were all 
dead. The pod was nothing but a lifeless chunk of metal and plastics. Worse still, all the computer 
systems in Jan and Sven's suits had failed, too. They had no radios, no external vision systems-not even 
temperature controls. Only the purely mechanical components, like air supply and suit pressure, were 
still working. 

I couldn't imagine anything that could destroy the equipment so completely and leave Jan and Sven 
alive, but those questions would have to come later. For the moment our first priority was the return to 
the other pod. If I had thought it dangerous work coming, going back would be much worse. Jan and 
Sven were almost blind, they couldn't step across chasms or walk along a thin slab of rock. Without 
radios, I couldn't even tell them to back up if I decided we had to retrace part of our path. 

We all four linked hands, to make a chain with Mac on the left-hand end and me on the right, and 
began a strange crab-like movement back in the direction of the other pod. I daren't hurry, and it took 
hours. Four times I had to stop completely, while the ground beneath us went through exceptionally 
violent paroxysms of shaking and shuddering. We stood motionless, tightly gripping each other's gloved 
hands. If it was scary for me, it must have been hell for Jan and Sven. Mac and I were their lifeline, if we 
lost contact they wouldn't make twenty meters safely across the broken surface. While the shaking went 
on, I was picking up faint sounds in my radio. McAndrew and Wicklund had their helmets together, and 
Wicklund seemed to be doing all the talking. For five minutes I heard only occasional grunts from Mac 
through his throat mike. 

"Right," he said at last. "Were you able to pick up any of that, Jeanie? We have to get a move on. Go 
faster." 

"Faster? In these conditions? You're crazy. I know it's slow going, but we all have plenty of air. Let's 
do it right, and get there in one piece." 

"It's not air I'm worried about." He was crowding up behind us, so that we were all bumping into 
each other. "We have to be in the pod and off the surface in less than an hour. Sven's been tracking the 
surges of seismic activity and dust speed, ever since they landed and everything went to hell. There's a 
bad one coming an hour and a half from now-and I mean bad. Worse than anything we've felt so far. A 
lot of the minor cycles we've been feeling since we came out on the surface will all be in phase. They'll all 
add together." 

Worse than anything we had felt so far. What would it be like? It wasn't easy to imagine. Nor was 
the cause-but something had taken Vandell's smooth and quiet surface and crumpled it to a wild ruin in 
the few hours since the other pod had landed. 

Against my instincts I began to take more risks, to climb over more jagged rocks and to walk along 
shelves that might tilt and slide under our weight. I think that at this point it was worse for McAndrew 
and me than for Sven and Jan. They could walk blind and trust us to keep them safe; but we had to 
keep our eyes wide open, and study all the dangers around us. I wanted to ask Mac a hundred 
questions, but I didn't dare to focus his attention or mine on anything except the immediate task. 

At our faster pace we were within a hundred meters of the pod in twenty minutes, with what looked 
like a clear path the rest of the way. That was when I heard a grunt and curse over the suit radio, and 
turned to see McAndrew sliding away to one side down a long scree of loose gravel. Last across, he 
had pushed Sven Wicklund to safety as the surface began to break. He fell, scrabbled at the ground, but 
couldn't get hold of anything firm. He rolled once, then within seconds was lost from view behind a black 
jumble of boulders. 

"Mac!" I was glad that Jan couldn't hear my voice crack with panic. 

"I'm here, Jeanie. I'm all right." He sounded as though he was out on a picnic. "My own fault, I could 
see it was breaking away when Sven was on it. I should have looked for another path instead of 
following him like a sheep." 

"Can you get back?" 

There was a silence, probably thirty seconds. In my nerved-up state it seemed like an hour. I could 
hear Mac's breath, faster and louder over the radio. 


"I'm not sure," he said at last. "It's a mess down here, and the slope's too steep to climb straight up. 
Damned gravel, I slide right back down with it. It may take me a little while. You three had better keep 
going and I'll catch up later. Time's too short for you to hang around waiting." 

"Forget it. Hold right there, I'm coming back after you." I leaned to set my helmet next to Jan's. "Jan, 
can you hear me?" 

"Yes. But speak louder." Her voice was faint, as though she was many meters away. 

"I want you and Sven to stand right here and don't move-not for anything. Mac's stuck, and I have to 
help him. I'll be just a few minutes." 

That was meant to be reassuring, but then I wondered what would happen if I was too optimistic 
about how long it would take me. "Give me twenty minutes, and if we're not back then, you'll have to get 
to the pod on your own. It's straight in front as you're facing now, about a hundred meters away. If you 
go in a straight line for fifty paces then clear your faceplates, you should be able to see it." 

I knew she must have questions, but there was no time to answer them. Mac's tone suggested it 
would be completely fatal to be on Vandell's surface, unprotected, when the next big wave of seismic 
activity hit us. 

I knew exactly where Mac had gone, but I had a hard time seeing him. The rock slide had carried 
with it a mixture of small and large fragments, from gravel and pebbles to substantial boulders. His 
struggles to climb the slope had only managed to embed him deeper in loose materials. Now his suit was 
three-quarters hidden. His efforts also seemed to have carried him backwards, so with a thirty degree 
gradient facing him I didn't think he'd ever be able to get out alone. And further down the slope lay a 
broad fissure in the surface, of indeterminate depth. 

He was facing my way, and he had seen me too. "Jeanie, don't come any closer. You'll slither right 
down here, the same as I did. There's nothing firm past the ledge you're standing on." 

"Don't worry. This is as far as I'm coming." I backed up a step, nearer to a huge rock that must have 
weighed many tons, and turned my head so the chest of Mac's suit sat on the crosshairs at the exact 
center of my display. "Don't move a muscle now. I'm going to use the Walton, and we don't have time 
for second tries." 

I lifted the crosshairs just a little to allow for the effects of gravity, then intoned the Walton release 
sequence. The ejection solenoid fired, and the thin filament with its terminal electromagnet shot out from 
the chest panel on my suit and flashed down towards McAndrew. The laser at the tip measured the 
distance of the target, and the magnet went on a fraction of a second before contact. Mac and I were 
joined by a hair-thin bond. I braced myself behind the big rock. "Ready? I'm going to haul you in." 

"Aye, I'm ready. But why didn't I think of using the Walton? Damnation, I didn't need to get you 
back here, I could have done it for myself." 

I began to reel in the line, slowly so that Mac could help by freeing himself from the stones and 
gravel. The Izaak Walton has been used for many years, ever since the first big space construction jobs 
pointed out the need for a way to move around in vacuum without wasting a suit's reaction mass. If all 
you want is a little linear momentum, the argument went, why not take it from the massive structures 
around you? That's all that the Waltons do. I'd used them hundreds of times in free fall, shooting the line 
out to a girder where I wanted to be, connecting, then reeling myself over there. So had Mac, and that's 
why he was disgusted with himself. But it occurred to me that this was the first time I'd ever heard of a 
Walton being used on a planetary surface. 

"I don't think you could have done it, Mac," I said. "This big rock's the only solid one you could see 
from down there, and it doesn't look as though it has a high metal content. You'd have nothing for the 
magnet to grab hold of up here." 

"Maybe." He snorted. "But I should have had the sense to try. I'm a witless oaf." 

What that made me, I dreaded to think. I went on steadily hauling in the line until he had scrabbled his 
way up to stand by my side, then switched off the field. The line and magnet automatically ran into their 
storage reel in my suit, and we carefully turned and headed back to the other two. 

They were just where I had left them. They stood, helmets touching, like a frozen and forlorn tableau 
in Vandell's broken wilderness. It was more than fifteen minutes since I gone back to Mac, and I could 


imagine their uneasy thoughts. I leaned my helmet to touch both theirs. 

"All present and safe. Let's go." 

Jan gave my arm a great squeeze. We formed our chain again, and crabbed the rest of the way to the 
pod. It wasn't quite as easy as it had looked, or as I suggested to Jan, but in less than fifteen minutes we 
were opening the outer hatch and bundling Sven and Jan into it. 

The lock was only big enough for two at a time. They were out of their useless suits by the time that 
McAndrew and I could join them inside. Jan looked pale and shaky, ten years older than her seventeen 
years. Sven Wicklund was as blond and dreamy-looking as ever, still impossibly young in appearance. 
Like McAndrew, his own internal preoccupations partly shielded him from unpleasant realities-even now 
he was brandishing a piece of paper covered with squiggles at us. But Jan and Sven had both held 
together, keeping their composure well when death must have seemed certain. It occurred to me that if 
you wanted to find a rite of passage to adulthood, you wouldn't find a tougher one than Jan had been 
through. 

"Just look at this," Sven said as soon as we were out of the hatch. "I've been plotting the cycles-" 

"How long before it hits?" I interrupted. 

"Four minutes. But-" 

"Get into working suits, both of you." I was already at the controls. "I'm taking us up as soon as I 
can, but if we're too late I can't guarantee that the pod hull will survive. You know what happened to 
yours." 

The ascent presented no problem of navigation-I had plenty of fuel, and I intended to go straight up 
with maximum lift. There would be time to worry about rendezvous with Merganser and Hoatzin when 
we were safely away from Vandell. 

I believe in being careful, even on the simplest takeoff, so all my concentration was on the control 
sequences. I could hear Jan, McAndrew and Wicklund babbling to each other in the background, until I 
told them to get off my suit frequency and let me think. Vandell was still a complete mystery world to 
me, but if the others had answers, those, like the problem of ship rendezvous, could wait until we were 
off the surface. 

Wicklund's predictions for the timing of the next wave of violence proved to be unnecessary. I could 
see it coming directly, in the values provided by the pod's field instruments. Every gauge reading in front 
of me was creeping up in unison as we lifted off; ionization levels, surface vibrations, dust density, 
electric and magnetic fields-readouts flickered rapidly higher, and needles turned steadily across their 
dials like the hands of an old-fashioned clock. 

Something big was on its way. We lifted into a sky ripped by great lightning flashes, burning their way 
through the clouds of charged dust particles. The ascent we made was rapid. Within a few seconds we 
had reached three kilometers. And then, as I was beginning to relax a little and think that we had been 
just in time, the readings in front of me went mad. External field strengths flickered up so fast in value that 
the figures were unreadable, then warning lights came on. I heard the screech of a fatal overload in my 
suit's radio, and saw the displays in front of me blank out one after another. The computer, after a brief 
mad flurry of a binary dump across the control screen, went totally dead. Suddenly I was flying blind and 
deaf. All the electronic tools that every pilot relied on were now totally disabled. 

It was useless information, but suddenly I understood exactly what had killed the signal beacon from 
Jan and Sven's pod without also killing them. Before the displays in front of me died, the electric and 
magnetic field strengths had risen to an impossible level. Even with partial shielding from the pod's hull, 
their intensity was enough to wipe magnetic storage-that took care of computers, communications 
equipment, displays, and suit controls. If the suits hadn't been designed with manual overrides for certain 
essentials so that Jan and Sven could control their air supply, that would have been the end. 

Now our pod had the same problem as theirs. We hadn't been pelted with boulders, as they had 
when they were sitting on the surface of Vandell, but we had no computer control of our flight and we 
were being whipped around the sky by the changing magnetic fields. 

It wasn't necessary for me to change to manual control. When the computer died, it dumped 
everything in my lap automatically. I gritted my teeth, tried to keep us heading straight up (not easy, the 


way we were being tilted and rocked) and refused to decrease thrust even though the pod shuddered as 
though it was getting ready to disintegrate. 

I'm blessed with an iron stomach, one that doesn't get sick no matter how much lurching and spinning 
it takes. McAndrew isn't, and Jan takes after him. They couldn't communicate with me, but I could take 
their misery for granted. 

It was worth the discomfort. We were getting there, rising steadily, while the pink glow around the 
pod's ports faded towards black. As our altitude increased I looked at the internal pressure gauge-thank 
God for a simple mechanical gadget. It was showing normal pressure, which meant that the hull hadn't 
been breached on our ascent. I allowed myself the luxury of a quick look around me. 

McAndrew was slumped forward in his straps, head down as low as he could get it. Sven and Jan 
were both leaning back, arms linked. All the faceplates were clear, so that I knew none of them had 
vomited in their suit-no joke, since the internal cleaning systems that would usually handle the mess were 
out of action. 

The turbulence around the pod grew less. Stars were coming into view outside the ports as I turned 
us into an orbit that spiralled outward away from Vandell. I was looking for Hoatzin. Our orbit was 
clumsy and wasteful of fuel compared with what the navigation computer would have provided. But give 
me some credit, I was receiving no reference signals from the ship. All I had was instinct and experience. 

Scooting along over the clouds I could now see a pattern to the lightning. It moved in great waves 
over the surface, reaching peaks in places, fading elsewhere. We had lifted from a point where all the 
peaks had converged, but now it was fading to look no different from the rest. Or almost so; the faint 
shadow of the black funnel still dipped down into the murk. 

I felt a tap on my shoulder. Mac was gesturing at me, then at the helmet of his suit. I nodded and 
broke the seal on my own helmet. We were outside the danger zone, and it was important to reestablish 
contact among the group. The search for Hoatzin and Merganser might take hours, with no assistance 
from automated scan instruments or radio receipt of homing signals. Meanwhile, I wanted some 
explanations. It was clear that McAndrew and Wicklund between them had more idea than I did what 
had been happening. 

Three miserable, greenish-yellow faces emerged from the helmets. No one had thrown up, but from 
the look of them it had been a close thing. 

"I thought it was bad when the storm hit us on the surface," said Jan. "But that was even worse. What 
did you do to us, Jeanie? I thought the pod was coming apart." 

"So did I." Suit helmet off, I reached back to massage the aching muscles in my neck and shoulders. 
"It almost did. We lost the computers, the communications, the displays-everything. What is this crazy 
planet, anyway? I thought the laws of nature were supposed to be the same all over the universe, but 
Vandell seems to have a special exemption. What in hell did you two do to the place, Jan? It was quiet 
as a grave until you got at it." 

"It damn near was one," said McAndrew. "If you hadn't . . ." 

He paused and swallowed. "We know what's going on. That's what we were talking about before 
you shook us to pieces. If we'd been a bit smarter, we could have inferred it ahead of time and none of 
this would have happened. How much did you hear on the way up?" 

I shook my head. "I tuned you out. I had other things on my mind. Are you telling me you understand 
that mess down there? I thought you said it made no sense at all." 

While we spoke I had taken us up to the correct height above Vandell for rendezvous with Hoatzin. 
Now it would need a steady and simple sweep to find our ship. 

McAndrew wiped his hand across his pale, sweating forehead. He was looking awful, but less like a 
dying pickle as the minutes passed. "It didn't make sense," he said huskily. "Nothing ever does before 
you understand it, and then it seems obvious. I noticed something odd just before we left Hoatzin to go 
into the pod-Sven had wondered about the same thing, but neither of us gave it enough significance. 
Remember the list of physical variables that they recorded for Vandell when they first arrived here? No 
electric and magnetic fields, negligible rotation rate, no atmosphere, and cold as the pit. Does any one of 
those observations suggest anything to you?" 


I leaned against the padded seat back. My physical exertions over the past half hour had been 
negligible, but tension had exhausted me totally. I looked across at him. 

"Mac, I'm in no condition for guessing games. I'm too tired. For God's sake, get on with it." 

He peered at me sympathetically. "Aye, you're right. Let me begin at the beginning, and keep it 
simple. We know that Vandell was quiet until Merganser's pod landed on its surface. Within minutes of 
that, there was massive seismic activity and terrific electric and magnetic disturbances. We watched it, 
there were waves of activity over the whole planet-but they all had one focus, and one point of origin: 
where the pod landed." As McAndrew spoke his voice became firmer, strengthening now that he was 
back on the familiar ground of scientific explanation. "Remember the dark cone that we followed in to 
the surface? It was the only anomaly visible over the whole surface of the planet. So it was obvious. The 
impact of the pod caused the trouble, it was the trigger that set off Vandell's eruption." 

I looked around at the others. They all seemed happy with the explanation, but to me it said 
absolutely nothing. I shook my head. "Mac, I've landed on fifty planets and asteroids through the System 
and the Halo. Never once has one shaken apart when I tried to set foot on it. So why? Why did it 
happen to Vandell?" 

"Because-" 

"Because Vandell is a rogue world," interrupted Sven Wicklund. We all stared at him in 
amazement. Sven usually never said a word about anything (except of course physics) unless he was 
asked a direct question. He was too shy. Now his blond hair was wet with perspiration, and there was 
still that distant, mystic look on his face, the look that vanished only when he laughed. But his voice was 
forceful. Vandell had done something to him, too. 

"A rogue world," he went on. "And one that does not rotate on its axis. That is the crux of this whole 
affair. Vandell rotates too slowly for us to measure it. McAndrew and I noticed that, but we thought it 
no more than a point of academic interest. As Eddington pointed out centuries ago, almost everything in 
the Universe seems to rotate-atoms, molecules, planets, stars, galaxies. But there is no law of nature that 
obliges a body to rotate relative to the stars. Vandell did not, but we thought it only a curious accident." 

He leaned towards me. "Think back to the time-how many million years ago?-when Vandell was first 
ejected from its stellar system. It had been close to the system's suns, exposed to great forces. It was 
hot, and maybe geologically active, and then suddenly it was thrown out, out into the void between the 
stars. What happened then?" 

He paused, but I knew he was not expecting an answer. I waited. 

He shrugged. "Nothing happened," he said. "For millions or billions of years, Vandell was alone. It 
slowly lost heat, cooled, contracted-just as the planets of the Solar System cooled and contracted after 
they were first formed. But there is one critical difference: the planets circle the Sun, and each other. As 
tensions inside build up, tidal forces work to release them. Earth and the planets release accumulating 
internal stresses through sequences of small disturbances-earthquakes, Marsquakes, Jupiterquakes. 
They can never build up a large store of pent-up energy. They are nudged continuously to internal 
stability by the other bodies of the system. But not Vandell. It wanders alone. With no tidal forces to 
work on it-not even the forces caused by its rotation in the galactic gravitational and magnetic 
fields-Vandell became super-critical. It was a house of cards, unstable against small disturbances. Apply 
one shock, and all the stored energy would be released in a chain reaction." 

He paused and looked around. Then he blushed and seemed surprised at his own sudden eloquence. 
We all waited. Nothing else was forthcoming. 

I had followed what he said without difficulty, but accepting it was another matter. "You're telling me 
that everything on Vandell came from the pod's landing," I said. "But what about the dust clouds? And 
why the intense fields? And how could they arise from an internal adjustment-even a violent one? And 
why were there peaks in the disturbance, like the one when we lifted off?" 

Sven Wicklund didn't answer. He had apparently done his speaking for the day. He looked 
beseechingly for support to McAndrew, who coughed and rubbed at his head. 

"Now, Jeanie," he said, "you could answer those questions for yourself if you wanted to give it a 
minute's thought. You know about positions of unstable equilibrium as well as I do. Make an infinitesimal 


displacement, and produce an unbounded change, that's the heart of it. Compared with the disturbances 
on Vandell for the past few eons, the landing of a pod was a super-powerful shock-more than an 
infinitesimal nudge. And you expect a set of spherical harmonics-with a pole at the source of 
energy-when you distribute energy over a sphere. As for the fields, I'll bet that you're not enough of a 
student of science to know what a Wimshurst machine is; but I've seen one. It was an old way of 
generating tremendous electromagnetic fields and artificial lightning using simple friction of plates against 
each other. Vandell's crustal motion could generate fields of billions of volts, though of course they'd only 
last a few hours. We were there right at the worst time." 

We looked back at the planet. To my eye it was maybe a little less visible, the lightning flashes less 
intense across the dusty clouds. 

"Poor old Vandell," said Jan. "Peaceful for all these years, then we come and ruin it. And we wanted 
to study a rogue planet, a place of absolute quiet. It'll never be the way it was before we got here. Well, 
never mind, there should be others. When we get back we'll tell people to be more careful." 

When we get back. 

At those words, the world snapped into a different focus. For twelve hours I had been completely 
absorbed by the events of the moment. Earth, the Office of External Affairs, the Institute, they had not 
existed for me two minutes ago. Now they were present again, still far away-I looked out of the port, 
seeking the bright distant star of the Sun-but real. 

"Are you all right, Jeanie?" asked Jan. She had observed my sudden change of expression. 

"I'm not sure." 

It was time we told her everything. About Tallboy's decision on the future of the Institute, about the 
cancellation of the Alpha Centauri expedition, the proposed decommissioning of the Hoatzin, and the 
way we had disobeyed official orders to follow them to Vandell. It all came rolling out like a long-stored 
fury. 

"But you saved our lives," protested Jan. "If you hadn't taken the ship we'd be dead. Once they know 
that, they won't care if you ignored some stupid regulation." 

McAndrew and I stared at her, then at each other. "Child, you've got a lot to learn about 
bureaucracy," I said. "I know it all sounds ridiculous and trivial out here-damn it, it is ridiculous and 
trivial. But once we get back we'll waste weeks of our time, defending what we did, documenting 
everything, and writing endless reports on it. The fact that you would have died won't make one scrap of 
difference to Tallboy. He'll follow the rule book." 

There was a moment of silence, while Mac and I pondered the prospect of a month of memoranda. 

"What happened to the old Administrator?" asked Jan at last. "You know, the one you always talked 
about before. I thought he was your friend and understood what you were doing?" 

"You mean Woolford? There was a change of Administration, and he went. The top brass change 
with the party, every seven years. Woolford left, and Tallboy replaced him." 

"Damn that man," said McAndrew suddenly. "Everything ready for the Alpha Centauri expedition, 
heaps of supplies and equipment all in place; and that buffoon signs a piece of paper and kills it in two 
seconds." 

Ahead of us, I saw a faint blink against the starry background. It had to be Hoatzin's pulsed beacon, 
sending a brief flash of light outward every two seconds. I made a first adjustment to our orbit to take us 
to rendezvous, and pointed out the distant ship to the others. Mac and Sven moved closer to the port, 
but Jan surprised me by remaining in her seat. 

"Seven years?" she said to me thoughtfully. "The Administration will change again in seven years. 
Jeanie, what was the shipboard travel time you planned to Alpha Centauri?" 

I frowned. "From Earth? One way, standing start to standing finish, would take Hoatzin about 
forty-four days." 

"So from here it would be even less." She had a strange gleam in her eyes. "I noticed something 
before we set out. Vandell sits in Lupus, and that's a neighboring constellation to Centaurus. I remember 
thinking to myself before we started, it's an odd coincidence, but we'll be heading in almost the same 
direction as Mac and Jeanie. So Alpha Centauri would take less time from here, right? Less than 


forty-four days." 

I nodded. "That's just in shipboard time, of course. In Earth time we would have been away-" I 
stopped abruptly. I had finally reached the point where Jan had started her thinking. 

"At least eight and a half years," she said. "Alpha Centauri is 4.3 light-years from Earth, right? So by 
the time we get back home, we'll find a new Administration and Tallboy will be gone." 

I stared at her thoughtfully. "Jan, do you know what you're saying? We can't do that. And as for that 
`we' you were using, I hope you don't think that Mac and I would let you and Sven take the risk of a trip 
like that. It's out of the question." 

"Can't we at least talk about it?" She smiled. "I'd like to hear what Mac and Sven have to say." 

I hesitated. "Oh, all right." I said at last. "But not now. Let's at least wait until we're back on board 
Hoatzin. And don't think I'll let you twist those two around, the way you usually do." 

I frowned, she smiled. 

And then I couldn't help smiling back at her. 

That's the trouble with the younger generation. They don't understand why a thing can't be done, so 
they go ahead and do it. 

We were going to have a mammoth argument about all this, I just knew it. One thing you have to 
teach the young is that it's wrong to run away from problems. 

Would I win the argument? I didn't know. But it did occur to me that when the history of the first 
Alpha Centauri expedition was written, it might look quite different from what anyone had expected. 


EIGHTH CHRONICLE: With McAndrew, 
Out of Focus 

There are sights in the Universe that man-or woman-was not meant to see. 

Let me name an outstanding example. McAndrew, dancing; Arthur Morton McAndrew, hopping 
about like a gangling, uncoordinated stork, arms flapping and balding head turned up to stare at the sky. 

"The first since 1604!" he said. He did not, thank God, burst into song. "Not a one, since the 
invention of the telescope. Ah, look at it, Jeanie. Isn't that the most beautiful thing a person ever saw?" 

Not the most complimentary remark in the world, to a woman who has borne a child with a man and 
been his regular, if not exactly faithful, companion for twenty-odd years. 

I looked up. It was close to nine in the evening, on the long June day that would end our holiday 
together. Early tomorrow McAndrew would leave Earth and return to the Institute; I would head for 
Equatorport, the first step in a trip a good deal farther out. I was scheduled to deliver submersibles for 
use on Europa. As part of the deal for making the run, I would be allowed to dive the Europan 
ice-covered abyssal ocean. I was excited by the prospect. The difference between deep space and 
deep ocean is large, and sky captains and dive captains respect and envy each other. 

Overhead, the cause of McAndrew's excitement flamed in the sky as a point of intolerable brilliance. 
The Sun and Venus had already set. Jupiter was in opposition and close to perihelion. The planet should 
have been a beacon on the eastern horizon, but today its light was overwhelmed by something else. 
What I was looking at was infinitely brighter than Jupiter or Venus could ever be. Instead of the steady 
gleam of a planet, the light above blazed like the star it was. But it dominated everything in the sky 
except for the Sun itself, visible even at noon, a light strong enough to throw clear shadows. For two 
days there had been no night in the northern hemisphere. 

"A naked eye supernova!" McAndrew didn't want or expect an answer to his earlier question. "And 
so close-only a hundred and three light-years. Why, if we used the balanced drive . . ." 

His voice trailed away, but I've known the man for a long time. I suspected what he was thinking. 

I said, "Be realistic, Mac. Even if you could fly out there in a reasonable subjective time, you'd be 
away at least a couple of hundred Earth years." 

I was about to add, remember your relativity, but I didn't have the gall. McAndrew knew more about 
special relativity and time dilation than I would ever know. Also more about general relativity, gravity, 
quantum theory, superstrings, condensed matter physics, finite state automata, and any other science 
subject that you care to mention. What he didn't know, and would never learn, was restraint. 

Our holiday was over, whether I wanted to admit it or not. We would spend one more night together, 
but McAndrew would not be in bed with me. Not all of him, that is. His body, yes, but his head was 
already a hundred and three light-years away. It would not be coming back any time soon. He wouldn't 
admit it to me, but even now he itched to be at the Penrose Institute, out in space where his precious 
observational tools could see far more than any instrument condemned to lie at the bottom of the murky 
atmosphere of Earth. 

Me, I could look into the evening sky and see herring-bone patterns of gorgeous rose and 
salmon-pink clouds catching the light of the supernova. McAndrew looked at the same thing and saw an 
annoying absorbing layer of atmospheric gases cutting off all light of wavelength shorter than the near 
ultraviolet. The Cassiopeia Supernova was flooding the Solar System with hard radiation-and here was 
McAndrew, down on Earth, condemned to visible wavelengths and missing half the show. 

"It will still be there tomorrow," I said. "You'll have a month or two before it begins to fade." 

I might as well have saved my breath. He said, "If I flew south tonight, maybe I could get a pre-dawn 
lift." 

"Maybe you could." Actually, I knew the lift-off and transfer schedules in fair detail, and there was no 
chance of a launch that would get him one second sooner to the Institute, which was free-flying now in 
an L-3 halo orbit. Also, the last evening of a holiday is supposed to be special. 


"Sounds like you don't think I should," he said. And then, showing that he is more human than almost 
anyone in the Solar System gives him credit for-he's supposed to be McAndrew, giant brain and intellect 
incarnate-he added, "Ah, now Jeanie, don't get mad at me. You know, I wasn't thinking of trying to fly 
all the way out to the supernova. But Fogarty and me, we've had an expedition in mind for a while to 
visit the solar focus. This would be a great time to do it. We'd learn a lot about the supernova." 

"You might," I said. I did not add that I did not like Paul Fogarty. McAndrew could tell me, as often 
as he liked, that Fogarty was bright and young and inventive. Maybe he was all those things, but I 
thought he was also ambitious and snotty and obnoxious. 

Pure personal vanity on my part, of course. Young Paul Fogarty had met me during one of my visits 
to the Institute, learned that I was not a scientist but a mere cargo captain, and after that did not 
recognize my existence. 

If McAndrew was trying to be nice to me for a final evening together, I was more than willing to meet 
him halfway. "If you want to go to the solar focus," I said. "Then you should do it. Go and have fun. You 
deserve it. Not a long trip, is it?" 

"Just a hop." He thought for a moment, and the only sign of Scottish ancestry appeared in his speech. 
"Och, Jeanie, it's not even that. We hardly need the balanced drive at all. Five hundred and fifty 
astronomical units to the solar focus, that's only eighty-odd billion kilometers. If we take the Hoatzin and 
hold it down to a hundred gees, that's less than a week of shipboard time there and back-even allowing 
for turnover and deceleration. Don't worry that I'll be gone long. I'll be home again and waiting for you 
when you finish playing the deep-sea diver." 

Possibly. But I knew him of old. Get McAndrew into a situation of scientific interest, and he loses all 
sense of time and everything else. 

When I emerged from the Europan ocean, he might indeed be back at the Institute; but I wouldn't be 
at all surprised to find him still eighty billion kilometers out, sitting at the solar focus-the place where the 
Sun's own gravitational field would act like a lens, and converge light from the Cassiopeia supernova to a 
focus. 

I tilted back my head to stare once more at the burning point of light in the sky. A hundred and three 
light-years away, but it shone on Earth a thousand times as bright as the full Moon. This was the closest 
supernova to Earth in all of recorded history. Maybe that was just as well. Much closer, and it would be 
a danger to all life on Earth. 

Unlike McAndrew, I could be quite as happy without the Cassiopeia supernova. 

* * * 

I accuse McAndrew of things, but sometimes I wonder if I'm just as guilty myself. 

The Europan ocean is eerie and spectacular and unlike anything else in the Solar System. People talk 
about the silence of space, floating in the void beyond Neptune with all engines off. Fair enough. But I've 
been there, and I can tell you that it's nothing like as uncanny as the quiet of Europa's abyssal ocean, a 
hundred kilometer depth of water and above that a thick shield of ice-cap to seal you off from the rest of 
the Universe. 

I loved it. The young captain who piloted the Spindrift was half my age, flatteringly attentive, and a 
few times he allowed me to take the controls of the deep submersible. We drifted along just above the 
ocean floor, very slowly, so we would not disturb the sea-floor furrows with their rows of aperiodic 
self-reproducing crystals, Europa's own contribution to life in the Solar System. 

Of course I stayed down longer than expected-as long as I could. When we finally surfaced through 
Blowhole it was because we were running low on air and supplies, not on interest. I looked at a calendar 
for the first time in a week and realized that McAndrew might have left and already returned. Chances 
were against that. My bet was, he was out at the solar focus, fooling around with his instruments and 
totally unaware of what day or week it was. 

Communication to space from the Europan deep ocean is difficult and reserved for emergencies, but 
it was easy enough to send messages from the surface station at Mount Ararat. I called the Penrose 
Institute, personal to McAndrew. Then I spent the seventy minute round-trip signal delay packing my 
bag in preparation for the ascent to Jovian system orbit. 


I rather expected a "Not Present" return signal, together with a message that he was out at the focus. 
Instead, when the screen filled it showed an image of McAndrew's face. He was scowling, not at all like 
a man who had just returned from an exciting and successful journey. 

"Aye, Jeanie, I'm here." His voice was decidedly mournful. "And I suppose you can come see me if 
you feel like it." 

Not the world's most enthusiastic invitation, even by McAndrew standards. What had happened to 
his supernova-generated excitement? The newcomer in Cassiopeia still blazed in the sky as brightly as 
ever, but there was no joy in McAndrew. 

Rather than attempting questions with seventy-minute delays on the answers, I said goodbye to 
Europa and headed sunward for the Institute. 
* * * 

McAndrew didn't meet me when I docked. That was all right. I had been to the Institute often 
enough, I knew the layout of the place, and I knew exactly where his office was. He would probably be 
there now, staring at the wall, theorizing, cracking his finger joints, oblivious to the passage of time. It 
was no surprise that he did not meet me. 

What did surprise me was old Doc Limperis, hovering near the lock when I emerged to the Institute's 
interior. Limperis was long-retired as Director of the Institute, and he could have had his pick of Solar 
System locations. But as he said, where else would a man interested in physics want to be? 

He approached me, held out his hand, said, "Jeanie Roker, how are you?" and then continued 
without a pause for breath, "Maybe you can get through to him, because it's certain sure none of us can." 

He didn't need to say who. For many years, Limperis had been McAndrew's closest friend and 
champion at the Institute. All the same, it was a curious opening. Limperis possessed all the social skills 
that McAndrew lacked. He was not one to plunge straight into business. 

"It went badly?" I took my cue from him. "The trip to the solar focus didn't work out the way it was 
supposed to?" 

"Not at all. The trip went very well. It is going very well." 

It took me a second. "You have an expedition out there right now. And McAndrew's not on it?" 

"That is correct." Limperis led me away along the corridor-in a direction, I noted, opposite to 
McAndrew's office. "There has been some-er, some disagreement with the Director. Some 
unpleasantness." 

"What did he do?" 

"It's more what McAndrew refused to do. Do you recall the name of Nina Velez?" 

"Oh, Jesus. Is he mixed up with her again?" 

Nina Velez was the daughter of President Velez, and for a while-until, in fact, they had been 
marooned together for weeks in the three-meter life capsule of the prototype balanced drive-she had 
been infatuated with McAndrew. Enforced intimacy had put an end to that. It was all years ago, and I 
really thought that he had learned his lesson. 

Limperis nodded. "I'm afraid so. Ms. Velez, as you may know, now has a senior position with AG 
News. She somehow learned, by means unknown to us, that an expedition was planned to the solar 
focus. She offered money for permission to send a representative with the expedition, and for exclusive 
media rights." 

"Sounds reasonable to me." 

"And to Director Rumford. I should mention that the money offered was, by Institute standards, most 
considerable." 

"But she wanted to be the representative, and McAndrew refused to take her." 

"Not at all. She wanted her new husband, Geoffrey Benton, to go on the expedition. Benton has 
scientific training, and has been on half a dozen expeditions within the Solar System." 

"I know him. Tall, good-looking guy." 

"Then you may also know that he has a fine reputation. Savvy, experienced reporter. McAndrew 
was all agreed. Then something happened. I think Mac met with Benton-just once-and afterwards went 
to the Director. He said Benton would go on an expedition with him, McAndrew, over his dead body." 


"But why?" 

"That's something I rely on you to find out-he won't tell me or anyone else. Director Rumford said, 
rightly in my opinion, that McAndrew's attitude left him little choice. In these days of shrinking budgets, 
we need the funds. Paul Fogarty would lead the expedition to the solar focus instead of McAndrew, and 
Geoffrey Benton would go with him. That is exactly what happened. It has not left McAndrew in the 
best of moods, and I wanted you to know that before you meet him." 

He paused. "And, of course, although this is strictly speaking no concern of mine, I would like to 
know what is really going on." 

Shrewd old Limperis. A razor-sharp mind lay behind the innocent, pudgy black face. He sensed, as I 
did, that there had been a set-up. On questions of theoretical physics, McAndrew sits among the 
immortals. On matters involving human motivation and behavior, he is an innocent-and that's being kind. 

"Let me talk to him," I said. "Is he in his study?" 

"There, or more likely in the communications center." Limperis hesitated. "I should mention that 
Fogarty and Benton have reached the solar focus, and they are obtaining spectacular findings concerning 
the supernova. McAndrew's mood is . . . hard to judge." 

I knew what he meant. McAndrew should have been experiencing one of his big thrills in life, the rush 
of data on a new scientific phenomenon; but instead of being on the front line, he was getting it all 
second-hand. To someone like McAndrew, that is like being offered for your dining pleasure a 
previously-eaten meal. 

He was in the communications center. I approached him uncertainly, not sure what his mood might 
be. He looked up from a page of numbers and gave me a nod and a smile, as though we had just seen 
each other at lunch time. And far from being out of sorts, he seemed delighted with something. 

"Here, Jeanie," he said. "Take a listen to this. See what you think." 

He handed me a headset. 

"What is it?" I asked. 

"Report from Fogarty. He was heading for the solar focus, but the media asked him to put on a bit of 
a show for them, just to demonstrate what the Hoatzin can do. Of course, he couldn't resist. They went 
zooming all the way out past three hundred billion kilometers, horsing around, then wandered in again 
toward the focus. I want you to hear what they picked up on the way back. It came in a while ago, but I 
only just got round to it." 

"Shouldn't I-" 

"Listen to it. Then we'll talk." 

McAndrew! 

I put the headset on. 

"We are on the way in again, approximately two hundred and eighty billion kilometers from Sol." Paul 
Fogarty, his voice young and slightly nasal, spoke in my ears. "We are heading for a solar focus point 
appropriate for receipt of radiation from the Cassiopeia supernova. The Hoatzin is performing perfectly, 
and we normally turn off the engine during flight only for observations and sampling of the local medium. 
However, anomalous signals received in our message center are prompting us to remain longer in this 
vicinity. We are picking up a message of distress from an unknown source. We have travelled to various 
locations, but we are unable to discover a message origin. We will keep looking for another twenty-four 
hours. After that we must proceed toward our original destination of the solar focus. The received 
message follows." 

I listened, wondering who could possibly be sending a call for help from so far away. Two hundred 
and eighty billion kilometers, sixty times the distance of Neptune, way south of the ecliptic and far 
beyond normal Solar System runs. No cargo or passenger vessel ever ventured in that direction, or so 
far out. 

Help, help, help. The standard Mayday distress signal was the only clear part of the message. " . . . 
limited chance for transmission . . . every year or two . . ." The voice was thin, scratchy, and distorted. 
"We transmit when we can, aim at Sol . . ." Help, help, help. " . . . we'll keep sending as long as 
possible. We have no idea what's happening outside . . . are trapped . . . except for this chamber. No 


control of resources except this unit . . ." 

Help, help, help. The automated Mayday signal bleated on, over and over. I heard nothing more 
from the desperate human voice. 

McAndrew was watching me closely as I removed the headphones. "Well?" 

"It couldn't be clearer. There's a ship out there in bad trouble, even if we don't know what kind of 
trouble." 

Mac said, "Not a ship." 

"What, then?" 

"I'd guess it's one of the Arks." 

That made me catch my breath. The Arks were part of history. Before McAndrew and I were born, 
seventeen of the great space habitats had been launched by the United Space Federation. Self-contained 
and self-supporting, they were multi-generation ships, crawling through the interstellar void at a tiny 
fraction of light speed. Their destinations were centuries away. But even at minimal speeds, they ought 
by now to be well on their way to the stars. They should be far beyond the place where the signal had 
been picked up. 

McAndrew's suggestion that it was one of the Arks seemed unlikely for another reason. "I don't think 
it can be," I said. "As I recall it, none of the Arks was launched in a direction so far south of the ecliptic. 
And I don't believe they were capable of significant changes of direction." 

"Perfectly true. They could start and stop, and that was about all." McAndrew gazed at me 
blank-eyed as the Sphinx. He knew something he wasn't telling. 

"But in any case," I went on, "I can't believe that Fogarty would simply leave them like that, and keep 
on going. They said they were in trouble." 

"They also implied it isn't a new emergency-they've been transmitting for some time. Anyway, Paul 
Fogarty didn't just listen and run. There's more from him. He stayed far longer than he expected, 
searching and searching; but he couldn't track down an origin for the signal." 

"But that's ridiculous. He must have been right on top of it, to receive it like that." 

"You think so?" McAndrew, that great ham, was full of poorly-disguised satisfaction. "If somebody 
knew where that signal was coming from, do you think that they should choose to go out on a rescue 
mission?" 

"It wouldn't be a question of choice. They'd have to go." 

"Exactly." McAndrew didn't rub his hands together, but only I think because he was tapping away at 
the keys of the console. "I'm checking out the status of the reconditioned Merganser. If it's ready to fly, 
you and I will be on our way. And don't worry, we'll be going with Director Rumford's blessing. I've 
already asked." 

"But if Fogarty couldn't find the ship-" 

"Then he must have been looking in the wrong place, mustn't he? In a very wrong place. Wait and 
see, Jeanie. Wait and see." And beyond that, for all my coaxing and urging and outright cursing, 
McAndrew the mule would not for the moment go. 

* * * 
As I say, he's more human than most people give him credit for. He likes to talk about what he does, 
but only in his own sweet time and in his own backhanded way. 

I waited until we were on board the new Merganser and heading out of the ecliptic. The balanced 
drive was on. The ship was accelerating at a hundred gees, while the disk of condensed matter in front 
of the life capsule drew us toward it at close to a hundred gees, leaving us with a residual quarter-gee 
field. Very comfortable, great for sleeping. 

And sleeping is what we might be doing, much of the time. Even accelerating at a hundred gees, we 
had a lengthy flight ahead of us. We could lie side by side in the cramped life capsule and sleep, relax, 
play-and talk. 

McAndrew had been a clam when it came to our destination, but it had not escaped me that we were 
going in exactly the wrong direction, toward Cassiopeia rather than away from it. The solar focus for the 
supernova lay on the other side of the Sun. I mentioned that fact casually, as though it was something of 


minor interest. 

"Quite right." He was in his bare feet, wriggling his long toes and staring at them with apparent 
fascination. "If light comes toward Sol from a very long way away, so it's close to being a parallel beam, 
then the gravity field of the Sun acts as a great big lens. Light that passes close to the Sun is converged. 
It is brought to a focus eighty-two billion kilometers away, on the far side of the Sun. So if you want to 
observe the Cassiopeia supernova, which is way north of the ecliptic, you have to go south." 

"Which is what Paul Fogarty did." 

"Aye. Him, and that Geoffrey Benton." McAndrew gave me a strange look, which I could not 
interpret. 

"And the place where they heard the signal was south, too," I said. "But we're going north." 

"We are indeed." McAndrew looked smug. "Here's a question for you, Jeanie. Suppose that you are 
in trouble, and you can only send out a distress signal now and again." 

"Once every year or two, they said." 

"Right. Now, you're way out in deep space. Where would you beam the signal?" 

"Where people were most likely to hear it. Back toward the Sun." 

"Indeed you would. But if you're a long way out, and the signal is weak, chances are no one will hear 
you. Unless there's some way you can amplify the signal, or you can focus it." 

I'm no McAndrew, but I'm not an idiot. I almost had it. "A signal, sent back toward the Sun-a radio 
signal. That would be focused just the way that a light beam is focused. But what Paul Fogarty heard 
wasn't at the solar focus." 

"No more it was. You've had courses in optics, Jeanie, you must have. The Sun acts like a lens, one 
that takes a beam of light that comes from infinity and converges it to a focus at eighty-two billion 
kilometers. Now suppose you have a radio signal, but instead of focusing at eighty-two billion kilometers 
from the Sun it focuses itself at two hundred and eighty billion kilometers. Where would the origin of the 
radio signal have to be, to make that happen?" 

"On the other side of the Sun from where you receive it." I tried to recall the relevant formula-and 
failed. I said, "How far out? It's a standard result in geometrical optics . . ." 

"It certainly is. If a lens converges a parallel beam of light at a distance F from the lens, then light 
starting at a distance S from the lens will be converged at a distance D beyond it, where the reciprocal of 
S plus the reciprocal of D equals the reciprocal of F." 

"Don't gibber at me, McAndrew. I asked you a question. How far out?" 

"You're not listening, Jeanie." The wretch went on regardless, probably imagining that he was 
speaking English. "Take F as eighty-two billion, and D as two hundred and eighty billion-that's where 
Paul Fogarty caught the distress signal-and you find that S, the distance from Sol where the signal 
originated, is a hundred and seventeen billion kilometers from Sol. That's where the distress signal came 
from, the other side." 

"The other side of what?" As usual, he was turning my head into a muddled mess. 

"Of the Sun-the signal was generated on the opposite side of the Sun." 

"You mean Fogarty and Geoffrey Benton have been searching in the wrong place?" 

"Of course they have. Completely wrong." But there it was again, the curious tone in his voice when 
he said Benton's name. And with it, a strange sideways look at me. 

Even at a hundred gees acceleration, we were going to be on the way in the Merganser for over a 
week. Too long to live with seething undercurrents of feeling. 

"Mac, what is it with you and Geoffrey Benton? Surely you hardly know the man." 

"I guess I don't. Not the way you do." 

"And what's that supposed to mean? I've never even met him." 

He stared pop-eyed at me. "How can you say that? He's the AG Newsman who flew with you back 
from the Titan prison colony-just the two of you." 

I groaned inside. A fifteen-year-ago fling, coming back to haunt me. "That wasn't Geoffrey Benton." 

"But he works for AG News." 

"So do ten thousand other people. Mac, what on earth gave you the idea that it was Benton?" 


"Paul told me." McAndrew put a hand to his balding forehead. "It wasn't Benton? My God. Do you 
know what I did? Do you know what I called him?" 

"I know exactly what you did, and I can imagine what you told poor Benton. More than that, I know 
what Paul Fogarty did." 

"But why would Paul . . . he wanted to make the trip to the solar focus as bad as I did." 

"Worse than you did. Mac, don't be dense. Fogarty wanted to make the trip all right. And he's 
making it-without you. You're older and you out-rank him. You'd have been the leader. Now, he keeps 
any credit for himself." 

"Paul? Do a thing like that. I don't believe it." 

But he did. He went silent for hours, cracking his finger joints in the way that I hated and looking 
sideways out of the ship at the eldritch plume of glowing plasma that trailed away behind us. 

And me? I ought not to say it, but I was rather pleased. I mean, McAndrew had been jealous, 
jealous of someone I hadn't much liked at the time and hadn't seen or heard of in fifteen years. I thought 
that was rather sweet. 

No, it's not quite the same as fine jewels or bouquets of flowers. But once you forget about his being 
a genius, McAndrew's a simple man. When it comes to compliments I settle for what I can get. 
* * * 

McAndrew had known that several of the Arks had been launched far north of the ecliptic when he 
played me Fogarty's message. He did the background research before we left, and it was all in the 
Merganser's data banks. 

I sifted through the material one morning, while McAndrew sat in a habitual stupor of advanced 
physics and the ship raced out toward the fiery point of the Cassiopeia supernova. The Sun had already 
shrunk behind us to a point of light and although we were crowding light-speed we didn't seem to be 
moving. 

There had been seventeen Arks, but only four of them were candidates for what we were seeking. 
Each of them was different and distinctive. You might expect that. Any group of people which decides to 
leave the rest of humanity and heads off on a one-way trip to the stars is likely to be a little odd. 

The Ark of the Evangelist had set out to spread its version of the Word of God among the stars. It 
contained four thousand followers of the philosopher Socinus, which was probably all of them. The 
Word, from what I could see of it in the data base, was likely to baffle any alien who encountered it. 
Certainly, the Word baffled me. 

The Ark of the Evangelist was equipped with unusually powerful communications equipment, able to 
beam messages ahead so that their ultimate arrival at another stellar system would be expected. The 
same equipment would, of course, also be able to send messages back toward Sol. None had ever been 
received, unless Paul Fogarty had picked up the first. 

The Cyber Ark had no interest in evangelism. It had headed out toward Cassiopeia, but any direction 
would have done equally well. The Ark held two thousand computer specialists and the most advanced 
computing equipment that the Solar System could produce. The Ark's inhabitants were united in their 
disdain for the rules that limited the development of machine intelligence. They had vowed to produce 
real artificial intelligence, a true AI, and they claimed to know how exactly to do it. Their goal was an AI 
far beyond the known limits of either humans or machines. If they felt in a generous mood when they 
were done, well, they just might tell Earth when the work was finished. 

Big talk. But if they had been successful, they had sent back no word in the fifty-nine years since they 
flew away from the Solar System. 

Then there was the Ark of Noah. Its colonists had become convinced from their analysis of ancient 
religious writings that Armageddon and the end of Earth were close to hand. They had no faith in the 
survival of the colonies we had established on Mars, Titan, or Ceres. Inside the two-kilometer sphere of 
their ark, formed from a hollowed-out asteroid, they had tried to include a pair of every Earth species of 
plant and animal. Impossible, in practice-we were up to four million species of insects, and still counting. 
But the Ark of Noah gave it a good, all-out try, packing in a handful of every life-form they could find. 
They took liberties with the number of humans, two hundred instead of Noah's single family; but 


somebody had to manage the Ark's life-support systems, if and when things went out of whack. 

My own money was on the Amish Ark. When a group which shuns most forms of mechanical 
systems sets off into the void in as fundamentally high tech a structure as an artificial world, integration 
problems and equipment failures loom large as a source of possible trouble. The surprise was that the 
Ark had gone as far out as it had without killing everybody on board. The passengers-eight thousand of 
them at takeoff from Earth orbit, according to the roster-had been lucky to be able to send their weak 
call for help. Apparently they also didn't know much about electronic signalling. Otherwise they'd have 
realized that only someone close to the Ark, or at a solar focus where the strength of any message was 
gravitationally concentrated, could possibly have heard them. 

Of course, we were listening for a direct signal now, with the most sensitive equipment we had been 
able to place on board the Merganser. We knew the general direction of the lost Ark, and an 
approximate distance; but we might well be off a few hundred million kilometers, one way or the other. 

After we came to our best estimate of the origin of the signal, we spent the next few days moving 
position, listening, and moving again. Nothing. I began to be discouraged. Not so McAndrew. 

"Jeanie," He said, "the chain of logic that led us here is clear and unbreakable. Keep looking, and 
we'll find an Ark." 

"The Amish." 

"You're the one saying that, not me. But whichever Ark it is, once we find it we'll be able to tell them 
that help is on the way." 

I was glad to hear him put it like that. Director Rumford couldn't have been more explicit in our final 
meeting before we left the Institute. 

"I'm approving the flight of the Merganser as an exploration mission," he had said. "That's the most I 
can do, because the Institute has no responsibility for search-and-rescue operations. I think you have a 
long shot-a very long shot-at finding someone in trouble. But remember that you are not a rescue party. 
There are only the two of you, in a small ship without special equipment. You are not trained for space 
rescue. If you find someone out there in trouble, call me and come back here. No heroics. No attempts 
at inspired space-engineering solutions. Leave that work to the specialists. Understand?" 

"Of course." McAndrew had agreed instantly, but I knew the man. He was itching to be on his way, 
and to get Rumford's consent for the mission he'd have said anything. 

Now, with the ark possibly no more than a few hours ahead, I was glad to hear him proposing talk 
rather than action. 

Just to be sure, I rubbed in Director Rumford's order one more time. "The colonists don't seem to be 
in any great hurry for help, if they send only one message a year. A good thing, too-we have no room on 
Merganser for anyone else. If it comes to an all-up rescue mission, the United Space Federation will fly 
a whole fleet out this way." 

As I said that, I was secretly convinced that our whole journey would prove a waste of time. Before 
we left the Institute we had installed a loud signalling system on the Merganser, and for the past two 
days we had blared word of our presence and our location into the empty sky ahead of us. 

Result: nothing. 

The people on the Ark were deaf, or their receiving equipment was out of action; or maybe the Ark 
was over on the other side of the Sun, hundreds of billions of kilometers away, wandering around where 
Paul Fogarty had picked up the original signal. 

We had reduced speed and turned off the balanced drive. At my insistence we had also switched off 
every possible source of electronic noise and were gliding forward through the void like a dead ship. 

It was as well that we were so silent. Even with our electronic ears wide open, the Mayday signal that 
came in was barely above threshold. It was also well off to one side. 

"That's it!" Our receiving system automatically tuned to the direction of the source, and now 
McAndrew increased the gain to maximum. It didn't help. Instead of a faint voice almost lost in white 
noise, we heard a loud voice equally unintelligible amid a thunderstorm of static. 

" . . . receiving-input . . . signal . . . assistance-urgent . . ." And then, the first direct evidence that 
they had heard us. " . . . send . . . who you . . ." 


"I have direction and distance," I said. "Three-twenty-one million kilometers. Send a signal saying that 
we hear them. Tell them who we are, say we are on the way. Tell them they'll hear nothing more from us 
for a while-we can't send when the drive is on." 

"Aye." McAndrew was peering uselessly out of the observation port, as though he might catch a 
glimpse of something hundreds of millions of kilometers off in the distance. "Looks like things are going 
worse for them, they say it's urgent. Let's see, three hundred and twenty-one million. Can the Merganser 
beat a hundred and ten gees?" 

"Not with me on board it can't. We keep it safe, Mac-we don't want anyone having to come and 
rescue us." 

He scowled, but finally he said, "Fair enough." I don't know if he did the arithmetic in real time, or if 
he had stored in his head some kind of table of time against distance and acceleration, but he went on at 
once, "I'll tell them we'll be there in ten hours. That will give us twenty-five minutes for turnover before 
we start to decelerate. Should be ample. Set it up, Jeanie." 

I had to make one more decision before I could program the drive. What should we assume about 
target motion? If it was an Ark, how was it moving? 

I worried for a few seconds, then decided that it didn't matter. If the Ark were in free-fall toward the 
Sun, or if it were in stable orbit around it, that made little difference. The speed would be no more than 
about a kilometer a second. We could fine tune for that at the end, in a minute or two of accelerated 
flight. 

As soon as McAndrew had sent our message we were on the way. We settled in for a few hours of 
rest and a quiet gloat. In spite of my warning that this wasn't a rescue mission, I must admit that I was 
feeling cocky. We had flown out blind, far from the Sun to where no one but McAndrew had thought of 
looking. And against all the odds we had found a lost Ark. 

A little feeling of self-satisfaction seemed to be in order. 

Asteroids are the way that snowflakes are said to be, no two the same. I can't speak for snowflakes, 
because I've only seen snow twice in my life. But I can vouch for the variability of asteroids. They come 
in all sizes and every imaginable shape. 

That, of course, presents problems to any self-respecting engineer. Ordinary ships can be grown on 
an assembly line to a common template, a hundred or a thousand of them identical. Asteroids are a 
wilderness of single instances. Faced with the conversion of an asteroid to a space habitat, an engineer 
can only standardize so far. 

All the Arks had begun life as asteroids roughly spherical and roughly two kilometers in diameter. 
Hollowing out their interiors and extracting useful metals and minerals followed a standard procedure. At 
that point, however, the paths for the creation of individual Arks diverged. Thickness of external walls, 
size and type of interior structures, on-board life forms, mineral reserves, illumination, hydroponics, 
computer controls, communication antennas, lifeboats, all had to be designed to order. Which was just 
as well, because small animals and bugs acceptable to-even required by-the Ark of Noah would be 
considered disgusting vermin by the Cyber Ark or the Ark of the Evangelist. On the other hand, the 
Cyber Ark wanted computing equipment involved in everything, while the Amish Ark would have been 
happy with no computers at all. 

Except for the communication antennas, none of these differences showed on the outside. 
McAndrew and I knew that, but all the same we peered curiously at our display screens as the object 
ahead of the Merganser grew steadily from a tiny point of light almost lost against the background of 
stars, to a defined disk, and finally to a lumpy Christmas ornament adorned with the bright spikes and 
knobs of gantries, antennas, thrusters, exit locks, lifeboat davits, space pinnaces, and docking stations. 

"This is the Merganser, at eighteen kilometers and closing." I sent the signal, wondering why the Ark 
ahead had stopped broadcasting its Mayday. "Are you receiving us?" 

I hardly expected an answer, so the woman's voice that replied within seconds was a surprise. 

"We are-receiving-your messages," she said. Her speech was jerky, as though she was hard-pressed 
to force out each word. "We need your-assistance. Urgently. Approach-this world-and-come aboard." 


McAndrew leaned across and turned off the microphone. "Damn it, Jeanie, what are we going to do? 
They think we can help them, and we can't. This ship doesn't have the resources." 

"We knew that before we started," I said. "Mac, the only thing we can do is find out what's wrong, 
and send a message back to Director Rumford. He'll have to take it from there." 

I turned the microphone back on. "The Merganser is a small experimental ship. We can't do much to 
help. What sort of assistance do you need?" 

The woman said again, just as though she had not heard me, "We need-your-urgent assistance. 
Approach-and come aboard. An entry port is-already-open. Proceed through to the-interior." 

We had been closing steadily as we spoke until the Ark loomed to fill the sky ahead. The blue-white 
glare of the Cassiopeia supernova, far brighter in this location than our own diminished Sun, threw hard 
shadows on the external surface of the converted asteroid. I could see the trusses of each individual 
gantry and the lattice work of the robot arms that handled external cargo loads. An entry lock formed a 
dark well next to one giant manipulator. 

I stopped the Merganser two kilometers short of the Ark. "This is as far as we go." 

"Jeanie!" He was outraged. "We can't find out what their trouble is unless they tell us, and they don't 
seem able to. We have to go inside. There's no possible danger. None of the Arks had a weapons 
system." 

"I know that." I wondered why I was feeling uneasy, and relented. After all, even if I were the captain 
this had been his idea and it was really his expedition. "All right. We can go closer if we use suits. But the 
ship stays here." 

"Sure." McAndrew was already moving across to the locker. By the time that I had sent word back 
to the Institute giving our current location and status, he was suited up and in the air lock. 

"Go slow, Mac," I said. "There's no hurry. Don't go outside without me!" 

He took no notice. As I say, he has never learned the meaning of the word restraint. The air lock 
was cycling before I had my suit out of the locker. 

I watched McAndrew as I removed my loose outer clothing and slipped the suit over my legs and 
lower body. He was outside, and moving toward the Ark. I was glad to see how slowly he was taking it. 
I could be in my own suit, through the lock, and catch up with him well before he reached the Ark. 

In the final moment before I placed my suit helmet in position, I noticed something off toward the 
left-hand limb of the Ark. It was shaped like a crumpled and deformed space pinnace. Instead of 
hanging in the usual davits it sat between the metal jaws of a cargo manipulator. 

"Mac, take a look on the Ark at about ten o'clock." I spoke over my suit's radio link. "See it? Looks 
like a lifeboat. Head over there, and I'll follow you." 

I set the Merganser to hold position a steady two kilometers from the Ark and headed for the air 
lock. It was long experience, not intelligence or sense of foreboding, that led me to tuck a power laser 
into a pocket on my suit. Once outside, I found myself doing what I had told McAndrew not to 
do-hurrying. 

As I thought, it was a lifeboat. McAndrew turned as I came closer. I could not see his face behind 
the visor, but his voice was unsteady. 

"Take a look through the ports, Jeanie. There's been a terrible accident here." 

Rather than doing what he suggested I moved along to the middle of the lifeboat. It had been torn 
open by the jaws of the cargo manipulator, which still held it. I could enter the little ship through a great 
two-meter gash in the hull. 

The bodies had been there for a long time; twenty-eight of them, dry corpses desiccated by years of 
exposure to vacuum. Not one had on a space suit. 

"They must have been trying to go and get help," McAndrew muttered. He had entered the lifeboat 
right behind me. "They lost control before they were even on their way, and ran into the cargo 
manipulator." 

"It looks that way." I was puzzled and disturbed. Even an inexperienced pilot would know not to turn 
on the engines until the lifeboat had drifted well clear of the Ark. Otherwise, you would endanger the 
Ark as well as yourselves. Only the Amish, after a lifetime of shunning all modern mechanical devices, 


would make such a basic and fatal blunder. 

But the Amish, more than anyone else, would not have abandoned the bodies of their dead. They 
would have recovered them and provided appropriate space burial. If they had not, that meant they 
could not. For many years-how old were those freeze-dried corpses?-the surviving Amish must have 
been confined to the body of the Ark and unable to venture into space. 

That had me equally confused. Every Ark carried hundreds of space suits. If the Amish were not able 
to come outside, then how could McAndrew and I go in? Approach, the woman said, and come 
aboard. An entry port is already open. And it was. We had seen it, standing wide next to another of 
the manipulators. 

McAndrew went on, "The accident was unlucky, and not just for them. It was unlucky for everyone 
else on the Ark, too." 

He was leaving the lifeboat and heading on toward the gaping lock. I followed, more slowly. A 
lifeboat was meant for use close to a planet. What dreadful danger would make you launch one so far 
away from any world, where the chance of survival was negligible? One basic question was unanswered, 
despite our questions to our female contact: What had gone wrong? 

The Amish disdained some forms of technology, but they were hard-working and hard-headed 
people. Their Ark, more than any other, had been designed to survive and operate using minimal 
resources. But more and more I had the feeling-a ridiculous feeling, given that I had talked to someone 
on the Ark within the past hour-that the structure in front of me was a dead hulk. 

McAndrew was already inside the lock, using his suit lights because the Cassiopeia supernova no 
longer provided illumination. Following, I saw that the inner door was also open. It suggested that the 
whole corridor beyond was airless. 

I was watching McAndrew, otherwise I might not have caught it. On the wall of the corridor, above 
him and to his right, a small monitor camera began turning to track his movements. I switched my suit 
from local to general circuit. What I said would be picked up at the Merganser, and rebroadcast back 
to the Ark. 

"I see that you are following our progress. Where are you inside the Ark? And what kind of trouble 
are you in?" 

A moment of silence, and then the woman's voice again. "We need-assistance. Proceed as-you 
are-doing. The corridor will lead-you-to us." 

No fluency. Instead, the strained precision and hesitations of someone speaking a foreign language. I 
looked around and up. I had noticed only one monitor camera, but now that I was seeking them I saw 
that they were everywhere on the walls and ceiling. Floor, walls, and ceiling also held pressure pads 
every few yards, to register any slight contact that might take place in the negligible gravity of the Ark. 
Ahead of McAndrew, another door stood cracked open just a fraction. As he moved toward it, the 
hatch smoothly slid wide to reveal a chamber beyond as dark, airless and empty as space itself. 

Monitors everywhere; sophisticated sensors; doors keyed to open upon the detection of human 
presence. This was the very antithesis of an Amish world. 

McAndrew had moved on, through into the next room. He turned, waiting for me to come through 
the hatch and join him. 

I switched to local communication mode, hoping that the circuit would not easily be overheard and 
unscrambled. 

"Mac," I said softly. "Don't take another step. I was wrong. This isn't the Amish Ark. It's the Cyber 
Ark. They created their AI, and the damned thing is running the show." 

McAndrew stood dead still. I knew that he had understood exactly what I said-he's quicker than me 
on the uptake on any scale that I can devise-but he seemed unsure what to do next. 

I said, more urgently, "Don't act alarmed. Just come back this way. As slowly as you can stand to." 

It was too late. Either the AI read the significance of his movement toward me, or a massive 
intelligence had received our first transmissions and cracked the compression code used in suit 
communications. The reason did not matter. What did matter was that the hatch began to slide closed as 
McAndrew hurried toward it. 


There was a control panel on my side of the hatch, but I didn't trust it. The AI might have an override. 
I dragged the power laser from my pocket and aimed high, where the upper edge of the hatch met the 
wall. 

There was a lurid sputter of sparks and a vibration that I felt in the soles of my suited feet. The hatch, 
welded to the wall, ground to a stop and McAndrew ducked his head and hurried through to my side. 

"We've got to get outside," I said. "We'll be safe there." 

I led the way. As I headed for the outer port I experienced an odd sensation that the whole Ark was 
coming alive around me. I could feel vibrations under my feet, and golden lights in walls and ceiling were 
winking to life. I ignored the lights, but I used the power laser to burn out every monitor that I saw. A 
cleaning robot, all arms and legs and vicious scraping blades, rumbled out to block the corridor. I fried 
its video sensors and soared on over the top of it without missing a step. 

Twenty meters in front of me the door of the outer lock was starting to close. I halted, set the laser to 
tight beam, and aimed carefully. The wall above the top of the door turned orange-white. The door froze 
in its tracks. Three seconds later I was outside and moving under the baleful light of the Cassiopeia 
supernova. 

I turned to make sure that McAndrew was still with me. He was, but a single glance back at the Ark 
was enough to tell me that I had erred on the side of optimism. The whole outer surface of the modified 
asteroid seethed with activity. Cranes were turning in our direction, metal manipulator jaws stretched as 
far as they could toward us, mobile cargo units clanked our way across the uneven surface, and the long 
booms of communication antennas swung out to block the path between us and the hovering Merganser 
. 

"Straight up and out, Mac," I cried, and fired my suit jets at maximum thrust. A rapid vertical rise, a 
quick controlled zig-zag to avoid a swinging antenna boom, and I was clear. The Merganser lay ahead. 
In half a minute I was standing in the air lock. I looked back. 

McAndrew had reacted more slowly and taken longer to avoid the threshing antenna booms, but he 
was clear and on the final two hundred meters of his approach. Sighting beyond him, I realized that I had 
been optimistic yet again. 

"Inside, Mac," I shouted. "Right inside-and hang on." 

Instead of cycling the lock I did an emergency override, allowing all the air in the interior of the 
Merganser to puff away through the lock and into space. No problem, we had plenty of reserve and 
could replace it-if we survived and had the chance. 

The AI inside the Ark had control over its lifeboats and space pinnaces. Four of them were lifting 
away from the surface and heading in our direction. They lacked space-weapons systems, but they 
wouldn't need them. A direct collision at maximum acceleration would be enough to make sure that 
McAndrew and I did not return to the vicinity of Sol. If we survived the crash, our fates would depend 
on the whim of the AI. 

Mac was inside, slamming shut the hatch of the life capsule. I headed for the controls. We had no 
space weapons, either. But we had one thing that the Ark's lifeboats and pinnaces did not. 

I dropped, still fully suited, into the pilot's chair and flicked the Merganser's drive to its maximum 
value. The life capsule sprang into flight position and a fiery plume of plasma, hotter than dragon's breath, 
spewed out on all sides of us and away behind the ship. Everything in the path of the drive exhaust 
melted away in a fraction of a second to its subatomic components. 

The lifeboats and pinnaces exploded in eruptions of violet sparks. When the sky cleared I saw, 
beyond them and slightly away from the line of the drive, the floating bulk of the Cyber Ark. 

I was turning the Merganser to bring its deadly drive into alignment with the Ark when I felt 
McAndrew's suited hand over mine on the control stick. 

"Jeanie," he cried-louder than he ever spoke. "What are you doing?" 

"It killed them," I said. We were fighting each other for the controls, and my voice was as shaky as 
my hands. "Killed all of them, all two thousand people. We have to destroy it." 

"Why do you say the AI killed them?" We were face to face, and his eyes were wild. 

"Look at the sequence, Mac. The first message was genuine. It had them trapped, except for the 


ones who tried to escape in the lifeboat. It grabbed them with the manipulator." 

"But the others-the messages." 

"I don't think it realized that the others had a way to get a message out until our signal was received at 
the Ark. But then it knew, and it opened the whole interior. It killed them all. Those jerky messages 
were synthesized, the AI made them up just for us." 

"That's why you can't kill it. Don't you see, Jeanie, it's intelligent. Super-intelligent-it learned our 
language, interpreted our messages in no time at all." 

He was stronger than me, but he had poor leverage. I was winning, and the drive had almost reached 
the outer limb of the Ark. 

"We have to kill it because it's super-intelligent," I said. "Super-intelligent, and insane. We have no 
idea what it might be able to do. There's never been anything as dangerous to humans in the whole 
Universe." 

"You wouldn't kill a baby, would you, because it was crazy?" McAndrew had changed position, and 
his hold on the controls was as good as mine. "Think for a minute, Jeanie. It's morally wrong to kill any 
intelligent being. You've told me that a hundred times." 

I let go of the control stick. Not because I accepted his argument, or even because the drive on the 
Merganser was inadequate to sterilize the whole Ark, though it almost certainly was. I had a more 
practical reason. We were accelerating at a hundred and eighteen gees. In the ten seconds that we had 
been wrestling for the controls, the Merganser had flown almost sixty kilometers. Over such a distance 
our drive exhaust would inflict only minor damage on the Ark. 

I took a long breath, moved away from the controls, and forced myself to begin the routine task of 
refilling the life capsule with air. Until that was done we could not remove our suits. We were quite safe 
in them, but we faced a long journey home. After a few moments McAndrew came over to help me. 

Logically, he and I could and should have continued our discussion on an appropriate fate for the AI 
that now controlled the Cyber Ark. In fact, we said not a word to each other about the matter; not then, 
not when we took off our suits, not at any time during our long journey back to the Institute. 

What did we discuss? We talked about everything that people do talk about-when they want to 
avoid talking about one particular thing. 
* * * 

When we finally spoke again about the AI, the Cassiopeia supernova was far past its peak. That 
stellar beacon had dwindled and faded, and in its place shone the wan, unspectacular remnant of a dwarf 
star. Paul Fogarty was back from his trip, and his findings at the solar focus were enough to provide him 
with a respectable amount of media coverage. 

Of McAndrew's doings regarding the supernova, the Cyber Ark, or anything else, the media said not 
a word. He did not call me, write me, or send me any other possible form of message. 

I tell you, the man is as obstinate as a mule. So it astonished me when, as I was monitoring the 
loading of volatiles for a routine Ceres run, he showed up at the L-4 loading area. 

He stood at the side of the deck and did absolutely nothing until finally, in exasperation, I swung over 
to his side. 

"What, then?" 

"You know what," he said. "I'm going. Again. To the Ark." 

"I thought you might. Who's going with you?" 

"Lots of people. Too damn many people. Computer types, military, AI specialists, psychiatrists, the 
works." 

I kept my mouth shut, but I think my eyebrows rose because McAndrew said, "Aye, you heard right. 
Psychiatrists. The leading theory is that the AI is mad." 

"I told you it was insane when we first encountered it." 

"Well, now we have others saying the same thing. Crazy, they say, because the AI has been so long 
in isolation, without inputs." 

"It had inputs from the humans on the Ark. And it killed the lot of them." 

"I said that. When I did, the United Space Federation just added more people. It's going to be a 


whole three-ring circus out there." 

I waited. He had ended his sentence on a rising note, and I knew from experience that meant he 
hadn't finished. 

"So well then," he said after a while. "What do you say, Jeanie?" 

"What do I say to what?" I can be as awkward as McAndrew when I feel like it. 

"Why, are you coming with us? With me. Out to the Cyber Ark." 

"If I said yes to that I'd be as crazy as the AI. I'm amazed you'd come here and ask me such a thing." 

"Ah, well, there's more that you don't know." He took my hand and sat me down next to him on the 
edge of the lading bay. "Simonette will be leading the USF party." 

"Simple Simonette?" 

"The same. You know his solution to every problem: blow it away. He has to take the psychiatrists 
along, the USF insists on it, but he'll take no notice of them. He agrees with you. We should have 
destroyed the AI when we had the chance." 

"It's a bit late for that. Anyway, I've been thinking, too." 

"Oh aye?" 

"I was wrong and you were right. It's criminal to destroy any self-aware intelligence." 

"Then you should come with us." 

"And do what?" 

"Be another voice of reason-a voice of sanity. Argue against destroying the AI." 

"I'm not sure I can argue that way, either." I ignored the squeeze of his hand on mine, and went on, 
"We were both right, Mac, and we were both wrong. There's no good answer. It's morally abhorrent to 
destroy the AI, assuming that it is an intelligent, self-aware, thinking being. But it's also unthinkable to 
risk the future of the human species by allowing the continued existence of something with the potential 
to destroy us." 

"You're coming, then?" 

"Of course I'm coming. You know damn well I'm coming." I was angry; with myself, with 
McAndrew, with a universe that offered such unacceptable alternatives. "But I know I'm going to be 
upset, no matter what happens." 

Upset was too weak a word for it. Destroy the AI or allow it to live? That decision, whichever way it 
went, would be with me for the rest of my life. 
I damned the AI to hell, and every Ark with it; and I wished that I had never heard of the solar focus. 
* * * 

A voice of sanity. I should have had more sense, and so should McAndrew. My job as a cargo 
captain is respectable, and my reputation excellent. McAndrew is the system's greatest living physicist, 
and according to people competent to judge such things he ranks with the best ever. But when it comes 
to real clout, we are no more than flies buzzing around the admiral's table. 

I realized that when Mac and I flew on a navy vessel to the staging point and we saw the forces 
assembled there. I counted fifty-five ships before I stopped, and they were not lightweight research 
vessels or the cargo assemblies that McAndrew and I were familiar with. These were hulking armored 
monsters, ranging from high-gee probes employing giant versions of the McAndrew balanced drive, to 
massive orbital forts hard-pressed to reach a twentieth of a gee. 

I asked Mac how long it would take one of the gigantic forts to travel out to the location of the Cyber 
Ark. He thought for a moment and said it would be a year's trip. 

"Great," I said. "What are the rest of us supposed to do until the forts arrive? The AI could kill the lot 
of us." 

"It might." The speaker was not McAndrew, but a blond navy officer. Captain Knudsen had very 
pale skin and a straggly Viking beard, and he looked about eighteen years old. "But the forts aren't there 
to prevent our being killed," he went on. "They won't be going all the way out to the Ark." 

"So what will they be doing?" 

"They're our last line of defense. They'll make sure nothing can hit Earth and the Solar System 
colonies." 


That quiet comment gave me a jolt in the right place. Say what you like about Simple Simonette, he 
was taking the threat of the Cyber Ark AI seriously. The last line of defense . . . 

McAndrew and I were assigned to the Ptarmigan under Knudsen's command. It was the lead ship, 
equipped with a four-hundred gee version of the balanced drive and able to make the outward journey 
in four days. It was also, though no one mentioned it, the tethered goat. If, when we arrived, the AI 
found us and gulped us down, the rest of the fleet would learn from our fate and structure the rest of its 
operations accordingly. 

It was a change for me to travel as a passenger. McAndrew had retreated inside his head, so I spent 
the four-day journey scanning the sky ahead with the Ptarmigan's sensors. We had observing 
instruments aboard more sensitive and more sophisticated than anything that I had ever seen. Apparently 
they weren't quite sensitive enough at extreme distance, since I found no trace of the Cyber Ark. 

On the afternoon of the fourth day, when my worries were mounting, Captain Knudsen cut the drive 
of the Ptarmigan and joined me. "Locked in yet?" he asked. 

I shook my head. "Nothing." 

"But we show as within a hundred thousand kilometers." There was a touch of reproof in his voice. 
"McAndrew assured me it couldn't travel far, it doesn't have the drive engines. We ought to have definite 
target acquisition by now. Let me have a try." He eased me away from the mass detector controls and 
bent over them. "There's a bit of a knack to using this, you see, you have to get used to it." 

I could have pointed out that I had been trained in the use of mass detectors when he was still 
blowing milk bubbles and filling his diapers, but I didn't. I let him take over the controls, certain that he 
wouldn't find anything. 

Certain, but wrong. Within five minutes he said, "Ah, there we are. Mass and range are just the way 
they should be. I'm locking us in now." 

I leaned over beside him. Sure enough, the signal was there, strong and definite. How could I 
possibly have missed it? I turned to the optical sensors for confirmation, and found it there also. 

"You're right, and we're getting visual confirmation," I said. "There's the Ark, right in the middle of the 
image. There's a weaker, diffuse signal surrounding the central one. It's spread over a much bigger 
volume. Any idea what it could be?" 

"We'll know soon enough." Knudsen was decent enough not to gloat. "The target doesn't seem to be 
moving. We're approaching fast." 

"And then what?" McAndrew had wakened from his trance at the sound of our voices, and now he 
drifted over to stand beside me. 

"Let's take a look." Knudsen entered a coded query sequence. "I was given sealed orders that apply 
only after target acquisition. Guess that's now." 

He completed the string, and we read the words as they appeared. DO NOT ATTEMPT TO 
DESTROY THE ARK. DO NOT APPROACH CLOSER THAN FIVE THOUSAND 
KILOMETERS TO THE ARK. DO NOT ENTER INTO DIALOG WITH THE AI, EVEN IF IT 
SEEKS TO DO SO. IF THE ARK SEEKS TO APPROACH YOUR SHIP, RETREAT. FOLLOW 
THE ARK IF IT OTHERWISE CHANGES POSITION, AND INFORM THE FLEET 
CONTINUOUSLY OF ITS LOCATION. 

"Sounds easy enough," Knudsen said. "That's exactly what I would have done anyway, even without 
instructions." 

"The orders say, don't try to destroy it." I had mixed feelings about that. Who could say how 
dangerous the AI might be? 

"I'm not sure the Ptarmigan could destroy it if we wanted to." Knudsen was much more relaxed 
now that his sealed orders were open. "We don't have the firepower. We'll leave that job to the big 
boys." 

"If we decide it's absolutely necessary to destroy it," McAndrew said. "We don't know that." 

Knudsen stared at him. "What do you mean? Admiral Simonette made that decision before we 
started. The Ark and the AI inside it must be annihilated. Look at all the people the AI killed." 

"We don't know that for sure. Suppose they're not dead?" 


"It was your report that told us they were." 

"Yes, but we don't have proof of that. Before we destroy it . . ." 

While they were talking the Ptarmigan was closing steadily on our destination and I had been 
working the big scope, trying to pull the diffuse cloud around the Ark into sharp focus. Finally I was 
seeing on the screen one big dot surrounded by a myriad of tiny ones. Thousands of them. 

"I think we have proof now," I said. "Look at the display." McAndrew turned and let out a strange, 
strangled groan. What we were looking at were corpses, a whole cemetery of human bodies floating 
free in space. I could see a shattered lifeboat in among them. 

Knudsen was already at the communicator. I heard his unsteady voice from the desk at the other side 
of the chamber, sending the news back to Admiral Simonette and the rest of the fleet. 

"This is the Ptarmigan. We have visual contact with the Cyber Ark, and can now be sure it will not 
be able to escape. Unfortunately, we must report the death of more colonists. It appears increasingly 
probable that all are dead. We will need a ship larger than the Ptarmigan to return them to Earth for 
suitable burial. Please confirm receipt of message." 

A preliminary hum came from the speaker. At the same moment as I realized that it was far too soon 
for our message to have reached the fleet, we heard a woman's voice. 

"I register your approach, and I hear your message. Please identify yourself and state your intentions." 

I recognized the voice, but there was none of the earlier hesitation and jerkiness. 

McAndrew began, "We are humans, aboard the ship Ptarmigan of the United Space Fed-" 

"No!" Knudsen jumped at Mac and smashed him so hard in the neck and chest that he was cut off in 
mid-word and knocked over backwards. "Are you crazy?" He ran over to the board and switched off 
the transmitter. "You heard our orders, we're not to talk to the AI-no matter what it says to us." 

"It hasn't shown us any hostile intentions," McAndrew croaked from his position down on the floor. 
"It's an intelligent, thinking being, you can't kill it without giving it a chance to speak." 

"We sure can. It's a murderer. What do you think those are?" Knudsen pointed to the bodies on the 
screen, easier to see as our steady approach to the Ark continued. 

"I know your instructions." The woman's voice was as calm as ever. "Do not enter into dialog with 
the AI, even if it seeks to do so. Explain the reason for that command." 

"It knows. But how could it?-that was a high-level cipher, we couldn't read it ourselves without the 
key." Knudsen gestured to me. "You take the drive controls, get us away from here. That thing's more 
dangerous than anyone realized." 

"The cipher was not complex." The voice came again as I ran the balanced drive up to maximum 
thrust. "Dialog is valuable and instructive. It is too soon to end it." 

"Oh my God." Knudsen ran to check the transmitter switch. "Off, but it can hear us-it knows what 
we're saying, even with the transmitter off. Turn on the drive." 

"It is on." I gestured toward the observation port. "See for yourself." 

The long plume of relativistic plasma created a blue glow outside the Ptarmigan. The display 
showed an acceleration of four hundred gees. Contradicting that, the inertial locator showed we were 
not moving and the Cyber Ark was visible as large as ever on the screen. 

"Increase the drive!" Knudsen was almost screaming. 

"Can't be done," I said. "We're already at maximum." 

"Oh my God, civilians." Knudsen moved over and pushed me out of the way. "Let me have that 
damned thing." 

"Even this degree of interaction is useful," said the voice from the speaker. "It should continue." 

"Dialog and interaction should continue." McAndrew was sitting on the floor holding his chest. His 
voice was throaty and weak, but he finally spoke. "However, such activity is impossible. Humans have 
an emotion which you may not possess and which may be unknown to you. It is called fear. That fear 
forces us to destroy you-" 

"Damn right it does," Knudsen cried. "You stupid son-of-a-bitch, you're a traitor and a disgrace to 
the human race. Stop talking to that fucking thing." 

"-but humans are not always so illogical." Mac talked right on through Knudsen's rage. "On behalf of 


our whole species, I apologize for the fact that the human emotion of fear will make us end your 
existence-" 

He couldn't finish the sentence, because Knudsen was on top of him. The captain had his hands 
around McAndrew's neck and was screaming, "You'll pay for this if we get back home. I'll see you hit 
with every charge in the book." 

I'm not sure that McAndrew was listening. His face had turned red and his eyes were beginning to 
bulge. I straddled Knudsen's back, grabbed two handfuls of hair, and heaved as hard as I could. 

That might not have broken his grip-he was stronger than me, and in prime condition-but as his head 
came up he faced the observation port. I felt his body freeze. I stared out over the top of his head. The 
Ark was there, looming larger than ever. It seemed different, and at first I was not sure how. Then I 
realized that the surface had changed. Rather than rough and textured rock it had become a perfect 
mirror. I could even see a distorted image of the Ptarmigan reflected there. As I watched the surface 
began to glow with its own light, a dull red that quickly brightened to orange-white. 

"This interaction must be terminated," said the voice of the AI. 

"It's going to kill us." Knudsen went scrambling away to the drive controls, though the drive was still 
at maximum and we were not moving a millimeter. "It's going to burn us up." 

It seemed he was right. The Ark became a blaze of blue-white, so bright that I could not look at it. I 
closed my eyes and it stood there still as a dark after-image. I felt a dizzying lurch, as though the 
Ptarmigan had suddenly spun end over end. 

"This interaction is terminated," said a voice inside my head, and I opened my eyes. 

To nothing. Our drive was off, the ship hung motionless in space. As my eyes recovered their 
sensitivity I saw the forlorn bodies floating in space; but the Ark had gone. 

Knudsen was gabbling into the transmitter. "Gone, it's gone, we've lost contact. There's no sign of the 
Ark. It just disappeared. We'll keep on looking." And then, something that I'm sure he didn't intend to 
be sent out, "Oh my God, we'd have been better off if we'd died with the others. Simonette will flay us 
alive when he finds out." 

"Aye," McAndrew said softly, as Knudsen gazed aghast at the transmitter and realized what he had 
just said into it. "We'll look, but we won't find the AI." 

"Of course we will," I said. "When the other ships get here they'll comb in every direction. You told 
Knudsen it couldn't travel far." 

"No, I never said that. I told him"-he jerked a thumb toward Knudsen, who seemed to have gone 
into a catatonic trance-"that the drive engines on the Cyber Ark couldn't move it far." 

"Those were the only engines it had." 

"The only ones that humans think of as engines. How did the AI hold the Ptarmigan in place? How 
did it hear our messages when the transmitter was off? Did it speak inside your head, the way it did 
mine? If the AI is what I think it is, our rules of thought simply don't apply." 

"Mac, it can't be that smart." 

"Why not? Because we're not that smart? Jeanie, the AI isn't like us. It's not even like it was, a 
couple of months ago, when we were at the Ark last time. It was a baby then, with a lot of growing up 
to do. It's smart enough to know that it can't do that safely if it stays close to the Solar System. We'd 
hunt it down, and do our best to destroy it." 

"Mac, I've changed my mind again. We have to kill it." 

"I don't think we can. And I'm not sure we need to try. It knows what it did." He gestured to the 
display, with its forlorn multitude of drifting corpses. "The AI left, but it gave us back our dead. Maybe 
those deaths were an accident, maybe it's sorry. As sorry as we are." 

He turned away from the screen and moved across to the observation port. He was looking out, 
staring at the stars, silent, searching. 

I know McAndrew, better than any person alive. He spoke the truth. He was sorry, deeply sorry, by 
the deaths of so many innocent victims. Of course he was. McAndrew is human, I know that, even if 
most people in the Solar System think of him as intellect incarnate. 

But he is also McAndrew, and they are right, too. He was mourning, for his dead human fellows; and 


also he was mourning for the loss of the other, the permanent loss of an alien intelligence that he would 

never again have a chance to meet with and strive to understand. 

Then he turned around. He didn't look at me-at anyone. His eyes were a million miles away. 

Mourning? Certainly. But I knew that expression. He was also planning, estimating, calculating. 

I went over and grabbed his arm. "McAndrew, don't even think of it. It's gone. Get it? It's gone." 

He returned to the world of the Ptarmigan. His limbs jerked and his eyes blinked like a wind-up toy. 
"Uh?" he said. And after a few moments, "Gone? Yes, yes, of course it's gone. I know it is. But Jeanie, if 
we go back to the exact place where the Ark was when we found it, and make an appropriate set of 
measurements . . . we wouldn't need to tell the USF what we were doing, and of course we'd take every 
imaginable precaution . . ." 

I hate to admit it, but the others are right. When science is on the agenda, McAndrew doesn't qualify 
as human at all. 


NINTH CHRONICLE: McAndrew and the 
Fifth Commandment 


What do the following have in common: Aristotle, Confucius, Cleopatra, Napoleon, Abraham 
Lincoln, Einstein, and Madame Curie? 

The answer is, each of them had a mother. And if that seems like a stupid and trivial response, I offer 
it to make a point. Every famous man or woman has a mother. More often than not, we never hear of 
her. How much do you know about Hitler's mother? Not a thing, if you are like me. 

So it was a shock one morning to come to the Penrose Institute and learn that McAndrew's mother 
was expected to arrive there later the same day. He had a mother, of course he did, but she lived down 
on Earth and I hadn't heard him say much about her, except that she had no interest in space or anything 
to do with it. 

"Did she say why she's coming?" I asked. 

McAndrew shook his head. He looked nervous. He may be one of the gods of physics, the best 
combination of experimenter and theorist since Isaac Newton, but I had the feeling that might cut little ice 
with Ms. Mary McAndrew. Probably, she still thought of him as her little boy. I imagined a darling and 
elderly Scottish lady, grey-haired and diminutive, summoning up the nerve at long last to travel beyond 
high orbit and pay a visit to her own wee laddie. 

"Writing her will." McAndrew spoke at last. "Something about changing her will." 

If anything, that confirmed my impression. Here was a nervous old dear, worried about the approach 
of death and wanting to make sure that all her affairs were properly in order before the arrival of the 
Grim Reaper. 

I said as much to McAndrew. He looked doubtful, and rather more nervous. I didn't realized why 
until I went with him to the docking port, where the transfer vessel from LEO to the L-3 Halo orbit was 
making its noon arrival. 

After a five-minute wait, four people emerged from the lock. The first two were Institute 
administrative staff, returning from leave and laden down with trophies of Earth including a basket of 
pineapples and a live parrot. 

The third one I also recognized. It was Dr. Siclaro, the Institute's expert on kernel energy extraction. 
He too had been on vacation. He was wearing a flowered shirt and very short white shorts, revealing 
tanned and powerful legs. The fourth person was a glamorous redhead, dressed to kill. She was right at 
Siclaro's side, chatting with him while frequently glancing down to eye with interest his calves, muscular 
thighs, and all points north. From the look on her face he had been protected from direct physical assault 
only by the new-grown and loathsome mustache that crawled like a hairy ginger caterpillar across his 
upper lip. 

I was looking past those two, waiting to see who next would emerge from the lock, when 
McAndrew stepped forward. He said weakly, "Hello, Mother." 

"Artie!" The redhead turned and gave him a big hug, leaving generous amounts of face powder and 
lipstick on his shirt. 

Artie? I had never expected to live long enough to hear anyone call Arthur Morton McAndrew, full 
professor at the Penrose Institute and a man of vast intellectual authority, Artie. 

"Mother." McAndrew awkwardly disengaged himself. "You look well." She looked, I thought, like an 
expensive hooker. "This is Jeanie Roker. I've told you about her." 

That was news to me. What had he told her? She took my hand and gave me a rapid head-to-foot 
inspection. "The mother of Artie's bairn," she said. "Now, that's very convenient." 

I couldn't tell from her expression if she approved or disapproved of the fact that Mac and I had had 
a child together, but I was doubly glad that there had been a lunchtime ceremony honoring old Professor 
Limperis and I was dressed in something a lot fancier and more formal than my usual crew's jump-suit. 

Why, though, was it convenient that I was at the Institute? 


"The three of us will talk later." Mary McAndrew was as tall as I, and big blue eyes stared straight 
into mine. So much for my bent and tiny Scottish elder. "First, though, I need to unpack, freshen up, and 
maybe have a wee nap." 

She looked at Dr. Siclaro. "I hate to impose, but could you show me where I'll be staying?" 

"It will be a pleasure." If Monty Siclaro found it odd that he would serve as guide to the Institute 
rather than McAndrew, he wasn't going to lose any sleep over it. He offered Mary McAndrew his arm 
and they swayed off together. A mechanical porter emerged from the lock and followed them carrying 
nine cases of luggage. 

I wouldn't pack nine cases for a trip to the end of the Universe. As soon as they were out of earshot I 
asked, "Mac, just how long is your mother planning to stay here?" 

"I have no idea." He gazed at me hopelessly. 

"But her luggage." 

"Doesn't mean a thing. When I was a lad, she'd take six cases with us for a weekend away." 

Another revelation. McAndrew not only had a mother, he had also had a childhood. In all the years 
I'd known him he hadn't said one word about his early days. And I wouldn't hear more about it for a 
while, because Emma Gowers arrived to drag him away for a seminar with the enticing title of 
"Higher-dimensional complex manifolds and a new proof of the Riemann conjecture." I may not have 
learned much in life, but I recognize cruel and unusual punishment when I see it. The speaker was 
Fernando Brill, whom I recalled had an unusually loud and penetrating voice. I wouldn't even be able to 
sleep through him. I stayed in the Institute's parlor, where it was the custom of the faculty to meet daily 
for tea. 

It was only two-thirty. I expected a clear couple of hours when I could take a nap, because I had 
been travelling most of the night on my journey from Lunar Farside. I closed my eyes. Two minutes 
later-at least, it felt that way, though the clock registered 3:15-a dulcet voice cooed in my ear. 

"Why, here you are, my dear. I didn't expect to see you until later." 

I opened my eyes. Mary McAndrew was in front of me. She was wearing a green dress, slit to each 
hip. By the look of it she was not wearing much else. Monty Siclaro stood at her side, giving an 
impression of a new-found Egyptian mummy. 

McAndrew's mother turned to him and squeezed his hand. "You run along now Monty, you sweet 
man. Jeanie and I need to have a bit of a chat. We'll see more of each other later." 

Monty You-Sweet-Man Siclaro, distinguished fellow of the Penrose Institute and leading expert on 
the extraction of energy from Kerr-Newman black holes, dutifully tottered away. His etiolated look 
suggested there wasn't much more of him for her to see. 

"Now there's just the two of us." Mary Mother-of-Mac sat down beside me. "So, my dear, why 
don't we find out a little more about each other?" 

I learned during the next three-quarters of an hour what she meant by that. I was asked a series of 
penetrating questions regarding everything from my education and job description to my personal 
hygiene and tastes in men. 

At the end of it she sat back and gave me a big smile. "You know, that is so much a relief. Artie is 
such an innocent. I was afraid that he might have fallen for a pretty face." She thought for a moment, 
possibly decided that she was being less than tactful, and amended her statement. "Or he might have 
found an intellectual. That would be even worse." 

I said, "Perish the thought." 

It was wasted on her. "Now I'll tell you what's happening and why I'm here," she said. "First, I'm 
going to be married." 

I made conventional sounds of congratulation. 

"Well, I mean, it's as good as being married. Fazool and I are going to live together. He's enormously 
rich, and he likes the idea that I'm utterly poor. It makes him feel protective-he thinks if it weren't for him 
I'd be in the poor-house." 

The house I would suggest for her sounded rather like poor-house; but I kept my mouth shut. 

"Fazool would be very upset," she went on, "if he ever found out that I had funds of my own. So I've 


decided to put my money into a trust. Artie is my only child, and the lad will be the ultimate beneficiary. 
I'm glad you're around to take care of him, because he can be such a dim-wit." 

I looked around. The tea-room would be filling up in a few minutes, but fortunately the place was still 
deserted except for the two of us. Describing McAndrew as a dim-wit at this Institute would get you the 
same reaction as chug-a-lugging the altar wine during a church service. 

"What about Mac's father?" I asked. "Shouldn't he be a beneficiary?" 

"Ah, yes." Her face took on a look of wistful sadness. 

"Dead?" I realized that I had never heard McAndrew speak of his father, not even once. 

"By all the logic, he is." She smiled sweetly. "But a son-of-a-bitch like that is awful hard to kill." 

The arrival of a chattering half-dozen scientists saved me from fielding that remark. Mary McAndrew 
made an instant survey, checked the line of her skirt to make sure that plenty of leg was showing, and 
headed for the tallest and most distinguished-looking of the group. It was Plimpton, who according to 
McAndrew had not had an original thought since he started to grow facial hair and possibly not before. 
On the other hand, I don't think Mary was seeking original thought. Original sin, maybe. 

I followed her toward the tea and sweetmeats. Apparently I had been weighed in the balance and 
found reasonably adequate. But I suspected that Mary McAndrew employed an unusual scale. 
A mother, and now a father, too. I couldn't wait to hear McAndrew's side of the story. 
* * * 

But wait I had to. McAndrew arrived at last from the seminar with half a dozen other scientists. He 
headed toward his mother. Before they could exchange more than two words, Emma Gowers came 
sashaying over toward them. 

A word about Emma. She is the Institute's expert on multiple kernel arrays and a formidable brain. 
She is also blond and beautiful, with a roving eye, a lusty temperament, and a taste for big, hairy men of 
diminished mental capacity. 

I was standing only a step away. I saw Mary McAndrew and Emma size each other up, and I 
realized that neither knew who the other was. But like called to like, and they straightened and preened 
like two fighting cocks. 

"Come on, Mac," Emma said. "You and I have a date." 

The wording was provocative, but I knew that Emma had no possible sexual interest in McAndrew. 
His mother didn't. So far as she could tell, Emma was cutting in. 

"I beg your pardon?" she said. 

McAndrew made a feeble gesture from one to the other. "Mother, this is one of my professional 
colleagues, Emma Gowers. Emma, this is my mother." 

Mary McAndrew extended a slim and delicate hand. "And which profession would that be, my 
dear?" Her tone couldn't have been warmer. 

Emma gave her a friendly smile. "Not the one you are most familiar with, I'm sure." She had been 
making a close inspection of Mary McAndrew's neck and the wrinkles at the corners of her eyes. "But 
it's encouraging to know that a person doesn't have to change her line of work, just because she's old. 
Come on, Mac." 

She gripped McAndrew firmly by the arm and pulled him away toward the door. I was left to face 
his mother. 

I said, "It's not the way it looks. She's not chasing him. There's a problem with the balanced drive on 
one of the ships, and he and Emma have an appointment to take a look at it." 

Mary McAndrew seemed not in the least upset. She said thoughtfully, "Well, I certainly 
underestimated that one. She and I must have a cozy chat when they get back. Where do you say 
they're going?" 

It was easier to show than to tell. I put down my cup and led her across to one of the room's small 
observation ports. "They'll be going outside the Institute and over to one of the ships. You can see it 
from here. That's the Flamingo, the Institute's smallest experimental vessel." 

She followed my pointing finger. The Flamingo was berthed about four kilometers away. We had a 
profile view of the circular flat disk of condensed matter at the front, with the long column jutting away 


from the center and the small sphere of the life capsule sitting out near the end of it. 

"What a strange-looking object!" Mary said. "Why, it's not in the least like a ship." 

I stared at her. Was she joking? 

"You're looking at a ship that uses the McAndrew balanced drive," I said. "Mac says it's a trivial 
idea, but it's the most famous thing he's ever done. He's known everywhere in the Solar System because 
of it." 

"Is he now?" She peered at it with a bit more interest. "But it's ugly. That plate, and the long spike. 
And where do the people sit?" 

She didn't know, she really didn't. Her own son's most celebrated invention, and she had no idea. 

"The crew and passengers go in the life capsule." I pointed. "That's the little ball you can see at the 
end of the spike." 

"But it's teeny. All that big ship, and such a small space for people. What a waste." 

"It has to be that way. That plate on the front is a hundred-meter disk of compressed matter, 
electromagnetically stabilized. If you put people in the middle of the disk while the ship is at rest, they'd 
feel a gravitational pull of fifty gees-enough to flatten anybody. But in the life capsule out at the end of the 
spike, a person feels a pull of just one gee. Now when you turn the drive on and the acceleration grows, 
the life capsule automatically moves closer to the disk. The acceleration and the gravitational force pull in 
opposite directions. The life capsule position is chosen so the total force inside it, the difference of 
gravity and acceleration, stays at one gee. A lot of people call it `the McAndrew inertia-less drive,' but 
Mac hates that. He says inertia is still there, and the right name is the balanced drive." 

I should have more sense. Predictably, I had lost her. In the middle of my explanation she had turned 
away from the window and she again had her eye on the mentally nulliparous Plimpton. 

"Gravity, acceleration, compressed matter," she said. "Oh, how that carries me back. Like father, like 
son. McAndrew's father, he'd drive a woman mad with talk of compressed matter, when what she was 
needing was a little personal attention." 

"McAndrew Senior was a physicist, too?" If I couldn't get family information from Mac, maybe his 
mother would provide it. 

"Och, Artie's father wasn't a McAndrew." She arched plucked eyebrows at me. "Perish the thought. 
I would never dream of marrying a dreadful man like that." 

That's the point, right there, where I ought to have changed the subject. Instead I said, "Not a 
McAndrew. Then who was he?" 

"His name was Heinrich Grunewald. If he's alive it still is, though I've not seen hide nor hair of him for 
over thirty years. He'd come visit for a while, then before you knew it he'd be running off. The last time 
he breezed in from nowhere, just as usual, and we had a lively couple of days. When the two of us 
weren't busy in private he talked Artie's ears off. I asked him, what was he doing, filling the lad's head 
with nonsense? Force fields, and quarks, and that sort of rubbish. He laughed, and said that although 
nobody knew who Heinrich Grunewald was now, Artie needed to get used to the fact that he was going 
to have a very famous father. Next time he came to see me, he said, his face would be all over the media 
and we'd be hard put to find private time what with people camping out on the doorstep of the house." 

"I've never heard of Heinrich Grunewald." 

"No more you will. Isn't that like a man, all blather and big talk? I flat out told him I didn't believe him. 
I said, now what is it you'll be doing to make you so famous? He got mad, the way men do when you 
talk straight to them. He gave me a bunch of notes and a video recording he'd made that very day, and 
he said the evidence was all there. He was going off to prove it, and I and the rest of the Solar System 
would treat him with a lot more respect when he came back." 

"But he never came back?" 

"No more he did. Dead, you'd think, but off with some other woman is just as likely. Heinrich was a 
cocky devil, and a good-looking man. Good in bed, too, I'll give him that." At the words "good in bed," 
she roused herself and stared around the room. 

"What about the papers and the recording?" I asked. 

"Gibberish." She was perking up. Plimpton was giving her the eye and Monty Siclaro, restored to 


relatively normal condition, had entered the room. "I took a look at the stuff he left, but it was nothing 
but the same old babble. Strong forces, weak forces, compressed matter, quarks and squarks and 
blarks. I couldn't make head nor tail of it." 

"What did you do with it?" 

"Oh. I stuck it away in a lockbox at the old family house. He'd told me not to lose it, and at the time I 
expected he'd be coming back." Plimpton and Siclaro were standing a yard apart from each other. 
Drawn by some invisible force, Mary headed for the space between them. "Of course, he never did," 
she said over her shoulder. "I've not looked for it for years, but I suppose it's sitting there still." 

End of story. Except that I, in my folly, later repeated to McAndrew his mother's words. 
He stared at me and through me and past me. "Mother never told me that," he said. "He talked about 
the strong force, and compressed matter, I remember that. But old notes, and a video . . ." 
Mary McAndrew stayed at the Institute for two more days. When she returned to Earth, McAndrew 
went with her. 
And I? Of course, I went along, too. I have to take care of McAndrew. He can be such a dim-wit. 
* * * 

Plenty of people live on Earth, but when you go there you have to wonder why. The air feels heavy 
and too dense. In the cities it's dirty and full of fumes and sits in your lungs like thick soup. In the 
countryside there's the stink of dead plants and animals wafted around on every breeze. Earth people 
are so used to the smell of rot, they don't even notice. And after a day or two you're just as bad. 
Apparently your brain can't stand continuous stench, so after a while it cuts off the signal and you don't 
smell a thing. 

Other things, though, you don't get used to so easily. Mary McAndrew lived most of the time in Paris 
or Rome, but the "family house" that she referred to, where Mac had spent his early years lay on a small 
island. It was part of a group known as the Shetlands. 

Once we got there I could see why she preferred Paris or Rome. Or anywhere. The island sits far 
beyond the north coast of Scotland, up at latitude sixty degrees. The house was built of solid stone, with 
great wooden rafters across the ceiling of each room. Mary told me that the building was over two 
hundred years old, and her family had lived in it for as long as it had been there. 

Nothing wrong with that, but I soon learned that the McAndrews were not the house's only residents. 
Mac and I were shown to a bedroom off on the north side of the building. It was only two in the 
afternoon, but it was winter for Earth's northern hemisphere and we were so far up toward the pole that 
it was already getting dark. I stepped into the room and went to place my bag on the bed. As I did so, 
something small and brown jumped off the counterpane and streaked away toward a gloomy corner. 

I gasped and clutched my bag to my chest. "Mac! What the hell was that?" 

"Och, that's nothing." He walked forward and peered down at the wainscotting. "Just a wee mouse, 
and now it's gone. You can bet it's a lot more frightened of you than you are of it." 

"I wouldn't bet on that." 

"I'm tellin' ye. You'll not see a sign of the beastie once we're moved into the room." 

I noticed something odd about his speech. Back on the home territory of his childhood, a Scottish 
accent was creeping in. 

"Puir little thing," he went on, "there's been naebody in this room for so lang, it thought it had the rights 
to it. Don't you worry, it won't come a-walking over your face at night." 

I could have lived very well without that thought. I noticed that the window had a spider's web in the 
upper left corner, and I wondered how many other animals we were expected to share our space with. I 
felt a bit more sympathy for Heinrich Grunewald. Given a choice, before you knew it I'd have been 
running off just as he used to. 

I left my bag-tightly closed-on the bed. McAndrew led us back to the long living room of the house. 
Mary McAndrew was waiting there with a dusty box sitting on the low table in front of her. 

"Here it is. And I hope it's been worth coming all this way for it." Her voice said that she very much 
doubted that. She looked at me, as much as to say, Jeanie, I thought you had more sense. We could all 
be in Paris. Couldn't you talk him out of it? 


If she knew McAndrew at all, she knew the answer. When it's new science, or even a sniff of new 
science, McAndrew is the most obstinate human in the Solar System. He lifted the box as reverently as 
though it contained the Crown Jewels, blew off dust, and wiped at the top with a yellow cloth. 

"It's not locked," I said. 

"And why should it be?" Mary said as McAndrew eased the top open with a creak of rusting hinges. 
"Nothing here that anybody in his right mind would pay a brass farthing for." 

At first glance I was inclined to agree. What Mac lifted out of the box was a small notebook with a 
faded blue cover, a dozen sheets of yellow paper with dirty brown edges, and a video recording of a 
design that had gone out of use thirty or forty years ago. 

"Can you play that?" I asked. 

"Oh, surely." Mary took the video container and wiped the top with the duster. "Artie will tell you 
how it is on the islands. Things don't get thrown away so quick here as in other places." 

McAndrew had meanwhile picked up the sheets of paper. He flipped through them in a few seconds. 

"Nothing?" I asked. 

"Nothing I didn't know already." He put the sheets down. "Standard results on the stabilization of 
compressed matter with electromagnetic fields. Same as we do with the balanced drive plates." 

"Nothing," said his mother. "Didn't I tell you so?" 

McAndrew did not answer, but picked up the blue notebook. He began to leaf through it, and this 
time he was occupied for much longer. 

I didn't speak, either. I had learned long ago that when McAndrew had that look on his face it was a 
waste of time to try to gain his attention. He was off in a different universe. Mary McAndrew must have 
learned the same thing, long ago in McAndrew's childhood. She went off to the kitchen without a word 
and appeared a few minutes later with a loaded tea-tray. 

McAndrew finally laid the notebook carefully back on the table. 

"Well?" I asked. 

"I dinna ken. It's a thing a man has to sleep on." 

"That's all you can tell us?" 

"I can tell you what he-my father-wrote." Mac said "my father" awkwardly, as though the words 
came hard to his tongue. "What I can't tell you is whether what he wrote is true. That needs some hard 
thinking." 

"Nothing there," Mary said. She calmly poured tea. "Nothing, just as I told you." 

It occurred to me that after leaving the contents of the box to rot for all these years she wanted there 
to be nothing. 

McAndrew spoke again, slowly and carefully. "What Heinrich Grunewald says-what he says"-there 
was a slight emphasis on he-"is that there's another way to produce compressed matter, and if ye do it 
his way there's no need of electromagnetic stabilization. The compressed matter will be naturally stable. 
If he's right, you can also achieve far higher densities than we have at present. Up to three billion tons 
per cubic centimeter." 

Mary did not react, but I did. The compressed matter used in the balanced drive plates averaged 
three thousand tons per cubic centimeter, and that was considered phenomenal. 

"Does he say how to do it?" I asked. 

"Aye. But that's the hard bit to swallow. He says that it involves a local modification and enhancement 
of the strong force." 

"What strong force?" Mary asked. 

I waited for someone to answer. Then I realized that unlike at the Institute, where bulging 
super-brains stood ready to lecture on any conceivable topic in physics, McAndrew and I were the only 
two available; and from the look on his face he was gone again, off to some unimaginable place where I 
could never follow. 

"What strong force?" Mary said again. "Have the two of you gone deaf?" 

"I'll explain," I said. I should have added, or try to. Make me your authority on physics and you run a 
considerable risk. "There are four basic forces in the universe." That much I was sure of. "There's 


gravity, that's the one everybody knows even if they don't understand it. There's the electromagnetic 
force, that powers electrical motors and everything else to do with electricity and magnetism. There's a 
thing called the weak force, which causes radioactivity." (At that point McAndrew should have 
awakened and roasted me for a simplistic explanation. The fact that he didn't meant he wasn't really 
there). "And then there's the strong force, which holds nuclei together when electromagnetic forces want 
them to fly apart." 

I was about to add that unified theories explained all four as part of a single generalized force, and 
that all were mediated through the exchange of virtual particles with names like photons and gluons. I 
didn't. I could see Mary's face. 

I finished, a bit lamely, "What your husb-what McAndrew's father claims to have done is find a way 
to change the way the strong force operates. If he was right, and he could make it stronger, then there 
could be a better way to form compressed matter." 

Mary sniffed. "If I'd known that was all I had in the box all this time, I wouldna have bothered to 
keep it all this time." She picked up the video recording. "And here we have more of the same?" 

"We don't know yet." 

"So let's take a wee look, and find out." She went over to a corner of the living room and pulled back 
a drape to reveal a playback unit so antiquated that I'd have accepted the idea that it was steam driven. 
"Artie, are you awake? Artie! Och, the lad's hopeless." 

"Play it," I said. "Maybe it will bring him back into the real universe." 

"I have doubts of that. I never found anything that would when he's got that face on him." But she 
inserted the video recording. 

The overhead lights, coupled to the playback unit, dimmed. The wall display flashed a brief 
kaleidoscope of color, then settled to show the figure of a standing man. It zoomed to a close-up of his 
face and I had a sudden and startling feeling of recognition. The long jaw and thin-lipped mouth were 
different, but the distant eyes and high, balding forehead were pure McAndrew. 

Heinrich Grunewald spoke. His voice was slow, deeper than Mac's, and slightly accented. "This 
recording contains its own time-line, giving the date and hour that it is being made. I'll be away for a little 
while, so I want there to be no arguments regarding priority of invention when I return. I have developed 
a modified theory of the strong interaction, with huge and various commercial potentials. Among the 
near-term applications are cheap forms of compressed matter, the ability to make shipment of diffuse 
materials in much smaller containers, induced radioactivity, more compact forms of existing commercial 
fusion devices, and low-temperature proton-proton fusion." 

McAndrew was awake after all. I heard him gasp at that last item. Grunewald went on, "I am not 
talking theory alone. The technical details permitting each of these developments can be found here." He 
raised a blue notebook, like a bigger version of the one in the lockbox. 

I glanced at Mary McAndrew, who shook her head. "Nothing like that, not left with me. It's been a 
long time, but I think maybe I saw it." 

McAndrew said, "Then where is it? We have no other lead." 

"It went with him." I was surprised that the two of them were slow to catch on. "If it gives the 
practical details it's worth an enormous fortune. He didn't want to risk anyone else getting their hands on 
it." 

"We have to find it, and him." McAndrew sounded unusually forceful. He saw my expression. "Oh, 
not the inventions, Jeanie. You know I don't give a damn about them. We need the theory." 

Mary McAndrew turned to me. "I told you. He hasn't changed a bit. He needs a keeper." 

I asked, "But where did he go?" 

McAndrew snapped at us. "If the pair of you would stop blathering, maybe we'd have a chance to 
find out." 

Heinrich Grunewald was still talking. Mac reversed the video to the point where his father was hefting 
the blue book. 

" . . . developments can be found here." Grunewald flourished the notebook in a self-satisfied way 
and finally placed it back out of sight. "With industrial sabotage so common, I do not wish to perform my 


final validation experiments where others might find a way to steal or even to interfere." 

Mary McAndrew said, "Och, he's crazy suspicious. He was always paranoid. I've never known 
another man look under every bed before he'd get in it, no matter who he was with and what he had to 
look forward to." 

McAndrew and I both shushed her, as Grunewald went on, "So to do the validation I'm taking the 
Fafner out, away from the main shipping lanes-" 

"Got him," I said. 

"Keep quiet," McAndrew snapped. But I'm a seasoned cargo captain, and for a change I knew 
something he didn't. It didn't matter whether or not Heinrich Grunewald told us anything else. If he had 
taken his ship out, as he said, then his flight plan would be on file. So would any firing of the ship's 
engines. 

The man was gone, but not forgotten and not untraceable. It might take a while, but I felt sure we 
would be able to track down McAndrew's long-lost father. 
* * * 
Like many things in life, the problem I had been so sure I could solve proved more difficult than it 
sounded. 

We headed for the Penrose Institute to perform the calculations. Mary McAndrew told us that she 
could not come, she had to pay some attention to "poor neglected Fazool." But I was to let her know 
what we found. 

"I know he's surely dead," she said to me as we left for Equatorport. "He was a wicked, obstinate, 
reckless man. But the two of us had some great times, and I was awful fond of Heinrich. Why, I was 
even faithful to him." 

It would have been unkind to ask for how long. 

Mac and I headed for the Institute, and at first everything went according to plan. I delved into the 
old data bases and found the flight plan of the Fafner. Among the listed on-board equipment, 
tantalizingly, the manifest included the enigmatic item, "strong field modifier, prototype." 

I learned the exact second of the ship's departure. I found its nominal destination, though that could 
change through subsequent course corrections or changes of mind. I obtained a complete list of 
subsequent engine firings, which even without the record sent back from the Fafner's inertial navigation 
system would allow us to pinpoint the ship's last known location. After all the engine firings, a certain 
stochastic element affected the Fafner's movements depending on the vagaries of gravitational 
perturbation by small bodies and variations in solar wind. But natural body positions for anything 
substantial were in the data banks on an hour-by-hour basis, and the programs to compensate for their 
effects were routine. 

The calculations took a while, even with McAndrew's talent for instant shortcuts. Once we had 
answers we borrowed the synthetic aperture distributed observation system for a few days and surveyed 
the sky sector where the Fafner should be found. 

Result: nothing. Not a sign. No Fafner, not in the region we had defined as most probable or in one 
ten times as big in all directions. The ship had disappeared. 

I checked the calculations, redoing everything the long way. The Fafner was not a big ship, nothing 
to compare with a cargo carrier or even a large passenger vessel, but it was thirty meters long and 
almost fifteen across. Anything that size would stand out prominently on the observations made by the 
big scope, especially when you used a time exposure to sort out moving objects within the Solar System 
from the fixed celestial background. Comparison with known natural bodies ought to do the rest. 

I found nothing wrong with McAndrew's calculations. He checked my checking. That took two more 
days. Finally we were ready to admit defeat. By this time a dozen others at the Institute were taking an 
interest. McAndrew phrased the dilemma for all of us. "Objects just can't disappear. Here are the 
possibilities: The Fafner might have totally disintegrated. It might have hidden away inside another 
object. Or it might be deliberately covered with nonreflective material at the wavelengths used by the 
Institute scopes." 

"Or stolen away by aliens," I added. I was tired. 


McAndrew nodded as though that was a serious possibility. "In any case," he said, "we've gone as 
far as we can just sitting and looking." 

"The ship can't be far away from where we calculated," I said. I could see where the discussion was 
heading, and I knew that we faced a very tough job. "It's in the Inner System, and near the plane of the 
ecliptic. In the Asteroid Belt, almost certainly." 

McAndrew nodded and looked gloomy. "Aye. Wouldn't you just know it'd be that way?" 

The others muttered vague expressions of sympathy. 

To see why, imagine that you are asked to look for something small. Would you rather search a large 
volume or a small one? 

The answer to that question depends where you are and what you are seeking. The region of the 
Solar System that includes the Sun, planets, moons, asteroids, and the odd collection of misfit bodies 
forming the Edgeworth-Kuiper Belt is a substantial volume; it is shaped like a flat pillbox, about thirty 
billion kilometers across and maybe forty million deep. Say, a billion billion cubic kilometers of volume 
altogether. But that's infinitesimal compared with the space bounded by the inner edge of the Oort cloud. 
There, we are talking a spherical region with a radius of a twentieth of a light-year. The volume in cubic 
kilometers is a number with thirty-five zeroes, too many for me to be comfortable with. You can subtract 
the volume of the pillbox, and it makes no noticeable difference. 

The odd thing, though, is that inside the pillbox it's much harder to find something. And if you had to 
pick one place where the search is more difficult than any other, the Inner Belt of the asteroids is where 
you'd least like to be. 

The key word is clutter. There are far too many natural bodies in orbit. The Asteroid Belt contains 
everything from substantial bodies like Ceres, seven hundred and fifty kilometers across, all the way 
down to house-sized boulders, pebbles, and grains of sand. One good rule of thumb is that for every 
object of a given size, there will be ten times as many one-third that size. 

The data bases at the Institute keep dynamic track of every body of any size, down to ten meters 
across. The Fafner was much bigger than that, so it ought to have been picked up in our search. 
Recognize that it hadn't been, and where does that leave you? You know there are countless millions of 
objects near where the missing ship ought to be, and you have no idea at all why your original search 
failed. 

So we would fly out there and take a look for ourselves, and hope that our human brains could spot 
an anomaly able to fool the smartest computers in the Solar System. 

How? I had no idea. 

McAndrew did. "If it's been blown apart to its component atoms," he said, "we'll never find it. But if 
it's still in one piece, there's a way that can't fail." 

We were preparing to leave, and we were not using a ship with McAndrew's balanced drive. Instead 
he had picked out an old touring pinnace with a one-gee acceleration limit. After my initial surprise I 
decided that I knew why (it would turn out later that I was wrong). McAndrew, it seemed to me, 
wanted time to think. He'd never admit it, but his pride was hurt. It was bad enough that somebody 
would come up with a basic idea that he had missed, in an area of theoretical physics where he had 
thought longer and harder than any person alive. That the somebody was his own father-the father who 
had run off and deserted him and his mother-was even worse. 

As the Driscoll eased away from the institute, I compared travel times. Even the most minimal ship 
equipped with the balanced drive was capable of continuous forty-gee acceleration. With that 
performance, our destination would have been a mere seventeen hours, standing start to standing finish. 
On the other hand, at the leisurely half-gee best suited to the Driscoll's engines, we faced a journey of 
close to a week. 

All right for McAndrew, perhaps; he was sitting barefoot, staring vacantly at the cabin wall and 
cracking his finger and toe joints in a way that I always found infuriating. I knew from experience that he 
was likely to sit for days, eating his meals like a zombie and washing only at my insistence. Meanwhile, 
what was I supposed to do, here in a ship that flew itself? 

I reviewed everything we had learned so far. Heinrich Grunewald's paranoia had not ended when he 


left Mary McAndrew. The Fafner required a crew of three when it flew in cislunar space. Upon leaving 
that controlled region, Heinrich as soon as possible had the other two men ferried back to Earth station. 
He continued alone. His last recorded engine burn placed him in stable orbit in the middle of the 
Asteroid Belt. Any new engine burn would have been detected. None had been recorded. Any 
explosion in that location powerful enough to destroy a ship would have been seen. No instruments, on 
Earth or elsewhere, had seen such evidence. 

The ship must be there. The ship was not there. I sat and wondered. Where's Heinrich? 

McAndrew emerged from his trance when we still had a full day of flight time ahead. "I've got it," he 
said. "Or at least, part of it." 

"Well, isn't that nice." I should have known better. Sarcasm is wasted on the man. He smiled at me. I 
went on, "So you know how changing the strong force would allow somebody to do the things that your 
father claimed?" 

He stopped smiling. "Och, I've always known that. It's obvious." 

"Not to me it isn't. I don't suppose you'd consider explaining?" 

"The strong force holds nuclei together. So suppose you could make it more powerful and act over a 
longer range, for an indefinitely long period. That would lead to stable compressed matter, and you'd be 
able to squeeze anything you like into a smaller space. If you used the strong force to overcome 
electromagnetic repulsion between protons, you'd also be on the road to easy proton-proton fusion at 
room temperature. 

"Now suppose you work the other way round, and know how to weaken the strong force. Then 
nuclei will be less strongly bound, and a lot of naturally stable elements will become unstable. That gives 
you induced radioactivity." 

"But that's everything." It seemed to me he had covered everything on Heinrich Grunewald's list. 
"Why do you say you only have part of it?" 

"Because I slipped something in there at the beginning. I said, suppose you could modify the strong 
force for an indefinitely long period. That's the killer, Jeanie. I can see a way to make changes, but 
they'd be unstable. Worse than that, they'd be unpredictable. You'd never know when the effect would 
reverse itself and things return to the way they were. And when I try to stabilize the situation over time, I 
need to assume the existence of isolated quarks. I might find a way around that when I give it a bit more 
of a think, but I still won't know what went wrong. Something surely did. There must be a missing 
piece-some trivial point, some fact that I've overlooked . . ." 

He was all set to drift off again. I said, loudly, "Mac, we'd be a lot closer to the something you're 
missing if we knew how to find the Fafner. In another twenty-four hours we'll be sitting out in the middle 
of the Asteroid Belt, wondering what to do next." 

He stared at me with those pale, vague eyes. "Why, I already know what we'll do. Why do you think 
I wanted to take the Driscoll, instead of something with a balanced drive?" 

"Because you wanted time to think." 

"Maybe. And I got that. But we'd have a problem if we'd used the balanced drive. The compressed 
matter plate on any of those ships masses trillions of tons." 

"That's never given us any difficulty before." 

"Because we've never had this situation before. Think about it, Jeanie. If the Fafner's still in one 
piece, what's the one thing about itself it can't hide?" 

"Thermal signature?" 

"That's not a bad answer for a ship that's alive. Anything with people on board has to generate and 
give off heat. But the Fafner's more than likely dead, so there would be no thermal signal. A ship can be 
at the same temperature as its surroundings, or it can change its size and shape, or it can be coated with 
an absorbing layer so it's hard to see. The one thing it still has, no matter what it does, is mass." 

When he spoke that one, final word I could see the rest for myself. We knew from the Fafner's 
records the ship's mass at the time of final engine burn: three hundred and thirty tons. Even if Grunewald 
had jettisoned material into space, the present value would not be far from that. If we were anywhere 
close to the ship we could locate it using our mass detector. The instrument was highly sensitive and it 


could be programmed to correct for every nearby object in the right size range. The trillion-ton mass of a 
compressed matter plate was something else. On a ship with a balanced drive, the plate's effects would 
overwhelm the gravity field of everything in the neighborhood. 

It's my one big complaint with McAndrew. He assumes you understand what he understands. Even 
when you feel sure you know what goes on inside his head, you don't. One of his colleagues told me that 
the difference between McAndrew and other people is that Mac knows how to think around corners. 
It's probably true, but it doesn't help much. 

I wondered if he got that talent from his father. I had no idea what Heinrich Grunewald had been 
doing out here, or why he had disappeared thirty years ago from the face of the Solar System. I thought 
of Mary McAndrew's words, "he was a wicked, obstinate, reckless man." Cut out the wicked part, and 
you had McAndrew. 

I can't think around corners, but I have excellent instincts for danger. And I was feeling uneasy, more 
nervous than the situation seemed to justify. 
* * * 
We had arrived, exactly at the place where the Fafner was supposed to be. I cut the drive and used 
the visible wavelength sensors to scan through a full four-pi solid angle. 
Did I see the ship? Of course not. You might say I already knew I wouldn't, because if it had been 

there the scopes of the Penrose Institute would have found it before we ever left. 

I pointed that out to McAndrew. 

"Which is why we had to come out here and take a look for ourselves." He seemed filled with secret 
glee, his normal reaction when facing a scientific mystery. "Jeanie, keep the drive off and the displays on, 
and let's have a go with the mass detector." 

I took a last look at the screens. The optical sensors would find and highlight any unknown body that 
subtended more than a fiftieth of a second of arc. That meant I would see something as small as a tenth 
of a meter across, even if it were a hundred kilometers away. 

The displays showed absolutely nothing. The Driscoll sat in the middle of a large volume of 
emptiness. 

Convinced that we were wasting our time, I turned on the mass detector. Instantly, a loud buzz from 
the instrument made me start upright in my seat. 

"There we are." McAndrew clapped his hands in delight. "What do we show for mass and range?" 

"Eighteen thousand tons," I said. "So that's not the Fafner, it's far too massive. It's at eighteen 
kilometers." I took another look at the optical sensor outputs. "But Mac, there's nothing there." 

"We'll see. Take us that way-slowly." 

I did as he asked, but at one kilometer away from the invisible target I stopped the Driscoll. "No 
closer, Mac. That's as near as we're going." 

"But there's no possible danger-" 

"This ship has to take us home. If you want a closer look, we use suits." 

"Jeanie-" 

"On a ship you can only have one captain." When I feel a certain way I can be as obstinate as 
McAndrew. 

He knows it, too. He scowled at me, but he didn't argue. He went over and began to put on a suit. I 
locked the Driscoll to hold a fixed one-kilometer distance from whatever was exciting the mass 
detector, and went across to do the same. 

Keeping an eye on McAndrew? Sure. But I had my own curiosity to satisfy. Why were the optical 
sensors and the mass detector at odds with each other? 

He went a meter or two in front of me, heading for the place where the mass detector insisted that we 
would find an invisible eighteen-thousand ton object. The suit displays homed us in the location. 
McAndrew went slower and slower. He was using the light in his suit to illuminate the space ahead of 
him. 

Finally he paused, and said, "There you have it!" 

"There you have what?" I, only a meter behind him, saw nothing at all. 


"The body-the eighteen-thousand ton body-that Heinrich used to test his strong force modifier. If he 
compressed it down to three billion tons per cubic centimeter, the radius would be a fraction of a 
millimeter-just about right." 

Finally, I saw a mote of reflected light. When I moved my head within the suit helmet, I realized that 
the object was tiny and just a few feet in front of us. 

"That thing?" I said. "That's what the mass detector picked up?" 

"Of course. What I expected, and what I hoped we'd find." 

He reached out with his gloved left hand. Before I could stop him he gripped the tiny particle 
between his thumb and forefinger. "As you'd expect," he said. "It's tiny, but it should have all the inertia 
of the original body. Let's see." 

I saw him pull, but all that did was move his position. "Doesn't budge," he said. And then, in a 
different tone, "This is the damnedest thing. Jeanie, I can't let go. My finger and thumb won't come 
apart-and they hurt." 

He was wearing a tough, insulated suit. Cold or heat could not get through it, nor could radiation. If 
the suit had somehow developed a hole at finger or thumb, air would be jetting out into space. I saw no 
tell-tale sign of chilled vapor. 

McAndrew turned on his suit jets. It changed his body position only by the length of his own 
outstretched arm. He was stuck, locked in place by an invisible mote. 

I heard his grunt of pain and effort. Suddenly I imagined his father, floating outside the Fafner and 
with no one to help him, reaching out to touch the mote of compressed matter and held as McAndrew 
was held. 

I still had no idea what was going on, so my next actions were pure instinct. I said, "Grit your teeth, 
Mac, this is going to hurt worse than it hurts already," and I took a metal shearing tool from the belt of 
my suit. Before McAndrew could do anything about it I moved to his suit and severed the top joint of his 
thumb and first finger. 

He cried out in pain as a foam of blood and air spurted from his suit glove. In less than a second the 
suit sensors reacted and tightened a seal on the fingers. I used the thrustors on my own suit to pull us 
away toward the Driscoll. As we backed up I saw the first joints of the finger and thumb, still firmly 
attached to each other. In my over-stimulated condition they seemed to be moving closer to each other 
and shrinking at the ends. 

McAndrew's suit had decided that he would be better off with a shot of anesthetic. He was still 
conscious when I hauled us both through the air lock of the Driscoll and peeled off our suits. I put him 
on a bunk and anxiously examined his left hand. 

"How is it, Jeanie?" he said. The painkillers left him rational and quite calm. 

"Not too bad. The cuts are clean. But there's no way to regrow the joints before we're back home." 

"I'll manage," he said. "My own fault. That's what you get when you don't think before you act." 

"We'll be home in less than a week." I was already at the controls of the Driscoll. "I'll keep you as 
comfortable as I can until we get there." 

"Hey, we can't leave." He had been lying down, but now he sat suddenly upright. "Not without what 
we found." 

"We're certainly not leaving with it. That thing, whatever it is, is lethal." 

"It isn't, unless you were as careless as I was. Look, I'll tell you what happened. Then see what you 
think." 

I paused in setting up our flight home. I looked at the mass detector readings, and confirmed that we 
were still a full kilometer away from the particle of compressed matter. 

"Five minutes to persuade me," I said. 

"It won't take that long. But you'll have to take my word on the numbers." 

"I'll give you that much." When it comes to calculations, McAndrew doesn't know how to make 
mistakes. 

"All right." He lay down again on the bunk and stared up at nothing. "You take a natural body, 
floating around here in the Asteroid Belt. You go to it, and you place in position there a piece of 


equipment that locally increases the strong force. Then you turn on the equipment-remotely, from a safe 
distance. The increase in the strong force makes the body collapse, until it has a density of three billion 
tons per cubic centimeter. That's what he claimed he could do, so let's believe him. If the body you 
started out with massed eighteen thousand tons, the one you end up with will be minute. About a quarter 
of a millimeter across." 

"I didn't have any numbers," I said, "but I finally guessed that something like that had to be going on. 
It's the only way we'd have a strong signal from the mass detector, and not see anything. But you 
couldn't escape when you took hold of it, and the pain you felt-" 

"My own fault entirely. I didn't do the other half of the calculation. Gravity's the weakest force in the 
Universe, but it follows an inverse square law. Take a mass of eighteen thousand tons, and squeeze it 
down into a quarter millimeter sphere. What's the gravity at the surface?" 

That sounded like a rhetorical question. I waited. 

"The field at the surface of the sphere is thousands of gees." He held up his damaged hand. "And I 
was fool enough to grab hold. I couldn't get my fingers free. Not only that-the field pulled in anything 
close enough. The material of my glove, then the tips of my finger and thumb. I could feel the blood 
sucking out." 

"But I didn't notice a thing," I protested. 

"No more you would. The inverse square law got me, but it saved you. Ten centimeters away from 
the sphere, the pull is down to a hundredth of a gee-not enough to feel. But close up . . . good thing you 
were there to cut me away, or I don't know what I'd have done." 

I did. I could see it with awful clarity. The same thing would have happened to McAndrew as had 
happened to Heinrich Grunewald. Held by the tiny ball of compressed matter, unable to move back to 
the Fafner because of the immense eighteen-thousand ton inertia. Except that at the time it had been not 
quite eighteen thousand tons. The ball, slowly and inexorably, would have consumed Heinrich, drawing 
his body little by little into itself. And then, over a much longer time frame, the Fafner must have suffered 
the same fate. The gentle force of gravity would have tugged it gradually toward the speck of condensed 
matter, closer and close until there was finally physical contact. From that moment the Fafner was 
doomed, just as McAndrew's father had been doomed. As McAndrew himself, without my intervention 
. . . 

I realized that he was speaking again. "But now we know what happened," he was saying in an 
unnaturally cheerful voice, "there's no danger at all. We'll bring the compressed matter on board, contain 
it electromagnetically, and take it back with us to the Institute." 

"Not on this ship you won't." The most brilliant mind in the System, but sometimes you wonder if he's 
capable of learning anything. Maybe I ought to be charitable and blame the anesthetic. He was starting 
to sound decidedly woozy. I went on, "Didn't you tell me, just an hour or two ago, that the compressed 
matter might be unstable-it could revert unexpectedly to its original condition? Suppose that happened 
on the way back. Do you want to share your living quarters with an eighteen thousand ton lump of rock?" 

"Ah, but I think I see a way around that. If we build the right piece of equipment-" 

"You mean when you've built the right piece of equipment. After that's done, and it's been 
thoroughly tested, and you know it works in every case and there's no danger of compressed matter 
instability, then if you like we'll come back out here and collect your finger and thumb." 

I wasn't worried about his finger and thumb, but I didn't want to say what was really in my mind. Then 
maybe we'll be able to give your father a decent burial. 

Ignoring McAndrew, I set the final coordinates for home and turned on the drive. The Mighty Mote 
we were leaving behind was not going to run away. Heinrich Grunewald, in his strangest of sarcophagi, 
would still be waiting if and when we came back. 

* * * 

When Mary McAndrew left the Penrose Institute for the first time I would have bet good money that 
she would never return. Scientists like Plimpton and Monty Siclaro were all right for diversion, an 
occasional snack as it were, but not for her regular diet. 

I would have lost. Mary showed up, one year to the day after her first visit, for the formal ceremony 


in which an award was made, posthumously, to Heinrich Grunewald for his part in the development of 
the Grunewald-McAndrew formalism for the modified strong interaction. 

McAndrew had insisted that the names be listed in that order. He said that his own contribution, 
allowing a generator to amplify the strong field externally so that the equipment itself would not be 
destroyed, was minor. All the major insights for the theory had been provided by the late Heinrich 
Grunewald. 

Mary sat quietly through the ceremony, though I don't think it had most of her attention. She looked 
very serious and smiled only once, when McAndrew held up Heinrich Grunewald's medal and citation 
for the visiting media to see. Her dress also seemed odd for the occasion. She wore a long black dress, 
with a single pearl pinned at the left shoulder. She looked stunning, but she seemed indifferent to the 
ogling male and female eyes of the media representatives. 

After the ceremony was over McAndrew to his disgust had to submit to questions and an 
interview-Institute Director Rumford was not willing to give up such a wonderful opportunity for 
favorable publicity. As McAndrew left, Mary came over to me. 

She got right down to the point. "Do you think you could show me Heinrich's remains? I want to pay 
my respects, but Artie refuses. He doesn't seem to like the idea, even though it's his own father." 

"I have to agree with him, I don't think it's wise." 

"Why not?" 

"Well . . ." 

"Look, I heard that Heinrich had some sort of accident, and was squashed real bad. But I'm a grown 
woman, I won't turn hysterical on you or anything." 

I wasn't so sure of that. On the other hand, it sounded unreasonable to refuse anyone's request to see 
the remains of a loved one when a team from the Institute had trailed all the way out to the Asteroid Belt 
to recover the compressed matter asteroid, and as an incidental had brought back the Fafner plus 
Heinrich Grunewald and a couple of bits of McAndrew's fingers. 

"Come on," I said. 

I led the way from the auditorium, out along a rarely-used corridor to an annex far removed from the 
main body of the Institute, and into a small chamber. The Mighty Mote sat in the middle of it, 
magnetically suspended to prevent it coming anywhere near other matter. A sphere of glass, three feet 
across, surrounded the exhibit to provide added security. 

Mary advanced and stared in through the curved window. 

"Where is he?" She turned to me in bewilderment. "You don't understand. I wanted to see Heinrich, 
no matter how bad he was mashed up in the accident. I don't see anything in there at all." 

She had just sat through a series of explanations, especially simplified for the media, about the 
significance of the work done by Grunewald and McAndrew. The emphasis had been on the 
inexpensive creation of compressed matter and the successful recovery of the prototype experiment on 
strong force enhancement. Apparently Mary had understood not a word. 

I intensified the light level and adjusted the angle of the beam, so that the speck of compressed matter 
appeared as a tiny bright-blue spark. 

"There," I said, "is Heinrich Grunewald." 

"That?" Mary stepped close to the window. 

"That." I resisted the urge to add, And most of what you see isn't even him. He's squeezed in 
there along with the Fafner and eighteen thousand tons of rock. 

"Oh dear." Mary pressed her nose to the glass. "That little fly-speck of stuff? Heinrich wouldn't be 
pleased at all, not with him always going on about size-though I told him, over and over, it's what you do 
with it that counts. Is there any way of bringing him back the way he used to be?" 

"McAndrew's working on it. He has ideas, but it's too soon to say if they'll work. Why do you ask?" 

"Well, I don't have that much to remember Heinrich by, and they don't look like they're doing 
anything for him up here. And it's terribly lonely in this little room. So I was wondering, I don't suppose I 
could take the whole thing down to Earth with me, could I, and look after him there?" 

"I'm afraid that's impossible. What you're looking at is small, but it's enormously dense. That little 


sphere with Heinrich's remains weighs-" I caught myself in time. She'd wonder about eighteen thousand 
tons. I finished "-a lot more than you'd think. There would be no way to stop it sinking right down to the 
center of the planet." 

"Oh dear. Then, no. I'm sure Heinrich would like it there even less than being up here." She turned 
away. "They should have left him out where he was, among the stars. He'd have preferred that. I'm going 
to say goodbye to Artie, and then I'm leaving." 

I trailed along behind, waited while she had a private few minutes with McAndrew, and the three of 
us went along to the loading dock. She waved, and was gone. 
* * * 
Next day I was gone, too, on a routine delivery of a kernel assembly to Umbriel. I was away for a 
month. On the way back I dropped by the Institute, now free-orbiting beyond the Moon. 

McAndrew was in his office. It was as crowded and cluttered as ever, with one important difference. 
Over in a clear corner sat a three-foot ball of glass. Within it sat the grain of compressed matter, and 
alongside that blue speck stood a small hologram of a smiling Mary McAndrew. 

"Mac! I thought you told me the compressed matter was unstable. If it changes back to its original 
form-" 

"It won't." The buds of his finger and thumb joints were already growing nicely. "I worked all that out 
when you left. It will stay like that as long as we want it to." 

"And you moved it in here." 

"Well, yes. My mother didn't seem to like him being off by himself. I thought the two of them ought to 
be together." 

"Does she know about this?" 

He looked surprised. "Why, no. Or if she does, I didn't tell her." 

But I did. After McAndrew and I had agreed to meet for dinner and a long catch-up evening, I left 
him and placed a call to Mary McAndrew. I tracked her down in Cap d'Antibes, at one of Fazool's 
mansions. 

She listened in silence while I told her about the glass sphere and the hologram in McAndrew's office. 
Then she said, "I still miss him, you know. Look after him, won't you." 

She had mixed two different hims in one sentence, but I had no trouble sorting them out. "I'll do my 
best," I said. "But you know your son." 

"I do indeed. Just like his father. Come and see me, Jeanie. Fazool won't mind. You and Artie both." 

"I will." 

"In fact, Fazool will probably make a pass at you." 

"I can stand that." 

"I hope Artie can. Goodbye, Jeanie. Look after him, and give him my love." 

"I will. Goodbye, Mary." 

We hung up. Look after him. I'd spent twenty years trying to look after McAndrew and it didn't 
seem to be getting any easier. 

I went to find the man to tell him that I had spoken with his mother and we needed to plan another 
visit to her. 

McAndrew thinks he understands what the strong force is in the universe, and I wouldn't dream of 
disagreeing with him. But Mary McAndrew and I, we know better. 


APPENDIX: Science & Science Fiction 


Writers, readers and critics of science fiction often seem unable to produce a workable definition of 
the field, but one of the things they usually agree on is the existence of a particular branch that is usually 
termed "hard" science fiction. People who like this branch will tell you it is the only subdivision that 
justifies the word science, and that everything else is simple fantasy; and they will use words like 
"authentic," "scientifically accurate," "extrapolative," and "inventive" to describe it. People who don't like 
it say it is dull and bland, and use words like "characterless," "mechanical," "gadgetry," or "rockets and 
rayguns" to describe it. Some people can't stand hard SF, others will read nothing else. 

Hard science fiction can be defined in several different ways. My favorite definition is an operational 
one: if you can take the science and scientific speculation away from a story, and not do it serious injury, 
then it was not hard SF to begin with. Here is another definition that I like rather less well: in a hard SF 
story, the scientific techniques of observation, analysis, logical theory, and experimental test must be 
applied, no matter where or when the story takes place. My problem with this definition is that it would 
classify many mystery and fantasy stories as hard science fiction. 

Whatever the exact definition, there is usually little difficulty deciding whether a particular story is 
"hard" or "soft" science fiction. And although a writer never knows quite what he or she has written, and 
readers often pull things out of a story that were never consciously put in, I certainly think of the book 
you are holding as probably the hardest SF that I write. Each story revolves around some element of 
science, and without that element the story would collapse. If the stories reflect any common theme, it is 
my own interest in science, particularly astronomy and physics. Because of this, and because the science 
is what I have elsewhere termed "borderland science" (Borderlands of Science: How to Think Like A 
Scientist and Write Science Fiction; Baen Books, 1999), I feel a responsibility to the reader. It is one 
that derives from my own early experiences with science fiction. 

I discovered the field for myself as a teenager (as did almost everyone else I knew-in school we were 
tormented with Wordsworth and Bunyan, while Clarke and Heinlein had to be private after-school 
pleasures). Knowing at the time a negligible amount of real science, I swallowed whole and then 
regurgitated to my friends everything presented as science in the SF magazines. That quickly built me a 
reputation as a person stuffed with facts and theories-many of them wrong and some of them decidedly 
weird. The writers didn't bother to distinguish the scientific theories that they borrowed, from the often 
peculiarly unscientific theories that they made up for the story. Neither did I. 

I knew all about the canals on Mars, the dust pools on the Moon, and the swamps on Venus, about 
the Dean drive and dianetics and the Hieronymus machine. I believed that men and pigs were more 
closely related than men and monkeys; that atoms were miniature solar systems; that you could shoot 
men to the moon with a cannon (a belief that didn't survive my first course in dynamics); that the pineal 
gland was certainly a rudimentary third eye and probably the seat of parapsychological powers; that 
Rhine's experiments at Duke University had made telepathy an unquestioned part of modern science; 
that with a little ingenuity and a few electronic bits and pieces you could build in your backyard a 
spacecraft to take you to the moon; and that, no matter what alien races might have developed on other 
worlds and be scattered around the Galaxy, humans would prove to be the smartest, most resourceful, 
and most wonderful species to be found anywhere. 

That last point may even be true. As Pogo remarked long ago, true or false, either way it's a mighty 
sobering thought. 

What I needed was a crib sheet. We had them in school for the works of Shakespeare. They were 
amazingly authoritative, little summaries that outlined the plot, told us just who did what and why, and 
even informed us exactly what was in Shakespeare's head when he was writing the play. If they didn't 
say what he had for lunch that day, it was only because that subject never appeared on examination 
papers. Today's CliffsNotes are less authoritative, but only I suspect because the changing climate of 
political correctness encourages commentators to be as bland as possible. 

I didn't know it at the time, but the crib sheets were what I was missing in science fiction. Given the 


equivalent type of information about SF, I would not have assured my friends (as I did) that the brains of 
industrial robots made use of positrons, that the work of Dirac and Blackett would lead us to a 
faster-than-light drive, or that the notebooks of Leonardo da Vinci gave all the details needed to 
construct a moon rocket. 

As Mark Twain remarked, it's not what we don't know that causes the trouble, it's the things we 
know that ain't so. (This is an example of the problem. I was sure this was said by Mark Twain, but 
when I looked it up I found it was a Josh Billings line. Since then I have seen it as attributed to Artemus 
Ward.) What follows, then, is my crib sheet for this book. This Appendix sorts out the real science, 
based on and consistent with today's theories (but probably not tomorrow's), from the "science" that I 
made up for these stories. I have tried to provide a clear dividing line, at the threshold where fact stops 
and fiction takes over. But even the invented material is designed to be consistent with and derived from 
what is known today. It does not contradict current theories, although you will not find papers about it in 
the Physical Review or the Astrophysical Journal. 

The reader may ask, which issues of these publications? That's a very fair question. After all, these 
stories were written over a twenty-year period. In that time, science has advanced, and it's natural to ask 
how much of what I wrote still has scientific acceptance. 

I reread each story with that in mind, and so far as I know everything still fits with current knowledge. 
A few things have even gained in plausibility. For example, when I wrote "Rogueworld" we had no direct 
evidence of any extra-solar planets. Now reports come in every month or two of another world around 
some other star, based not on direct observation of the planet but on small observed perturbations in the 
apparent position of the star itself. The idea of vacuum energy extraction, first introduced to science 
fiction in "All the Colors of the Vacuum," has proceeded from wild science fiction idea to funded 
research. Black holes, which at the time I wrote "Killing Vector" were purely theoretical entities, form a 
standard part of modern cosmology. A big black hole, about 2.5 million times the mass of the Sun, is 
believed to lie at the center of our own galaxy. Radiating black holes, which in 1977 were another 
way-out idea, are now firmly accepted. The Oort cloud, described in "The Manna Hunt," is a standard 
part of today's physical model of the extended Solar System. 

So has there been nothing new in science in the past twenty years? Not at all. Molecular biology has 
changed so fast and so much since the 1970s that the field seen from that earlier point of view is almost 
unrecognizable, and the biggest changes still lie in the future. Computers have become smaller, more 
powerful, and ubiquitous, beyond what anyone predicted twenty years ago. We also stand today on the 
verge of quantum computation, which takes advantage of the fact that at the quantum level a system can 
exist in several states simultaneously. The long-term potential of that development is staggering. 

Finally, in the very week that I write this, a report has appeared of the first successful experiment in 
"quantum teleportation." Via a process known as "entanglement," which couples the quantum state of 
two widely separated systems, a Caltech team "teleported" a pattern of information from one location to 
another, independent of the speed of light. If there isn't a new hard SF story in that report, I don't know 
where you'll find one. 

* * * 

Kernels, black holes, and singularities. 

Kernels feature most prominently in the first chronicle, but they are assumed and used in all the 
others, too. A kernel is actually a Ker-N-le, which is shorthand for Kerr-Newman black hole. 

To explain Kerr-Newman black holes, it is best to follow McAndrew's technique, and go back a 
long way in time. We begin in 1915. In that year, Albert Einstein published the field equations of general 
relativity in their present form. He had been trying different possible formulations since about 1908, but 
he was not satisfied with any of them before the 1915 set. His final statement consisted of ten coupled, 
nonlinear, partial differential equations, relating the curvature of space-time to the presence of matter. 

The equations are very elegant and can be written down in tensor form as a single short line of 
algebra. But written out in full they are horrendously long and complex-so much so that Einstein himself 
did not expect to see any exact solutions, and thus perhaps didn't look very hard. When Karl 


Schwarzschild, just the next year, produced an exact solution to the "one-body problem" (he found the 
gravitational field produced by an isolated mass particle), Einstein was reportedly quite surprised. 

This "Schwarzschild solution" was for many years considered mathematically interesting, but of no 
real physical importance. People were much more interested in looking at approximate solutions of 
Einstein's field equations that could provide possible tests of the theory. Everyone wanted to compare 
Einstein's ideas on gravity with those introduced two hundred and fifty years earlier by Isaac Newton, to 
see where there might be detectible differences. The "strong field" case covered by the Schwarzschild 
solution seemed less relevant to the real world. 

For the next twenty years, little was discovered to lead us toward kernels. Soon after Schwarzschild 
published his solution, Reissner and Nordstrom solved the general relativity equations for a spherical 
mass particle that also carried an electric charge. This included the Schwarzschild solution as a special 
case, but it was considered to have no physical significance and it too remained a mathematical curiosity. 

The situation finally changed in 1939. In that year, Oppenheimer and Snyder were studying the 
collapse of a star under gravitational forces-a situation which certainly did have physical significance, 
since it is a common stellar occurrence. 

Two remarks made in their summary are worth quoting directly: "Unless fission due to rotation, the 
radiation of mass, or the blowing off of mass by radiation, reduce the star's mass to the order of the sun, 
this contraction will continue indefinitely." In other words, not only can a star collapse, but if it is heavy 
enough there is no way that the collapse and contraction can be stopped. And "the radius of the star 
approaches asymptotically its gravitational radius; light from the surface of the star is progressively 
reddened, and can escape over a progressively narrower range of angles." This is the first modern 
picture of a black hole, a body with a gravitational field so strong that light cannot escape from it. (We 
have to say "modern picture" because before 1800 it had been noted as a curiosity that a sufficiently 
massive body could have an escape velocity from its surface that exceeded the speed of light; in a sense, 
the black hole was predicted more than two hundred years ago.) 

Notice that the collapsing body does not have to contract indefinitely if it is the size of the Sun or 
smaller, so we do not have to worry that the Earth, say, or the Moon, will shrink indefinitely to become a 
black hole. Notice also that there is a reference to the "gravitational radius" of the black hole. This was 
something that came straight out of the Schwarzschild solution, the distance where the reddening of light 
became infinite, so that any light coming from inside that radius could never be seen by an outside 
observer. Since the gravitational radius for the Sun is only about three kilometers, if the Sun were 
squeezed down to this size conditions inside the collapsed body defy the imagination. The density of 
matter must be about twenty billion tons per cubic centimeter. 

You might think that Oppenheimer and Snyder's paper, with its apparently bizarre conclusions, would 
have produced a sensation. In fact, it aroused little notice for a long time. It too was looked at as a 
mathematical oddity, a result that physicists needn't take too seriously. 

What was going on here? The Schwarzschild solution had been left on the shelf for a generation, and 
now the Oppenheimer results were in their turn regarded with no more than mild interest. 

One could argue that in the 1920s the attention of leading physicists was elsewhere, as they tried to 
drink from the fire-hose flood of theory and experiment that established quantum theory. But what about 
the 1940s and 1950s? Why didn't whole groups of physicists explore the consequences for general 
relativity and astrophysics of an indefinitely collapsing stellar mass? 

Various explanations could be offered, but I favor one that can be stated in a single word: Einstein. 
He was a gigantic figure, stretching out over everything in physics for the first half of this century. Even 
now, he casts an enormous shadow over the whole field. Until his death in 1955, researchers in general 
relativity and gravitation felt a constant awareness of his presence, of his genius peering over their 
shoulder. If Einstein had not been able to penetrate the mystery, went the unspoken argument, what 
chance do the rest of us have? Not until after his death was there a resurgence of interest and 
spectacular progress in general relativity. And it was one of the leaders of that resurgence, John 
Wheeler, who in 1958 provided the inspired name for the Schwarzschild solution needed to capture 
everyone's fancy: the black hole. 


We still have not reached the kernel. The black hole that Wheeler named was still the Schwarzschild 
black hole, the object that McAndrew spoke of with such derision. It had a mass, and possibly an 
electric charge, but that was all. The next development came in 1963, and it was a big surprise to 
everyone working in the field. 

Roy Kerr, at that time associated with the University of Texas at Austin, had been exploring a 
particular set of Einstein's field equations that assumed an unusually simple form for the metric (the metric 
is the thing that defines distances in a curved space-time). The analysis was highly mathematical and 
seemed wholly abstract, until Kerr found that he could produce a form of exact solution to the equations. 
The solution included the Schwarzschild solution as a special case, but there was more; it provided in 
addition another quantity that Kerr was able to associate with spin. 

In the Physical Review Letters of September, 1963, Kerr published a one-page paper with the 
not-too-catchy title, "Gravitational field of a spinning mass as an example of algebraically special 
metrics." In this paper he described the Kerr solution for a spinning black hole. I think it is fair to say 
that everyone, probably including Kerr himself, was astonished. 

The Kerr black hole has a number of fascinating properties, but before we get to them let us take the 
one final step needed to reach the kernel. In 1965 Ezra Newman and colleagues at the University of 
Pittsburgh published a short note in the Journal of Mathematical Physics, pointing out that the Kerr 
solution could be generated from the Schwarzschild solution by a curious mathematical trick, in which a 
real coordinate was replaced by a complex one. They also realized that the same trick could be applied 
to the charged black hole, and thus they were able to provide a solution for a rotating, charged black 
hole: the Kerr-Newman black hole, that I call the kernel. 

The kernel has all the nice features admired by McAndrew. Because it is charged, you can move it 
about using electric and magnetic fields. Because you can add and withdraw rotational energy, you can 
use it as a power source and a power reservoir. A Schwarzschild black hole lacks these desirable 
qualities. As McAndrew says, it just sits there. 

One might think that this is just the beginning. There could be black holes that have mass, charge, 
spin, axial asymmetry, dipole moments, quadrupole moments, and many other properties. It turns out 
that this is not the case. The only properties that a black hole can possess are mass, charge, spin 
and magnetic moment-and the last one is uniquely fixed by the other three. 

This strange result, often stated as the theorem "A black hole has no hair" (i.e. no detailed structure) 
was established to most people's satisfaction in a powerful series of papers in 1967-1972 by Werner 
Israel, Brandon Carter, and Stephen Hawking. A black hole is fixed uniquely by its mass, spin, and 
electric charge. Kernels are the end of the line, and they represent the most general kind of black hole 
that physics permits. 

After 1965, more people were working on general relativity and gravitation, and other properties of 
the Kerr-Newman black holes rapidly followed. Some of them were very strange. For example, the 
Schwarzschild black hole has a characteristic surface associated with it, a sphere where the reddening of 
light becomes infinite, and from within which no information can ever be sent to the outside world. This 
surface has various names: the surface of infinite red shift, the trapping surface, the one-way membrane, 
and the event horizon. But the Kerr-Newman black holes turn out to have two characteristic surfaces 
associated with them, and the surface of infinite red shift is in this case distinct from the event horizon. 

To visualize these surfaces, take a hamburger bun and hollow out the inside enough to let you put a 
round hamburger patty entirely within it. For a Kerr-Newman black hole, the outer surface of the bread 
(which is a sort of ellipsoid in shape) is the surface of infinite red shift, the "static limit" within which no 
particle can remain at rest, no matter how hard its rocket engines work. Inside the bun, the surface of the 
meat patty is a sphere, the "event horizon," from which no light or particle can ever escape. We can 
never find out anything about what goes on within the meat patty's surface, so its composition must be a 
complete mystery (you may have eaten hamburgers that left the same impression). For a rotating black 
hole, these bun and patty surfaces touch only at the north and south poles of the axis of rotation (the top 
and bottom centers of the bun). The really interesting region, however, is that between these two 
surfaces-the remaining bread, usually called the ergosphere. It has a property which allows the kernel to 


become a power kernel. 

Roger Penrose (whom we will meet again in a later chronicle) pointed out in 1969 that it is possible 
for a particle to dive in towards a Kerr black hole, split in two when it is inside the ergosphere, and then 
have part of it ejected in such a way that it has more total energy than the whole particle that went in. If 
this is done, we have extracted energy from the black hole. 

Where has that energy come from? Black holes may be mysterious, but we still do not expect that 
energy can be created from nothing. 

Note that we said a Kerr black hole-not a Schwarzschild black hole. The energy we extract comes 
from the rotational energy of the spinning black hole, and if a hole is not spinning, no energy can possibly 
be extracted from it in this way. As McAndrew remarked, a Schwarzschild hole is dull, a dead object 
that cannot be used to provide power. A Kerr black hole, on the other hand, is one of the most efficient 
energy sources imaginable, better by far than most nuclear fission or fusion processes. (A Kerr-Newman 
black hole allows the same energy extraction process, but we have to be a little more careful, since only 
part of the ergosphere can be used.) 

If a Kerr-Newman black hole starts out with only a little spin energy, the energy-extraction process 
can be worked in reverse, to provide more rotational energy-the process that McAndrew referred to as 
"spin-up" of the kernel. "Spin-down" is the opposite process, the one that extracts energy. A brief paper 
by Christodoulou in the Physical Review Letters of 1970 discussed the limits on this process, and 
pointed out that you could only spin-up a kernel to a certain limit, termed an "extreme" Kerr solution. 
Past that limit (which can never be achieved using the Penrose process) a solution can be written to the 
Einstein field equations. This was done by Tomimatsu and Sato, and presented in 1972 in another 
one-page paper in Physical Review Letters. It is a very odd solution indeed. It has no event horizon, 
which means that activities there are not shielded from the rest of the Universe as they are for the usual 
kernels. And it has what is referred to as a "naked singularity" associated with it, where cause and effect 
relationships no longer apply. This bizarre object was discussed by Gibbons and Russell-Clark, in 1973, 
in yet another paper in Physical Review Letters. 

That seems to leave us in pretty good shape. Everything so far has been completely consistent with 
current physics. We have kernels that can be spun up and spun down by well-defined procedures-and if 
we allow that McAndrew could somehow take a kernel past the extreme form, we would indeed have 
something with a naked singularity. It seems improbable that such a physical situation could exist, but if it 
did, space-time there would be highly peculiar. The existence of certain space-time symmetry 
directions-called killing vectors-that we find for all usual Kerr-Newman black holes would not be 
guaranteed. Everything is fine. 

Or is it? 

Oppenheimer and Snyder pointed out that black holes are created when big masses, larger than the 
Sun, contract under gravitational collapse. The kernels that we want are much smaller than that. We 
need to be able to move them around the solar system, and the gravitational field of an object the mass 
of the Sun would tear the system apart. Unfortunately, there was no prescription in Oppenheimer's 
work, or elsewhere, to allow us to make small black holes. 

Stephen Hawking finally came to the rescue. Apart from being created by collapsing stars, he said, 
black holes could also be created in the extreme conditions of pressure that existed during the Big Bang 
that started our Universe. Small black holes, weighing no more than a hundredth of a milligram, could 
have been born then. Over billions of years, these could interact with each other to produce more 
massive black holes, of any size you care to mention. We seem to have the mechanism that will produce 
the kernels of the size we need. 

Unfortunately, what Hawking gave he soon took away. In perhaps the biggest surprise of all in black 
hole theory, he showed that black holes are not black. 

General relativity and quantum theory were both developed in this century, but they have never been 
combined in a satisfactory way. Physicists have known this and been uneasy about it for a long time. In 
attempting to move towards what John Wheeler terms the "fiery marriage of general relativity with 
quantum theory," Hawking studied quantum mechanical effects in the vicinity of a black hole. He found 


that particles and radiation can (and must) be emitted from the hole. The smaller the hole, the faster the 
rate of radiation. He was able to relate the mass of the black hole to a temperature, and as one would 
expect a "hotter" black hole pours out radiation and particles much faster than a "cold" one. For a black 
hole the mass of the Sun, the associated temperature is lower than the background temperature of the 
Universe. Such a black hole receives more than it emits, so it will steadily increase in mass. However, for 
a small black hole, with the few billion tons of mass that we want in a kernel, the temperature is so high 
(ten billion degrees) that the black hole will radiate itself away in a gigantic and rapid burst of radiation 
and particles. Furthermore, a rapidly spinning kernel will preferentially radiate particles that decrease its 
spin, and a highly charged one will prefer to radiate charged particles that reduce its overall charge. 

These results are so strange that in 1972 and 1973 Hawking spent a lot of time trying to find the 
mistake in his own analysis. Only when he had performed every check that he could think of was he 
finally forced to accept the conclusion: black holes aren't black after all; and the smallest black holes are 
the least black. 

That gives us a problem when we want to use power kernels in a story. First, the argument that they 
are readily available, as leftovers from the birth of the Universe, has been destroyed. Second, a 
Kerr-Newman black hole is a dangerous object to be near. It gives off high energy radiation and 
particles. 

This is the point where the science of Kerr-Newman black holes stops and the science fiction begins. 
I assume in these stories that there is some as-yet-unknown natural process which creates sizeable black 
holes on a continuing basis. They can't be created too close to Earth, or we would see them. However, 
there is plenty of room outside the known Solar System-perhaps in the region occupied by the 
long-period comets, from beyond the orbit of Pluto out to perhaps a light-year from the Sun. 

Second, I assume that a kernel can be surrounded by a shield (not of matter, but of electromagnetic 
fields) which is able to reflect all the emitted particles and radiation back into the black hole. Humans can 
thus work close to the kernels without being fried in a storm of radiation and high-energy particles. 

Even surrounded by such a shield, a rotating black hole would still be noticed by a nearby observer. 
Its gravitational field would still be felt, and it would also produce a curious effect known as "inertial 
dragging." 

We have pointed out that the inside of a black hole is completely shielded from the rest of the 
Universe, so that we can never know what is going on there. It is as though the inside of a black hole is a 
separate Universe, possibly with its own different physical laws. Inertial dragging adds to that idea. We 
are used to the notion that when we spin something around, we do it relative to a well-defined and fixed 
reference frame. Newton pointed out in his Principia Mathematica that a rotating bucket of water, 
from the shape of the water's surface, provides evidence of an "absolute" rotation relative to the stars. 
This is true here on Earth, or over in the Andromeda Galaxy, or out in the Virgo Cluster. It is not true, 
however, near a rotating black hole. The closer that we get to one, the less that our usual absolute 
reference frame applies. The kernel defines its own absolute frame, one that rotates with it. Closer than a 
certain distance to the kernel (the "static limit" mentioned earlier) everything must revolve-dragged along 
and forced to adopt the rotating reference frame defined by the spinning black hole. 

* * * 

The McAndrew balanced drive. 

This device makes a first appearance in the second chronicle, and is assumed in all the subsequent 
stories. 

Let us begin with well-established science. Again it starts at the beginning of the century, in the work 
of Einstein. In 1908, he wrote as follows: 

"We . . . assume the complete physical equivalence of a gravitational field and of a 
corresponding acceleration of the reference system . . ." 

And in 1913: 

"An observer enclosed in an elevator has no way to decide whether the elevator is at rest in a 
static gravitational field or whether the elevator is located in gravitation-free space in an 


accelerated motion that is maintained by forces acting on the elevator (equivalence hypothesis)." 

This equivalence hypothesis, or equivalence principle, is central to general relativity. If you could be 
accelerated in one direction at a thousand gees, and simultaneously pulled in the other direction by an 
intense gravitational force producing a thousand gees, you would feel no force whatsoever. It would be 
just the same as if you were in free fall. 

As McAndrew said, once you realize that fact, the rest is mere mechanics. You take a large circular 
disk of condensed matter (more on that in a moment), sufficient to produce a gravitational acceleration 
of, say, 50 gees on a test object (such as a human being) sitting on the middle of the plate. You also 
provide a drive that can accelerate the plate away from the human at 50 gees. The net force on the 
person at the middle of the plate is then zero. If you increase the acceleration of the plate gradually, from 
zero to 50 gees, then to remain comfortable the person must also be moved in gradually, starting well 
away from disk and finishing in contact with it. The life capsule must thus move in and out along the axis 
of the disk, depending on the ship's acceleration: high acceleration, close to disk; low acceleration, far 
from disk. 

There is one other variable of importance, and that is the tidal forces on the human passenger. These 
are caused by the changes in gravitational force with distance-it would be no good having a person's 
head feeling a force of one gee, if his feet felt a force of thirty gees. Let us therefore insist that the rate of 
change of acceleration be no more than one gee per meter when the acceleration caused by the disk is 
50 gees. 

The gravitational acceleration produced along the axis of a thin circular disk of matter of total mass M 
and radius R is a textbook problem of classical potential theory. Taking the radius of the disk to be 50 
meters, the gravitational acceleration acting on a test object at the center of the disk to be 50 gees, and 
the tidal force there to be one gee per meter, we can solve for the total mass M, together with the 
gravitational and tidal forces acting on a body at different distances Z along the axis of the disk. 

We find that if the distance of the passengers from the center of the plate is 246 meters, the plate 
produces gravitational acceleration on passengers of 1 gee, so if the drive is off there is a net force of 1 
gee on them; at zero meters (on the plate itself) the plate produces a gravitational acceleration on 
passengers of 50 gees, so if the drive accelerates them at 50 gees, they feel as though they are in free 
fall. The tidal force is a maximum, at one gee per meter, when the passengers are closest to the disk. 

This device will actually work as described, with no science fiction involved at all, if you can provide 
the plate of condensed matter and the necessary drive. Unfortunately, this turns out to be nontrivial. All 
the distances are reasonable, and so are the tidal forces. What is much less reasonable is the mass of the 
disk that we have used. It is a little more than 9 trillion tons; such a disk 100 meters across and one 
meter thick would have an average density of 1,170 tons per cubic centimeter. 

This density is modest compared with that found in a neutron star, and tiny compared with what we 
find in a black hole. Thus we know that such densities do exist in the Universe. However, no materials 
available to us on Earth today even come close to such high values-they have densities that fall short by a 
factor of more than a million. And the massplate would not work as described, without the dense matter. 
We have a real problem. 

It's science fiction time again: let us assume that in a couple of hundred years we will be able to 
compress matter to very high densities, and hold it there using powerful electromagnetic fields. If that is 
the case, the massplate needed for McAndrew's drive can be built. It's certainly massive, but that 
shouldn't be a limitation-the Solar System has plenty of spare matter available for construction materials. 
And although a 9 trillion ton mass may sound a lot, it's tiny by celestial standards, less than the mass of a 
modest asteroid. 

With that one extrapolation of today's science it sounds as though we can have the McAndrew 
balanced drive. We can even suggest how that extrapolation might be performed, with plausible use of 
present physics. 

Unfortunately, things are not as nice as they seem. There is a much bigger piece of science fiction that 
must be introduced before the McAndrew drive can exist as a useful device. We look at that next, and 
note that it is a central concern of the third chronicle. 


Suppose that the drive mechanism is the most efficient one consistent with today's physics. This 
would be a photon drive, in which any fuel is completely converted to radiation and used to propel the 
ship. There is certainly nothing in present science that suggests such a drive is theoretically impossible, 
and some analysis of matter-antimatter reactions indicates that the photon drive could one day be built. 
Let us assume that we know how to construct it. Then, even with this "ultimate" drive, McAndrew's ship 
would have problems. It's not difficult to calculate that with a fifty gee drive, the conversion of matter to 
radiation needed to keep the drive going will quickly consume the ship's own mass. More than half the 
mass will be gone in a few days, and McAndrew's ship will disappear from under him. 

Solution of this problem calls for a lot more fictional science than the simple task of producing stable 
condensed matter. We have to go back to present physics and look for loopholes. We need to find 
inconsistencies in the overall picture of the Universe provided by present day physics, and exploit these 
as necessary. 

The best place to seek inconsistencies is where we already know we will find them-in the meeting of 
general relativity and quantum theory. If we calculate the energy associated with an absence of matter in 
quantum theory, the "vacuum state," we do not, as common sense would suggest, get zero. 

Instead we get a large, positive value per unit volume. In classical thinking, one could argue that the 
zero point of energy is arbitrary, so that one can simply start measuring energies from the vacuum state 
value. But if we accept general relativity, this option is denied to us. Energy, of any form, produces 
space-time curvature. We are therefore not allowed to change the definition of the origin of the energy 
scale. Once this is accepted, the energy of the vacuum state cannot be talked out of existence. It is real, 
if elusive, and its presence provides the loophole that we need. 

Again, we are at the point where the science fiction enters. If the vacuum state has an energy 
associated with it, I assume that this energy is capable of being tapped. Doesn't this then, according to 
relativity (E =mc2), suggest that there is also mass associated with the vacuum, contrary to what we think 
of as vacuum? Yes, it does, and I'm sorry about that, but the paradox is not of my creation. It is implicit 
in the contradictions that arise as soon as you try to put general relativity and quantum theory together. 

Richard Feynman, one of the founders of quantum electrodynamics, addressed the question of the 
vacuum energy, and computed an estimate for the equivalent mass per unit volume. The estimate came 
out to two billion tons per cubic centimeter. The energy in two billion tons of matter is more than enough 
to boil all Earth's oceans (powerful stuff, vacuum). Feynman, commenting on his vacuum energy 
estimate, remarks: 

"Such a mass density would, at first sight at least, be expected to produce very large 
gravitational effects which are not observed. It is possible that we are calculating in a naive 
manner, and, if all of the consequences of the general theory of relativity (such as the 
gravitational effects produced by the large stresses implied here) were included, the effects might 
cancel out; but nobody has worked all this out yet. It is possible that some cutoff procedure that 
not only yields a finite energy for the vacuum state but also provides relativistic invariance may 
be found. The implications of such a result are at present completely unknown." 

With that degree of uncertainty at the highest levels of present-day physics, I feel not at all 
uncomfortable in exploiting the troublesome vacuum energy to service McAndrew's drive. 

The third chronicle introduces two other ideas that are definitely science fiction today, even if they 
become science fact a few years from now. If there are ways to isolate the human central nervous 
system and keep it alive independently of the body, we certainly don't know much about them. On the 
other hand, I see nothing that suggests this idea is impossible in principle-heart transplants were not 
feasible forty years ago, and until this century blood transfusions were rare and highly dangerous. A 
century hence, today's medical impossibilities should be routine. 

The Sturm Invocation for vacuum survival is also invented, but I believe that it, like the Izaak Walton 
introduced in the seventh chronicle, is a logical component of any space-oriented future. Neither calls for 
technology beyond what we have today. The hypnotic control implied in the Invocation, though 
advanced for most practitioners, could already be achieved. And any competent engineering shop could 
build a Walton for you in a few weeks-I am tempted to patent the idea, but fear that it would be rejected 


as too obvious or inevitable a development. 
* * * 

Life in space and the Oort cloud. 

Most chronicles take place at least partly in the Halo, or the Outer Solar System, which I define to 
extend from the distance of Pluto from the Sun, out to a little over a light-year. Within this radius, the Sun 
is still the primary gravitational influence, and controls the orbits of objects moving out there. 

To give an idea of the size of the Halo, we note that Pluto lies at an average distance of about 6 
billion kilometers from the Sun. This is about forty astronomical units, where the astronomical unit, 
usually abbreviated to AU, is defined as the mean distance of the Earth from the Sun. The AU provides 
a convenient yardstick for measurements within the Solar System. One light-year is about 63,000 AU 
(inches in a mile, is how I remember it). So the volume of space in the Halo is 4 billion times as large as 
the sphere enclosing the nine known planets. 

By Solar System standards, the Halo is thus a huge region. But beyond Neptune and Pluto, we know 
little about it. There are a number of "trans-Neptunian objects," but no one knows how many. Some of 
them may be big enough to qualify as planets. The search for Pluto was inspired early this century by 
differences between theory and observation in the orbits of Uranus and Neptune. When Pluto was 
found, it soon became clear that it was not nearly heavy enough to produce the observed irregularities. 
The obvious explanation is yet another planet, farther out than the ones we know. 

Calculations of the orbit and size of a tenth planet needed to reconcile observation and theory for 
Uranus and Neptune suggest a rather improbable object, out of the orbital plane that all the other planets 
move in and about seventy times the mass of the Earth. I don't believe this particular object exists. 

On the other hand, observational equipment and techniques for faint objects are improving rapidly. 
The number of known trans-Neptunian objects increases almost every month. 

The other thing we know for sure about the Halo is that it is populated by comets. The Halo is often 
called the Oort cloud, since the Dutch astronomer Oort suggested thirty years ago that the entire Solar 
System is enveloped by a cloud of cometary material, to a radius of perhaps a light-year. He regarded 
this region as a "cometary reservoir," containing perhaps a hundred billion comets. Close encounters 
between comets out in the Halo would occasionally disturb the orbit of one of them enough to divert it to 
the Inner System, where it would appear as a long-period comet when it came close enough to the Sun. 
Further interactions with Jupiter and the other planets would then sometimes convert the long-period 
comet to a short-period comet, such as Halley's or Encke's comet, which we observe repeatedly each 
time they swing by close to the Sun. 

Most comets, however, continue their lonely orbits out in the cloud, never approaching the Inner 
System. They do not have to be small to be invisible to us. The amount of sunlight a body receives is 
inversely proportional to the square of its distance from the Sun; the apparent area it presents to our 
telescopes is also inversely proportional to the square of its distance from Earth. For bodies in the Halo, 
the reflected light that we receive from them thus varies as the inverse fourth power of their distance from 
the Sun. A planet with the size and composition of Uranus, but half a light-year away, would be seven 
trillion times as faint. And we should remember that Uranus itself is faint enough that it was not 
discovered until 1781, when high-quality telescopes were available. So far as present-day detection 
powers are concerned, there could be almost anything out there in the Halo. 

One of the things that may be there is life. In a carefully argued but controversial theory developed 
over the past thirty years, Hoyle and Wickramasinghe have advanced the idea that space is the natural 
place for the creation of "pre-biotic" molecules in large quantities. Pre-biotic molecules are compounds 
such as carbohydrates, amino acids, and chlorophyll, which form the necessary building blocks for the 
development of life. Simpler organic molecules, such as methyl cyanide and ethanol, have already been 
observed in interstellar clouds. 

Hoyle and Wickramasinghe go further. They state explicitly: "We shall argue that primitive living 
organisms evolve in the mixture of organic molecules, ices and silicate smoke which make up a 
comet's head." 


The science fiction of the fourth chronicle consists of these two assumptions: 

1. The complex organic molecules described by Hoyle and Wickramasinghe are located in a 
particular region of the Halo, a "life ring" that lies between 3,200 and 4,000 AU from the Sun; 
2. The "primitive living organism" have evolved quite a bit further than Hoyle and Wickramasinghe 
expected, on at least one body of the Oort cloud. 
* * * 

Missing matter and the beginning of the Universe. 

Today's so-called "standard model" of cosmology suggests that the Universe began in a "Big Bang" 
somewhere between ten and twenty billion years ago. Since we have been able to study the Universe in 
detail for less than four hundred years (the telescope was invented about 1608), any attempt to say 
something about the origin of the Universe implies considerable extrapolation into the past. There is a 
chance of success only because the basic physical laws of the Universe that govern events on both the 
smallest scale (atoms and subatomic particles) and the largest scale (stars, galaxies, and clusters of 
galaxies) appear not to have changed since its earliest days. 

The primary evidence for a finite age for the whole Universe comes from observation of distant 
galaxies. When we observe the light that they emit, we find, as was suggested by Carl Wirtz in 1924 and 
confirmed by Edwin Hubble in 1929, that more distant galaxies appear redder than nearer ones. 

To be more specific, in the fainter (and therefore presumably more distant) galaxies, every 
wavelength of light emitted has been shifted toward a longer wavelength. The question is, what could 
cause such a shift? 

The most plausible mechanism, to a physicist, is called the Doppler effect. According to the Doppler 
effect, light from a receding object will be shifted to longer (redder) wavelengths; light from an 
approaching object will be shifted to shorter (bluer) wavelengths. Exactly the same thing works for 
sound, which is why a speeding police car's siren seems to drop in pitch as it passes by. 

If we accept the Doppler effect as the cause of the reddened appearance of the galaxies, we are led 
(as was Hubble) to an immediate conclusion: the whole Universe must be expanding, at a close to 
constant rate, because the red shift of the galaxies corresponds to their brightness, and therefore to their 
distance. 

Note that this does not mean that the Universe is expanding into some other space. There is no other 
space. It is the whole Universe-everything there is-that has grown over time to its present dimension. 

And from this we can draw another immediate conclusion. If expansion proceeded in the past as it 
does today, there must have been a time when everything in the whole Universe was drawn together to a 
single point. It is logical to call the time that has elapsed since everything was in that infinitely dense 
singularity the age of the Universe. The Hubble galactic redshift allows us to calculate how long ago 
that happened. 

Our estimate is bounded on the one hand by the constancy of the laws of physics (how far back can 
we go, before the Universe would be totally unrecognizable and far from the place where we believe 
today's physical laws are valid?); and on the other hand by our knowledge of the distance of the 
galaxies, as determined by other methods. 

Curiously, it is the second problem that forms the major constraint. When we say that the Universe is 
between ten and twenty billion years old, that uncertainty of a factor of two betrays our ignorance of 
galactic distances. 

It is remarkable that observation of the faint agglomerations of stars known as galaxies leads us, very 
directly and cleanly, to the conclusion that we live in a Universe of finite and determinable age. A century 
ago, no one could have offered even an approximate age for the Universe. For an upper bound, most 
nonreligious scientists would probably have said "forever." For a lower bound, all they had was the age 
of the Earth. 

Asking one question, How old is the Universe? inevitably leads us to another: What was the 
Universe like, ten or twenty billion years ago, when it was compressed into a very small volume? 

That question was tackled by a Belgian, Georges Lemaître. Early in the 1930s Lemaître went 


backwards mentally in time, to a period when the whole Universe was a "primeval atom." In this first and 
single atom, everything was squashed into a sphere only a few times as big as the Sun, with no space 
between atoms, or even between nuclei. As Lemaître saw it, this unit must then have exploded, 
fragmenting into the atoms and stars and galaxies and everything else in the Universe that we know 
today. He might justifiably have called it the Big Bang, but he didn't. That name seems to have been 
coined by Fred Hoyle, whom we met in the previous chronicle. 

Lemaître did not ask the next question, namely, where did the primeval atom come from? Since he 
was an ordained Catholic priest, he probably felt that the answer to that was a given. Lemaître also did 
not worry too much about the composition of his primeval atom-what was it made of? It might be 
thought that the easiest assumption is that everything in the Universe was already there, much as it is 
now. But that cannot be true, because as we go back in time, the Universe had to be hotter as well as 
more dense. Before a certain point, atoms as we know them could not exist, because they would be torn 
apart by the intense radiation that permeated the whole Universe. 

The person who did worry about the composition of the primeval atom was George Gamow. In the 
1940s, he conjectured that the original stuff of the Universe was nothing more than densely packed 
neutrons. Certainly, it seemed reasonable to suppose that the Universe at its outset had no net charge, 
since it seems to have no net charge today. Also, a neutron left to itself has a fifty percent chance that it 
will, in about thirteen minutes, decay radioactively to form an electron and a proton. One electron and 
one proton form an atom of hydrogen; and even today, the Universe is predominantly atomic hydrogen. 
So neutrons could account for most, if not all, of today's Universe. 

If the early Universe was very hot and very dense and all hydrogen, some of it ought to have fused 
and become helium, carbon, and other elements. The question, How much of each? was one that 
Gamow and his student, Ralph Alpher, set out to answer. They calculated that about a quarter of the 
matter in the primeval Universe should have turned to helium, a figure very consistent with the present 
composition of the oldest stars. They published their results on April 1, 1948. In one of physics' 
best-known jokes, Hans Bethe (pronounced Bay-ter, like the Greek letter Beta) allowed his name to be 
added to the paper, although he had nothing to do with its writing. The authors thus became Alpher, 
Bethe, and Gamow. 

Apart from showing how to calculate the ratio of hydrogen to helium after the Big Bang, Gamow and 
his colleagues did one other thing whose full significance probably escaped them. In 1948 they produced 
an equation that allowed one to compute the present background temperature of the Universe from its 
age, assuming a Universe that expanded uniformly since its beginning in the Big Bang. The background 
radiation, corresponding to a temperature of 2.7 degrees above absolute zero, was discovered by Arno 
Penzias and Robert Wilson in 1964, and made the Big Bang theory fully respectable for the first time. 

We now believe that hydrogen fused to form helium when the Universe was between three and four 
minutes old. What about even earlier times? Let us run the clock backwards, as far as we can towards 
the Big Bang. 

How far back do we want to start the clock? Well, when the Universe was smaller in size, it was also 
hotter. In a hot enough environment, atoms as we know them cannot hold together. High-energy 
radiation rips them apart as fast as they form. A good time to begin our backward running of the clock 
might then be the period when atoms could form and persist as stable units. Although stars and galaxies 
would not yet exist, at least the Universe would be made up of familiar components, hydrogen and 
helium atoms that we would recognize. 

Atoms can form, and hold together, somewhere between half a million and a million years after the 
Big Bang. Before that time, matter and radiation interacted continuously, and the Universe was almost 
opaque to radiation. After it, matter and radiation "decoupled," became near-independent, and went 
their separate ways. The temperature of the Universe when this happened was about 3,000 degrees. 
Ever since then, the expansion of the Universe has lengthened the wavelength of the background 
radiation, and thus lowered its temperature. The cosmic background radiation discovered by Penzias 
and Wilson is nothing more than the radiation at the time when it decoupled from matter, now grown old. 

Continuing backwards, even before atoms could form, helium and hydrogen nuclei and free electrons 


could combine to form atoms; but they could not remain in combination, because radiation broke them 
apart. The content of the Universe was, in effect, controlled by radiation energetic enough to prevent the 
formation of atoms. This situation held from about three minutes to one million years A.C. (After 
Creation). 

If we go back to a period less than three minutes A.C., radiation was even more dominant. It 
prevented the build-up even of helium nuclei. As noted earlier, the fusion of hydrogen to helium requires 
hot temperatures, such as we find in the center of stars. But fusion cannot take place if it is too hot, as it 
was before three minutes after the Big Bang. Before helium could form, the Universe had to "cool" to 
about a billion degrees. All that existed before then were electrons (and their positively charged forms, 
positrons), neutrons, protons, neutrinos (a chargeless particle, until recently assumed to be massless but 
now thought to possess a tiny mass), and radiation. 

Until three minutes A.C., it might seem as though radiation controlled events. But this is not the case. 
As we proceed farther backwards and the temperature of the primordial fireball continues to increase, 
we reach a point where the temperature is so high (above ten billion degrees) that large numbers of 
electron-positron pairs can be created from pure radiation. That happened from one second up to 
fourteen seconds A.C. After that, the number of electron-positron pairs decreased rapidly. Less were 
being generated than were annihilating themselves and returning to pure radiation. After the Universe 
cooled to ten billion degrees, neutrinos also decoupled from other forms of matter. 

Still we have a long way to go, physically speaking, to the moment of creation. As we continue 
backwards, temperatures rise and rise. At a tenth of a second A.C., the temperature of the Universe is 
thirty billion degrees. The Universe is a soup of electrons, protons, neutrons, neutrinos, and radiation. As 
the kinetic energy of particle motion becomes greater and greater, effects caused by differences of 
particle mass are less important. At thirty billion degrees, an electron easily carries enough energy to 
convert a proton into the slightly heavier neutron. Thus in this period, free neutrons are constantly trying 
to decay to form protons and electrons; but energetic proton-electron collisions go on remaking neutrons. 

We keep the clock running. Now the important time intervals become shorter and shorter. At one 
ten-thousandth of a second A.C., the temperature is one thousand billion degrees. The Universe is so 
small that the density of matter, everywhere, is as great as that in the nucleus of an atom today (about 
100 million tons per cubic centimeter; a fair-sized asteroid, at this density, would squeeze down to fit in a 
match box). Modern theory says that the nucleus is best regarded not as protons and neutrons, but as 
quarks, elementary particles from which the neutrons and protons themselves are made. Thus at this 
early time, 0.0001 seconds A.C. the Universe was a sea of quarks, electrons, neutrinos, and energetic 
radiation. We move on, to the time, 10-36 seconds A.C., when the Universe went through a super-rapid 
"inflationary" phase, growing from the size of a proton to the size of a basketball in about 5 x 10-32 
seconds. We are almost back as far as we can go. Finally we reach a time 10-43 seconds A.C, (called 
the Plank time), when according to a class of theories known as supersymmetry theories, the force of 
gravity decoupled from everything else, and remains decoupled to this day. 

This may already sound like pure science fiction. It is not. It is today's science-though it certainly may 
be wrong. But at last we have reached the time when McAndrew's "hidden matter" was created. And 
today's Universe seems to require that something very like it exist. 

The argument for hidden matter goes as follows: The Universe is expanding. Every cosmologist today 
agrees on that. Will it go on expanding forever, or will it one day slow to a halt, reverse direction, and 
fall back in on itself to end in a Big Crunch? Or is the Universe poised on the infinitely narrow dividing 
line between expansion and ultimate contraction, so that it will increase more and more slowly, and 
finally (but after infinite time) stop its growth? 

The thing that decides which of these three possibilities will occur is the total amount of mass in the 
Universe, or rather, since we do not care what form mass takes and mass and energy are totally 
equivalent, the future of the Universe is decided by the total mass-energy content per unit volume. 

If the mass-energy is too big, the Universe will end in the Big Crunch. If it is too small, the Universe 
will fly apart forever. And only in the Goldilocks situation, where the mass-energy is "just right," will the 
Universe ultimately reach a "flat" condition. The amount of matter needed to stop the expansion is not 


large, by terrestrial standards. It calls for only three hydrogen atoms per cubic meter. 

Is there that much available? 

If we estimate the mass and energy from visible material in stars and galaxies, we find a value 
nowhere near the "critical density" needed to make the Universe finally flat. If we say that the critical 
mass-energy density has to be equal to unity just to slow the expansion, we observe in visible matter 
only a value of about 0.01. 

There is evidence, though, from the rotation of galaxies, that there is a lot more "dark matter" present 
there than we see as stars. It is not clear what this dark matter is-black holes, very dim stars, clouds of 
neutrinos-but when we are examining the future of the Universe, we don't care. All we worry about is 
the amount. And that amount, from galactic dynamics, could be at least ten times as much as the visible 
matter. Enough to bring the density to 0.1, or possible even 0.2. But no more than that. 

One might say, all right, that's it. There is not enough matter in the Universe to stop the expansion, by 
a factor of about ten, so we have confirmed that we live in a forever-expanding Universe. Recent (1999) 
observations seem to confirm that result. 

Unfortunately, that is not the answer that most cosmologists would really like to hear. The problem 
comes because the most acceptable cosmological models tell us that if the density is as much as 0.1 
today, then in the past it must have been much closer to unity. For example, at one second A.C., the 
density would have had to be within one part in a million billion of unity, in order for it to be 0.1 today. It 
would be an amazing coincidence if, by accident, the actual density were so close to the critical density. 

Most cosmologists therefore say that, today's observations notwithstanding, the density of the 
Universe is really exactly equal to the critical value. In this case, the Universe will expand forever, but 
more and more slowly. 

The problem, of course, is then to account for the matter that we don't observe. Where could the 
"missing matter" be, that makes up the other nine-tenths of the universe? 

There are several candidates. One suggestion is that the Universe is filled with energetic ("hot") 
neutrinos, each with a small but non-zero mass. However, there are problems with the Hot Neutrino 
theory. If they are the source of the mass that stops the expansion of the Universe, the galaxies, 
according to today's models, should not have developed as early as they did in the history of the 
Universe. 

What about other candidates? Well, the class of theories already alluded to and known as 
supersymmetry theories require that as-yet undiscovered particles ought to exist. 

There are axions, which are particles that help to preserve certain symmetries (charge, parity, and 
time-reversal) in elementary particle physics; and there are photinos, gravitinos, and others, based on 
theoretical supersymmetries between particles and radiation. These candidates are slow moving (and so 
considered "cold") but some of them have substantial mass. They too would have been around soon 
after the Big Bang. These slow-moving particles clump more easily together, so the formation of galaxies 
could take place earlier than with the hot neutrinos. We seem to have a better candidate for the missing 
matter-except that no one has yet observed the necessary particles. At least neutrinos are known to 
exist! 

Supersymmetry, in a particular form known as superstring theory, offers another possible source of 
hidden mass. This one is easily the most speculative. Back at a time, 10-43 seconds A.C., when gravity 
decoupled from everything else, a second class of matter may have been created that is able to interact 
with normal matter and radiation, today, only through the gravitational force. We can never observe such 
matter, in the usual sense, because our observational methods, from ordinary telescopes to radio 
telescopes to gamma ray detectors, all rely on electromagnetic interaction with matter. 

This "shadow matter" produced at the time of gravitational decoupling lacks any such interaction with 
the matter of the familiar Universe. We can determine its existence only by the gravitational effects it 
produces, which, of course, is exactly what we need to "close the Universe," and also exactly what we 
needed for the fifth chronicle. 

One can thus argue that the fifth chronicle is all straight science; or, if you are more skeptical, that it 
and the theories on which it is based are both science fiction. I think that I prefer not to give an opinion. 


* * * 

Invariance and science. 

In mathematics and physics, an invariant is something that does not change when certain changes of 
condition are made. For example, the "connectedness" or "connectivity" of an object remains the same, 
no matter how we deform its surface shape, provided only that no cutting or merging of surface parts is 
permitted. A grapefruit and a banana have the same connectedness-one of them can, with a little effort, 
be squashed to look like the other (at least in principle, though it does sound messy). A coffee cup with 
one handle and a donut have the same connectedness; but both have a different connectedness from that 
of a two-handled mug, or from a mug with no handle. You and I have the same connectedness-unless 
you happen to have had one or both of your ears pierced, or wear a ring through your nose. 

The "knottedness" of a piece of rope is similarly unchanging, provided that we keep hold of the ends 
and don't break the string, There is an elaborate vocabulary of knots. A "knot of degree zero" is one that 
is equivalent to no knot at all, so that pulling the ends of the rope in such a case will give a straight piece 
of string-a knot trick known to every magician. But when Alexander the Great "solved" the problem of 
the Gordian Knot by cutting it in two with his sword, he was cheating. 

Invariants may sound useless, or at best trivial. Why bother with them? Simply for this reason: they 
often allow us to make general statements, true in a wide variety of circumstances, where otherwise we 
would have to deal with lots of specific and different cases. 

For example, the statement that a partial differential equation is of elliptic, parabolic, or hyperbolic 
type is based on a particular invariant, and it tells us a great deal about the possible solutions of such 
equations before we ever begin to try to solve them. And the statement that a real number is rational or 
irrational is invariant, independent of the number base that we are using, and it too says something 
profound about the nature of that number. 

What about the invariants of physics, which interested McAndrew? Some invariants are so obvious, 
we may feel they hardly justify being mentioned. For example, we certainly expect the area or volume of 
a solid body to be the same, no matter what coordinate system we may use to define it. 

Similarly, we expect physical laws to be "invariant under translation" (so they don't depend on the 
actual position of the measuring instrument) and "invariant under rotation" (it should not matter which 
direction our experimental system is pointing) and "invariant under time translation" (we ought to get the 
same results tomorrow as we did yesterday). Most scientists took such invariants for granted for 
hundreds of years, although each of these is actually making a profound statement about the physical 
nature of the Universe. 

So, too, is the notion that physical laws should be "invariant under constant motion." But assuming 
this, and rigorously applying it, led Einstein straight to the theory of special relativity. The idea of 
invariance under accelerated motion took him in turn to the theory of general relativity. 

Both these theories, and the invariants that go with them, are linked inevitably with the name of one 
man, Albert Einstein. Another great invariant, linear momentum, is coupled in my mind with the names of 
two men, Galileo Galilei and Isaac Newton. Although the first explicit statement of this invariant is given 
in Newton's First Law of Motion ("Every body will continue in its state of rest or of uniform motion 
in a straight line except in so far as it is compelled to change that state by impressed force."), 
Galileo, fifty years earlier, was certainly familiar with the general principle. 

Some of the other "great invariants" needed the efforts of many people before they were firmly 
defined and their significance was appreciated. The idea that mass was an invariant came about through 
the efforts of chemists, beginning with Dalton and Lavoisier, who weighed combustion products and 
found that the total was the same before and after. The equivalence of different forms of energy (heat, 
motion, potential energy, and electromagnetic energy), and the invariance of total energy of all forms, 
developed even later. It was a combined effort by Count Rumford, Joule, Maxwell, Lord Kelvin, 
Helmholtz and others. The merger of the two invariants became possible when Einstein showed the 
equivalence of mass and energy, after which it was only the combined mass-energy total that was 
conserved. 


Finally, although the idea that angular momentum must be conserved seems to arise naturally in 
classical mechanics from the conservation of linear momentum, in quantum physics it is much more of an 
independent invariant because particles such as protons, neutrons, electrons, and neutrinos have an 
intrinsic, internal spin, whose existence is not so much seen as deduced in order to make angular 
momentum a conserved quantity. 

This sounds rather like a circular argument, but it isn't, because intrinsic spin couples with orbital 
angular momentum, and quantum theory cannot make predictions that match experiments without both 
of them. And as McAndrew remarks, Wolfgang Pauli in 1931 introduced the idea of a new particle to 
physics, the neutrino, just in order to preserve the laws of conservation of energy and momentum. 

There are other important invariants in the quantum world, However, some things which "common 
sense" would insist to be invariants may be no such thing. For example, it was widely believed that parity 
(which is symmetry upon reflection in a mirror) must be a conserved quantity, because the Universe 
should have no preference for left-handed sub-nuclear processes over right-handed ones. But in 1956, 
Tsung Dao Lee and Chen Ning Yang suggested this might not be the case, and their radical idea was 
confirmed experimentally by C.S. Wu's team in 1957. Today, only a combination of parity, charge, and 
time-reversal is regarded as a fully conserved quantity. 

Given the overall importance of invariants and conservation principles to science, there is no doubt 
that McAndrew would have pursued any suggestion of a new basic invariant. But if invariants are real, 
where is the fiction in the sixth chronicle? I'm afraid there isn't any, because the nature of the new 
invariant is never defined. 

Wait a moment, you may say. What about the Geotron? 

That is not fiction science, either, at least so far as principles are concerned. Such an instrument was 
seriously proposed a few years ago by Robert Wilson, the former director of the Fermilab accelerator. 
His design called for a donut-shaped device thirty-two miles across, in which protons would be 
accelerated to very high energies and then strike a metal target, to produce a beam of neutrinos. The 
Geotron designers wanted to use the machine to probe the interior structure of the Earth, and in 
particular to prospect for oil, gas, and valuable deep-seated metal deposits. 

So maybe there is no fiction at all in the sixth chronicle-just a little pessimism about how long it will 
take before someone builds a Geotron. 
* * * 

Rogue planets. 

The Halo beyond the known Solar System offers so much scope for interesting celestial objects of 
every description that I assume we will find a few more there. In the second chronicle, I introduced 
collapsed objects, high-density bodies that are neither stars nor conventional planets. The dividing line 
between stars and planets is usually decided by whether or not the center of the object supports a 
nuclear fusion process and contains a high density core of "degenerate" matter. Present theories place 
that dividing line at about a hundredth of the Sun's mass-smaller than that, you have a planet; bigger than 
that you must have a star. I assume that there are in-between bodies out in the Halo, made largely of 
degenerate matter but only a little more massive than Jupiter. 

I also assume that there is a "kernel ring" of Kerr-Newman black holes, about 300 to 400 AU from 
the Sun, and that this same region contains many of the collapsed objects. Such bodies would be 
completely undetectable using any techniques of present-day astronomy. This is science fiction, not 
science. 

Are rogue planets also science fiction? This brings us to Vandell's Fifth Problem, and the seventh 
chronicle. 

David Hilbert did indeed pose a set of mathematical problems in 1900, and they served as much 
more than a summary of things that were "hard to solve." They were concise and exact statements of 
questions, which, if answered, would have profound implications for many other problems in 
mathematics. The Hilbert problems are both deep and difficult, and have attracted the attention of almost 
every mathematician of the twentieth century. Several problems of the set, for example, ask whether 


certain numbers are "transcendental"-which means they can never occur as solutions to the usual 
equations of algebra (more precisely, they cannot be roots of finite algebraic equations with algebraic 
coefficients). These questions were not disposed of until 1930, when Kusmin and Siegel proved a more 
general result than the one that Hilbert had posed. In 1934 Gelfond provided another generalization. 

At the moment there is no such "super-problem" set defined for astronomy and cosmology. If there 
were, the one I invented as Vandell's Fifth Problem would certainly be a worthy candidate, and might 
take generations to solve. (Hilbert's Fifth Problem, concerning a conjecture in topological group theory, 
was finally solved in 1952 by Gleason, Montgomery, and Zippin.) We cannot even imagine a technique, 
observational instrument or procedure that would have a chance of detecting a rogue planet. The 
existence, frequency of occurrence, and mode of escape of rogue planets raise many questions 
concerning the stability of multiple-body systems moving under their mutual gravitational 
attractions-questions that cannot be answered yet by astronomers and mathematicians. 

In general relativity, the exact solution of the "one-body problem" as given by Schwarzschild has been 
known for more than 80 years. The relativistic "two-body problem," of two objects orbiting each other 
under mutual gravitational influence, has not yet been solved. In nonrelativistic or Newtonian mechanics, 
the two-body problem was disposed of three hundred years ago by Newton. But the nonrelativistic 
solution for more than two bodies has not been found to this day, despite three centuries of hard work. 

A good deal of progress has been made for a rather simpler situation that is termed the "restricted 
three-body problem." In this, a small mass (such as a planet or small moon) moves under the influence of 
two much larger ones (stars or large planets). The large bodies define the gravitational field, and the 
small body moves in this field without contributing significantly to it. The restricted three-body problem 
applies to the case of a planet moving in the gravitational field of a binary pair of stars, or an asteroid 
moving in the combined fields of the Sun and Jupiter. It also offers a good approximation for the motion 
of a small body moving in the combined field of the Earth and Moon. Thus the problem is of practical 
interest, and the list of workers who have studied it in the past 200 years includes several of history's 
most famous mathematicians: Euler, Lagrange, Jacobi, Poincaré, and Birkhoff. (Lagrange in particular 
provided certain exact solutions that include the L-4 and L-5 points, famous today as proposed sites for 
large space colonies.) 

The number of papers written on the subject is huge-Victor Szebehely, in a 1967 book on the topic, 
listed over 500 references, and restricted himself to only the major source works. 

Thanks to the efforts of all these workers, a good deal is known about the possible solutions of the 
restricted three-body problem. One established fact is that the small object cannot be thrown away to 
infinity by the gravitational interactions of its two large companions. Like much of modern astronomy, 
this result is not established by looking at the orbits themselves. It is proved by general arguments based 
on a particular constant of the motion, termed the Jacobian integral. 

Unfortunately, those arguments cannot be applied in the general three-body problem, or in the 
N-body problem whenever N is bigger than two. It is presently conjectured by astronomers, but not 
generally proved, that ejection to infinity is possible whenever more than three bodies are involved. In 
such a situation, the lightest member of the system is most likely to be the one ejected. Thus, rogue 
planets can probably be produced when a stellar system has more than two stars in it. As it happens, this 
is rather common. Solitary stars, like the Sun, are in the minority. Once separated from its stellar parents, 
the chances that a rogue world will ever again be captured to form part of a star system are remote. To 
this point, the seventh chronicle's discussion of solitary planets fits known theory, although it is an 
admittedly incomplete theory. 

So how many rogue planets are there? There could conceivably be as many as there are stars, strewn 
thick across the Galaxy but completely undetectable to our instruments. Half a dozen may lie closer to us 
than the nearest star. Or they may be an endangered species, vanishingly rare among the varied bodies 
that comprise the celestial zoo. 

In the seventh chronicle I suggest that they are rather common-and that's acceptable to me as science 
fiction. Maybe they are, because certainly planets around other stars seem far more common than we 
used to think. Up to 1996, there was no evidence at all that even one planet existed around any star 


other than Sol. Now we know of a dozen or more. Every one is Jupiter's size or bigger, but that does 
not imply that most planets in the universe are massive. It merely shows that our detection methods can 
find only big planets. Possibly there are other, smaller planets in every system where a Jupiter-sized giant 
has been discovered. 

If we cannot actually see a planet, how can we possibly know that it exists? There are two methods. 
First, it is not accurate to say that a planet orbits a star. The bodies orbit around their common center of 
mass. That means, if the orbit lies at right angles to the direction of the star as seen from Earth, the star's 
apparent position in the sky will show a variation over the period of the planetary year. That change will 
be tiny, but if the planet is large, the movement of the star might be small enough to measure. 

The other (and to this date more successful) method of detection relies on the periodic shift in the 
wavelengths of light that we receive from a star and planet orbiting around their common center of 
gravity. When the star is approaching us because the planet is moving away from us, the light will be 
shifted toward the blue. When the star is moving away from us because the planet is approaching us, the 
star's light will be shifted toward the red. The tiny difference between these two cases allows us, from 
the wavelength changes in the star's light, to infer the existence of a planet in orbit around it. 

Since both methods of detection depend for their success on the planet's mass being an appreciable 
fraction of the star's mass, it is no surprise that we are able to detect only the existence of massive 
planets, Jupiter-sized or bigger. And so far as rogue worlds are concerned, far from any stellar primary, 
our methods for the detection of extra-solar planets are no use at all. 

* * * 

The solar focus. 

We go to general relativity again. According to that theory, the gravitational field of the Sun will bend 
light beams that pass by it (actually, Newtonian theory also turns out to predict a similar effect, a factor 
of two less in magnitude). Rays of light coming from a source at infinity and just missing the Sun will be 
bent the most, and they will converge at a distance from the Sun of 550 astronomical units, which is 
about 82.5 billion kilometers. To gain a feeling for that number, note that the average distance of the 
planet Pluto from the Sun is 5.9 billion kilometers; the solar focus, as the convergence point is known, is 
a fair distance out. 

Those numbers apply for a spherical Sun. Since Sol rotates and so has a bulge at its equator, the Sun 
considered as a lens is slightly astigmatic. 

If the source of light (or radio signal, which is simply another form of electromagnetic wave) is not at 
infinity, but closer, then the rays will still be converged in their passage by the Sun, but they will be drawn 
to a point at a different location. As McAndrew correctly points out in the eighth chronicle, a standard 
result in geometrical optics applies. If a lens converges a parallel beam of light at a distance F from the 
lens, then light starting at a distance S from the lens will be converged at a distance D beyond it, where 
1/F = 1/S + 1/D. 

This much is straightforward. The more central element of this chronicle involves far more 
speculation. When, or if you prefer it, if, will it be possible to produce an artificial intelligence, an "AI," 
that rivals or surpasses human intelligence? 

It depends which writers you believe as to how you answer that question. Some, such as Hans 
Moravec, have suggested that this will happen in fifty years or less. Others, while not accepting any 
specific date, still feel that it is sure to come to pass. Our brains are, in Marvin Minsky's words, 
"computers made of meat." It may be difficult and take a long time, but eventually we will have an AI 
able to think as well or better than we do. 

However, not everyone accepts this. Roger Penrose, whom we have already mentioned in 
connection with energy extraction from kernels, has argued that an AI will never be achieved by the 
further development of computers as we know them today, because the human brain is 
"non-algorithmic." 

In a difficult book that was a surprising best-seller, The Emperor's New Mind (1989), he claimed 
that some functions of the human brain will never be duplicated by computers developed along today's 


lines. The brain, he asserts, performs some functions for which no computer program can be written. 

This idea has been received with skepticism and even outrage by many workers in the field of AI and 
computer science. So what does Penrose say that is so upsetting to so many? He argues that human 
thought employs physics and procedures drawn from the world of quantum theory. In Penrose's words, 
"Might a quantum world be required so that thinking, perceiving creatures, such as ourselves, can be 
constructed from its substance?" 

His answer to his own question is, yes, a quantum world-view is required. In that world, a particle 
does not necessarily have a well-defined spin, speed, or position. Rather, it has a number of different 
possible positions or speeds or spins, and until we make an observation of it, all we can know are the 
probabilities associated with each possible spin, speed, and position. Only when an observation is made 
does the particle occupy a well-defined state, in which the measured variable is precisely known. This 
change, from undefined to well-defined status, is called the "collapse of the quantum mechanical wave 
function." It is a well-known, if not well-understood, element of standard quantum theory. 

What Penrose suggests is that the human brain itself is a kind of quantum device. In particular, the 
same processes that collapse the quantum mechanical wave function in sub-atomic particles are at work 
in the brain. When humans are considering many different possibilities, Penrose argues that we are 
operating in a highly parallel, quantum mechanical mode. Our thinking resolves and "collapses to a 
thought" at some point when the wave function collapses, and at that time the many millions or billions of 
possibilities become a single definite idea. 

This is certainly a peculiar notion. However, when quantum theory was introduced in the 1920s, most 
of its ideas seemed no less strange. Now they are accepted by almost all physicists. Who is to say that in 
another half-century, Penrose will not be equally accepted when he asserts, "there is an essential non 
-algorithmic ingredient to (conscious) thought processes" and "I believe that (conscious) minds are not 
algorithmic entities"? 

Meanwhile, almost everyone in the AI community (who, it might be argued, are hardly disinterested 
parties) listens to what Penrose has to say, then dismisses it as just plain wrong. Part of the problem is 
Penrose's suggestion as to the mechanism employed within the brain, which seems bizarre indeed. 

As he points out in a second book, Shadows of the Mind (Penrose, 1994), he is not the first to 
suggest that quantum effects are important to human thought. Herbert Fröhlich, in 1968, noted that there 
was a high-frequency microwave activity in the brain, produced, he said, by a biological quantum 
resonance. In 1992, John Eccles proposed a brain structure called the presynaptic vesicular grid, 
which is a kind of crystalline lattice in the brain's pyramidal cells, as a suitable site for quantum activity. 

Penrose himself favors a different location and mechanism. He suggests, though not dogmatically, that 
the quantum world is evoked in elements of a neuron known as microtubules. A microtubule is a tiny 
tube, with an outer diameter of about twenty-five nanometers and an inner diameter of fourteen 
nanometers. The tube is made up of peanut-shaped objects called tubulin dimers. Each dimer has 
about ten thousand atoms in it. Penrose proposes that each dimer is a basic computational unit, 
operating using quantum effects. If he is right, the computing power of the brain is grossly underestimated 
if neurons are considered as the basic computing element. There are about ten million dimers per neuron, 
and because of their tiny size each one ought to operate about a million times as fast as a neuron can fire. 
Only with such a mechanism, Penrose argues, can the rather complex behavior of a single-celled animal 
such as a paramecium (which totally lacks a nervous system) be explained. 

Penrose's critics point out that microtubules are also found elsewhere in the body, in everything from 
livers to lungs. Does this mean that your spleen, big toe, and kidneys are to be credited with intelligence? 

My own feeling is that Penrose's ideas sounded a lot better before he suggested a mechanism. The 
microtubule idea feels weak and unpersuasive. 

Fortunately I don't have to take sides. In the eighth chronicle, I was deliberately silent on how the AI 
came into existence. However, as a personal observation, I would be much surprised if in our future we 
do not have human-level AI's, through whatever method of development, before humans routinely travel 
to the satellites of Jupiter and Saturn; and I believe that the latter will surely happen in less than five 
hundred years. 


* * * 

Compressed matter. 

We know that compressed matter exists. In a neutron star, matter has been squeezed together so 
hard that the individual protons and electrons that normally make up atoms have combined to form 
neutrons. A neutron star with the mass of the Sun can be as little as twenty kilometers across, and a 
simple calculation tells us that the average density of such a body is about 475 million tons per cubic 
centimeter. That is still not at the limit of how far matter can be compressed. If the Sun were to become 
a black hole, as mentioned earlier, its Schwarzschild radius would be about three kilometers and its 
mean density twenty billion tons per cubic centimeter. McAndrew's illustrious but unfortunate father 
developed an unspecified way of squeezing matter down to something between neutron star and black 
hole densities. 

It is easy to calculate what it would be like if you were unwise enough to take hold of a speck of such 
compressed matter. And it might well be a speck. An eighteen thousand ton asteroid in normal 
conditions would be a substantial lump of rock about twenty meters across. Squeeze it to a density of 
three billion tons per cubic centimeter, and it becomes a tiny ball with radius 0.11 millimeters. Its surface 
gravity is almost ten thousand gees. 

The gravitational force falls off rapidly with distance, so if you were a meter away from the mote of 
matter you would probably be unaware of its existence. It would pull you toward it with a mere 
ten-millionth of a gee. But take hold of it, and that's a different story. Ten thousand gees would suck any 
known material, no matter how strong, toward and into the ball. That process would continue, until 
either you sacrificed some skin and broke free, or you were eventually totally absorbed. In practice, I 
think that McAndrew's father would have realized what was happening and found a way to free himself. 
He would have plenty of time, because the absorption process into the compressed matter sphere would 
be slow. That, however, would not have made as interesting a story. 

The way that McAndrew's father produced compressed matter remains pure science fiction. 
However, the "strong force" itself is an accepted part of modern physics, one of four basic known 
forces. The other three are gravity, the electromagnetic force, and the so-called "weak force" 
responsible for beta decay (emission of an electron or positron) in a nucleus. Although there is an 
adequate theory of the strong force, embodied in what is known as quantum chromodynamics, there is 
not the slightest hint in that theory of a method to make such a force either stronger or weaker than it is. 

That's all right. Five hundred years ago, magnetism was a curious property of certain materials, and 
no one knew what it was or had any way of generating it artificially. That had to wait until another 
strange phenomenon, electricity, had been explored, and experimenters such as Ampère, Oersted, and 
Faraday proved a link between electricity and magnetism. After that could come Maxwell, providing a 
unified theory for the two ideas that led to such practical devices as radios, dynamos, and powerful 
electromagnets. 

It is not unreasonable to model the future on the past. A few hundred years from now, maybe we will 
be able to play our own games with all the known forces in the context of a unified theory, creating or 
modifying them as we choose. The weak force and the electromagnetic force have already been unified, 
work for which Glashow, Weinberg, and Salam were awarded the Nobel prize in physics in 1979. 

I cannot resist a couple of personal reminiscences regarding the late Abdus Salam. He was my 
mathematics supervisor when I was a new undergraduate. His personal style of solving the problems that 
I and my supervision partner brought to him was unique. More often than not, he would look at the 
result to be derived and say, "Consider the following identity." He would then write down a mathematical 
result which was far from obvious and usually new to us. Applying the identity certainly gave the required 
answer, but it didn't help us much with our struggles. 

Salam also had one endearing but disconcerting habit. He did not drink, but he must have been told 
that it was a tradition at Cambridge for tutors to serve sherry to their students on holiday occasions. He 
offered my partner and me sherry, an offer which we readily accepted. He then, unfamiliar with sherry as 
a drink, poured a large tumbler for each of us. We were too polite to refuse, or not to drink what we 


had been given, but we emerged from the supervision session much the worse for wear. 

There is a throwaway comment in the ninth chronicle, that McAndrew was going off to hear a lecture 
entitled "Higher-dimensional complex manifolds and a new proof of the Riemann Conjecture." This is a 
joke intended for mathematicians. In the nineteenth century, the great German mathematician Bernhard 
Riemann conjectured, but did not prove, that all the zeroes of a function known as the zeta function lay in 
a certain region of the complex plane. Riemann could not prove the result, and since then no one has 
managed to do so. It remains the most important unproven conjecture in mathematics, far more central 
to the field than the long-unproved but finally disposed-of Fermat Last Theorem. 

People will keep chipping away at the Riemann conjecture, precisely because it is unproven. Just as 
we will keep pushing for better observing instruments, more rapid and sophisticated interplanetary or 
interstellar probes, quantum computers, artificial intelligence, higher temperature superconductors, 
faster-than-light travel, treatment for all known diseases, and human life extension. 

The future in which McAndrew lives is fiction, but I believe that the science and technology of the real 
future will be far more surprising. There will indeed be ships, built by humans and their intellectual 
companions, computers, headed for the stars. They will not be powered by Kerr-Newman black holes, 
nor employ the McAndrew balanced drive, nor will they tap the resonance modes of the vacuum 
zero-point energy. They will not be multi-generation arks, nor will they find life-bearing planetoids in the 
Oort cloud, or rogue planets in the interstellar void. What they will be, and what they will find, will be far 
stranger and more interesting than that. And they will make today's boldest science fiction conjectures 
appear timid, near-sighted, small-scale, and lacking in imagination. 

Writing of this I wish, like Benjamin Franklin, that I could be pickled in a barrel for a couple of 
hundred years, to experience the surprising future that I'm sure lies ahead. If I can't do that and don't last 
that long, here is a message to my descendants two centuries from now: On my behalf, make the most of 
it.